A Nostalgic Gem with Incredible Food! From the moment we walked into this beautifully decorated, nostalgic diner, we knew we were in for a treat. I made a reservation for a party of six, and even though we arrived a little early, the staff was incredibly accommodating and seated us right away without a problem. Outstanding Service We had an absolutely delightful server! They were incredibly knowledgeable, patiently answering all of our questions about menu favorites, and provided top-notch customer service from start to finish. It really made the whole experience that much better. Delicious, Authentic Food The kitchen serves up delicious, authentic, and very well-portioned dishes. Our group ordered a large variety of items, and every single person raved about their meal! Some of the absolute standouts included: -The giant meatball -The Reuben sandwich, featuring fantastic house-made pastrami -Classic, perfectly blended milkshakes Comforting, rich matzah ball soup We all left with full, happy bellies and are already looking forward to our next visit. I highly recommend stopping by if you want great food and a wonderful atmosphere! read more

Brooklyn Diner - Soft and chocolatey 8-inch cookie. - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I honestly don't want to tell anyone to go to this place. I don't want to tell anyone about their food! This place has unbelievable CHICKEN POT PIE! Okay okay I said it. This place is too good to sleep on. The food, service, atmosphere are fantastic! But the chicken pot pie is to die for! It's as big as your head and way larger than your stomach! Go! But for the love of all things holy don't back it up like every other amazing restaurant in NYC! I'll be back! read more

See all

I visited Brooklyn Diner hoping for a great experience, especially since it came recommended through a cashback app. Unfortunately, my visit was mixed. When I arrived, my server was chatting at the bar talking about cocktails and didn't notice me for a while. She apologized once she realized, which I appreciated, but the service continued to feel inattentive. I ordered a three‑cheese omelette and specifically mentioned that I don't eat bacon or sausage. When the dish arrived, it had bacon on top. I'm not someone who sends food back unless absolutely necessary, but in this case I had to. The server seemed frustrated and implied that all omelettes come with bacon, which made the interaction uncomfortable. I also asked about the toast, since it didn't look like the challah bread I'm used to. Instead of explaining, the server discussed my question with a colleague within earshot, which felt unprofessional and a bit embarrassing. The bright spot of the visit was another staff member -- a woman with blond hair -- who approached me, apologized sincerely, and offered pastries to make things right. Her kindness really stood out and is the reason I'm giving this review a fair rating instead of a negative one. Overall, the food was fine once corrected, and the restaurant has potential, but the service experience was disappointing. I hope this was just an off day, because the staff member who stepped in showed what good hospitality can look like. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

It is the epitome of a flashy diner with nothing really to show for except looking like a diner. Ordered: Two eggs any style with potatoes, bacon and bread on the side. ($21) 3/5 Even if the plate was the size of starter plate I'd still have a gripe about the proportions here. For $21 dollars I was shocked by the amount of food that was not on my plate. And the meal was mediocre at best. You always hope for the best at these places but sometimes it is going to be exactly what you think it is. Chocolate Milk: 2/5 - Gobsmackingly sweet. If a parent gave this to their child they'd be boucning off the walls all day, or worse, they might actually think its also too sweet. Service: 5/5 - It was commendable. We went on Christmas Eve. Despite their continuous rush they seemed to be flipping tables quickly so we were able to be seated wo a resvervation no problem. Our meal also came very fast which is always appreciated. Breakfast isn't really my thing any way read more

See all

The food was pretty disappointing. The waffles were hard and tough to chew through. The pigs in a blanket and turkey in the turkey club sandwich was dry. The smoked salmon and omelette were okay. Seated quickly around noon on a Saturday. read more

See all

When I go to NYC, I go to this diner and the service has been excellent. The staff has been great.

Menu options look appealing. Ordered chicken and waffles, peruvian chicken and the french toast. The french toast and italian sausage were delicious. The chicken and waffles seemed pre-frozen and lacked flavor. And the peruvian chicken was moist but unseasoned. Service was exceptional. Ambiance is fine. read more

The line was shorter than other places nearby so we gave this place a try before our show. They seemed understaffed and the staff did not seem well trained. Buns for customers were stored in a tomato box, and then used for a customer's sandwich. The same staff switched from sweeping to line cook without changing gloves too. The food was alright, and I had no complaints. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Buns stored with unwashed produce - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We visited here today from San Diego before seeing a play. What an experience. Our server, Yomaira was the best. What a wonderful New York experience!!! read more

A night in NYC always calls for a stop at the Brooklyn Diner, one of my longtime favorites from when I lived in the Northeast. I'm so glad I went back because it didn't disappoint. My server, Gabriela M., was amazing and friendly. I followed her recommendations and went with the shrimp tacos, and they absolutely satisfied my palate; fresh, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. The side of guacamole was a little taste of heaven. Great dining experience as expected read more

See all

I've never spent much time in Time Square the entire time I lived here, but now I am exploring the city like a tourist. We tried this place out after traveling all day and this place did not disappoint, but will warn you the prices are high. You're in Time Square, it's gonna cost you. I ordered their signature chicken noodle soup and my mom had the cheeseburger and fries. Both dishes executed perfectly. I loved the chicken noodle soup and the fresh veggies and shredded chicken was all very fresh and flavorful. The challah toast was dry though. I'd consider coming back here if needing a solid meal in a casual location. Lots of good people watching too! read more

Brooklyn Diner - Chicken noodle soup - fresh veggies and shredded chicken, yum! - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Pleasantly surprised by the food here especially being a diner. But I've come to learn that diners in NYC have some of the best food - even gourmet standards. Went here after a comedy show so it was past 8:30 and the place was only partly full which was great as we were seated immediately. We had some fun with the mirrors there - got some fun photos sitting next to them looking at ourselves. I ordered the pollo cubano and it was amazing! First of all it came with this very gourmet presentation with the chicken stacked over the Spanish rice topped with the caramelized onions and pico de gallo and a side of lemon - I was very impressed! And it was quite delicious- the textures and depth of flavors in each bite - mmm mmm mmmm. I was hungry too and I ate the whole thing! Very satisfying. The hubs ordered their famous hot dog the 15-bite frankfurter which is huge and comes with sauerkraut and side of fries. He enjoyed and it and it was filling too. We were both very satisfied! Service was friendly and efficient. Overall great experience! read more

See all

We stopped by on a whim and were quickly seated. I sent my first drink back it was too strong. My second drink was good and the chicken and waffle was decent. Our server was very busy but the place didn't seem that busy. I guess stop by and check them out and let me know your thoughts....I guess I wasn't too overly impressed! read more

Brooklyn Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came to this restaurant for the first time 3 years ago and had the best burger. I told everyone how the burger was the best ever until..... I went back and had the same burger and it was just ok. Our waiter the first time was also amazing, while the waiter on my second visit was basic and underwhelming service. 2 completely different experiences here. Don't think I'll be returning. read more

Only giving this place a 1 because our waiter was very kind and quick with getting our order. The food was not even hot it was barley warm, we got the pancakes which was about $15 for one pancake, which already seemed steep already for just one pancake but we decided to give it a try because it must be good right? No, the pancakes were stale, hard, and barely warm. Obviously eating in Times Square comes at a cost but we assumed for the prices this place would be at least somewhat decent, we ended up spending $60 on three pancakes and water. As I said the waiter was great no complaints to the service, the food was such a waste, would definitely not come here again unfortunately. read more

We met a friend for lunch here. It was our first time. Our waiter was Ashraf. He was friendly and helpful with menu items. He didn't rush us and was there when we needed his attention. Our friend ordered onion rings and the footlong hotdog with no bun. I got the tuna salad, with cheese & lettuce on challah bread with slaw. Husband got the cheeseburger & fries. We liked the booths and decor. It felt like a diner. Service was quick, and the food was good. I like my slaw creamy, and didn't eat the vinegar based slaw served here. But someone else might like it a lot. Husband enjoyed his burger and fries, Friend liked the hot dog and onion rings and I enjoyed my tuna salad. read more

This was my second time eating here and both experiences were very good. I was seated immediately and the service was excellent. The food came quickly and was cooked well. It's average for the price but exactly as described. The ambiance is cool and plays off being a stones throw from Times Square. At each visit there was an eclectic mix of tourists and what I perceived as regulars. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

We came here as a suggestion from the security guard at the NBC Studios (Brandon). We ordered the French Toast, Avocado Toast w a side of smoked salmon and a single pancake w a side of fresh strawberries. Our server was Ash and what a joy he was. We shared many meaningful personal stories and he was so kind and gracious to us. If we are back in NY, we will surely be back to visit Ash. read more

Everything is superb here! People take care and food tastes fresh! No trip to Manhattan is complete without a meal here!

First meal after landing in New York and we needed a place to go that had a restroom. This restaurant is clean and very cozy. It has a diner feel to it. Service wasn't great but our food made it. Ordered the hot pastrami and oddly enough it does not come with fries so I added a basket. The pastrami on its own was great. It melted in your mouth and was delicious. It was stuffed between two pieces of bread with no condiments. Fries were hot and delicious. The rest of the food was okay. Convenient location being in Times Square. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing atmosphere- right in time square but makes you feel relaxed in the hustle of NYC. The food was good - recommend the pancake and steel cut oats. The service was amazing. Our server, Ash, was so warm! He made us feel like family! Went over and about to make use feel welcome! read more

Great place for a late lunch waiting to check into our hotel! Everyone ordered something different (matzo ball soup, cheeseburger, reuben and chicken fingers and fries, shakes), and it was all solid. Waitstaff was friendly and attentive. read more

I came here for dinner. Brooklyn Diner USA is a modern diner with retro decor serves large portions of classic American dishes like hot dogs and chicken pot pie. Their chicken pot pie is their signature dish and sold out very quickly. The food I ordered all tasted delicious . This place does get very packed and busy. Friendly and attentive services. Because it gets really busy during peak hours, the food did take quite a while. But overall, everything was good and this is a very good spot for burgers! Ordered: Appetizer: Pigs in a Blanket $16.00 Entree: Smashed French Dip Burger $23.95 + Backyard Burger $24.95 Drink: Pineapple Mojito $16.00 read more

See all

Brooklyn Diner is between 3 and 4 Stars for me. I was telling a Yelp friend about the Huge piece of Key Lime Pie I had here and I unknowingly had an allergic reaction. Bottom line I insisted my daughter have lunch with me once when I was visiting before I moved here. The portions were so huge but back then I had a bigger appetite! So after I moved here I came for the huge pieces of pie and just made it a meal! I feel like service would have been better. If you're one of many tourists having lunch they figure you're not returning! Maybe that's just the way I was treated or it was because I just ordered dessert! Waiting to be seated takes forever. That's another reason I don't eat here anymore. The high points are delicious food and huge portions. To me it's worth the price. read more

I can't begin to express what a wonderful experience we had at the BROOKLYN DINER. The food and coffee were so good and fresh!!! The experience was only topped by the exemplary hospitality of our server, Ash! He was so friendly and efficient and made our dining experience so fun and memorable! If you go, be sure to ask for him and the homemade Italian sausage! You will not regret either choice! read more

From the moment we walked in, the vibe was a little off. The host was not the best; maybe she was unfriendly because this location is right by Times Square but service overall was lackluster. The burger itself was good, although I asked for medium and it was a bit more rare than I would have liked. Fries were good. All in all, this spot is fine albeit overpriced and touristy. read more

See all

Just had a quick bite at the Brooklyn Diner on W43rd Street, Manhattan. I've been here many times and it's never disappointing! The service was quick and pleasant and they got us out in time for our 7p show. Our waitress,, Gabriella, was terrific! Try it you'll like it! read more

Thank you Ash for you wonderful service. Ash is a very lovely man and kind. Great serve! This Southern girl enjoyed talking to you. BTW-break was awesome. read more

Loved this restaurant!!! Server Ashtov was fabulous!! Very friendly and helpful. Pastrami sandwich was to die for, chocolate milkshake yummy too. Huge hot dog very good. I definitely would come back here. read more

Cozy place to stop by after a day of walking and enjoying NYC. Terrific food... fresh, very tasty, good quality, good size. The staff is outstanding. Very attentive and cordial. My family and I are in love with this place. Really recommend it. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Chicken Pot Pie - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in for breakfast as it was one of the earliest to open. We got the omelette and avocado toast. The toast was piled high with avocado!!! Service was good. The tables were too close for my comfort but no worse than most places in NYC. read more

As a spot, in Times Square, to grab a bite and take a load off, Brooklyn Diner checks the boxes. They have an inviting atmosphere, a friendly and attentive staff, and a menu where anyone can find something. And on top of that, they have late hours. We stopped in for a quick bite while roaming around after a show and were pleased with our choice. Everyone in our four-some had a taste for a little something different and the menu treated us well. Personally, I had a turkey club and a strawberry milkshake and both were great and sizable! And tasty! My meal really hit the spot! Although our waiter switched just after drink orders, no idea why, we saw no curtailment of service or positive atmosphere at our table. He did a wonderful job of punctuality and attention. Will you be blown away at your visit here? No. But you won't be disappointed either. Go on, give them a shot. read more

Huge servings. Very fresh salads. Everything we ordered was very good. Went after a show service was great.

Such a great spot! The food is consistent and I really approached that everyone there from the host to those in the kitchen work tireless to ensure your experience is one to enjoy and remember! I really enjoyed the club sandwich and the cheesecake was yummy too! I recommend this spot to everyone! read more

Brooklyn Diner - Dining area - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

This find was a splendid surprise. My friends and I were seeing a show in the theater across the street, and had some time before. We saw this diner and stopped in. We grabbed a seat at the counter and ordered some coffees while sharing a sandwich. It was a Sunday morning so it was busy inside the restaurant filled with a lot of tourists. We ordered a sandwich, which was delicious. The service was quick and the waiter was wonderful. The prices weren't even that bad for the location. I'd definitely recommend giving it a try if you are in the area. read more

Highly recommend! The staff and owners were super friendly and helpful making sure everyone was sat right away! Food was delicious, one of the places where you have to try something different each time. Decor was also super cool! Felt cozy with the holiday decorations read more

Great food and great atmosphere! Ash was our server and he was so kind and friendly to us in addition to being a great server. Loved our experience and this will be one of our regular stops in NYC! read more

We went to both locations. One for lunch and one for breakfast. Great menu. Service is fast and pleasant. Diner vibes.

Right in the heart of hustle/bustle of Times Square. A seasoned waiter did a very good job. For lunch shared a large bowl of matzo ball soup and pastrami sandwich both tasted great. Soup won out -large matzo ball, lots of chicken. Sandwich tasted excellent,but for $28 didn't have much meat on it. Came with 2 slices of pickles & a very small bowl of coleslaw. Bread was great. read more

Brooklyn Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by to grab a quick breakfast and was shocked by the breakfast prices. Sure, it's NYC. Sure, it's near Time Square. But to charge $15 for eggs, toast, and 3 pieces of fried polenta (instead of home fries) is criminal. Plus an additional $6 for coffee (endless thankfully) and another $5 for 2 slices of bacon or ham. So you're looking at around $26 for a very basic breakfast, and there really aren't that many choices on the breakfast menu. By comparison, our local diners in Schenectady have amazing food, lots of choices, and would be about the same price for two people after tax and tip. Price complaints aside, the food was okay. The eggs were good, the polenta was yummy, but the bagel was 100% no Brooklyn bagel. It had great flavor, but was a little hard on the inside, and if you know good New York bagels, they are always chewy on the inside. The waiter was really sweet and nice. Brought me my own little carafe of decaf coffee, checked in on us regularly, and was very attentive. A good experience overall, minus the ridiculous NYC pricing. read more

Brooklyn Diner - My $26 breakfast!?! - Diners Near Me - New York, New York