The service is AMAZING and the food is divine! A must have when in The Lower Keys. Love Love read more

We heard good things about this place. Food was pretty good, but we ordered a bottle of wine and a fly flew into our glass. They threw out nearly a third of the bottle and did not bother to provide another glass or give us anything in return. For the price there are much better options in this area of the keys. read more

Delicious every time! Carrot Cake was a perfect compliment to a fabulous dinner. Service was perfect too. Be back soon!

What a hidden gem! This will be on our agenda every trip to the keys. The food was amazing along with the service. I've never regretted not getting pictures of our food more! It was amazing. It wasn't super crowded either. We will be back!!!! read more

Wow!! Have eaten at the Broil at least eight times. Everything is excellent !! Went there tonite and the Chef JR made his delicious bread pudding as a special desert. Do yourself a favor - don't miss the opportunity to enjoy this wonderful restaurant !!! read more

If you don't stop here while in the FL Keys, you are missing the mark! Superior food; above the cut service; desserts delectable.. the owner's carrot cake is the best! read more

Fantastic ! Atmosphere. Food. Service. Had the shrimp appetizer. Amazing. The chop salad was great. Blue cheese homemade dressing beyond description. Bacon wrapped filet with baked potato. Husband got NY strip. I had chocolate cake and he had cheesecake. My only disappointment was the bread. Needed more flavor. Can not say enough about how good ! read more

See all

First class from the front door, all the way through the meal, and to the awesome coffee and dessert. Beautiful and clean inside. A calm environment. Beautiful and friendly staff. Steak is up there with top steak houses like Lugers and Berns if not better. Fish cooked to perfection. A wonderful experience. Thank you. read more

Went with a local, food was off the charts! Salad was presented so eloquently. Their specials were so yummy! Great wine selection. A must go in cudjoe key read more

Fantastic food and service is great! They don't do reservations so just come and enjoy!

New steak restaurant on Cudjoe key. Had a great dinner and overall dining experience. Service was beyond good. Our Steaks and everything else were cooked to perfection . They only serve beer and wine but the wine selection was good as well. They don't take reservations so if it's busy you might have to wait. They had an outdoor seating area as well. Highly recommended. Will be back next time we come back. read more

All of the food was prepared so well and was so fresh. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. The restaurant is large and the decor is tasteful and relaxing. The steak was prepared perfectly and the carrot cake and chocolate cake with vanilla icing divine. Wonderful reasonably priced fine dining choice. read more

Absolutely wonderful!!! We could not have been happier with our visit! The food was spectacular! Our group had the seafood pasta, the Sinatra steak, the BBQ swordfish and the filet. Everyone of us said we would get the same thing when we come back! The lobster mashed potatoes were heavenly. The service was perfect and the unveiling of the dinners was such a fun touch! Can not wait to return!!! read more

Our experience with Broil was probably the best. We live here and explore area often. Food was amazing, service is great and overall this is the place where you definitely need to stop. I could have given them 10 stars if I could. read more

I can't understand how this restaurant is receiving good reviews. It has some good elements such as pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff and tastey vegetables, but as far as the overpriced gristley beef goes it turns the entire dinning experience into one that makes you wishing you were at Burger King. How the owners can serve this poor quality beef at those sky high prices, I don't know. Everyone in our dinner party agreed the beef was not even close to good. Do yourself a favor and go some where else. read more

Tried this relatively new restaurant. The food and the service were excellent. The entrees came with a great salad and veggies. This area needed a another hi end restaurant and Broil fills this need. Prices were reasonable. We will be back. read more

Please please stay open forever. What a great addition to the Cudjoe/lower keys restaurant scene. Tired of too many fry joints around here. This eatery is so classy and the food is top-notch In every way. Impeccable service, and attention to detail. Prices are commensurate with other restaurants of this caliber on Cudjoe. Entire vibe of restaurant and bar is so classic and upscale but very comfortable and inviting. read more

Our server Lonis was lovely and helpful. The meal was exceptional, perfect scallops and steak. My favorite restaurant in Chicago sadly closed, I think I've found a new favorite! The music and atmosphere were relaxing. Ok to dress up or go casual. read more

We happened to be staying 5 minutes from here... but if you're closer to downtown... worth.the.drive!! We often eat at 5 star restaurants and this may be at the top of that list! Not only is the food amazing but the service is impeccable! A must while you're in the Key West area! read more

Broil - "Yellow Belly" and "Steak Sinatra". We also had their Shrimp Atascedaro and BBQ scallops apps which were amazing. - Seafood Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

OMG this place was amazing! We came in starving and left with dessert to go we were so full but couldn't resist! The BBQ scallops were the best we have ever had. Everything was over the top and the service was spectacular! Recommend! 5 stars for sure! read more

Broil - Seafood Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

See all

Amazing service, food and atmosphere! Staff and owner are attentive and accommodating. Must try! We will be back.

A pleasant surprise outside of the touristy downtown Key West district. Family owned, owner greets each table during meal and follows up on your experience. Tri-tip app was tender and tasty with the Bernaise sauce. Chopped salad had a very unique presentation, as well as a great, fresh flavor. Bacon wrap scallops in Mango chutney had a multitude of blended flavors. Everything went well together. My wife had the swordfish and thoroughly enjoyed it. We capped the evening off with the homemade carrot cake, moist, not to sugary and full of flavor. Great wine and beer selection, however no mixed drinks available. With the attention of the staff, upscale ambiance and excellent meal, definitely a place to go for a special evening out. read more

Small, quaint, and quiet with a nice atmosphere and friendly staff (a great place for date night). We enjoyed the filet mignon and sides, which were especially good (jalapeño baked potato and lobster mashed potatoes). We thought Broil s prices were very reasonable. read more

The food and atmosphere at this restaurant are definitely five star however I am not a beer nor wine drinker and would prefer a nice cordial after dinner, and that is the only reason they did not receive the full five stars. Excellent food and service. read more

Absolutely perfect combination of ambience, service, fantastic food. We had the Steak Sinatra (filet medallions with lobster mashed potatoes, Filet Mignon, and New Strip. Not only were they excellently cooked, but the sides and especially the salads were awesome. read more

Our first visit and I was completely overjoyed with our meal, the service and the atmosphere. What a great place and wonderful menu selection. I can't wait to go back and try everything on the menu. The specials also looked amazing. Hats off to the chef and a big thank you to the wait staff. read more

Don't let the lack of flashy lighting cause you to miss Broil on Cudjoe Key. The room was well-appointed, the greeting warm, and the service 5 star. Steak Sinatra was my choice, the NY strip my companion's-we could not have been more pleased. Ready to kick it up a notch one night? Here's your place. read more

What a gem! I did not expect to find this level of dining in the Keys. It is a small, friendly establishment, around mile marker 21. They specialize in steak and seafood. The four of us had four different selections, and we all raved. The seafood linguine was excellent and quite filling. The shrimp dish was good, but a bit over cooked. The steaks, wrapped in bacon, were amazing. The salads and sides were also very good. We topped it off with a chocolate creme brûlée. The wine list was also excellent and reasonably priced. This is a small place with indoor and outdoor dining. No reservations accepted. We will be back again! read more

Everything was delicious ~ the service was top notch and the atmosphere was lovely ~ we look forward to dining there again soon

Fabulous, upscale prime steak house. Steaks cooked perfectly, great salad, lobster mashed, salted baked potato. Safe room for Mr Weiss's supremely moist carrot cake. read more

First of all the credit card system was "down." Fortunately I had cash enough to pay. Second, very medicore food. For a steak place, the meat was tough and barely edible. I love a good steak. I'll look elsewhere. I couldn't even finish a half. read more

The best steakhouse in the FL keys.... Treat yourself to the scallop appetizer and aunt Jackie! The filet and lobster are to die for! You may be full at that point, but you need to to try the carrot cake. Literally the best carrot cake I have ever had! So get it to go if you need to. Don't miss this spot while you're in the keys. read more

Wow. Really blown away by our experience at Broil. Unassuming from the outside, but when you walk through the doors you're transported into an elegant island steakhouse. It lives up to it's name -and surpasses it. From the time we walked through the door we were treated like royalty, and this was during a busy dinner hour. The service was unlike any we've experienced in the Keys. They were pros; attentive, knowledgeable, caring. Truly five star service- CLOCHES and all. And the food was amazing. The menu was so enticing, it was hard to choose (but our waiter helped with that). Also have to note, as it's so rare now in high end restaurants, that entrees were served with a salad (a very beautiful one) and choice of a side. Their prices are more than fair (unlike Square Grouper who now charges $40 for plain old yellowtail. You'll find a yellowtail option here for less that's topped with lump crabmeat, by the way). This place just gives the people what they want. If you're a local or a tourist, you must try this place. All of the love for BROIL. read more

Fabulous food and service. My linguini was absolutely perfect, with the scallops cooked to perfection. All of the staff were attentive and kind. This was an excellent restaurant if I could, I would give more than 5 stars. read more