I have never been so excited and anxious to eat at a restaurant before. Excited, because, come on, its the oldest known restaurant in the world! Anxious, because of the many mixed reviews of rude an pushy wait staff, the fact that locals don't really know too much about it and that it's just a tourist trap.
Celebrating our honeymoon in Spain, we really wanted the experience to go well. Whew! Thank God it did! We made reservations at 8pm for two days later. The only other reservation time was 11:30pm for the very next night. I know locals eat really late into the night, but we just couldn't do that. We asked to be seated in the basement, which was a really cool atmosphere. Of course, everyone was a tourist. But it's ok. Still pretty cool. We ordered their specialties, roasted suckling pig and roasted lamb, with a side of mushrooms. We also ordered a jar of sangria and dessert after dinner. Delicioso!!! Mui bien! Everything was so juicy, so tender, slightly crisp skin on the suckling pig, a tiny bit salty for my liking, but really really good. The sangria was not too strong, but not too weak either. The dessert was mango pieces with ice cream and custard. Soo yummy!
We made lovely conversation with an American family next to us, and we sat there eating for over two hours. No one rushed us, no musician came up to us asking for money like other yelp reviews noted, nada. Todo bien.
We remembered that they will charge for bread if they placed it on your table, so we politely declined it when they placed it on our table. We also wanted to save room for dessert. They did end up charging us for the bread even though we didn't eat it, but after explaining this to our waiter, he went to get it changed. He ended up giving us the same bill with the charged bread, but he had it fixed again. Not sure if that was their way of sneaking in a few extra euros or an honest mistake, but it didn't turn out to be a big deal. Our friendly diners next to us had a huge cockroach in their jar of sangria. That was pretty nasty. The waiter took all the glasses from them and their jar, and returned with a new jar and glasses. The thing is, the sangria is in one giant vat. So the new sangria they have and the sangria I was drinking still probably had cockroach juices all up in there. Gross. "Don't think about it too much... Restaurants are all like this." I thought to myself. No one made a big scene, and again, it was fine.
Now, cost. Yes, it is a bit on the expensive side. I think we ended up spending close to $100 USD, but for the amount of food we had and its quality, along with the ambience an culture, it was definitely worth it. In NYC, the fact that it's a known tourist attraction would have hiked up these prices double! For real, son.
All the wait staff was friendly. After dinner, I wanted to take a picture of this one cook cutting up the jamon. He not only let me take the picture, but he and his colleague encouraged me and went out of his way to let me cut it and show me the proper technique of cutting it!!! And took a pic of me and my husband while doing that. They started to clap and laughed and complimented me. I know they were just being nice since I really didn't know what I was doing, but it was just, on the whole, very very great experience. Loved it!! read more