Hard to believe that such a solid custom cookie spot is in Fife! I live in Fife/Edgewood and I can tell you that I had zero idea this place was here, and I've been in the area for almost 4 years. I was in need of some custom cookies for a meeting, and fast. I reached out to Bon Appetina's and was replied to swiftly and to my surprise, they agreed to place a rush order for me for a small additional charge. I was so grateful I didn't have to scramble to find somewhere else! Pickup and payment was super easy. It was a little hard to find the spot since it's in a warehouse complex sort of setup, but once I found it we were golden. They have the door locked until you ring for pickup but they answered quickly and my box was labeled and ready to go. I was so happy with how they turned out! Everything was exactly as communicated and they looked so cute - and delicious! The person receiving them was so excited about them which was my entire goal, so that alone was a 5 star experience. Definitely super happy with this order and I'll be reaching out to them in the future for other custom orders. read more

Christina was so kind, communicative, and accommodating to my short notice custom order of cookies for my friends surprise bday party! She truly made the ordering and pick up process so easy for me, even coming from out of state. I would even say that she went above and beyond to help me make this happen. Despite my order being small, I felt like there was just as much care and consideration put into it as I would expect a larger order to receive. 10/10 recommend, thank you Bon Appetina's for helping make my friends birthday a little extra special! read more

Bon Appetina's - custom shortbread cookies - so yummy and turned out so good! (forgot to get a picture of just the cookies, oops!) - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

I ordered cookies for my friend's baby shower to be given to guests as a "thanks for attending" favor. I worked with Christina and explained my design idea for the cookie and her designer did not disappoint and exceeded my expectations. Not only were the cookies beautiful but they were delicious! Soft, buttery and not overly sweet with the frosting. I highly recommend this bakery. I plan to order more personalized cookies from them for future events I'll host. Christina is so responsive too with inquiries, and coordinating pick-up. She was so sweet and included two extra cookies that we sampled with delight! So good!!! read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

Bon Appetina's is phenomenal! Seriously, this place is such a hidden gem, if you're in the market for a great designer sugar cookie then look no further. Bon Appetina's was actually recently recommended to me by another bakery after my first cookie designer fell through. And I have to say I'm so happy I had gotten this recommendation because my vision for my sons birthday cookies truly came to life. I had messaged them 10 days before my event and they were so accommodating. They prefer emailing them directly instead of using yelp so they can respond quicker but they responded within hours of me inquiring if it was even possible to still get these cookies done. I sent them pictures of what we wanted and they gave me some options on exactly how I'd want them. Bon Appetina has limited hours and days of operation but they truly deliver on their products. Not only were these sugar cookies beautiful but also some of the best sugar cookies I've ever tasted. And not only did they look and taste amazing but they also prepackaged them all for me to make my life that much easier and the packaging was included in their pricing which many places charge extra for. They sent me an invoice the day before pickup and when I got there to pick up the cookies they even went through the box to make sure I was happy with the final product. Truly spectacular service all the way around. These were such great party favors for my sons birthday. I know if I ever need cookies for any type of event this will be my go to place. read more

See all

Had them do custom cookies with my friends Bitmoji face and they turned out awesome! Also I had them do Beyoncé cookies for a watch party I had several years ago and never did a review for that ( shame on me). Basically they're the Sh@& and if you're looking for custom cookies this is your place. read more

Bon Appetina's - Bitmoji cookie - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

See all

My daughters cookies and cake pops where perfect for her party! They tasted delicious and were so cute on her Sweets Table! Amazing customer service, they went out of their way to make sure I was able to have a pick up time that worked for me. Very talented and I can't wait to order again for my mother n laws birthday celebration in October!! The colors were exactly what I expressed I wanted too. Very satisfied with the finished product. read more

Bon Appetina's - Look at these amazing cookies! - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

See all

My employer has some custom printed cookies made recently, handed out to staff. Looked amazing, tasted great, had an unknown hair/fiber in it so that's. Fun. read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

My whole experience was a 10/10! They made my custom made Winnie the Pooh sugar cookies for my baby shower and they're absolutely beautiful. I ordered 24 and they're all not only packaged with care but made with love as well! You can really tell they took there time! Even with my rattles they switched the color of the lettering so that it would match perfectly (the little things that they don't have to do). They accommodated my needs and everything went very smooth! I will 100% be coming back here for any special event and I also got a sample cookie which was absolutely delicious may I add! 10/10 recommend!! read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

Ordered two dozen cookies for my granddaughter's birthday. They were wonderful to work with and the cookies were amazing! They tasted great and they were decorated beautifully! Definitely will be using them again! read more

Guys. I literally am writing this with tears in my eyes! I recently ordered from another bakery, only to have her cancel 2 (TWO!!!) Days before an event. Frantic, I called 3 places to see if anyone could help me with 40 cake pops for my god-daughters first birthday party.. Not one could help me. My last call was to Bon Appetina's. I should have called them first! I called asking for literally anything, if they had any left-overs..anything.. Without hesitation or the slightest sound of annoyance in his voice that this crazy lady was asking for 40 cake pops in 24 hours, he let me know that he would see what he could do. I didn't even explain my situation to him until after peter told me he could at least ask! He called me 15 minutes later, saying he could do it, and even make some cute simple designs! HE DELIVERED THEM THE NEXT DAY. When he dropped the box off, he asked me to open them and look, because the designs he had told me about on the phone were not what we had talked about. I opened the box to these amazing cake pops! He had heard me say them theme was "baby shark", and they created little sharks with details and FINS omg I died. These people had no idea who i was, didn't have to care about my petty first world problem, yet they went out of their way to go above and beyond. They are just as delicious as they were adorable, they made the shark pops red velvet (so genius lol) and the water pops cookies and cream... I legit will now find a reason to order cake pops for every occasion because of this place. read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

See all

I cannot say enough good things about Bon Appetina's. Peter was incredibly thorough and kind throughout our emails planning out what treats we wanted for the party. He accommodated every request we made, and the designs they chose and printed for the "1" and "2" cookies were awesome. The cake pops we requested, lions in party hats, were absolutely adorable. Everyone in attendance commented on how cute the treats were--and how delicious!!! Everything we ordered from Bon Appetina's tasted and looked great. Friendly, professional service with quality made baked goods. You really couldn't ask for a better experience. They went above and beyond, and we are so thankful! read more

See all

Christina went the extra mile on a plan to get a last-minute order completed for me.

The buttery shortbread cookies are soooo good! I get them as a special treat every time I work my hospital job where they sell them. Gives me something extra special to look forward to! YUM! read more

I ordered cookies for my daughter's graduation party from the UW. They turned our perfect. My daughter posted a picture of the cookies on Instagram and said, "Thanks to my mom for being extra!" The owner was very friendly. I wouldn't hesitate to order from them again. read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

I love Bon Appetina's! Their cookies and cake pops are not only perfectly decorated for any occasion, but are delicious, too! I order end of the year cookies every year for my middle school students; last year's emoji design cookies were a big hit with my 7th-graders! These cookies aren't just for kids, though - - my husband & I enjoy their artisanal chocolate chip cookies, too! read more

Bon Appetina's - 7th-graders celebrating end of the school year with Bon Appetina's emoji cookies! - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

The blueberry cookie is great Our little loved her lemon cake pop. We ran across their both at the Fife Easter egg hunt. We'll be getting some of their cookies you can color in on my kids birthday. It's a great idea with a fair price. You buy a stack of cookies with edible markers to color them in. I love the idea and it's fun. More importantly though the flavor is great read more

SHOUT OUT TO PETER AT BON APPETINA's. I called from Florida about special cookies for a family member in WA who had Covid. Peter was wonderful, as he designed special Cookies and made sure they got there. My family member is better & loved the cookies. Thanks Peter for being so kind. Bless you. read more

Bon Appetina's - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

Now it's not very often that a small mom-and-pop gets bought out and the new Owner makes the product better - but in this case the O'Hara's made very sure they not only maintained but improved on the product. Deliciously made cookies and cake pops, with perfect shortbread texture and hard shell icing makes their treats irresistible! Top job ... read more

See all

I ordered Sesame Street cookies for my grandsons 1st birthday and it was a HIT. They tasted great and everyone loved it. I will definitely order from them again. Peter was great and gave me all info I needed. I for sure will order again from them again. read more

Great Customer Service! I definitely recommend for anyone to order cookies and cake pops here! They know how to bring your ideas to life! Most cookies like this don't taste as good as they look.... but when I Ate my first cookie, it was delicious! Everyone at my child's party loved the cookies and cake pops as well! read more

Bon Appetina's - Toy Story themed Short bread Cookies! - Desserts Near Me - Fife, Washington

Wonderful family run business! I love seeing family supporting each other! The desserts are just the icing on the cake or so to say. They are great quality. You can see someone is a perfectionist in the quality control department. Amazing experience and it's like they kick it up to another level when you order. If you walk in its one thing, but you give them time to know exactly what you want? BOOM next level. read more

All I can say is Bon Appetina's is the best!!! Wonderful and very professional and personable!!! read more

These cookie treats made my dessert table! I was so pleased with the design being exactly what I requested - thank you, Peter and crew! I asked for a design from a cartoon they had to look up online for one set of cookies and for another I sent in a picture of the font I had in mind and they did each set of cookies just right. It's such a good feeling amidst the stress of planning a big party to have something turn out so right. My guests didn't want to eat them (at first!) because they were so "cute and clever". As an aside, the "best by" date is far enough out I could mail some to friends who couldn't make the party and they were delighted! You guys rock! read more

I am speechless about the quality of the cookies and desserts. It's not just the taste that absorbs me, it's the DESIGN. They turn everyday desserts into design masterpieces. It's so beautiful, that I think I could sing about it. Like seriously, the designs are beautiful! Cake pops become cats, infinite cookie designs, PRINTING ONTO FROSTING EVEN! I NEVER KNEW THAT WAS POSSIBLE! Like, the only time I've seen something printed on desserts was frosting on cakes and cookies. THIS IS JUST NEXT LEVEL! I would rate this 6 stars if I could, but I can't, so I'll just have to roll with 5 stars. Either way, this place is BRILLIANT! You should go there. Trust me, you won't regret it. read more

Peter and the team at Bon Appetina's are incredible! We purchased a large order of custom cookies for our annual luncheon. Not only was the customer service great from the onset, but they came through in the clutch to provide additional cookies after a last minute surge in registration. They really went above and beyond!!! And, the cookies TASTE AMAZING! If you are in need of cookies, whether it be one or hundreds, I highly recommend choosing Bon Appetinas! This satisfied customer will definitely be a repeat customer! -Jonathan Jackson, Executive Director at Palmer Scholars read more

Bon Appetina's made it so easy for me to order surprise cookies for my mom, even though I live out of state. They delivered them right too her in the time frame that they gave me, and she loved them so much she had to hide them from my dad. They were attentive to detail, yummy, and helped me give her the perfect Mother's Day surprise. read more

So delicious!!!!!!!! I had these at a friend's kids' birthday party and they were decorated so cute! The shortbread is soft and is just absolutely perfect. read more

Bon Appetina saved my event!! I had a company cancel my cookie order 2 days before I needed them. I called Bon Appetina and they were able to rush my order and the cookies turned out amazing. Everyone loved them, they looked great, quick and easy ordering. read more

The best cookies ever! Had these at Fox Hallow Farm a couple weeks ago. I LOVE shortbread so was so happy when I had one, kids loved them as well. I wish she was closer, we are in Renton but we head that way enough for soccer so may have to make a pit stop one day! Beautifully decorated as well. read more

They make the best cookies! I've purchased cookies for several occasions and people always rave about them! The owner is awesome to work with! read more