It was a Serendipitous visit- as we were driving by Batesville the Sunday before Presidents' Day…read more Thought we'd just stop and see what it looked like. Forgetting all about their famous cherry Thing-A-Lings. What a surprise when we discovered they still had plenty- we splurged and picked up a dozen. Also noticed the other array of tantalizing pastries they had. The cherry Thing-A-Lings were fresh and tasty. I can see why they have a cult following. Looking forward to stopping back sometime to try some of their other favorites.

The cherry thing-a-longs are worth every single minute of the wait. The most delicious pastry with…read morecherry I have ever had.

i've been coming here for years and the baked goods are so good! love supporting a local shop, and…read morethe ambiance is nice too. the coffee is good as well, especially if you like it on the sweeter side (which i do!). only thing i haven't been a fan of is their bagel/egg sandwiches, which makes sense since they're the only thing to my knowledge that's not made in house. would recommend the brownies, muffins, quiches, and frappes for sure!

Chocolate chip cookies was undercooked, greasy, and had almost no chocolate in it. Really yucky…read more On the other hand, the cinnamon roll was classic pure goodness and great flavor. I really wanted to try the coffee cake cookie as I have never seen that cookie flavor, but one cookie was enough. They should list the prices on the items in their display case. The woman working at the counter was very nice - thank you for that. But if you can't make a decent chocolate chip cookie, stop offering them.

I have been generally dissatisfied with donuts in Indiana. These are the best I've found so far,…read morebut they're not perfect. I'll give them credit for being fresh-fried and having a good dough flavor. The apple fritter was particularly good, with nice big chunks of apple. However, I found some of the donuts (especially the glazed) to be too soft, and many donuts had so much sweetness in the dough that it was overwhelming when taken together with the glaze. They definitely deserve their reputation and their regular crowd, but I don't think I'd make a special trip from Bloomington.

Thanks, fellow Yelpers, for sending me to Magic Morning Bakery. The 5 star rating for this little…read morebakery is well deserved. There were many patrons going in and out with bags of donuts when I arrived early morning. I needed a treat to take to an event and, of course, I found out last minute. The shop is pristine and simple. The cases were filled with amazing donuts, cookies and cakes. There was so much to chose from. Those cream pies were incredibly tempting. I opted for a tray of turtle brownies. The brownies were smothered in caramel and nuts. The chocolate brownies was the consistency of a rich fudge. Needless to say, the brownies disappeared fast, so fast that I didn't have a chance to get a photo. The service was quick and friendly and I was off in a flash. Prices are incredibly reasonable. I plan on trying those iconic cookies on my next visit. I highly, recommend.

Their baked goods are the best! "Only 2 people in store at a…read moretime" policy is so strange to me though... slows the line so much... I asked them if it's a Covid thing, and they said it's because "it can get too loud," what?? I just want to take a minute to see what's available before I order, I won't make any noise!

If you enjoy waiting outside no matter the weather this is the bakery to visit, they only allow 2…read morecustomers in at a time which is ridiculous. The GF selection is average at best. And to cap it all of the parking situation is terrible.

I grew up with my dad taking me for a donut just the two of us and have a soft spot for local donut…read moreshops. We had to do some paperwork at Edward Jones and had heard about the donuts next door. We have driven by this place at least 100 times visiting my husband's family, we simply had to check it out this time. Walked in and we were warmly greated. When we said we were first timers, the sweet woman that was chatting with us said we should have come earlier we were there around 10am and most of the invenotry was gone! She recommendes the sour cream cake donut and WOW! I was glad we listened, so good. We also tried the maple custard. I love custard, but not much for maple flavor but my husband gave it two thumbs up. We will be back and much earlier next time! We heard they are also adding a coffee bar soon.

I am from out of town and their information said they are open until 1pm. It is 10 am and the doors…read moreare locked and there was someone in the kitchen working. I was stopping to buy several donuts for clients. I wish hours are accurate. I made a special trip off I65 to stop because the reviews were good. I'll try the next bakery on yelp. Hopefully the next bakery in Seymour will be open since they say closes at 3 pm.

You will not be disappointed on any selection of treats. The flavors and choice change daily from…read morecookies, cupcakes, whoopie pies, etc. Check out her Facebook page for the choices of the day. I am from Seymour but reside in Indianapolis, if I could drive here weekly to get my sweet fix I would! This place is at the top of my list for favorite cupcakes! When you walk in the bakery it is decorated nicely. It feels welcoming and very clean!! There is also a fun spot for kids to play. You can enjoy your treats there or take them with you!

The donuts are so delicious and reasonably priced. I also ordered a large caramel macchiato latte…read moreand it was even better than SB coffee!

One of the best places in Salem is this place. Best donuts I've ever had. And the brownies are…read moresooooo good. The coffee is standard. Nothing crazy special. They could stand to get a better roast. Employees are very sweet and kind. Great place to hang out. Tons of seating.

I love love LOVE this place. The employees are so friendly and helpful. The items taste amazing…read more The cakes are so beautiful and the prices are very fair! Highly recommend this bakery!

OMGosh!! So fun, you grab a tray and tongs and get whatever you want! So many choices! Excellent…read moreprices and flavors! Welcome to Flavor Town! You must go check them out