Had a very nice experience at Bobby Bay's recently. I was visiting from out-of-town and my original restaurant selection was not open. I looked on Yelp and quickly pivoted here and I'm glad I did! The woman behind the counter was very kind and personable to everyone who walked in, there were free cookies that they were testing out that customers could take, and the seating was limited but clean. The big windows give nice views out to the parking lot and the rolling hills beyond. I ordered a "Rancher" which was one of the hot sandwiches. A bit like a cheesesteak but with ranch dressing and bacon. The sandwich was ready in no time at all and tasted great! Could definitely see myself coming back next time I'm in the area. read more

Bobby Bay's - Rancher - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Tough place to review. Got the Johnny Boy sandwich and fries. Johnny boy was prosciutto, thick sliced mozzarella, soprasetta, arugula and olive oil. The fries are always fantastic here! Definitely a top choice if you come here. The sandwich tasted great. The main problem I have is that I am not a fan of their rolls. The rolls are very doughy and seemed like there was too much roll for the sandwich. The service was quick and fast, the lady at the front register was very kind. Great service is always a plus in my mind for a restaurant. The location was clean, easy parking, and setup nice on the inside with plenty of seating. The price per sandwich is a little bit expensive. read more

Bobby Bay's - Johnny Boy - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

To start off this place has the feel of a nice little mom and pop sandwich shop. The seating is limited but the inside is nice, they have a variety of food on the menu, they have good taste in music and the service is really welcoming. So let's start with the fries! The crunch on the outside with a pillowy inside was great, added some salt and pepper and the fries were delicious! Now onto the Cheesesteak, it is a shaved ribeye steak sandwich with onions, whiz and cherry pepper mayo. I got no mayo which in retrospect I should've just kept it on. On cheesesteaks I don't really like the thick cuts (like Geno's) I'm more of a thinner slice which this is. There was one bite that was a bit chewier than I liked but besides that one bite the bread was great, I did have a bite of my dad's which had the cherry pepper mayo and it was really good so next time I would definitely get that. So for the Cheesesteak I would give it a solid 8/10 and overall I would say a solid 8.3/10! Definitely would recommend! read more

See all

Stopped here for lunch with my family. It was a Sunday in Lancaster which meant most of our usuals weren't open so we decided to try Bobby Bays. We ordered at the counter and sat in a booth. I got the classic burger. Burger was good but I think route 66's are better. We also got a side of loaded fries which were very good. My daughter wanted a turkey sandwich which she also enjoyed. Defintley on the pricier side for a fast casual place but I would go again if it happened to be convenient. read more

See all

As we walked into the cute, small shop kind of place, some of us were skeptical but in the end it turned out great. We ordered at the counter from a nice and helpful cashier/waitress and sat down at our table. The whole place was very clean and had nice decor and classic booths to sit at. We got our order of French fries right away and they were a great start to our meal. Soon later, we got all of our sandwiches including a tender cheesesteak, a caprese sandwich, and a turkey sandwich (they also could make a plain cheese sandwich for our 6 year old). All were delicious with fresh ingredients. The best thing throughout all the sandwiches was the fresh, soft, tasty, perfect texture bread. If I knew the bread was so good before ordering I would've ordered a few plain rolls to bring home. Overall, Bobby Bays is a great sandwich place to go for a tasty lunch out and I recommend going there. read more

Second try and the same shortcoming. Today we tried a Bobby (cheesesteak), a chicken cheesesteak, and The Turk (a turkey hoagie). Uniformly everyone complained about the narrowness and thickness of the rolls that made the sandwiches sloppy to eat and too dense. Otherwise taste is top notch. We just all wish they'd bring in more appropriate bread for these types of sandwiches. Sorry, the bread is critical, and a fail. read more

Omg this food is to die for, especially the bread. Don't skip the loaded fries either!!!

Awesome online ordering. Creative sandwiches. Cheesesteaks not overly stuffed and the diehards may not prefer their rolls but I loved my sandwich. Cherry pepper mayo amazing. All revisions to items made perfectly. Friendly woman at the counter had me out in seconds. Would gladly return. read more

We were waited on by a friendly lady on a Monday night and even though there were multiple to-go orders - our food was served within 5-10 minutes. I had the crispy chicken which I enjoyed. The flavor was GOOD. The only negative was that the bacon wasn't crispy on my sandwich or my SIL's burger. Next time I will make sure to ask for crispy bacon. All of us enjoyed our meal and will come back again. read more

See all

Not what it's hyped up to be. The restaurant was clean and there were no other patrons inside. The subs came out hot, which was expected since we were the only ones dining in at the time. The fries did not seem to be hand cut. But the fries were over cooked and not enjoyable. The cheesesteaks were overly greasy. Depending on the cut of beef, I know it might be a little greasy. Do not add oil to the bun. Too greasy to eat. Def not worth $15 a sub for a subpar sandwich. Very disappointed in this place. read more

Bobby Bay's - OG Bobby's Cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

I recently moved to Lancaster and thought it would be difficult to find a good sandwich shop... After much research and talking to friends and strangers, I discovered Bobby Bay's! The place is convenient, clean, has a very pleasant staff, and the best turkey hoagies by far. My favorite is called the Turk. My last visit I switched to a cheesesteak and it was absolutely delicious. Please give this place a try. It might not look like much from the outside, but it's definitely worth the experience. Unfortunately I eat my hoagie so fast that I forget to take pictures. Maybe next time read more

Sandwiches are definitely a step above others. Quality ingredients and really good bread. A sweet woman is the cashier occasionally. Nice place. Mortadella. read more

Bobby Bay's - Big Vito and burber - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Shopping at TANGER. Wanted a quick nosh. Fries are absolutely amazing - hot, fresh and skin on. Coleslaw - fresh, cold and just a little kick. Chicken cheesesteak with Cooper Sharp - bun just right and lots of protein. Craig got The Big Vito - bread just the right texture, fresh ingredients, lots of Italian cold cuts and the right spice. Will be back. read more

Bobby Bay's - Yummy yummy fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I'm from the St. Louis, MO area. So I was excited to try this while I was in Pennsylvania. I saw it had good reviews so figured it was worth a shot. And it was! So here's another good review. Food came out quick and was soooo yummy! read more

Bobby Bay's - Chicken Philly and fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We stopped at the new Mt.Joy location for chicken cheese steaks and all the talk about delicious sandwiches is absolutely true. Staff is very friendly and helpful. There is seating both inside and in the front of the store. read more

Giving Bobby Bays one more try with an order of their cheesesteak and the Big Vito. This time, the hubby and I were loving BB's greasy, cheezy, flavorful cheesesteak, with meat spilling out and landing on my chin, lap and most importantly, my mouth. A huge improvement from my previous visit. Unfortunately, the Big Vito could have been a huge palate success, had it not been for the heavy handed, slathering of mayo and the overly thick slice of sharp (and I mean Sharp) provolone cheese - stealing the show, so all you really taste is a very sharp cheese and a load of mayo. I suggest, thinner slices of cheese, less mayo and to lay the meat on top of each other, vice folding it, as if it were luggage. read more

Good service - nice cashier Cheesesteaks were good but a little bland for my taste Loaded fries were nice and crispy with real bacon and a good cheese sauce. Booth seating read more

Bobby Bay's - Chicken Cheesesteak and Bobbys Cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

HEY BOBBY BAY YOU MADE MY DAY YOUD BEAT BOBBY FLAY THERE IS NO AMOUNT I WOULDNT PAY ANYONE WHO GIVES THIS LESS THAN 5 IS CRAY Ok, but really this is fantastic. The sandwiches are in the mid-teens for price but I could easily get two meals from one sandwich (they are 10in). You really can't compare the cost to other spots when they are baking the rolls fresh, cooking everything and using high quality meats and cheeses. The Italian was even excellent the next day after it spent 4 hours in the danger zone unrefrigerated. The bread is tremendous. Fries were good but wouldn't get again. read more

See all

I loved Bobby Bay's!! we had the Sorrento Salad and Don Parma, and The Turk. The service was quick and sandwiches were delicious. Although you wouldn't necessarily come here for salad, they are not to be slept on because ours was delicious too. The inside is cute and well decorated, if a little small. Would love to come back soon and try another of their unique and tasty options! read more

See all

Ok when I saw the menu and the ingredients ( Truffle Whiz, cherry pepper mayo ) that I didn't know if I'd like them or not on a cheesesteak BUT! I was pleasantly surprised the ingredients went together very well and the beef was a high grade meat very very delicious. read more

See all

Food was fair, not very good, my wife couldn't finish hers (due to not caring for it). Prices were fairly high for what you actually get.

Nice little sub shop. This was our second time at Bobby's. Got the Italian and Cali Cheesesteak. Both were delicious. The sub rolls are good. Subs were made quickly. read more

Bobby Bay's - Italian sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Stopped in for lunch. Had cheesesteaks with beef and chicken. The sauce was good as the bread but needed more meat. The timing was good.

We very much enjoyed our sandwiches from Bobby Bay's. Fresh ingredients and great bread that really hit the spot. Call ahead or order when you get there. read more

Bobby Bay's - el Ricky and Cali Style - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Awesome subs! I've have hot and cold subs and they're all 5/5! This is my new go to Lancaster spots for subs.

Place was very clean. Wife and I ordered the same sandwich. Her sandwich looked good. My sandwich? Roll was burnt and very little meat...extremely dry. We traveled a good distance based on reviews...my bad. read more

Excellent. Food was fresh, tasted great. Perfect on the go, quick meal. Will eat here again when we are back in the area. read more

Excellent!! My brother and I were up here for a funeral and decided to have an early lunch. I had the Diablo and he had the JohnnyBoy. The bread was fresh baked and delicious and the subs were large. Mediterranean fries had a layering of flavors. Highly recommended! read more

Bobby Bay's - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

The sub was great and they even opened earlier since we were waiting outside. Thanks for the great customer service.

Great sandwich place in Lancaster. Quaint sandwich shop with lots of excellent options. I got The Turk and it was delicious. They make their own bread and it made the sandwich. Different flavor profiles than typical but also some standards with their own twist. Friendly staff and quieter atmosphere. Would highly recommend for lunch. Quick and efficient service. read more

Bobby Bay's - Half of The Turk-House made bread, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo, Finlandia Swiss, advocacies and I added pickles. - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

First time and sorry it took this long. Nice selection and definitely quality items. Our food was out in short time.

Friendly staff, the Tuscan fries were quite good as was the BLTA, but the reason I will be coming back is the Chicken Cheesesteak! read more

Bobby Bay's - Half of a chicken cheesesteak, BLTA and Mediterranean Fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Most definitely the best sandwich place in town with a fresh selection and awesome bread. Highly recommend for your next pickup order!

Me and my girlfriend drove 40 minutes to bobby bays and the customer service wasn't the best the lady at the counter wasn't very welcoming and had a look on her face the whole time we were ordering,she talked like she was in a rush also when we were eating we noticed her giving another customer attitude and making faces while he ordered, for the food the loaded fries were very good,the papi burger was very salty it had potential with the sweet and spiciness it had but was the saltiness was just over powering which made it hard to to enjoy the bobby cheesesteak was very good but honestly not worth dealing with the attitude read more

We tried Bobby bay's for the first time today at the new location in Mount Joy. It was delicious! But I was kind a little bummed with how thick the prosciutto was. I think they may be slicing it themselves(?). Maybe slice it thinner, it'll be easier to digest and chew. I am in the industry myself and after studying at the culinary institute of America, we were always taught to slice prosciutto real thin. It just tastes better too and digests better. My husband got the caprese sandwich and he loved it cause it was light but we both agreed it could use a little more mozzarella since that is the main component. He said maybe a juicier tomato that's ripe enough. Maybe leave the mozzarella in the water as well and he said maybe a little more basil. The bread was delicious and easy to eat and we loved that! Other than that, it was delicious and affordable and we will be back! read more

Bobby Bay's - Caprese - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Have tried the Bobby's Cheesesteak and the Chicken Cheesesteak... both very good. Cherry pepper mayo was surprisingly very tasty in both, especially tasted it more in the chicken cheesesteak. Bread stayed fresh/crunchy on the outside even with it loaded with everything on the inside. Service was quick both ordering in the restaurant, and ordering online. Small place but some seating available. read more

Quality ingredients and quick service. Just heard about this place so figured I'd try it. Make sure you read the menu because they don't make things like the italian the traditional way I'm used to. My gf liked the salad as well. cole slaw was way too watery but the flavor was great. Potato salad was good too read more

Bobby Bay's - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Sorry but to pay $17.00 for lunch is crazy. The view is worth it though....a cemetery! Wondered how they could afford the sales price on the property ..... now I know how. Sorry I won't be back Heard a guy ask if they had a turkey/ham combo....the answer from girl was a flat out NO...really you couldn't offer adding turkey to the ham? Give it a year to stay in business read more

It is a typical sandwich shop. I stopped by to pick up. The Cobb salad and chef salad were fresh and crispy. The cheesesteak was to die for.. It is nice to have another choice at this end of town. The food is fresh and not high in sodium like the fast food restaurants. Give it a try it is well worth it. read more

Ordered takeout from here, the Bobby cheesesteak was SO good I even had the second half the next day and it was still delicious. Will definitely order again, fries were decent as well. My boyfriend had a burger (2 patties) very delicious, he enjoyed. read more