While our first impressions left us a little concerned, when the food arrived, we weren't disappointed! There was only one young man there when we arrived who took our orders and then said "this may take a few minutes, I'm the only one here and I don't know how to make the sandwiches". We then sat in the dark dining room wondering if we made the right choice and what to expect. About 25 minutes later (as promised) he came out with our food. They looked and tasted fantastic! A second older man brought out the last one and apologized for his absence as he had been delayed while buying supplies. He turned on the lights and we had an excellent lunch (along with a good story). If you like a great cheese steak sandwich, on tasty bread, this is the place in Red Lion. It is staying on our list for our next visit! read more

They have my very favorite cheese steak! They are filled to over-flowing with meat! Should probably be eaten in two meals, but it is sooo good that I always eat the whole thing!!!! As others have said, you sometimes have to wait a bit for your order as there is usually only one person there, but they are worth the wait! read more

Been both to eat in and carry out. Highly recommended by locals, justified by tasty, overstuffed subs. Generally quickly prepared. Just beware of the up-charge for credit card use. read more

Got the spicy Italian toasted and fries. The flavor in the sub was very good and the lettuce was very good quality. The fries were also very good. Ordered pick up and it took a little longer than expected but no big deal. I wouldn't go back for the Italian but would be interested in trying o it the cheesesteak. The prices are not bad for what you get as you can tell all the ingredients are fresh and high quality. read more

the best, it's amazing, deliciousauthentic three meals in one steak sub philly authentic cheese steak one hundred percent

Yummy chopped cheesesteak subs, $15 with huge amount of chopped rib eye, we split one. Street parking by only, wings and burgers but did not sample them. read more

Great food especially the subs and great service and staff. Support local businesses is key for their success. You won't regret giving Broadway Sub Shop a try. read more

Even with the opening of Hefty Lefty's at Franklin Street Social, Broadway Subshop still has the best cheestesteaks in the area. So much easier to get in and out of, too. read more

I will never support this business after my interaction with the owners. I wanted to try it out and get a cheesesteak. I told my father I was going to get food there and he told me about a situation when he went . When the cashier was giving him the change for his order they kept the bills and put it in the tip jar and handed back the coins to my father. My father, a retired police officer who served this community for over 35 years didn't want to say anything and make a big deal of it. Maybe they would get offended and do something to the food. Anyway I was still going to get food there, but I was going to let them know of the incident that occurred in the past. Come to find out the cashier was their son. A simple apology would have sufficed. But no, I was met with aggression, condescending tone, and disrespect. They said our son wouldn't do that, taking no accountability. I said my father was a police officer for this community, he wouldn't lie about that. The husband said he wanted to talk man to man with me like he wanted to fight, asking why my father didn't say anything. The husband says we don't even want to serve people like that ( my father is a 78 year old man not looking for problems) then said my father was probably a grimy cop who would ruin peoples lives for no reason. (Which doesn't make sense because your life only gets ruined if there is evidence for conviction.) This is how they feel about people that dedicate their lives to this community. The wife kept pushing the 2 dollar bills in face saying since it was such a big deal take the money. I didn't touch it. She left it on the counter, condescendingly telling me to take it. To me it's not about the money. It's about right and wrong. They could have just said sorry about that we will look into it. I even told them I don't want anything to make up for it. I was even still going to order food and support them. I just wanted to let them know. But after being talked to with blatant disrespect I will never support this families business and I will inform everyone I know about this horrible interaction at broadway sub shop. Go to golden crust or central pizza. Those families deserve the support, they won't treat you like this. Edit: you have cameras put up the video if it wasn't true. Not the way to run a business. Still no accountability. read more

I had their overstuffed cheesesteak ! I was shocked on how fulfilling, cheesy & awesome it tasted ! Broadway Subshop is 10 x's better than any cheesesteak in Philadelphia. Even better than the legendary Pat's Steaks & Geno's. The service is very exceptional! They always are courteous, friendly & treat me like family when I go in to their establishment! Trust me they are the best light years ahead of the rest ! read more

Broadway Subshop - A big Thumbs up for Broadway Sub Shop of Red Lion, PA ! - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

Visiting from Chicago and this is my first time having a cheese steak that did not have have peppers lmao, this hit the spot. it was FILLED and it was seasoned good. 10/10 would reccomend coming especially if you are not able to make it to Philly like me. Ty yall, keep doing what you are doing . Very nice people read more

See all

Got an authentic Philly Cheesesteak at this spot. It was every bit delicious as getting one in South Philly. Wiz and meat juice were oozing out of the soft yet crispy roll and the fries were perfectly golden brown and hot, doused them with some malt vinegar and got down on my food. Wow! The owner and his son run the joint and they both checked on me to see if the food was satisfactory, he even chatted with us for a few minutes which was really cool. When you are in downtown York, PA make sure you hit this small sandwich shop, you won't regret it. read more

Fantastic Sun Shop HUGE portions and fair prices. The traditional Philly cheesesteak was everything it should be. We will be back! read more

Broadway Subshop - Chopped cheesesteak left and Philly cheesesteak right - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

See all

Here is the real truth they make excelent subs with one exception All the subs with burgers are strips of burger maybe at te most half of one burger is in a half of the sub.I am not paying that kind of money anymore for those. This is the only place I have ever encounted this and it will the last. Honest un biased reveiw. Sorry I don,t sugar coat the truth read more

OUTSTANDING I'm a cheesesteak snob, and more importantly an Italian Roast Pork proponent. This place NAILS them both. The steak is so overstuffed, you can't possibly be disappointed. And it's fresh quality beef! Pro Move: get them to sub in the sharp provolone. But the STAR of the show was that Roast Pork. Primos is my all time favorite for Italian cold cut hoagies..but their Roast Pork had some terrible pork on it. I was expecting similar here. Wrong. The pork itself is freshly roasted in its own juices. You can tell. Big hunks and strands. The sharp provolone is legit (it's in crumbles, not slices). And that broccoli rabe is dead-on. Garlicky, juicy, just the right amount of bitter. Every single time I'm in town, I'm stopping by for one of each. read more

Broadway Subshop - Italian Roast Pork (left) and Mushroom Cheesesteak with sharp provolone subbed in (right) - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

This is our 3rd time eating at the Broadway Subshop. I've gotten a chop steak twice and an Italian cold cut tonight, toasted. These folks have yet to disappoint. The ingredients are always fresh and they get our special requests right every time. They take a little bit longer, but I think there's a few reasons, none that are bad: they take the time to get each order right, they run a tight ship as a FAMILY run business, and let's face it, they're busy, and for good reason; they make excellent subs. I look forward to my next order! Thank you Broadway family for another excellent Friday night dinner. read more

Pretty good food! And a good cheesesteak too. Food takes about 30/45 mins to prepare but i would think it's worth it. Also very good cheese fries. read more

New in the area. Definitely don't skimp people. My date had the Philly Cheesesteak and I had the California cheesesteak and we ordered cheese fries. Everything was amazing. Will definitely go back. read more

Great flavor and plenty of meat!!!! Ordered the mushroom cheesesteak with light sauce. I've been wanting to try them for awhile and I'm glad I finally did!!! read more

Broadway Subshop - Mushroom cheesesteak. Light sauce - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

See all

Good burgers, fast service and great employees. Will go back again. The atmosphere was also very good. Thank you

Amazing food. Hands down!! Will definitely go back. Cheesesteak are delicious and you definitely get your moneys worth of food.

I'm from the area but moved to Alabama, I came home to Windsor for a visit and my family wanted to try this place. Now in Alabama there are no good pizza shops like home and heaven forbid they think they can make cheesesteaks or cheeseburger subs. My cousin got a Cali cheesesteak, her hubs tge cheesesteak with mushrooms and I got the cheeseburger sub... OMG talk about fat subs, so much meat and veggies, they were perfect, wait is there a word for more perfect? They are soooo good and the price, wow the price is amazing! Definitely replaced my old go to for my cheeseburger sub, definitely taking the hubs there when I come up in May... #fatkidhappiness read more

Everything we've had from Broadway has been delicious. Their cheesesteaks are the best around. I highly recommend this place. And they're open on Monday's which not a lot of places around here are. The couple running the shop are always super friendly when we come in. Thanks guys! read more

Amazing family owned sub shop that is very accommodating to the picky eater!!!! Great food! read more

Broadway Subshop - Mac n cheese Philly cheesesteak (chicken) and a buffalo chicken cheesesteak - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

Don't go to subway, don't go to some pizza shop, just go here. Legit bread and authentic read more

Broadway Subshop - a half eaten sub sandwich - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Red Lion, Pennsylvania

All I can say is, Mac and cheese Philly Steak. Everything on the menu is fantastic. Local family ran business. Put them on the top of your list. read more

Ok, I consider myself somewhat of a Philly cheesesteak aficionado. I have been going to Philadelphia since the 1980's. I pretty much have tried all the well known cheesesteak brands out there. There's some really good ones (Jims, Dalessandro's) then there's some REALLY BAD ones (Pat's,Geno's)ugh. If you are a purist like me, you order your steak "wiz-wit" which means cheese wiz and onions. So, I definitely know what a real Philly steak tastes like! My brother, recommended that I try Broadway Sub Shop for a cheesesteak. He told me they are everything a Philly steak should be. Well...I decided to go check this place out. All I can say is WOW! I was blown away at the fact of how much it tasted exactly what I'm used to! Other places in the York area claim to make Philly style steaks, but they are imposters. I mean, this cheesesteak is straight up LEGIT man! Thinly sliced and chopped meat, real cheese wiz, rough cut onions, fresh baked local roll. I'm talking epic proportions! Smile factor of 10. It most reminds me of Dalessandro's steaks in Philly. Can't wait to go back. I live about 2 miles away and I'll be a regular at this place no doubt. Kudos to the owner... You have something special here! read more

We ordered subs this evening and they were delicious! Our subs were filled to the top with meat and the owner was extremely friendly. We will definitely return! read more

i had high hopes for this place after seeing the google reviews that must be friends of the owners . Unfortunately ,this buisness did not live up to the reviews . Waiter was great . Very respectable . My food was a different story . Half of my California cheese steak was hard as a rock the other half turned to mush while trying to eat it . Cheap cheese , cheap bread ,cheap ingredients . not what i expected from a buisness that is supposed to specialize in cheese steaks. Staff was slightly snappy aswell . Would not recommend and will not be going back. read more

Tried this place for the first time last week. Really good cheeseburger sub. So glad to have a sub shop around that uses traditional soft sub rolls instead of the flatness with the harder crust most PA sub shops around use. The guy that took my order was really friendly and even gave our dog in the truck a treat. read more

Best cheesesteaks period...... Tender cheesy goodness.

Great cheese steaks! ESP the Mac and cheese cheese steak! They were busy that night and worth the hour and fifteen min Waite! Staff was friendly and quick once I got the the shop to get my food! Will be going back for sure! read more

We tried this sub shop for dinner this evening. It was awesome! Plenty of meat in my cheeseburger sub & my husband had a California cheesesteak that was delicious. I saved the other half of mine for lunch tomorrow. Large sized subs for a great price! They were wonderful! Try it out--you'll be delighted!! read more

we waited nearly a hour and half for 2 chicken tender kids meal and a sub. a hour later after waiting they told us they didn't have chicken tenders and we had to reorder then waited 20 more minutes. and they forgot cheese and our condiments. definitely need patience to eat here. and read more

I had heard a few good reviews about this little sub shop, so I thought I'd give it a try. When I called and placed the order I was a little disappointed about the wait time, an hour and fifteen. Nonetheless I decided to give it a go, because I knew it was a recent start up. I picked up the order exactly and hour and fifteen minutes later. The staff, owner I think, was extremely nice. The order looked good, so I preceded home. We unpacked the contents of our order, 3 subs and a salad. Boy were these subs packed, heavy. I thought, wow these are hearty subs. The salad was good size also. We all agreed the subs were piled with ingredients. The meat was very flavorful, and all the veggies crisp. Best sub I've had in a while. By the way it was a spicy Italian sub. The kids agreed and so did their mother, she had the salad. Long story short, excellent food, well worth the wait. Will definitely put on my list as a new favorite! read more