I have to say i'm very impressed. Everything the food the service the food, the service i highly recommend it.Pepperoni 8in pizza Blue Italian Donuts, Garlic Knots, and a Slice Cheese pizza everything was wonderful and excellent. I have to say, personally is really wonderful to be able to travel to and from places without having to travel far, which is a wonderful thing especially if you have it delivered. The ambience was really great. Not to mention, it wasn't even all that busy so I was able to get In-N-Out with my order No problem. I can't wait to come here again. read more

See all

Got here about 1 PM place was empty grabbed a few slices to go for lunch. Cool Mural from local artist in dinning area on wall. Street parking. read more

See all

Another great takeout meal from Blue Pizza. Starters Tasty meatballs with sauce and cheese Garlic Knots Greek Salad with housemade dressing Pizzas Sausage with ricotta New Jersey Grandma Pepperoni Everything was ready right on time, and delicious. Also, noticed that they have added tablecloths to increase ambiance and oregano sprinkle to add a little more zest to the pies. Always a treat with friendly service. read more

See all

After reading mixed reviews, I took the chance of ordering from Blue Pizza. By the looks of the picture, you should be able to understand my disappointment. The pizza was overcooked and the presentation was horrible. I did order close to closing time but still expected a great, quality product. The dough has potential but the shrimp was overcooked and the sauce was bland. Not sure I would order again since my first experience was not the best. read more

Blue Pizza - Buffalo shrimp pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

Blue Pizza wasn't great. I stopped in for a slice to check it out, and I wasn't really impressed. I really liked the amazing artwork of a whale on the wall, and the staff member was really nice, but other than that, there weren't many positives. All of the tables were covered in crumbs, the condiment station was nasty, and my slice of pizza was good, but not quite worth the $5 I paid for it. I might stop in some time in the future, but there's a lot of better chain and local options than this one. read more

See all

Blue Pizza is now open in a new location near USC on Devine street on the side of Fire House Subs. The space is nice big and open and the staff are very friendly. The pizza remains delicious. In fact, it's the best pizza in Columbia at this time in my opinion. I often get the traditional Grandma Pizza, my husband's favorite. We haven't had this pizza since leaving Queens! Blue Pizza is a gem! Love, Live Love it! read more

Great pizza and subs. Good customer service and prices. Lots of topping to pick from

Finally GRET PIZZA IN COLUMBIA PROPER! Thin crust and convenient location (formerly Nikki's) that has really awesome tri-state style pizza. The service from Logan was awesome and they offer a military discount! read more

I was not expecting much because of the three star rating. It was light one night, and I believe they are on Door Dash which is where we placed an order. We ordered a 16" carnivore pizza. Again given the review rating, my expectations were low. However, when I opened the box, I was pleasantly surprised. It looked amazing. The slices are a great size, plentiful toppings and cheese, and a nice crust. The pizza was delicious. My favorite pizza place has some competition. read more

Blue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

See all

Food, service and atmosphere was great. Nice place to grab a pizza and people watch. read more

Blue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

Now that I've had this about 2-3 times, I feel I can confidently leave a review. I'm a northern transplant from NJ, and I can safely say this pizza reminds me of home. The crust is thin and crunchy, and the taste is pretty dang spot on. Folding a slice and eating it, I wouldn't be able to tell an NJ slice and a blue pizza slice apart. I will say, there's been a pizza we ordered where there was far too much grease for my liking, but that's pretty typical of NJ pizza anyway. So, while annoying, it is authentic. The things we've ordered so far were: - 2 plain slices - garlic knots - 1/2 plain 1/2 bacon pizza - 1/2 plain 1/2 bacon & chicken pizza The slices, like any NJ joint, were kind of lackluster. But I'm a firm believer that you should never judge an NJ pizza spot on their slices. So, that's why we got some pies and waited to review. Disappointingly, the garlic knots suck. I would say it nicer, but really there's no way to get around it. They suck. They barely tasted like garlic, and I could probably get better ones at Publix. That being said, it didn't deter me from coming back. I just was pretty miffed. The 1/2 plain, 1/2 bacon pie was pretty good, coming from someone who doesn't really like bacon all that much. This was the pie that was a bit too greasy for my liking. I'd say it was the bacon, but my next order said otherwise. The 1/2 plain, 1/2 bacon & chicken pie was the best thing I've eaten from this place. My partner had a hankering for a chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza and unfortunately for him I'm not a big fan of ranch, so we settled with this. I have to say, it had us wishing we got the whole pie as chicken & bacon. It was that good. AND it wasn't greasy. Overall, I'd say this is a great place to go if you want a taste of home, or if you're looking for some authentic NJ pies. Really hope they add stuff like cheesesteaks, hoagies, etc in the future. **Ratings: Plain slices: 5/10 Garlic knots: 2.5/10 1/2 plain, 1/2 bacon pie: 6/10 1/2 plain, 1/2 bacon & chicken pie: 8.5/10 I'll give this place a 4.2/5 for now. Price: ~$20 for a large pie. Pretty standard. read more

Blue Pizza - 1/2 bacon 1/2 plain large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

The worst pizza I've ever had in my life. I ordered through GrubHub. The pizza was tough, the edges were inedible. I spent a lot of money on a shrimp scampi pizza. There was like 1 piece of shrimp pretty slice of pizza. Greasy sauce (and hardly any of that), no where near enough cheese, just basically disgusting. Didn't look anything like the picture on the website. Don't waste your money, go elsewhere. I've had better pizza from a gas station. Rip off. read more

Blue Pizza - Terrible pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

Really good pizza, restaurant is a bit of a dive. But the zah makes up for it. Good fresh dough and sauce.

Tried Blue Pizza on a whim with my wife and loved every minute and bite of the experience! Not only was the food excellent, but so was the service. The two gentlemen that made our order and served us did everything to go above and beyond! the seating was a tad small so if you're in a big group you may want to give them a heads up but we would both recommend this place to anybody and everybody!!! read more

Blue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

Pizza was good ! Had a slice of cheese and a chicken bacon range . Was a quality piece of pizza. Def will be back if in by that way ! Customer Service was great Also!!! read more

I have ordered from Blue pizza multiple times now My go to order - margharita add pepperoni Haven't gotten anything else but this will make you happy! read more

Best pizza in Columbia. Jersey style. Their garlic knots are amazing-so light and airy. Not heavy and filling. The pizza is not greasy and super fresh. The family Owners are all so nice. Try the jalapeño pineapple. Delicious. Eating there tonight!! read more

Hi. Blue pizza SC is an awesome pizza place! Logan served me and was expedient, friendly and helpful! I had the caprese salad which was yummy. Then I ordered a personal cheese with pineapple, black olives & mushrooms & extra red.sauce. Twas yummy! Ambience is very casual with average noise. 5 stars! I shall return! read more

Everything is wonderful, their red sauce is truly amazing. Love the donuts and the white pizza too, this place is great! I'm super picky about pizza, and this place meets all of my standards beautifully read more

See all

I am a Grandma slice believer. Perfect Sunday pizza. The staff is so friendly. If you order consistently they feel like family. Ambience is blue as hell. Small kitchen with wicked good food. read more

Blue Pizza - New Jersey Grandma 16in - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

See all

Delicious pizza and friendly service. We added ricotta and mushroom to the Andrew Miller pizza. I would suggest take-out instead of dine-in but definitely will order again! read more

Blue Pizza - Andrew Miller pizza with mushroom & ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

See all

Pretty close to NY/NJ style pizza. Definitely filled the missing void for this Long Island transplant.

Worst run business I've ever seen. Most nights it will take you 45 minutes to get one slice of pizza. The pizza is pretty good but get ready to wait 8 years for it. Ridiculous. read more

Delicious pizza and quick service. The NJ pizza was perfect. Highly recommend! Go get a pizza! read more

Blue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, South Carolina

Great pizza with some great options too! Donny took care of me on check out and the service was excellent!

I like the low-key vibe of the place. The outdoor seating is a nice area to enjoy your meal. Our server was very timely with being things out, checking on us, etc. The inside looks a little rundown, but we came for pizza. The carnivore was very good. At lot of places have a hard time with pizzas of that nature, as it's usually too greasy, but they nailed it. Kids liked the cheese pizza as well. The one drawback is that they do t have fountain drinks, only cans, so you're limited on your beverages unless you feel like buying multiple. Overall one of the better pizza spots in Columbia. Would definitely recommend. read more

The pizza we ordered was not good and was in fact almost inedible (in our opinion). It was very bland, lacking in herbs and spices. It was overcooked, the cheese was not tasty and the sauce was far too sweet. I wanted to like it, because we love NJ style pizza (my husband's family is from new jersey, we are very familiar with that style of pizza), but this was not a good experience. We do not recommend Blue Pizza. read more

Trash. I'm from up top and this is just not it! crunchy thin crust, sauce has no flavor, and way too much for one slice of cardboard. The service was excellent though. read more

This is a great pizza. The style is very different from other area pizzas. It is crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. The flavors are on point. The antipasto salad will amaze you. If you are looking for a unique pizza experience, go here! read more

Sauce was horrible pizza and meatball sandwich were burnt and very hard For $36 for the two items I would have expected a little better food. We also didn't get the chips and pickle that were supposed to come with the sandwich. Their sauce is very acidic and the meatballs tatsted like frozen store brand read more

Got the Margaritaville pizza and it was one of the best Margherita pizzas I have had. I wish I had taken a picture before I dived in but it just looked too good. read more

Order to go from there. Got pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knit were dry and had no taste what do ever. Even the marinara tasted bland. The pizza I order wasn't even prepared like the description. Again, it was bland and chewy. read more