This traditional Pizza kitchen place serves up excellent food, and our wonderful server, Cindy, made sure we received great service throughout our visit. For appetizers, we had the Roasted Gorgonzola Chips and Calamari Rings, which came with a tasty homemade marinara sauce. For our entrée, we shared the Penne al Basilico with Meatballs. Everything was absolutely delicious, with generous portions. What a great place. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Pizza was amazing as always, beer cold and our waiter took good care of us including boxing up the leftovers.

We had the meatballs and a pepperoni pizza and both were great! Everything was freshly made with great flavor! Service was wonderful the entire staff from DJ to Dara, they were vibrant, kind and helpful. The restaurant is clean with fitting decor, the outdoor patio offers comfortable shading in the afternoon. Had a great experience and will definitely be back. read more

The pizza is always excellent-we've enjoyed this place for over 5 years. We typically do take out, but have also eaten in, and the service has been great with both. read more

Had the Italian sub!! I got it to go and I hate when subs get soggy... BUT... they put the olive oil and vinegar on the side so amazing. 5 star read more

We always order to go. It is always warm, delicious, and never seems to be enough! The buffalo chicken pizza and stromboli are a must. Even just a "cheese" pie as the south calls it is amazing. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

I can't say enough good things about Tonella's! Everyone there is so nice, always great service and the food is fantastic. And if you like bread... I mean who doesn't... get a loaf of their homemade bread and have them slice it and served with some marinara sauce for dipping as an appetizer!!!! Can't go wrong!!!! read more

The food is always great. The service is always great. This is our favorite place to dine out.

Our go- to! Simply the best pizza with freshest ingredients!! The staff is always friendly

Awesome pizza. Fresh , hot, a really good pie. Friendly staff. I recommend this restaurant to all pizza lovers.

Great food and great service -- we love their lasagna and garlic knots! Haven't tried the pizza yet, but their pastas are very good. Atmosphere is nice and comfortable. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Penne Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

See all

This restaurant has the best wait staff than most in this area! Very friendly and knowledgeable and helpful. The food here from pizza to stuffed shells is fabulous. Highly recommend this Italian restaurant!! read more

Food and service were both very good. I prefer Tonella's to the Italian chain restaurants.

Food is always good. Staff makes you feel like you are part of the family. Love the bruschetta. read more

Nice place and Its been around for a while. I usually go for lunch and get the 2 slice special . Always good , never disappointing . Happy customer here. Excellent NY style pizza , I really like the crust and cheese . Very friendly staff too. read more

We were on vacation and one day decided we did not want to cook. We ordered pizza from here and it was delicious! It was close by to where we were staying so it was a win win situation. We got a large for 4 of us and it was honestly too much lol read more

Very good! We just moved to the area and I was tasked with picking up the pizza. I Yelped to find a good place and I read the reviews and settled on here. I am glad we did! The fact the place was hopping when I went in was a good sign. The service is prompt and friendly and even the patrons were nice. I ordered the Margherita pizza and the Supreme. I added the Tuscan salad for good measure and I topped it off with a cannoli. The pizza is excellent! Thinner crust, very flavorful and a decent amount of toppings. You can't ask for more! I put the salad in the fridge and it was even good the next day! I am definitely coming back! read more

Called and explained pizza was inedible and owner said the cook used a little to much olive oil! And a new cook ?!Didn't offer refund only credit ! This is the furthest thing from New York pizza I've ever seen!!!! I lived in New York City! Raw dough , oily grocery store cheese , garlic from a jar, actually negative 1 star if was an option read more

See all

I really want to like Tonella's but I just think it's too expensive for what it is. The food is kind of basic and quite bland. Service is alright though, and it gives a family feel. read more

Service and Pizza is amazing The gentleman who answers the phone to take orders is always so uplifting and amazing read more

We just moved here a few months back, and have tried many local pizza places. Only one of all those has been good, until today! Tonellas is now going to be our new go to! We decided to try something new today and so glad we did. The service was fast and our waitress, sherry, was just so sweet and amazing. And you really can't beat a true ny style pizza, but good luck finding someone who can make one good down here, unless you go here. It was SO good! We had the left overs for dinner, and the crust heated up perfectly. We opted to choose our own toppings, but I'm sure they are all delicious! I was too full for dessert but next time, going to try the grilled pound cake, it sounds devine! read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Large NY crust meatball, mushroom and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

Great little puzza place - reminds me of a NYC pizzeria. The thin crust pizza is delicious , salads are nice, and the staff/service are excellent. Plus, they offer gluten free pizza crusts! I love Tonella's! read more

Mediocre experience for more expensive yet mediocre pizza than Bellacino's Grinders. I have to say the couple of times I've been here it's been slow and so has the service. Don't recommend. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - How busy it was. - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

Great New York style pizza, got the supreme, it was fabulous. Also got the sausage with peppers, onions, and sauce. Highly recommend.

Pizza tasted good and had great thickness, the best NY style crust I have had in a long time

I call into get a to go and had to call back 3 times by the time I got to the parking lot I was making my order from the parking lot. Food was ok! Only eat there every 3 months. Wish it was just a bit better. read more

Tonellas has always been a great Italian pizza restaurant. It is well liked in our community and we absolutely love the pizza, lasagna and garlic knots. The bread is awesome too. read more

We checked the reviews and should have followed our instinct. Service was ok but the food was sub par. The serving size was ridiculously small and prices were clearly too high. We overheard the table next to us discussing their disappointment as well. read more

Paid $20 for a medium pizza with 2x pepperoni and mushrooms. I wouldn't be posting this if it was an isolated incident of topping skimping, but it seems to be the norm now at this place. And that is a shame. The crust and sauce are good, truly NY/NJ style pizza. It just seems like the more their business grows, the less they care about detail. Oh, well, Dano's is the best pizzeria in the Columbia area, so I will just drive farther to get the best. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

Really good NY style pizza. Not a lot of variety in toppings. Basic traditional toppings. Crazy expensive.

We moved here from New Jersey and were so thankful to find this restaurant. We desperately missed real Italian pizza with the thin crust until we happened upon this place. It's delicious! We go once a week ever since we discovered them. Their other dishes are good as well. The staff is so friendly and they go out of their way to make sure you are happy with your meal. On Wednesdays it's half off beer and wine. They get a crowd that night, and it's a lot of "regulars", which means the food is consistently good. They also have carry out. I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Delicious thin crust pizza! Real Italian style! - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

Do not order the garlic knots, they are nothing like a garlic knot should be, they were sweet and VERY buttery with zero garlic and also semi raw and uncooked. The grandmas pie was Eh, must be the same dough bc it wasn't a traditional tasting crust. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - The laughable garlic knots... do not order - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

It's been a few months since I came here, but it's hard to forget how great of an experience I had. The service we received was absolutely perfect and the food lived up to my high expectations. I heard the pizza tasted like NY pizza from a fellow New Yorker friend of mine, so my expectations were immediately raised because I have high standards for NY style pizza, since I grew up eating it my whole life. Little did I know this little restaurant was the one... the one to have the closest flavor and texture I've ever tasted to the real thing without actually being in NYC. We didn't try anything else on the menu, but that dish and the service in itself were all I needed to write this review. read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

This establishment has been around for a long time with pizza that was truly indicative of a NY pizza. However, over the last several years it appears the goal has been to reduce the quality of the pizza, elevate their pricing to where their pizza is not even close to a NY pizza. It may look like one in the box but the shrinking amount of dough and its quality has reduced their pizza to that of a flatbread pizza. We recently ordered two pies and were thoroughly disappointed with the awful quality of pizza's that they charge you in excess of $50. As someone who has grown up with NY pizza, their pizza today doesn't remotely resemble a NY pizza. They're also very skimpy on the sides which they charge a hefty amount for the limited quantity. The flavor of the sauce is very good but the dough is awful which is also important in a quality pie. The crust doesn't even rise and anyone who has truly had a NY pizza knows the crust rises very nicely and even has large bubbles along a crust. Some folks who enjoy a good NY pizza actually relish the crust and butter it but the pies we had recently were flat and tasteless. It is disappointing as we used to call this our go to pizza but for the price you're wasting a lot of money. read more

had pizza there a couple months ago. was not eatable. Worse pizza I ever had. loaded with cheese and semi raw dough. Didn't even deserve 1 star. read more

Decent pizza here. Since moving from NY, we have yet to find a comparable or near comparable pizza. This is a 6 out of 10 at best. Very expensive too add. Skip the dinners and especially "to go" . Be more reasonable on the prices Mr. Owner! read more

Been a few years since we visited Tonellas until recently. Was pleasantly surprised. The margarita pizza was fresh and just what we were looking for. We took our server Paulette's advice and got the seasonal bread pudding (apple cinnamon). It was ridiculous. We will be back for more pizza and bread pudding! read more

Tonella's Pizza Kitchen - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

See all

I'm elderly AND only frequent here maybe twice monthly . . They're quite pricey BuT assuming homemade crust ( they say ) couple weeks ago bought a med 3 item for roughly $20 ?? read more

Ordered a large cheese pie to go when I got home it was burnt! It was very expensive I expected better. No cheese in middle of pie!

The staff and service at Tonella's were amazing. They were very busy and we had a pop in group of seven, we didn't wait long at all and the place was very clean. The staff were super nice and very helpful. The food was amazing! Keep up the great works guys!!! TC read more