Came to Montauk on the off season and had to get ourselves a bacon egg and cheese while we were out…read morehere. This deli has been here for as long as I can remember coming out this way, and I was thrilled to see it was still opened during off season. We ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go. Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was giving clean, well stocked, and well organized. Prices are what they are given that it's Montauk. But my sandwich was piled high with bacon, eggs were cooked well and cheese was melted, so I really can't complain.

Excellent $10 Turkey and cheese with mayo and hot peppers sandwich. Big bag of Hal's salt and…read morepepper chips - expensive but excellent.

I went there with my family for a quick bite after the beach. Wow the baby back ribs, delicious…read more Jerk pork butt amazing and moist, iver the yellow rice with sweet plantains. Wish you were closer to home.

When grabbing lunch in Montauk this is my go-to. They have a hot buffet with lots of options. Today…read moreI got yellow rice, beans, jerk pork and cabbage (as the salad). All so good! The pork was tender and spicy! This lunch plate, a grilled cheese for my nephew and bottle of water cost $22. I didn't see a sign regarding a credit card fee but my guess is that they might have one. The employee at the register asked all customers how they were paying. No seats inside to eat. There are multiple picnic tables outside.

This review is for the ice cream. We took a wrong turn at a marina nearby while looking for ice…read morecream and happened to talk with an employee of Tony's. He had us follow him in our car and took us right to the ice cream section. OMG, what a selection. It was hard to choose. In the end we bought the half pints: original fudge ice cream sundae and rainbow cookie ice cream sundae. As we are staying 20 minutes away, the employees gave us some ice in our bag. Despite the heat, it didn't melt on the way home. The rainbow cookie ice cream sundae was far superior.

Best food out east. Everything is fresh and the meat is A+. Sandwiches are great and the Cesar wrap…read moreis the best thing on the menu. New ownership is great and it's a great buy what ever you get.

Read reviews that Herb's Market has the best fried chicken in town! And it absolutely was!…read more I was exploring Montauk Village Main St with my parents and we stumbled upon the market. Much to my surprise, the place was quite empty walking in maybe due to its huge space. My dad wanted deli meats, but I recommended the fried chicken. My parents sat down at these large picnic benches while I ordered a bunch of fried chicken by the piece! When I got to the counter, the guy informed me that there was only white meat left and that he would put in a new batch of dark meat now. I waited patiently for 15 minutes while the new batch was fried. Then, I ordered a bunch of wings, legs, and a thigh. I'm so happy we were able to order by piece because nobody likes white meat in my family even though it's the most meaty. I was also surprised that the white meat costs the most! The chicken was beautifully battered and flavored. Not too thick nor too salty! It was out of this world and it is what will bring me back to Montauk. The place also sells a bunch of pantry items, sandwiches, salads, and drinks. Once you order you pay at the cash register by the front door. Very friendly people!

Now that Montauk has morphed into a chi-chi destination, sourcing reasonably priced nutritious fare…read morehas become quite the challenge. Thank goodness Herb's Market is still around offering hearty deli sandwiches, freshly made fried chicken and ribs, beverages, salads and more. All served up by friendly young personnel with no sneering pretentious vibes in sight.

Hungry and on the beach? GO TO DITCH WITCH! I went here everyday while vacationing on the sunny…read moreDitch beach. Day 1: chipotle wrap+buffalo wrap+jamaican patty = $20 Day 1 part II : chipotle wrap+buffalo wrap+quesadilla+2frescas =$23 all of this was split between 2 people of course...2 very satisfied people. tastes best after a swim - not before!

We heard from a local friend that this place was right on the beach and that it was pretty good…read more Went there on a weekday morning and it was a great experience. The person that took our order was friendly. The food came pretty quickly and it was excellent. I had a breakfast burrito and my wife had a breakfast sandwich. Both were very good and they were definitely less expensive than one would expect in that zip code. We will be back!

A health market with fresh produce and dry goods. An extensive menu offers breakfast, lunch and…read moresmoothies, as well as coffees. Take out or eat in. Many vegan options! The smoothies are delicious and you can customize with a variety of additions. The service was fine but it did take a long time to get a salad, wrap and smoothie.

It's such a lovely spot ! I highly recommend Naturally Good if you are a fan of healthy organic…read moreplaces. I love the chili here in the winter. Super tasty baked goods - big fan of the blueberry banana gluten-free muffin!! Fresh organic juices & smoothies Great coffee Star girl made me the best latte I've ever had.

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was jammed at 7:00 on a Thursday. Price - ~$80-$100 (appetizer, entree, drink, tip) Food - 4/5 - much better than anticipated. Service - 3/5 - fine service, nothing remarkable. Ambiance - 4/5 - chill vibe with live music. Overall - 4/5 - place turned out to be much better than anticipated. Food was incredibly tasty, good variety, and fine portions. Smashed potatoes and lamb sliders were awesome. Service was fine, fast but nothing beyond that. Ambiance was nice with the live music. Although could've been some breaks here or there with it, it created a nice spot. Would definitely return. Best Dish - Smashed potatoes and lamb sliders Would Return - Definitely

Super Fantastic food!…read more From the outside kind of looks like laid back casual taco spot! Inside very causal yet cool surfer vibe. Service and margaritas were great. Not fancy! Laid back, casual! The menu and what came out of the kitchen was exceptional and "5" worthy alone. We had some sushi grade tuna tacos with crispy wonton style shells. The tacos were dressed with all the right flavors and additions you would expect from a top sushi joint. Excellent! We also had Moroccan spiced lamb sliders! Wow good! Perfect! Go to the Gig Shack just to get this! 100% worthy the trip. Id say the menu is somewhat surfer-fusion with California taco influence. There are lots of options. We are glad we tried Gig Shack and will return. Highly recommended casual, cool vibe location, with fantastic food!

"This is some Willy Wonka sh*t" - Me after tasting the Everything Bagel Martini at Bird on the…read moreRoof. Truly, the cocktails and menu at this restaurant are so inventive and flavor packed it feels as if there has to be something supernatural happening in the kitchen and behind the bar. We came here in early May and sat at the bar. Dillon took great care of us, walked us through the menu and made stellar recommendations all around. After having my mind blown by the Everything Bagel Martini, we moved on to share the charred octopus and Leggy's Thighs. The charred octopus was tender, and paired so well with the citrus fruits on this plate, plus the bite of pistachios?! So well put together. Leggy's thighs (RIP Leggy) were literally the best chicken I'd ever had, fall off the bone tender and topped off with flavorful furikake and hot pickled fresno chilis. We also split the Wagyu sando which I'm literally still thinking about. Wagyu on milkbread?! What an excellent idea. Live acoustic music was going on the night we were here which really added to the cozy ambiance. They also have trivia here on Thursdays (Dillon, if you're reading this, we hope your team wins the championship). 10/10 no notes. Come here if you can get a table.

The food is above average and the service was average. I left a ten dollar tip on a 160 dollar…read moremeal. Ten dollars is the most I tip anywhere regardless of check amount. Please Google how much waiters are paid hourly in New York State minimum. It is about 20 dollars. Only the Deep South still pay waiters a low hourly wage. After I left a tip and clearly wrote 10 dollars and clearly wrote the 170 dollar total I noticed the next day my tip was changed by staff to 29 dollars and my bill was now 190 total. I called the next day and said there was a mistake and I was accidentally overcharged. I gave the staff all the grace in the world. I was then asked if there was a problem with the service after giving 10 dollars!! These obnoxious, smug thieves were caught red handed and could not just refund my 19 dollars without first asking why I ONLY tipped 10. I was going to do a police report so it was good they at least credited back my 19 dollars they stole after I caught them. I wish I did not even leave a ten dollar tip. Waiters in New York make at least 20 an hour. You do not owe them another 20 percent. Btw they made my tip 20 percent AFTER taxes were included. I would eat here again tbh but I will pay in cash the next time. Don't use credit cards with these gonifs.

Bake shop is for take out only…read more The coffee beats anything on the Montauk strip in the morning- lots of customers, so always fresh pots served. Pastries were very good AND a bit expensive. The service is slow due to a great assortment of goodies and customers who have to get their own coffee for the first time in their life. As long as you are OK with takeout, great place to go!

A true gem in montauk! That coffee is great & the pastries are even better. We got a glazed donut,…read morecranberry scone, pecan cinnamon roll, and every flavor of rugelach. Food was so good we forgot to take pictures. Staff was friendly. A must visit!

My husband and I stopped into this deli while we were in the area recently and really enjoyed our…read moreexperience. There is no sit down inside the restaurant, but we got our food sat at the picnic tables outside, which was very nice. Our food was very very tasty my husband had a meatball sub that he said was outstanding and he eats meatball subs often so I trust his opinion. I had a salad which was so big and that I had enough for the next day and then some and it was also very tasty. The service was friendly and preparation was relatively quick and it was overall very very good experience. Highly recommend when you're in the area.

I was really craving a caprese sandwich after a beach day. I got the F1, hot, and an H1 it took…read moreabout 15 minutes to get. My bf loved his- the said solid 4. I enjoyed mine but the focaccia bread wasn't like a thick puffy light foccacia, it was thin and not very olive oily. There wasn't enough basil or tomatoes to the cheese ratio and the cheese wasn't super melty, that being said bread and cheese is never a bad combo- solid 3 for me, next time will add pesto and I think it'll be a winner Staff was okay, not very friendly. Outdoor tables very dirty. Overall solid sandwich, I would call ahead take to go to the beach.