The burger and Cookie Monster ice cream add Oreo and sprinkles are incredible The burger and Cookie Monster ice cream add Oreo and sprinkles are incredible read more

John's Drive-In - Cookie Monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

Good ice cream and milkshakes. Quick and friendly service. Prices typical for area. Parking adequate at least in off season. Cash Only.

Delish and inexpensive burgers, chicken, fries and ice cream in downtown Montauk. There is usually a line but it moves quickly. Great lunch/dinner wallet friendly joint! read more

John's Drive-In - Double cheeseburger - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Honestly quite disappointed. I was so excited to end my day trip from nassau with this local store but the flavors, price, and anount that was scooped didn't do it justice. The workers were a bit snippy and there was barely anywhere clean to sit. Not only that, the outside seating (once we did find a seat), there was a stench that just radiated from the store that made me and my boyfriend want to throw up. Prices of the scoops and whatnot were listed but additional cone selections caught us off guard with how the prices increased. Please let us know how much a waffle cone charge is gonna be beforehand. The menu is misleading. Be prepared to bring cash if you do come (as they are only cash) and be prepared to wait on a long line towards the evening. I waited about 15-20 minutes I believe. read more

John's Drive-In - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This place has unbelievable ice cream. Long lines. But goes fast A place you have to go too read more

John's Drive-In - Flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

Very classic Montauk spot - popular for a long time. Burgers, chicken nuggets, fries, etc. all fresh and delish ice cream! Cash only and the line can get long. Cute inside but sometimes messy. read more

This is my favorite ice cream that I have ever had. I have been going to this place every year for 14 years and it still amazes me how good it is read more

Best burger in the Hamptons, also one of the cheapest. Their ice cream is also fresh and really good. read more

John's Drive-In - Burger sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Love John's ice cream. Usually don't visit in the fall so was excited to see the pumpkin flavors. I got a large with pumpkin Oreo and raspberry chocolate truffle, which is what I usually order. The pumpkin Oreo was so good I wish I just got that since it's not a flavor you can usually get. read more

See all

Such great if you arrive at Montauk late at night, their burgers in front of always hit even my dog approved and she's picky but seriously nine out of 10. Recommend been going here for years. read more

John's Drive-In is such a consistent burger spot. There has never been a time that I've visited that the food wasn't freshly made, hot, and satisfying. The workers are always trying to complete the orders as quickly as possible. They were polite and well organized. Yes during the summer months, it gets extremely crowded which makes it a bit difficult to eat inside, but there's nothing like driving down to any of their many overlook parking lots and viewing the beach. If you're looking for a quick bite to eat, I recommend giving them a try. read more

John's Drive-In - Big John Burger with Waffle Fries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This place has very good food. Very authentic fried chicken, burgers, and milk shakes. We tried to get a reservation at harvest on fort pond but they were very busy so me and my wife went here to grab a bite before we went back to grab dinner later that night. I ordered a bacon cheese burgers, onion rings, and a vanilla shake that home made and the milk shake was amazing. John's makes there ice cream in house and it's out of this world. My wife got a chocolate shake which was amazing as well and an order of French fries. The food was made fresh to order and was one the best burger/ chicken spots I been to in a while. Very authentic fried chicken and burgers. You could smell the goodness brewing from down the block coming from John's. Definitely a great spot to check out if you're staying in Montouk. I ruined my appetite later on that night and didn't get to enjoy dinner cause I ate like a fat boy here and it was totally worth it. This place is a staple in Montouk. The staff are all family and black owned and very nice people. Def give these folks a try! read more

See all

CASH ONLY! We stopped in for a quick lunch. I had the burger and it was meh. The meat to bread ratio was good but I didn't like the texture of the meat. I tried a French fry from the other person's order and it was good. I was watching my carbs so I stopped at just one. read more

See all

This is over-priced, fried carnival food. This could be a really great place to eat because of the location and how they present online but it does not deliver. Very corporate, soulless experience all around. No old time vibe or service. It's unfortunate read more

On the way back from Montauk this past Saturday night, stopped in John's Drive-In for some late night grub. I grabbed a chicken caesar salad and a coffee ice cream... both were sooo good. They have both handmade and soft serve ice cream, which was cool to see both options available. My homemade coffee ice cream, in a large sugar cone, was absolutely divine. Parking was super easy. The only annoying part was drunk patrons (even older adults.. woof!) but that's on them, not the restaurants fault. While they were causing a scene, the staff were patient with them, so major kudos to the hardworking John's Drive-In employees! read more

Unpretentious burger/ice cream joint. Priced fairly and unexpectedly delicious. 10/10 for the burger, fries, and milkshake. If you want a cheaper meal option that serves quick, this is the spot for you. Take note it's cash only. read more

I love the small town, beachy, nostalgic feel of John's Drive-In. I stopped here with a friend after climbing the lighthouse, strolling the beach, and shopping the town. The food hit the spot! It was a sunny winter afternoon, so we ate at one of the tables outside as the day began to wind down. It's now my go-to Montauk restaurant for a casual bite to eat. Highly recommend for the food and the feels. read more

John's Drive-In - A chipotle chicken wrap, jalapeño poppers, a cheeseburger, and a box of clam strips. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Had a very nice burger and fries for lunch during a winter weekend in Montauk. Burger was very tasty and pretty good. Too cold to have ice cream. read more

John's Drive-In - Decor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

$35 cash only for 2 non generous one scoop cups with toppings. A 2 scoop cup ice cream cup with toppings and a $9.19 shake (Yowzers). Help me understand how 5 scoops of ice cream and 6 ounces of milk cost me $35? Getting that bill was colder than a rocky road sundae read more

Was not expecting it whatsoever and had one of the best cheeseburgers of my whole life.

Great experience at John's Drive-In this year. I ordered chicken fingers and fries and my husband ordered a burger. Everything is made fresh so you might have a short wait, but trust me, it's worth it! Our meal was delicious. A little on the pricier side, but that's to be expected in Montauk. This is a classic restaurant that I highly recommend dining at! read more

See all

This place is the cutest! Not actually a drive in but a little burger shop. They have fries, chicken fingers, and homemade ice cream. My son loves chicken fingers and was so excited about the ones here in particular. Loved the beach vibes of the place and friendliness of everyone working. Service was quick too! One thing to mention is that they only take cash but they do have an ATM inside but prices are reasonable as well. read more

See all

John's Drive In is quintessential Montauk- the former Montauk that is. Back when Montauk was a fishing village at the end of the island and not so chichi. It offered fried food, burgers and a multitude of ice cream flavors and options. Fast forward to Summer of 2024 and nothing much has changed- it is the same as it ever was. While I don't have the inspiration for the food options at John's, the ice cream is frequently an end of night destination for the sweet tooth. Service is fine as the seasonal workers muddle through another busy Summer night. Ice cream options include Soft serve, hard ice cream and everything in between including some downright wacky flavors. A good value proposition is getting really tough to find in Montauk (see my review of Ralph's) so it's comforting to find it in the best example of comfort foods- Ice cream!. The 46 cent sprinkle option is a good example of an eye for value. One day I may be tempted to try the Jalapeño cheese poppers.... Maybe. Sometimes the lines are into the street so it proves that John's just may be around for another 30 years. read more

John's Drive in is great. The food is so good, flavorful with decent portions. The staff understands customer service. They're welcoming, polite and helpful. The place is old school with the booth/bench style seating. As well as outdoor seating under an awning. There is ample parking for plenty of patrons. We ordered the cheeseburger, fries , onion rings and a drink. The burger was cooked perfect and juicy. Crispy fries and the onion rings were really good. All in all I would definitely return. A1 service read more

See all

Is this the worst burger in Montauk? Enjoy 3 slices of unmelted Sysco-brand American cheese, a bursting mouthful of raw white onion, and a sticky squirt of mayo, ketchup, and relish. The classic cheap road-side burger, with the quality, flavor, and texture to match. If you're craving the familiarity of a hospital cafeteria cheeseburger, then John's is your spot. Your stomach will be rumbling and roiling from the experience as you drive away. Service was polite and excellent. Ambiance was akin to a prison's visitor lobby (note the faded, neglected decor and faint smell of disinfectant and grease). read more

John's Drive-In - Unmelted American cheese on the Big John Burger with Cheese. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

The Ice Cream is the best I've ever had in my life. The service was amazing. The ambience is amazing

The workers are very nice and helpful. I enjoy the food as they have a wide selection and the price is good for the area it's in. The only downside id say is they only take cash but if you can get over that this is definitely a good option. They also have homemade ice cream which is a plus! I got the flounder and chips and substituted the fries for onion rings which they did with no issue! :) will go again read more

After visiting the beach, this is the best casual place to find something to eat. The most recent time I went was in the late afternoon and there was no line. I ordered a small burger (yes! they do smaller burger sizes in case you don't want to eat too much but still want a burger) with fries and a milkshake. The other friend I was with ordered the 6 piece chicken nuggets. After waiting, we sat outside to eat. The food was fresh and was exactly the quick, tasty, and a little greasy food I was looking for. One of the best attributes of this place is that it has the feel of a stereotypical burger and fries outpost with the informality of a beach town. In my opinion, this place has some of the best milkshakes. In addition to having the classic flavors, they have homemade ice cream that they can use to make any flavor and they always seem to get the ratio of the shake right. What is especially rare for a place in the Hamptons is that this place is extremely reasonably priced. I always look forward to going back here after a long drive to Montauk or after a day on the beach. Just note that the business is cash only. read more

John's Drive-In - 6 piece chicken nugget set - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Big fan of the convenience of John's Drive-In. The large diner-like menu and quick orders are a winner if you're not in the mood for a more typical sit-down restaurants. read more

3.5 / 5.0 - There aren't many places open late in Montauk, so John's gets pretty busy at night. We came here 2 nights in a row, because there wasn't anything else open where we could get a bite to eat at 10pm. The service is not fast or great (or even good), but the prices were very reasonable--especially for Montauk, where everything is pricier than the city. The first night, I had: - Chicken Nuggets ($4.83 for 5 pieces) - Homemade Ice Cream ($4.14 for a Small cup) They have a wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors and the Mint Chip was great. It came out right away at the cashier. The Chicken Nuggets took a while longer, but they were good. The second night, I had: - Cheeseburger ($3.96) - French Fries ($3.08 for Small) This took even longer, but both were good, especially considering the price. They have tables inside and some picnic tables and benches outside as well. I would recommend eating outside if possible, to avoid having to encounter or engage with their aggressive staff. When my bf tried to use their ATM to get cash (because this place is cash only), they kicked him out. And while we were eating outside, the staff started fighting with a group of girls. As long as you're prepared to wait (in line to order and afterwards for your food) and don't encounter their aggressive staff, this would be a good option for late-night burgers or ice cream. read more

See all

A 4 star option for what it is: fast food (burgers, chicken, fries) and ice cream that's open late in the town of Montauk. Most of the negative reviews are for service (I'd describe it as indifferent but it's essentially a fast food restaurant so I don't expect white glove treatment), food quality (it's not fine dining nor is it intended to be), that it only accepts cash (it has an atm) and that it's often busy (if it wasn'tit would be out of business). But if you need an inexpensive bite late at night or want to make the kids happy with some ice cream, this is a good choice. read more

John's Drive-In - Oreo ice cream. Kid approved. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Let's start with the pluses: Conveniently located, the place has a very casual, retro vibe. The menu is large. The prices are great. The staff is super nice, providing very good service, and it is open off-season with terrific hours. The homemade ice cream is absolutely fabulous!!! Some of the very best ice cream of our lives!! So, kudos to John's for those things!!! However, the real food is bad. The French fries are some of the worst ever, though the portion size is fine. The fried cod fish is terrible: imagine the world's thinnest fish over-fried and hard - that's it. The bathroom is very inconveniently located in the outside, rear......so we were happy that it was not snowing. (Was this a former gas station?) Oddly was no mirror in the bathroom, as in some jails. Anyway, the vibe is good, and the ice cream is amazing - so go for those!! read more

THE best homemade ice cream on Long Island, if not Earth. I've never had any other food there, so can't comment on that. One caveat: I ordered a quart of ice cream to go. It appeared to be full before the lid went on. When I got it home 10 minutes later and dug into it, still frozen, I discovered an empty gap of air in the middle of the container. I was shorted about ¾ cup, by my guess. That's nearly a quarter of what was paid for, simply missing. I didn't take a photo because you can't "see" non-existent ice cream. We had other, smaller containers but I didn't personally open them. My advice: Don't miss this truly amazing ice cream! Just be sure to watch as your order is packed. read more

YES. YES. YES. you need to go here if you're in montauk!!! it's so cute, so old fashioned, AND the workers are so sweet and friendly. the ice cream is incredible i would go back again next time we're here :) read more

Terrible service late night. Place closed early and told us to get out after we paid for food that we didn't get. Brutal don't go here

It was amazing. The ice cream was so yummy. It was melting really fast, but it was so delicious. The onion rings are awesome they were so good. The mozzarella sticks were really good not as good as the ice cream or onion rings though. read more

Great for people watching and the line moves quickly. Ice cream was creamy and delicious! It was the best chocolate almond joy ever!! Classic all American ice cream joint! Waffle cone is enough for two!! read more

A tradition for me and my family for decades. The variety is astounding. Can't comment on the entrée items, but the ice creams and all manner of desserts always hit the spot. read more

Awesome spot for a bite or something sweet. Very retro 50's style diner, people were super nice and attentive. Had the home made ice cream and it was amazing! Will def be back again read more

Had to try this place in Montauk and wasn't disappointed at all with the Food. We did a Ubber Eats which took forever but the order was still hot and hit the mark. Food: bacon cheeseburger was killer. What put it over the top was the sauce, the thick cut cheddar cheese and the brioche style bun. Not too sugary and the size of the bun fit the patty. Also I was expecting a grease induced burger and that wasn't the case at all. The bacon was crisp. The burger was cooked well and not too fatty. Overall just a really good burger and would eat it again... and again. Wings were good but too salty for my taste. Crispy fried goodness but would probably not order them again and go maybe for the onion rings. read more

John's Drive-In - Big John Burger with Bacon and Cheese. With a side of Wings. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montauk, New York