Was not expecting it whatsoever and had one of the best cheeseburgers of my whole life.read more

Love John's ice cream. Usually don't visit in the fall so was excited to see the pumpkin flavors. I…read moregot a large with pumpkin Oreo and raspberry chocolate truffle, which is what I usually order. The pumpkin Oreo was so good I wish I just got that since it's not a flavor you can usually get.

Awesome local candy shop in the heart of town. Tons of verity, and charm! They even had the old…read moreschool dot candy on paper that brought me back 30 years to my childhood!

Always a friendly face when visiting! Our family always makes a quick visit to the Candied anchor…read morewith each visit to MTK. Unique selection, great beverage selection including specialty ice coffees to sip while you savor your favorite hard to find childhood and international candies! Try it you'll feel like a kid again!

Without a doubt our favorite restaurant in Montauk. Always great service and food…read more Amazing place to eat with incredible sunsets!. Our fav's the calamari sushi roll, cauliflower side and the traditional lobster roll! In the summer the wait may be long but if plan it correctly, you can enjoy the musical entertainment first and then dinner! A two for 1 deal!

5 + location and view…read more 4 minus overall No reservations, so depending on time of year you may have to wait for a table. We have been here a number of times and usually enjoy our meal and experience. They have Good sushi selections and usually have nice fresh seafood selections. We had Tile fish prepared with escarole, white beans, and crispy leaks. Quite good! We also had wild Alaskan salmon that was somewhat disappointing. Id skip that! Was kind of dry and a bit fishy. Not terrible, but not really exceptionally enjoyable either. Service was good! They definitely work hard! They were washing down the table next to us as we sat down which is fine. Unfortunately, they were using some kind of solution that smelled like dirty or rotten damp rags. Unfortunately the smell took a while to dissipate and impacted our party's experience. It also probably reduced our ordering of pre-meal apps and drinks, not intentionally, but because it wasnt appetizing. We will probably return, because our experience might have been off a bit because they are not in full season yet.

Came here to end the perfect birthday day and it was honestly incredible! I think I was slightly…read moreoverwhelmed but next time I'll be more prepared and decisive!

They have lots of flavors on hand ( more than most other locations). Very attentive , knowledgeable…read moreand friendly staff. A well managed location.

Great place to stop in for a quick, easy bite and some fire coffee…read more Very chill spot, right off the main strip and in walking distance to both the beach and town. The croissant was delicious as was the coffee. Line was long, but service was fast. Definitely recommend for a nice morning stop.

As a matcha snob this iced matcha latte was quite delicious. Very dark and not watered down. Quite…read moreexpensive though and with added vanilla syrup and oat milk it came out to be $9. Very nice staff and super friendly. I loved the inside of the place so cute and have free water.

Are at the inlet cafe along the water (unsure if the menu is the same for topside) but we expected…read morean average meal with a beautiful setting. What we got were GREAT meals, and cold wine with a beautiful setting. -Ahi Tuna: 5/5, seasoned and seared perfectly. If I'm being totally honest this may have been the best I've ever had anywhere. -Fish Tacos: 4/5, great flavor but lacking fish. Seemed to be overstuffed with filler but still delicious. -Calamari: 5/5, all rings which is always a plus for us. Seasoned great. Overall we were very surprised with the quality of the food and left very satisfied. Considering the view, location, and quality I'd consider this a great value for what you're paying. Definitely coming back

Topside is our first stop on vacation to Montauk. Yesterday afternoon was perfect !! Matt, the…read morehost, is so personable and really on his game. It was a beautiful day, we started with Prosecco and margarita and enjoyed the boats going in and out of the inlet. Starters were raw clams (so tiny- yum) and shrimp cocktail - big and fresh. Everything is artfully plated. As my favorite watermelon feta salad wasn't on the menu - actually a blessing - I tried the Lobster caprese salad and it was a miracle. I took a picture. My husband's fish and chips was hot, crunchy, and not greasy at all. Plenty of fries. A couple cocktails, beautiful scenery and a fantastic meal is the way that we jump start our Montauk trip. Highly recommend it. Note- there's a lot of talk about Gosmans just being sold blah, blah, blah. No worries the Topside hasn't changed a bit. No kids allowed- probably too dangerous. Not the worst idea for my serenity fix either. Cheers ! To the folks complaining about the price- you're in the wrong town. Topside is a treat for us, worth every penny !!

The other day we bought 4 pints of frozen chopped clams. Wow! We were over the moon with the…read morequality of them... just superb! The container was full of clean clams and cut the perfect size for our Rhode Island clam chowder. Great prices too! We also tried their crusty bread and peach pie. Bread was delicious and pie crust/filling was perfect! Thank you Gosman's Fish Market for giving us excellent customer service and selling such quality food! We will be back!

The best place to go for fresh fish to bring home to cook. Also cooks lobster to take out. The…read moremarket has a variety of fruits and vegetables, ice cream and baked pies. It's not cheap but then, nothing in Montauk is.

Bird on the Roof in Montauk was such a great brunch find! I had one of the best scrambled egg…read moredishes I've ever had--scrambled eggs with burrata and avocado. I've never had this combination before, and it was absolutely brilliant. Honestly, I'd go back just for this dish alone. The restaurant itself is really cute, and we were thankfully able to snag a table without a reservation on a Sunday for brunch--but only because we came early before the crowds rolled in around 9 - they def rolled in as we were leaving! My husband ordered the French toast, which was also delicious. You really can't go wrong with their breakfast or brunch options, but the scrambled eggs with burrata and avocado truly stand out. Highly recommend!

Great little brunch spot in Montauk. We walked here for an off season breakfast and were able to be…read moresat immediately. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, the restaurant is very cute and service was very quick. I had the shakshuka which was very solid but I wish it had two eggs. My boyfriend had the BLT which he really enjoyed. We also ordered a side of home fries - good but came out a little cold- and the French toast latte- delicious. Prices were obviously expensive but I found the meal pretty filling. Overall a great Montauk spot.

Such a fun atmosphere. All staff seemed eager to accommodate needs. David was great. DJ was a nice…read moretouch for the end of our dinner. Dinner turns into an after-party just FYI. We ordered a ton of food (two-three of a few dishes) which was all very satisfying, but the Branzino stood apart. The striped bass carpaccio was flavorful, but it would have complemented better if it were chopped thinner. The lobster was tender and soft. French fries were nice and crispy thin. I loved the tomatoes (tomates olivettes confites). Cauliflower could have done without as both servings weren't to temperature -- more on the warm side. However, I would recommend just about everything we ordered (see proper French dish names below). Drinks were all good; we just ordered classic drinks/wine/cocktails. Let's talk dessert! We tried everything except the fruit. My absolute favorite was the crepes dentelles! Second favorite, the chocolate ice cream. Beignets were ok, a little too dense inside instead of airy/puffy. And the brioche cake (or tropezienne a la vanille) was sweet - a couple of bites are plenty. French names: Carpaccio De Bar Rayé x2, Gosman's Live Lobster x2, Tomates Olivettes Confites x2, Pommes Frites À L'origan x3, Choux-Fleurs Marinés Et Dorés Au Four x2.

Worst experience ever, waiter was rude, lobster fettuccini took over an hour. Multiple tables…read moreserved prior and a nice $537 bill Lobster was dry, the pasta flavorless

Gonna go with 4 stars…read more Ice cream sundae is as real good - cherry vanilla with hot fudge and gummy bears. Little awkward when I asked for gummy bears as a topping and the woman started weighing them on a scale? She runs a tight ship! Convenient location and reasonable (for Montauk) prices.

Interesting little store off the beaten path. Thankfully GPS is great for finding fun stores…read more There is a sign on the door regarding service dogs, but I opted to leave said dog with SO in the car with the air running. There are so many choices for fudge. Prices are a bit high, but that happens in tourist areas. After a few days of tasting this fudge, I am happy I did get some. Purchased 4 different flavors. Also purchased some salt water taffy and found that to be tasty as well. There are many "penny" candy options along the wall if you don't want taffy or fudge. Go visit, bring lots of cash, enjoy the sweets. It's a tourist area, parking during high season may be an issue.