I love this location and it's all because of an employee by the name of heart she had the best customer service she's the one that took my phone call to take my order she was patient she was very kind she was very knowledgeable about the food there gave me lots of suggestions I felt at home as soon as I went to pick it up she was very very hot hospitable the store was very clean it smelled good and I will definitely be back thank you Blackjack Pizza for hiring such wonderful customer service people it really makes a difference thank you for this wonderful experience heart you are a rockstar read more

We ordered $77 on pizza and calzones, they missed making an entire pizza and we had to wait an extra 25 minutes for it to be made. By the time it was done, all the other pizza was cold.....but they gave us a lovely free cookie . Service here is not good, not what it used to be. read more

Ordered pizza today and it was delicious! The order was made correctly, it was just out of the oven. Ordered a thin crust and hand tossed. We haven't been here since new ownership, we'll definitely be back. Ms. T. read more

I ordered two pizzas online. One of the pizzas was not even close to what I ordered. I ordered a hand tossed pizza with ranch dressing, chicken, mushrooms and sausage. They gave me a hand tossed pizza with pepperoni, tomato sauce, sausage and mushrooms. I called and told them the issue. They immediately blamed it on me for not ordering correctly. I took the pizza to them to see, they refused to remake the pizza or refund my money. I have never ordered anything from blackjack pizza before and rest assured I will never order anything from them again. ​ read more

Called in one item I have ordered before, person that took the order over the phone rang it up incorrectly so when I went to pick it up and the order was wrong I was told it would be another hour until I get the correct order. Zero customer service. They did not care about making their mistake right. Was looking forward to what I ordered because I do like their food... shucks read more

If i could have i would have give them negative stars. The crust was raw on the calzone. We had extra ingredients that were not on the order. One calzone had onions and plenty of them, but it wasn't on the order. It was missing ingredients. Wings were raw and couldn't eat them. I will not order from this place again. Very disappointed. read more

The lunch special was delicious. It was enough for me and my toddler to share. I always pick up through the drive thru!!! Yelp won't let me post this review unless I type more words so here there are! read more

DO NOT EAT HERE. (If you actually get your food) Just about the worst pizza joint you could go to. The children employed are extremely unprofessional, rude, and have no customer service skills. I'm genuinely shocked at the 2.5 star rating. Very generous of people. They charged my card twice for the same order that they then lost. Refused to refund me, then blamed it on them "just being in high school". Please do not give your money to this business as the owner clearly does not value you as a customer, which is obvious, due to the lack of training provided for said children. 1 star because it won't let me do zero. read more

If I could give a zero I would. Not only is it horrible service the staff are not properly trained in costumer service the food is always burnt or not cooked. The last couple of times I have ordered one pizza was completely burnt and the other one was not fully cooked. When speaking to the manager/owner you could tell it did not matter to her. While I was in the drive thru picking up my food you can hear someone in the background belittling the employees. This is definitely not a place I will continue to do business with. If you want good pizza and good service go somewhere else!!! The owner and manager there do not care! read more

Second time trying this place, and as has been the case with everything else we have tried in this area, so close to home...really good. Tonight, my husband and I ordered calzones. His a simple sausage and cheese, mine moz., feta, artichoke hearts, red onion, green olives and sausage. Mine was packed with yummy goodness, could only eat half of it. Worth the time and money! Drive thru pick up so convenient. read more

Blackjack Pizza - Artichoke heart, red onion, green olives, sausage, moz. and feta cheeses, calzones - Pizza Near Me - Firestone, Colorado

I don't know why this location can't remember to send sauce with calzones or bread sides. It is very frustrating, and it is a reoccurring issue. read more

Blackjack Pizza - Where's my damn sauce again!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Firestone, Colorado

Giving it four stars because I like blackjack Pizza so while I was waiting for my food next door to be ready I noticed that the lights were off in this building where as the hours stated they were open until 9:00 p.m. and then all the sudden the lights were back on these guys are looking at their watches waiting for this place to close down hoping that nobody will come in I'm waiting for somebody to come in at the last minute LOL that is funny because I've worked in food industry for a while and that's just the way it goes makes me laugh Young generation they're just like oh my God can I just get out of here no son you have to work read more

Horrible service and wait times. Inconsistent quality. Waited at the window for several minutes before I was even acknowledged. I order online. Each time I do it says 20 minutes but it is never ready then. Just double whatever time the website says and your order *might* be done by then. I don't see how they can continue to stay open at this point. Hopefully something better takes their place when they close. read more

ordered pizza and brownie on Dec 10 2022 pizza was burnt, brownie was burnt, cold and hard as a rock. Will never be back. Very dissapointing. read more

I have ordered delivery a few times and they seem to almost always forget the drink. Not so happy about their customer service especially because the pizza and drinks are not cheap, I paid for the drink the best they can do is credit that back to me but that's not even an option because they say they will, and it never gets done. Expensive lack of good customer service not the best tasting missing items when delivered burn or flavor less at times read more

I walked In at 11:00am today to order food for lunch. I was the only customer in the store. Before even walking inside it looks like it was a closed establishment, like the black jack restaurant is ready to pack up and move. Immediately walking in this restaurant establishment it is the dirtiest place I have ever been to. The store needs to be dusted and sanitized severely. There are boxes for the pizza and other items on the ground extremely unsanitary and a health code violation. There are random supplies laying around in the store which was dissatisfying to look at. The employee said it would take around 20 minutes which was fine, but that is a long time for one pizza and being the only customer. As a first time customer here I was disappointed. I won't be returning. I suggest to the other people reading this review it's not worth it. Trust me. read more

Previous 4 years 4-5 stars. Last 5 orders 1 star. Pizza was burnt, half the pizza was also missing the crust somehow... 2 liter exploded when opened. I did the 3 strike rule but went to 5 strikes for previous years service. read more

Lunch with sister today and we met our first celebrity. It's Mothra! From Godzilla! I was starstruck! Sis, not so much. But I guess that's what she gets for eating a salad. Would have been 5 stars but Mothra wouldn't autograph my Dale Earnhardt commemorative plate. So no stars! read more

Blackjack Pizza - Oh no! It's Mothra! Someone call Gozeera! - Pizza Near Me - Firestone, Colorado

They almost never pick up the phone, we ordered online to pick up. Only for my husband to have to wait another 25 minutes for them to make one of the two pizzas we ordered because it had been mixed up, and when the pizzas arrived only one half of one was sliced? Like an actual half was whole how do you forget to slice a pizza all the way.. either that or it was done on purpose. If you like more bread than cheese in your pizza this is the place to go, lack of customer service don't bother eating there. It used to be an alright place but now it almost feels like you're bothering them to make you a proper pizza. read more

This is the best pizza in the Carbon Valley area. Best price, best taste, best variety. The owners are community minded and do their best to serve our town the best pizza. The salads here are solid as well. Also, it sounds silly but they have ranch dressing here that is killer. Whatever you get make sure to snag a ranch dipper-you'll be in ranch heaven! read more

I like to order the cauliflower pizza but the wait time is like forever!!! I can drive there faster to pick it up then to have to wait nearly an hour and a half for delivery. There app sucks where dominos at least gives you updates all the time so your not waiting all night read more

There is a young woman employee but I don't know her name, however she was working Saturday prior to closing. This young woman is super friendly and very pleasant and very nice. She takes the time to ask you how you are doing and she has an awesome amazing personality and she makes you feel welcome and more then just another customer in the drive through. You can tell that she takes her job seriously and she goes the extra mile to properly serve her customers read more

So I've been going to Blackjack for a while and this is the sorriest excuse for a cheese bread that I've ever seen. Ordered this just now and they told me it was fine and that it's completely like it usually is. Idk if the Firestone location has things handled. read more

Blackjack Pizza - As the manager at Firestone Colorado on Wednesday Dec 2, 2020 would describe to me as "Not a burnt pizza, lots of cheese. And as usual." - Pizza Near Me - Firestone, Colorado

See all

Decided to try Blackjack after a 30 year boycott. And then I remember why I don't like blackjack. We walked in to get 2 large pizzas. After 45 minutes of sitting in their frigid lobby, I asked my husband what was taking so long for 2 pizzas. Apparently our pizzas had been ready for a while and were sitting there under a heat lamp for at least 20 minutes. Then on topof that, they got our order wrong. We only took the pizzas because we didn't want to wait another 45 minutes. Deplorable service! Very disappointed! read more

I like the wings at this place, but the service has taken a serious dive. Last night was the final straw. Ordered online and the app said the order would be ready in 20 minutes. Arrived in 25 minutes and was told I'd have to wait a "couple minutes". Waited an additional 20 before I went into the restaurant and asked if they'd forgotten me. "We're sorry, I'll take that out to your car in five minutes". At this point, I asked if they could just deliver it: "I don't know how to change that on the order". Waited ANOTHER 15 minutes before they brought it out. Me: "Do you know I've waited over an hour for something your app said would take 20 minutes?" Reply: "Sorry, have a nice night." (with a sneer). Won't be back. read more

We ordered our pizza and was told it woulld be 45 minutes. At an hour and 10 minutes we called and were told the pizza was about to leave the restaurant and would be another 30 minutes. That was half an hour ago. The person who answered the phone was rude and said "that's what it is." The pizza arrived....2 hours after order. It was cold and not even cut the whole way through. We will not ordering from them again. read more

Really great pizza their deserts are amazing I really hope I go there soon again!-your friend Shiver Me T.

I ordered from here on Sunday the 5 th if January and my husband ordered hit wings. He ended up getting salmonella from them

This will be the last time we order from them. It always takes over an hour to get our pizza delivered. Even when the estimated time is 35 minutes. And after the long wait we receive pizza that is cold and isn't cut. Too many other places to order from here in town to pay for this anymore. read more

I wish I could give zero stars after my last experience. We called to get a large pizza and cheese bread, 25$? That price is crazy for a basic order. So we called back maybe a minute or two later to cancel our order (dominos is a lot cheaper) the owner starting arguing and raising his voice at me claiming the pizza was already in the oven. There is no way within a minute a pizza is made and in the oven. He continued to argue saying it's wrong of me to cancel an order and that it costs them atleast 12$ to make that pizza. I wasn't even finished talking to him when he hung up on me. Horrible customer service and even worse it came from the owner. Won't be back anymore. read more

This location does not care about the health of the customers. Went inside to pay and pick up my Pizza. Most of the employees were not wearing masks including the one helping me. He said they were not having customers sign due to safety reasons. I commented that he and several of the employees were not even wearing masks but they care about people not signing for credit cards...? I understand there are several young people working there but other businesses have young adults working and wear masks. There are many people who don't have jobs who would be happy to work here and would wear masks. I will not be going to this location until the mask policy is lifted by the government as the employees don't care about the law or their customers! read more

Have made large orders from this place several times in the past year. Every time they deliver on-time with hot, fresh, tasty pizza. Average order is over a hundred dollars and includes 6-10 pizzas. They're always within 90 minute or less, even during busy times. They've bailed me out when other caterers have failed on multiple occasions and are now my "go-to" lunch supplier for meetings. read more

We've been ordering from this location for over 5 years now. The pizzas are on point, the salads and sides are delicious, and we are huge fans of the Calzones!!! We ordered ice cream once, and they even gave us a bonus flavor (THANK YOU!). We've had a couple snags here and there, as to be expected, but after notifying the owner, everything was rectified. This is our go to pizza choice, try them, you won't be sorry! read more

This is the best pizza ever! We come to visit often (from AZ) and it is the first thing I want when we arrive. Perfect cheese, sauce & toppings. Also one of the only pizza places that offer green olives as a topping. read more

If I could give zero stars then I would. I ordered for carry out, clarified that it was the correct location two times waited in the parking lot for 30 minutes to find out that my order was never even made. The kids who came to the window acted as if I was the one who made the mistake and told me that they could get a manager if I'd like. I used to be a delivery driver At the Blackjack in Louisville so I know very well that my order was taken and just never put down. I ended up not even getting anything this place needs to hire a new staff! read more

I keep ordering from this place expecting different experience because I see the owner trying hard to make it right, but nothing changes. Delivery usually takes at least an hour even though I live less than 10 mins away (stated estimated time is 45 mins) and the pizza is lukewarm. I used a promo code to get free item and it's always forgotten. Their pizza taste ok, maybe it will taste better if it's delivered hot. read more

Love this place! Amazing pizza and impressive customer service. The employees are all super kind and work hard to make sure you get exactly what you order at a fair price and with speedy delivery. The pizza is fresh and addicting. I won't order from anyone else! read more

So tonight we got pizza from blackjacks and a salad. Got an antipasta salad and added banana peppers. Got the salad and it was wrong. Called the store and they said opps i guess we will refund you your banana peppers. 1.50 extra. And then she said she can remake it but she needs the old one back. Het the new salad it has half the stuff it from the first and looks like it was kicked around. What a joke of a place. read more

Just stopped in for lunch on a bicycle ride. Staff was friendly pizza was great. Thank you. Maybe don't order for delivery? read more

We order from this location a LOT at work and it is consistently the best pizza place in town. The pies are not only tasty but always beautiful and the delivery drivers are friendly and always get our orders right. The salads are fresh and crispy. The only bad thing I have to say is that we are super bummed the Popper Topper pizza is no longer available...we would literally gobble that pie in complete silence and then smile at each other with that knowing satisfied look. That being said we still adore the other offerings. Well done, Firestone! Keep up the excellent work! read more