We snagged some late lunch slices on a Monday afternoon (Loveland, CO) for take out. Service was friendly, answered questions & offered suggestions. It's wonderful they offer purchase by the slice. We tried 4 varieties and every one was unique and delicious. We had: Classic NY Pepperoni, Sweet Gino (focaccia crust), Deep dish with cheese and bacon, and the Wiseguy. 3 different crusts with savory toppings and some a hint of sweetness. The deep-dish had the least toppings but the crusty cheese on the bottom of the crust made it delicious! The Wiseguy was really nice (hint of sweetness) and the Sweet Gino tasted reminiscent of Italy and I loved the crunchy focaccia crust. Absolute Yumminess. I heard the pepperoni was tasty also. To top it off we got 3 cannoli's to try. OMG yum! Just go for it, they're delicious. Loved getting to try Slice House while in town. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Came with my son one day and it was good. Waited a while, but the pizza was great when we finally got it. Next day decided to order when we were having friends over. Order was said to be ready in 55 minutes. Yikes. Got to the restaurant and they hadn't even started it. It's now 20 minutes past when my order was said to be ready and it's still not. Ordered a slice while I wait and the girl behind the counter seemed inconvenienced that I asked. Paid for that too. Won't be back. Edit: adding two stars because they tried to make it right. Was given a free pizza card and it took 80 minutes total. Got home and they also forgot the hot honey and ranch I paid for. Ugh. read more

The counter guy was so helpful and patient since I had no idea what I wanted and the place was clean and everyone was nice and the food was fantastic!! Definitely coming back! Taking a menu home so I can be a bit more informed of my choices read more

We've enjoyed the pizza at Slice House since they opened. But, they had GREAT deals for take out that have since vanished from the menu? It was like a pizza, salad and dessert to go only for $49.00. I guess the costs were too much, but that was a noted plus! The pizzas are good, not the best pizza but decent, the prices seem to be going up? Idk? Dinner for 4 over $100 for pizza& salad with drinks seems high. Overall it's okay, but not seeing the value now. read more

Okay I normally don't write bad reviews like this. But I do write alot of food reviews, and this place was not good 10$ a slice of pizza and 40$ for a full size pizza. Not only that but slices are small are you kidding me this place is a joke. It doesn't end there it's mediocre pizza. I would compare it to the same as grocery store frozen pizza. Now I won't leave a 1 star the staff were really nice. Overall in short terms nice staff absolutely horrible pizza. read more

Unfortunately, I have to rewrite my review of this place after Mike begged and pleaded with the community for us to come back and give him another shot. Decided to order an extra large pizza $40 with tip online since our young son decided he needed to go to sleep early and we didn't want to cook. Pick the pizza up 10 minutes earlier than online told me to come and it was already sitting there waiting 7pm not 7:11. When I got home I realize that 90% of the pizza was burnt. We ordered a half-and-half pizza and the toppings were on five of the six slices. My wife's a vegetarian and doesn't eat meat and the pepperoni was on two of her three slices. I also didn't realize when ordering an extra large pizza. You only get six slices instead of eight you would think that would feed more people. I called the store to see if I could get a refund since I wasn't interested in eating their pizza anymore and was told no I could get a credit instead then they checked with the owner Mike and he didn't even have the decency to come to the phone and say anything to me instead they told me I may see a refund within one day so now I have to figure out what I'm gonna do for dinner and I'm short to pay for that dinner. Again, really appreciate Mike taking the time and the opportunity to speak with an unhappy customer. I realize he was in a meeting busy in a meeting 7:30 at night but happen to be standing there when I came in to get my pizza. Crazy! I really wish people would take better care of their customers. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Burnt pizza and one of the cheese slices with pepperoni on it. Horrible quality. - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

See all

I was really excited to try this place as it had some cool pics online and seemingly a good reputation. We ordered the Medium Little Italy Pizza, 8 wings and two tiny glasses of wine and it was $100. I'm thinking-ok, this has to be the best pizza ever, right? And---no. It was no better than Papa John's, Dominos, etc, in my opinion and way overpriced for what you are getting. It also took almost an hour to get our food. I might go back to get a single slice sometime so I could try some of the other doughs, but it is definitely not a go-to. read more

The pizza was so good. They were open on Easter Sunday and we were able to get lunch. The service was amazing and quick. The atmosphere was great and inviting. We'll definitely be coming here again. read more

From the first bite, you can tell they know what they're doing. The crust is just right crispy on the outside, soft on the inside and the sauce has great flavor without overpowering the toppings. Everything tastes fresh, well-balanced, and made with care. The menu has solid options, whether you're going classic or trying something a little different, and it all comes out hot and delicious. The atmosphere is relaxed, the service is friendly, and it's the kind of place you'll want to come back to again. read more

Best lunch deal in town, food has always been great and the people are very customer oriented. Great indoor and outdoor seating. We work for the school district and this is our go to spot read more

Was excited to try. Lots of variety and variations to choose from. The ingredients were great. My knock on this place; it is NOT "NY style". It was more Detroit style. I didn't hate it, it just isn't NY Style pizza. The red sauce was a little too sweet for my liking. Also-the slices were not piping hot. They were...warm. I want my pizza so it leaves scar tissue on the roof of my mouth hot. I'll let it cool down if needed, but it's gotta be HOT. The pizza was overall good pizza. I enjoyed the Grandma Sweet Gino. ***I'd like to address "Ana T" and that "I'm a victim" review. TROLL. That's what she is. Look at all of that moron's reviews. All one star. You hated the place because there were "too many white people"? You were mistreated because you're "GAY"? I mean, did you come into the place yelling; "YO...just so you all know...WE'RE Hispanic and GAAAAAYYY!!!" Well, if you did, then everyone understands why the flies swarmed around you and people were stand offish. People don't like to talk to stupid. Btw-the staff was super nice to us, but that might be because I'm a CUJINI and yelled as I entered, "YO, I'm a HETEROSEXUAL". That must have been it... read more

Still like the flavors. The last few months, some of the pizzas are overcooked. Thus, it doesn't stay hot long and the texture is crispier. Not liking this shift from evenly cooked to overcooked. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani in Loveland: Next-Level Pizza Vibes in the Rockies! Yooo, Colorado pizza squad--drop everything and hit up Slice House by Tony Gemignani in Loveland! This spot is straight-up legendary, slinging slices from a 13-time World Pizza Champion with styles like New York thin, Sicilian thick, Detroit deep-dish, and Grandma pies that are pure perfection. Fresh dough, killer sauces, premium toppings--every bite screams artisan mastery! We rolled in for a whole pizza to-go, grabbed a table to chill, and that's when the magic happened. Mike (the franchise owner, aka Michael Tingus, an absolute gem of a human) came through MULTIPLE times like we were family. First, he introduces himself with that infectious energy, checks on us, then bounces back with a complimentary bowl of their homemade meatballs in sauce--tender, juicy orbs swimming in rich, herby marinara that had us moaning! Next? He surprises us with three massive slices of the exclusive Colorado Kid (only here in Loveland!): creamy Alfredo base, melty mozzarella, applewood-smoked bacon, sliced bison sausage, green + fried onions, Romano, oregano, and garlic oil drizzles. Bold, smoky, cheesy explosion with that perfect crispy-chewy crust--demolished in minutes! Even as he was heading out, Mike looped back one more time to make sure we were good. Talk about next-level hospitality! The whole staff is friendly, professional, and on point. And the spot? Gorgeously designed with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere--modern vibes, cozy seating, and that killer patio overlooking the mountains. This isn't just pizza; it's an experience that'll have you hooked and coming back for more. 11/10, no debate--Slice House Loveland is the spot! Who's grabbing slices with me ASAP? #SliceHouseLoveland #TonyGemignani #ColoradoKid #PizzaHeaven #MeatballGoals read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Amazing pizza. Great service. Good prices. Looking forward to going back there again.

These guys are the real deal. All the ingredients are of the highest Italian, old-school standards. The use Marzano tomatoes to make their sauce. You can't get more authentic than that. They were sold out of the cannolis and Spumoni, so they must be good too. I took my slice to-go but next time I will eat it there while it's nice and hot. read more

We tried this for the first time. Ordered cheesy garlic bread that was a hoagie bun with provolone that appeared to be microwaved for 30 seconds. No evidence of it being toasted just a soggy hoagie bun with cheese. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza with hot honey. The pepperoni was great, lots of it, but the pizza was really greasy. I used a paper towel to remove the grease. The crust was the biggest disappointment. I've had better pizza crust in hospital cafeterias. I honestly prefer a Dgiorno crust over this. We will stick to Arte's, Urban Fields, Justine's, and Pizza Vino. read more

Ordered a couple pizzas to go. Was told they were ready far before the scheduled pickup time (almost 30 minutes early) - which normally wouldn't be an issue but we were attending an event on a timeline and set our pickup time intentionally. When we arrived the pizzas weren't in any sort of temperate holding space, so they were lukewarm at best. And the worst part.... The total came out to almost $90. For sub par, cold pizza. It wasn't anywhere near good enough to validate that kind of price tag. read more

This has been one of the worst experiences at a restaurant from the start flys on the pizza they were serving you couldn't even eat without being swarmed by flys ... I don't like to speculate but the owner either don't like Hispanic people or gay people. The entire time there it was weird greeted everyone one that came in including the people sitting down. All white .. if you're going to run a business make sure you treat everyone the correct way. -Deleted my partners review on google but here is another one- read more

The food was delicious! Tony was attentive and you can tell he truly cares about the food he serves! It's a MUST visit! One of the BEST pizzas in town! read more

The food is amazing and I got free desert.my family and I love this place.for my next birthday I'm going to buy this pizza.

We wanted to add onion to our pizza and we were told they do not add to any pizza it's as on the menu only! Then the pizza we wanted to order was going to take a minimum of 45 minutes to make. It's obvious they just want you to order their premade slices and not order a whole pizza. The pizza was nothing special, way too much sauce. There are no blinds or curtains on the windows so you get blinded by the sun. It is also not really geared for a larger group as we had to move tables to accommodate our group of 7. Some of the staff was pleasant but others looked at you like you had 2 heads or ignored you. Needless to say this was a one and done, we won't be back. read more

I was greeted as soon as I walked in. The slice counter looks incredible and fresh. I had the Gino slice which had really sweet sauce and incredible cheese that complimented the crust. read more

The flavor is good, the topping/cheese/sauce ratio is good, the crust is good. But I imagine it would be better hot. I ordered delivery and while I understand that will cause some heat loss, it was so cold the cheese had stuck to the box and pulled paper up when I grabbed the first slice. According to the order tracking it was only in-transit for like 10 minutes, so unless it rode on the hood of the driver's car it sat for a while after it was made, as it arrived ahead of the estimated delivery window when ordering. Since you can buy by the slice, and they're not cool with changing up toppings, it's not unlikely that they make the pizzas in large batches and that mine sat for a bit. We'll probably give it a try in-person next before we write it off. read more

I want to start off by saying I'm a fan of their crust/slice sizes and the service was solid. I need a cheese slice to really test a place. Their cheese was like a higher quality Costco slice. Nothing stood out about the sauce. The pepperoni slice was loaded though! It's decent, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it read more

Ordered a Detroit Cal Italia to go. The first pizza landed on the floor while cooking. 33minutes they sent text to tell me while we waited in car because inside restaurant was freezing. I came in and they said it would take 7-8 Minutes to rectify. They gave us 2 of the most salty chocolate chip cookies ever. 1 bite and we tossed. 22 minutes later the pizza was ready with apologies. Got in the car and pizza was cold. Brought home reheated pizza in convection oven for 12 minutes. Pizza was chewy ass hell, prosciutto was tough and there was so little cheese and meat but plenty of balsamic glaze to make to sweet. It said fig but not a lick of it on the pizza. $41 for 4 slices of crap. 1 and done read more

Tried to get food here on Valentine's Day, and I placed an online order an hour before I wanted the food. Came to pick it up and the food was not ready (ok it's a busy day) but then they accidentally burnt the pizza, and they said it would take another 45 minutes to bake a new pizza. We couldn't wait so we asked for a refund instead which they agreed to. We did take the meatballs which were ready (and delicious). However, I called back two times over the next week inquiring about my refund, and was promised it would be taken care of but I never received it. I finally gave up, and I likely won't be back. I would love my refund though! read more

My overall experience with Slice House was fantastic. I tried the "Colorado Kid". Being honest I was pretty skeptical about bison on a pizza but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and flavor. The service was great for me too everyone that I met was warm and welcoming. I definitely see myself coming back to try other another piece of their pies. read more

New to Loveland, Slice House offers a wide variety of by-the-slice and whole pies in NY and thick Sicilian crust styles . A bit disappointing that they were advertising happy hour specials that they wouldn't honor yet. Service was friendly and helpful. We sat on the patio and an employee fired up the outdoor heating for us. Could've done without the loud house music or mind-numbing glow of the big screen that made having a conversation challenging. Pizza was certainly better than local corporate chains, but for my money it doesn't exceed Arte Pizzeria in quality and taste given the higher than average prices. read more

Slice house has one of the best pizzas in Colorado you have to go in and try the "Colorado kid pizza". The service was fantastic and the owners couldn't have given us a better greeting. They checked on our table multiple times and made us feel at home. Definitely recommend!!!!! read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Grand opening front entrance - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

pizza was old, sitting too long in case. salad was tastier than pizza. we have better quality pizza locally

We love the pizza here. Any of the slices that you choose that are displayed are usually ready pretty quickly. If you order from the menu it takes a bit longer for the food. We have been going regularly for a few weeks now and the food never disappoints. The only downside is the indoor seating is very limited. Once the weather is warmer there will be a good amount with their patio, but sometimes we stand to eat. read more

I've dined here 5 times. Food is consistently fresh, like homemade, delicious with generous portions. This food is NOT AT ALL like Pizza Hut, Papa John's, Papa Murphy's, etc.... Now, my only 'go to' pizza place AND reasonably priced. Appreciate the meal special for $10 (until 3:00pm). The Servers are personable and accommodating. Shout out to Brad, the Franchisee, for creating a very nice Foodie experience. Slice House, an excellent restaurant presence in Loveland! read more

Our first time going was amazing! The owner and staff were very nice and gave us complimentary gelato and a cookie. Highly recommend!

Been interested in trying new pizza place in town. Wish it was better. ordered for carry out at 720 on Saturday, online says 40 minutes, quite a while but ok, I'll wait. Get the pickup at 8:05, 45 minutes later, place is not busy. Told 5 more minutes, no problem, maybe they had a rush earlier. Come back in 8:12, "they're just cutting it now". Finally get it at 8:20 Or 8:25 even. Drive a minute home in a very toasty vehicle. Pizza is cold. it's decent, but not great, not for the price, service or cold after waiting for it to be very late. Got to think it's a staffing issue, but enough that myself and friends aren't bothering to try again. read more

My wife and I were visiting family and decided to give this place a try. Our grandkids recommended we try their slices. Boy the pizza was amazing but the customer service was unbelievable. A nice young man named Tim approached us immediately to inform us of their delicious pizzas. The register gal was a real hoot and our charming server Juan was actually from Boise Idaho like us so we stopped and had a great conversation. Next time we are visiting we will definitely be back. read more

This is by far the best pizza place in Loveland! I'm truly grateful such a place is here. I really like the setup and the pizza is amazing. Deep dish, New York style, grandma style... the salad we split since it was big. I love the football on the big screens, and they have an excellent patio with heaters. I hope they have a plan for winter, since that would be the only pinch on their business. Staff is super polite, and the place is very clean. It is about the price of Justine's but offers way more. It's nice to have great pizza with ingredients that are soo fresh! read more

our first time experience went like this. we called, to order a pie. we were told," we don't take call in orders". i went there to order a detroit deep dish pie. she said,"it will take about 1/2 hr." i said,"i'll wait". she gave me a beeper. 1/2 hour later, the beeper beeps i go into the store, present the beeper to the counter person. there seems to be some confusion ! i wait, and wait, and wait, (patiently). finally, she comes back, and informs me the kitchen has burned my pizza, and asks if i would like another, or a refund. i take the refund, and go b______'s pizza, order a pie, wait 15 minutes, and get a nice, large pie, for 1/2 the price. my avice= don't go here ! read more

We wanted to check this place out last Thursday and it did not disappoint!! the thin crust pepperoni was delicious! cooked perfectly. the chicken wings were some of the best I've ever eaten! soo tasty! the salad was awesome a well balance of seasoning, and pecan nuts and cheese! We were also offered up to sample their meatballs, which again did not disappoint and were tender, moist, and some of the best tasting meatballs I've had in a long time! We will definitely be back! Keep up the good work guys!! read more

Amazing pizza, even better pasta and outstanding service! We will be making this a regular date night spot! :)

Great pizza. Great service. Clean restaurant. Nothing much more to say other than the fact that is was so good I had to write a review. Keep it up! read more