My wife and I were heading home from visiting my folks for Christmas. We stopped here to have a little bit of lunch and I'm glad we did. My wife got this steak nachos that was loaded with steak and cheese and onions and mushrooms and sour cream and lettuce. She really enjoyed her lunch. I got the cheeseburger and french fries. The burger was just as I asked, and it was very tasty. Our server was a very nice young lady who was a tenant and even got me a to go cup of tea. Restaurant was decorated nicely and we enjoyed our visit. I would highly recommend stopping by for a good meal read more

Black Stallion Steakhouse - Steak nachos - Steakhouses Near Me - Monticello, Kentucky

See all

Just moving to the area we decided to try this steakhouse. Charlie our server was awesome. I had the Catfish (which was excellent) my husband had the Bourbon BBQ Bacon Burger (which was huge) and excellent as well. The only drawback was they had our choice of Dos Equis Amber on the menu which we ordered only to find out they no longer carry it. Overall this was a nice welcoming experience. read more

Service was great. Food was not good. Parmesan crusted chicken was grilled chicken slapped with garlic salt and smothered in cheese... this is NOT Parmesan crusted chicken. Steaks were over cooked and not great. Would not recommend read more

The food was good, the rolls small but were very good but when I asked for one to eat with my food the waiter said sure but never did I bring more. That was disappointing since I like bread with my food. I only had one prior to getting served so it wasn't like it was going to break the bank. So if you like bread go somewhere else. read more

We visit Monticello a couple times a year. I used to work in the area and we tried this place for the first time. Other reviews have been all over the place but we decide to give it a try. The service was great. Super friendly! And the food was amazing! The prices were even better! We were with a large group and it makes it nice to be able to afford to take them somewhere nice all together. And the place was beautifully decorated and clean. We definitely recommend this place and will be back! read more

See all

Came back here on 6/17/23 , a year later and order the same same steak, btw my last review took place in 2021 if you notice there's a photo of my receipt showing prices from '21 there's nearly a 40% increase in 3 years! Anyway back to my review was just there Saturday and the steak was absolutely horrible! Mind you this was 2 years in the making. How can a place do this? Or do I have terrible luck? 2 steaks 3 years apart and both are horrible but at least this time they comped me $18 and I didn't eat the steak, they if I wanted another steak I said no because who needs 3 in a row? When you cut into your steak you don't want to see grey or that white stringy stuff cartilage muscle gristle that's what I got! Nope black stallion you list me as a steak customer so it's cattlemen's only now! Plus they have a huge salad bar! read more

Food was good and huge portions. Ribeye skillet was unbelievable. But you better be very hungry coming in.

Dined for the first time Saturday, October 28th. Great experience. Our table ordered Ribs, Chicken Parm and Ribeye tips as well as potato skins for an appetizer. Everyone's meal was delicious. The salad bar had a nice selection. Our server was exceptional and the staff clearing tables was great too. read more

Nice little local restaurant. Food pretty good cocktails as well. Staff is always nice. Comfortable atmosphere. I liked it a lot

Love their chicken breast lunch or dinner. They have seasoned fries, salad bar or baked potato with your meal.

Made a special trip here with the parents and was not disappointed. I had the chicken taco salad. It was HUGE with lots of tender flavorful chicken. The service was fast and friendly, all extra requests were brought out right away...those rolls will need some extra butter. This is one of those rare places these days that have a salad bar and I hope to sneak back down there and give it a whirl. read more

Good food and reasonable prices. Traditional steaks and American fare. Definitely recommend.

I ate here yesterday. I got the fried catfish, it tasted funny and weird. I didn't think anything of it. I ate about 3/4 of the catfish. Left that night feeling weird and off. Woke up the next morning feeling fine. A few minutes after I took a shower my stomach started feeling weird. I suddenly started feeling overwhelmingly tired. I started throwing up everywhere. I threw up about 20 times, no exaggeration and almost passed out. Went to the doctor to see what was going on and turns out I have food poisoning. The catfish was the last thing I had ate. Don't go here unless you want to be sick to your stomach. read more

Not bad Extensive menu is worrisome Stick with basics and you won't be disappointed The basic burger is always very good Otherwise a little hit and miss Service is usually pretty good unless they are very busy. Servers always pretty friendly read more

Driving through the area for work and was looking for something besides fast food. I ordered the steak nachos, and they were legit some of the best I have had! Server was friendly, quick service. I would definitely recommend! read more

The shrimp dinner was subpar for the price.....got steak fries ordered french fries told the server when the food was delivered and he said i tell them nothing happened the sweet tea tasted like they never cleaned the pot the only good thing on my plate was the asparagus it was fresh not frozen out of a bag could have gone to DQ for half the price... read more

The food is awesome. Steaks are cooked perfectly. Chicken in cooked perfectly. Don't understand why it's not a 5 star all the way around. Even the service is great. We will definitely eat here again. Thank you for a great experience. read more

Friendly staff and great service! Always a welcoming atmosphere! The Nachos are great!

Great food. Big portions. Good prices. Excellent service!

They have the best steak I've ever ate. I drive from Jamestown through the mountains to get here to have one. Great atmosphere as well. We will be back soon. read more

No star if possible order a paper jack hamburger well done and it came out raw with cold fries and sent back and came out raw again. 100% not happy. My husband's sirloin ordered med well came out rare read more

Great meal with the tween-child; I had a burger and fries, following a pretzel appetizer, and we closed it out with some cheesecake. While the kid had a standard soft drink I chose to try three of their self-brewed beers. I found the farmhouse red to be quite delicious, and took home a growler of it (which was still tasty two days later). I like ambiance, and the food is very tasty - I'm a fan read more

Their food is delicious: it can be a very long wait thou. The longest Iv waited for something simple as curly fries, and cheese sticks is 45 minutes. The service is friendly as well. They do come and check on you frequently. Sometimes too frequent. But it's okay. I highly recommend the chicken in rice with the cheese sauce. It's is the best. read more

CowboySteak TipsTeriyaki ChickenBaby Back Ribs. Very good food. Great service. Rolls and honey butter were amazing. read more

This is an amazing place to eat. I would recommend the salmon and asparagus along with the salad bar. You will not go home hungry.

very good food, clean nice service, priced well. Huge Hawaiian Burger with Canadian bacon and Swiss with really good sauce. great seasoning on the shrimp and very yummy club sanwich with lots of meat read more

See all

I would give this place a negative five stars if I could. Waited almost an hour on a piece of leather they call medium rare steak, the spinach dip was Watery and my husbands ribs were so tough they bent his fork. Asked for a manager and they said "what do you want me to do about it" we've are there 3 times and the food has been terrible every time. P.S I wrote this exact same bad review on Facebook and they remove every bad review they get. This place is a JOKE. Can't believe people enjoy eating here. read more

Great everything on the menu. Great service and great atmosphere. Best steakhouse I've tried in forever.

On the area visiting and decided to have dinner here. Wait staff was not in a hurry about anything...seating, drinks,apps.... Ordered steak tips and ribeye with potato skin app. The skins were great, crunchy shell, soft fluffy potato inside. Steak tips were chewy and seasoned more in a fajita style. Ribeye was tender and flavorful. Prices were ok. Wouldn't be on my must do list next time in town. read more

Such a wide variety to satisfy everyone's cravings. I have enjoyed every menu item I've tried. The rolls! So fresh, light and delicious. If you order broccoli get the Queso dip over it. My favorite. read more

Amazing experience. I had the best steak I have had in a long time. Highly recommend the porterhouse! My boyfriend had the full rack of baby back ribs and they were falling off the bone. Overall experience was fantastic. Passing through and found this place on yelp! Don't miss it! read more

I had the 10 oz. sirloin steak (cooked medium) with loaded baked potato and my husband had the New York Strip steak (cooked medium rare) with steak fries and broccoli. We were both very pleased with how our steaks were cooked and seasoned. They were delicious! Our server was very friendly and efficient. Our food was served timely and we enjoyed our whole meal. The new Columbia restaurant is clean, modern looking, and very nice. We were impressed and will definitely be returning customers! read more

We had a pretty horrible experience with our waitress tonight. I want to give props for the food, I bought a filet mignon cooked med rare, but came out almost a blue, waitress never came back. Young blonde girl who wasn't even a server came and helped me. She promptly took care of my steak and everything was good. Our waitress never once came back to see how we were doing or how our food was. She sent the other girl to even give us our check. I really don't understand what the waitress was doing, I asked the young girl where our server was, she said she was standing inside. If you ever wonder why you don't make tips, how about you pay attention to your tables. I tipped the other girl 28 bucks just because she was amazing! This place would get a five star review if it wasn't for the horrible waitress, an way undercooked steak. When you buy a 30 dollar steak, the waitress should be paying attention to the guest needs and wants. read more

Went for lunch, first time eating here. My steak was under cooked and my wife's was over cooked. She ate hers and I sent mine back. The server was friendly and they did provide a military discount. The steaks were average. The chicken my wife got with here steak was really thin. read more

Ok I have a system for the local restaurants, 3 strike rule. Well, the black stallion only has 2 strikes they made it up today when I went there lunch today. The ribeye was great baked potato and asparagus. The appetizer I had was the bacon cheddar fries were really good. One suggestion would be is try changing the up to a hot cheddar cheese sauce that the cheese won't congeal when they cool down. Anyone everything was on point. Good job Black stallion. read more

Well it is a pretty good place to eat, not many restaurants in this area and only steak house around. Fish tacos were amazing. Service was bad family was gathered here for dinner and I had to go get own napkins , move empties to another table so food would fit on table. But all and all food looked good that others ordered and I will say the fish tacos were some of the best I have had . read more

Would recommend to everyone! Fast friendly service! Food amazing and hot! Very impressed! Our first time here! Will be back! read more

See all

We gave this another try from the last time we were here a year ago. As long as you get steak, it's good. We got the steak with salmon and the southwest chicken. The salmon was so extremely salty and very fishy. To their credit, they made another and that one wasn't salty but still fishy. We did appreciate their effort and didn't make a big deal of it. It was edible. The chicken was dry, salty and the cheese sauce was extra salty. Was able to eat enough to satisfy the hunger (and dink a lot of water - ha!) The salads and sides we ordered were very good: side salad, Caesar, baked potato and potato soup. The soup was ok. They do have a desire to get it right and that was appreciated. I must remember to order the steaks only ;) read more

Nothing worse then getting shrimp that has not been deveined. Showed the waiter and he took it back to the kitchen. Now the manager comes to my table after throwing the uncleaned shrimp away showing me a picture of a frozen shrimp bag. Fresh frozen uncleaned shrimp. He started arguing so I asked for my bill. Never seen nothing like. Never Again Bikers Beware of this restaurant read more

This was the worst experience we've had in a very long time dining out. We were really excited based on Yelps four star rating especially after a full day at the lake and in the sun. Our waitress was the worst I've ever encountered. It was very clear that she could care less about our needs or dining experience. She never once refilled our drinks. One of our guests ordered broccoli and cheddar soup and was never given a spoon. We stopped another waitress trying to get a spoon and refills but still no luck. We have no idea if the soup was good or not because we were never able to try it. The food was terrible also. The steak we ordered should have been cooked to medium rare and it was well done. It was very tough and mostly inedible. On of our guests got a hamburger and for some reason the bun was soggy. Also the chicken Alfredo was not good. The broccoli and noodles were soggy as if it had been soaking in water for quite a while. On the brighter side, theIr salads, the yeast rolls and the appetizer we ordered (fried pickles, onion rings, mild wings) were pretty good. Once our waitress finally did return, we told her we were never given any refills or a spoon and she rudely said " well then is there anything I can get you now?" There was no apology or effort to in any way make amends. She still never offered any refills or spoon. It was very clear that she did not care. At this point we were beyond done and just asked for our bill. read more