I give this place a 4 because of their affordability, helpfulness and tastiness. They have the best chicken Caesar salad, I have to get it when ever I order from here so good. The pizza is always good, and their lunch specials are great. They are friendly and honest about their wait times. Inside the place isn't much to write home about, but most pizza places aren't. Great place for just a slice or a whole pizza read more

For the Thanksgiving holiday and ensuing weekend, I ordered pizza from Berthoud Pizza Company. It's a small pizzeria and doesn't offer no dining in option. It's ALL takeout. I noticed some negative reviews of this place. However, I do not agree with those negative reviews. I actually enjoyed the pizza I ordered from here. My only slight constructive criticism is to have an ordering menu at the counter rather than hanging on a wall in front of a bench where people sit. Anyone sitting there blocks the view of the menu. My pizza wasn't burned. I felt it was baked to near perfection. I ordered a large deluxe. I had some pizza leftover for the next day. Each time I had a slice I thought how impressed I was with their pizza. I hedged between this pizzeria and another one in town. So glad I chose this one! I recommend Berthoud Pizza Company if you're in town visiting or local. Also, I love how they offer "Mike's Hot Honey" dipping sauce for your pizza crust. I bought one which was plenty for my pizza. Thumbs up from me! When visiting Berthoud again, I will return to this pizzeria, no doubt! read more

I wish there was a 3.5. While I like BPC, it doesn't blow me away. I am notoriously harsh on pizza and this one just doesn't quite have it. While I like it more than an average place, it isn't something I will shout from the rooftops about. A little light on sauce and the crust could be a bit crispier. Close but no cigar. On a side note, my wife is gluten free and says the GF pie here is one of the better ones that she has had. (I have tried BPC three times before reviewing.) read more

Berthoud Pizza Company - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berthoud, Colorado

See all

I've enjoyed this pizza at least two other times. So disappointed this time! it was a 10 inch supreme for ~$20.It was over cooked-- even burnt! The sausage was MINCED!! and dry. Seriously, a bummer of a pizza..... maybe if you tried the veggie...? read more

This is what you get for a large 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 ham. $18 dollars and some change. Wow read more

Berthoud Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Berthoud, Colorado

We were staying at an Airbnb in Berthoud and looking for a local restaurant to support. After reading the reviews and checking out their website, we decided to give this place a try. Charming pizza place that makes delicious food! Highly recommend giving them a try, you won't be let down. read more

Berthoud Pizza Company - Garlic pesto knots - Pizza Near Me - Berthoud, Colorado

See all

I was surprised it was called Berthoud Pizza company and it was in Loveland as I live in Berthoud but it was truly worth the trip! The pizza was fabulous! In fact some if the very best I've ever had and I've tried a lot. I'm very picky about crust and so many pizzas being over sauced, but this pizza offered the perfect balance! I love the outside seating and service was fast and friendly! It's my go to pizza place and I highly recommend it to all pizza lovers and even those who are just unsure. You won't be unhappy! read more

I've eaten a lot of pizza in my travels and I'm personally a ny style guy. I thought they captured that perfectly. Cheese was good, crust was done right and the sauce wasn't over powering or too much. The pizza rolls were different than what I was expecting but I enjoyed them thoroughly. All in all, good price too and on a Friday night it was ready in 20 minutes for pickup read more

Berthoud Pizza Company - Pepperoni rolls - Pizza Near Me - Berthoud, Colorado

See all

Best pizza anywhere around here. New York style extra special ground sausage! There's enough another pizza place here in berthoud that just does not compare let alone places like Pizza Hut or Domino's read more

This is the BEST pizza ever. It is so delicious! I love a simple cheese za but they have all different combos. Classic, which white sauce, or meaty! You also MUST get the pepperoni rolls. They are so dang good. Best pizza in town! read more

First time at the Berthoud Pizza Company. Ordered a garden salad, which was very good. Also had their low-carb cauliflower pizza bowl which was excellent. Topped it off with an order of the sweet Thai chili wings, very tasty! Would definitely recommend this place. read more

I spent over $80 on pizzas for them to show up with caramelized cheese. The pizza was so thin it was difficult to hold.

Check Your Pizza Before Leaving The Store Because Berthoud Pizza Cannot Be Checking Their Pizza The bottom is fully carbonized I live over 20 minutes away so I could not go back. They did offer a credit But tonight's dinner in not edible read more

See all

Go to pizza place in Berthoud. Service is always good. It's a takeout only and the food is a fair value.

Love their pizza and salads. Homemade ranch dressing is amazing! Service is excellent. read more

Ok - don't walk, run to this place. Best pizza I have had in a very long time. Total yum. I had the Margherita Pizza and my husband had the Supreme with side salads. Smack yo mama good. read more

Love the pizza and cheese bread great customer service small place but that's ok pick up or delivery good job BPCo

It's the best pizza in Berthoud and the surrounding area, and trust me, we've tried them all! Berthoud Pizza is our weekly Friday Pie Day go-to, and you can't go wrong with anything you order. The crust is crisp, yet chewy, and it's the only crust everyone in the family (even the kids) will eat! The pepperoni rolls are excellent, don't pass them up! And the wings are great as well. Oh, and don't forget about the ranch, I don't know what they put in it, but it's addicting! Not only is the food excellent, but everyone there is super friendly and welcoming! read more

Got moldy Mac and cheese. I order some food from here to pickup. I got a pizza, wings, garlic knots, and Mac and cheese. Looked at the Mac and there is a green clump of what seems to be mold. I called the place and the guy was not very willing to help either. He claimed that there was "blue cheese" within the Mac. We have gotten this item before and there is never blue cheese. Even so there is only one clump no other place in the Mac has this "blue cheese". It doesn't even list blue cheese as part of the item. Not only this but the guy on the phone acted as if I were stupid not knowing what blue cheese is. read more

Berthoud Pizza Company - Buffalo Mac - Pizza Near Me - Berthoud, Colorado

Our fav pizza shop! Pricer than fast food pizza but you get what you pay for. ALWAYS delicious. Also staff is kind and helpful. Don't miss the wings or appetizers either, so good! read more

The performance did not match the marquee or hype. Basic pizza for premium price. Great service but product is just OK read more

Delicious pizza and good customer service. Tons of unique options. You'd find a place Like this in a big city most often rather than a small town. Just wish they had delivery! read more

Always delicious pizza, and really friendly service. Would highly recommend Berthoud Pizza Company!!

Great pizza, a lot of variety in the menu. We enjoy as our local go to pizza place. Regular customers with consistent results.

Love this place! Good value for money. Open til 8. Always an energetic feel when you pick up.

In areas that are slowly becoming more and more dominated by corporate chains, it's difficult to find good local places anymore. Berthoud Pizza Company is an exception. We visited BPC while in Colorado for a Christmas vacation and we have NO regrets. Very small, simple place but constant traffic in and out. We decided to sit inside and eat there. We were able to catch the end of a good football game and enjoy a supreme pizza and a ham and pineapple one. When they got my pizza wrong, they were all too adamant about making it right and were so sweet about it. Bonus points for the garlic knots that were ridiculously good! I'm only sad that we didn't take any pictures of our food before devouring it! Thanks for a good local experience, Berthoud Pizza Company. read more

Cannot say enough good things. Easily the best pizza pie in Northern Colorado, and not that close. Excellent gluten free options, too. Why anyone would go to either of the other pizza places in town is beyond me. read more

I'm actually considering switching to an all pizza diet after eating here. First of all the pesto garlic knots...I still dream about the pesto garlic knots. Absolutely delicious. My kids and I ate them all up in the car so my husband wouldn't even know about them. They were that good. Then the white pizza...another home run. Hubby did get some of that. It was gone in a flash. I am so glad we tried it! Nice to have another good option so close to home! read more

Eat this pizza often. We always get a great pizza and friendly service. They offer other dishes and salad as well.

Excellent pizza. Probably the best pizza in Berthoud. Their prices are a little high though, compared to competitors.

We absolutely love Berthoud Pizza Company! The staff is so friendly and they take covid serious to protect their guests. I used to order pizza for my cheat nights but now I can order from at any time due to their new low carb menu. Their cauliflower bowls are to die for! read more

This is my favorite pizza! The Greek is amazing! It is so delicious that I can't stop ordering it. I definitely want to try the other toppings as well. This place is amazing! The toppings are so fresh and flavorful! I highly recommend! read more

Always an excellent pizza! My own favorite is pepperoni. My friends like the Greek and the chicken bacon ranch. They make a generous salad with fresh greens and great homemade dressings. read more

Pizza is the best in town for sure and Calzones are amazing appetizers are all good. If you are looking for a pizza spot give this place a shot. read more

The pizza is delicious! Chewy crust and fresh cheese. The salads are fresh and big enough for two if you want to use as a side salad. We have likes every pizza we've tried. read more

This pizza is really tasty and the small, personal location makes you feel like you're ordering from an old friend. They have specials and the pizza is as good as their prices. They have some younger folks working there to help and they are polite, professional and helpful. I can't wait until pizza day again! read more

Pizza is very good, and service is direct. There is little ambiance as this is basically a take out pizza business with just a few tables for eat in. read more

Awesome hometown Pizza Joint! Great Pizza! The owner are great people! Best pizza in Berthoud, CO.

Good pizza with parmigiana and red pepper flakes on it. A little Italian seasoning. Quick. Easy. Nice location for me. Only misgender sometimes. Otherwise perfect. read more

Phenomenal pizza for such a small company, head and heals over everything else in the area, only suggestion would be to rotate one of the pizzas with something new once a month or so seasonal pizzas. read more