Justine's has great pizza. Very authentic. A generous amount of toppings & a wonderful crust.

The pizza here has always been good until our last two visits (both within the past month). There has been a change in the cheese and IMO not for the better. It had nice stretch but now it's more chewy. Harder to get a slice and it doesn't taste as good. The staff is always friendly but this doesn't make up for what I consider to be cheaper ingredients. It will be hard for us to give them another try. read more

Justine's Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Bar service was great Pizza was very good. Some of the best pizza in the area. My only issue is their two sizes are too big for being by myself or with one other person. They need to make some smaller sizes. read more

We had peperoni & sausage and was impressed with the portion of meat for the $$ :D The services was impeccable! Made us feel like home, met new ppl and pretty much hung out with them during our visit :) Local joint, which we like -- so we will be back!! read more

A 10 of 10 second to none! The most scrumptious pizza. Justine's special is our favorite along with Cherry Calzone! Yummy! We will be back. Plus the best part being this is a D.C. establishment and Bargs root beer, which are the best when paired with pizza! read more

See all

We come in to Justine's on a monthly basis - even with the change in ownership, Justine's continues to be the best in town. We absolutely adore Miss Jen, she makes it such a warm and welcoming experience. And Jack, the new owner, is so kind every time we see him. Thank you for a fantastic experience every time. Delicious! read more

We hadn't been here in a while & saw that they had new owners so were curious if things would still be as great as before. Happily, they are. Maybe even better! We highly recommend & will be back for more! read more

Food- excellent pizza...qualifies as 'parlor' style pizza Service - don't be surprised if if the owner stops by to greet you; very good Ambiance - comfortable and quieter than large dining rooms Try it out! read more

Long time customer and very disappointed with the change of ownership. While the pizza seems unchanged, the new owners are not very pleasant. Part of going to a small neighborhood restaurant that has a limited menu and long wait times is the quality of the food but also having an enjoyable, positive experience with the people that work there and feeling that they appreciate your business. That is no longer the case. I've had two bad experiences and witnessed a third by another pair of customers which makes me feel it's not just me or a single bad day. read more

Fabulous pizza. Good Customer service. One disappointment- their checkout system has an auto-tip choice. Tacky. Went from classy to tacky with that little tech upgrade. read more

I'd rate this experience ZERO out of five, if that was an option! Following waiting over an hour for our pizza and observing that the music was way too loud for a dining room full of predominantly older patrons, 26-yr-old co-owner Jack Hummel followed my 83-yr-old mother, who walks VERY slowly, & I to my car, to ask if we'd paid our bill... which we had, without complaining, & still tipping 20%. IGNORANT & INSULTING! LEARN FROM THIS & DO BETTER, JACK! Co-owner mom, Amy Hummel, here's a teaching moment. The bartendress was lovely! And, I believe Amy Hummel stopped by to ask how everything was, which is also appreciated! read more

Super cool place. Great pizza and good service. Always a pleasure to drop in for a pizza and a beer. You can't any better in the Loveland area in my opinion read more

Nicely refurbished interior. I love the classic art that's painted on the walls of the rat pack from the 60's! Tastefully done. A lot of locals eat here so it's definitely got the approval of Loveland! Full bar is awesome and the pizza is incredible. Highly recommend! read more

The service was just okay. The vibe hasn't been the same since Greg passed along the ownership. Probably won't be coming back...

Great pizza! Good crust! We really like Mike's Special! Definitely is worth the wait!

We shouldn't have waited so long to try Justine's Pizza. It's much nicer inside than the modest exterior suggests, with lots of wood and a remarkably good hand-painted portrait of Frank Sinatra on the rear wall. It's a welcoming place; every employee we talked to was friendly. The "Eheart Special" pizza (not sure why it's so named) could just as easily have been called a "Meat Lover's Special"; it was packed with delicious toppings. Very greasy, very filling - and that's how I know that it also reheats at home unusually well. If I had to ding anything, it would be the crust; some are good enough to eat plain, but we didn't think this was one of them. Overall though, very good experience and we'd like to go back. read more

If you are in the mood for Pizza, Justine's is the place. The pizza is always delicious and you can have a cold one while you are waiting.

Probably some of the better pizza I've had in Colorado so far. We did a 5 topping pizza and salads. You can tell they know what they're doing and it feels like a family business. Pizza seems to be their focus, sides are limited and the salad is basic. We'll be back for more pizza! read more

Justine's Pizza - 5 topping combo! - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

Great sauce and topping options. Service is prompt and friendly. Prices are reasonable and comparative with competitors.

The pizza is cooked perfectly and has the right amount of toppings. The cheese bread is cheesy and buttery and made on soft bread with a crispy crust. My margarita was nicely balanced and hit the spot. Service was very friendly. read more

See all

Best pizza in Loveland in my opinion !! Service is always top notch and they all seem like they really enjoy being a part of the team !! I have always done take out but the dining area is always packed with large groups and it looks like a regular dine in spot for many !! Friendly Staff, Fresh ingredients, and a unique and delicious dough. Again, I like the undercarriage a little well done and I always have had it cooked perfectly to my liking! My tip....Get the anchovies on the side ( If you like the fish on your pie...they hook you up !!) read more

Went here strictly because it shared the same name as my daughter. It was hands down some of the best pizza I've had in the country. Crust was perfect, toppings and sauce perfectly balanced, and the service matched up to its super cool vintage jazzy ambiance. read more

Local spot with a cool vibe. Great place to grab a pizza and drinks with some friends!

Pizza was delicious however... We waited over an hour for our pizza . It was brought to our table at 8:50pm. At 9 pm we were told we close at 9pm while cussing multiple times at us. And other customers were also there that had received their food late. Extremely poor service!!! And not cheap prizes.. took our enjoyment away! read more

Order at the counter and then sit down. Maybe call ahead. Might be the best pizza in down. Very good. Honey was fab! Old school vibes. read more

Justine's Pizza - Pineapple, bacon, onion - Pizza Near Me - Loveland, Colorado

My husband and I have tried 4 times this year to eat in at Justine's in Loveland CO. Each time we were advised of a 45 - 60 minute wait to be served! Even though we were there for an early dinner (4:30 or so). The wait was predominantly due to the take out business there. The pizza is good, but not worth that kind of wait. They need to rethink what kind of business they are in. If they are take out only - advertise that way! Not Worth The Wait!! read more

Delicious every time! Owner is always the first face you see which is rare in this day and age. Atmosphere is that of an old school pizza place. Nothing not to love about Justine's. Chuck read more

This is literally the only pizza place that I can go to and not feel gross after I eat it. I have no idea what they do differently, but it's worth the wait every time. read more

I love this place, great pizza, sandwiches and the salads are good too. Get there early or order take early. Dine in is fun and great beers and drinks feet from your table. read more

Old school pizza! Perfect sauce! All ingredients are fresh and plentiful. This is the best pizza around.

Amazing veggie pizza!!! Loved it!! Great salad, bread and service!! We will be back!!

We went to Justine's last night and it was fantastic! Tasty, fresh made pizza. They make their own sauce and dough then put it in the oven and it's served piping hot at your table. We were offered complimentary ranch and honey which I thought was really awesome. We really enjoyed ourselves and felt like it was worth the money. We'll definitely be back! Also, for some reason my phone has lost the picture I took so I'll have to get one next time. read more

We went to justines on a random Wednesday night and it had a steady flow of guests come through but I cannot say enough great things about the staff. Everyone was SO attentive and so friendly!! We got two pizzas to split between a few of us and the crust... oh my goodness... SO delicious! I don't really like greasy pizza either so this was PERFECT as there was hardly any on them! We will definitely be back and even to order from here for takeout moving forward! read more

Love the pizza! So so good! It lived up to all the expectations I thought about! And they even provide honey for your pizza too ;) great service and great ambiance all around! 10/10 read more

Yes, it's the awesome Pizza joint of Loveland! Probably the best I've had in this town! Nothing too fancy, just good quality ingredients, served fresh out of the oven and cheese still wonderfully melting. Good kinda rustic atmosphere to it and a good beer selection to boot. They get it, and it shows :-) read more

If you want amazing Pizza, go to Justine's. Best pizza I have had except for Cart Driver in Denver (but that is altogether a different kind of situation). Don't go to Justine's if you are going to be put off by a long wait, or give a bad review and recommend they do something different to make your individual experience better. There is a reason this place regularly has an hour and a half wait to get your pizza...! Order ahead and pick it up. Betting you won't be disappointed. read more

Order early but the best pizza. We arrived at 6:30 and ordered as we arrived. Greg said is it ok as there is about 1-1/2 hour wait. While we had no issues sitting at the bar knowing the pizza was that good there are times where there is 2 hour wait. They are a huge take out order restaurant. No matter what it is worth the wait. read more

This is by far the best pizza I have found in Colorado. Fantastic owner/employees. Pizza is fantastic and the people are always very friendly and helpful. read more

I grew up in Loveland and eating Justine's Pizza when I was young. It's been in Loveland since 1971. I rediscovered it after years and ordered the Justine's Special 13" (Beef, sausage, pepperoni, onion and olives and mushroom) The portions of the items are very generous and large cuts instead of the scrawny cuts you get at a lot of pizza restaurants. It was delicious. I ordered take out and was a little late getting there and the pizza was still hot and tasty. Service was very friendly. A little pricier that pizza chains, but well worth it because having a generous amount on toppings. Night and day difference in my opinion. I Glad I found it again after all these years. I feel like its better than Black Jack and that was my favorite before! read more

Loved Justine's Pizza! We just moved to the area and wanted to dine-in somewhere that's local. We live not too far away so decided to give it a try. It's big inside! I wasn't expecting the atmosphere inside based on the exterior. Nice booths and tables, a full bar inside, and great ambiance. You order at the counter, and the staff working was crazy nice! We ordered a pepperoni large pizza and drinks. Pizza is a thinner style hand-tossed (more NY style). Lots of toppings and excellent flavor! I liked it. I'd prefer a deep dish style, but enjoyed this none-the-less. Price was reasonable for the amount of food. Staff walked around and checked on folks often. Just really nice people! Definitely recommend. We were here at 4PM on a Saturday, and it wasn't busy inside but they were already backing up with lots of to-go orders, so patience required. read more