Well-stocked for a small-looking place. Excellent fastener selection for common and esoteric little screws, washers, etc. Very limited selection of plumbing fixture cartridges etc. Good, clean, organized local mom & pop shop alternative to the big stores. Keep them fed! read more

I'm old enough to remember when my family first moved to this town during my teen years and there was a bowling alley in this location instead of a hardware store; said bowling alley long gone now, although you can sort of ascertain the configuration and outlines of that bygone "pleasure palace" for what passed for the working-class in Bernardsville (I can't imagine that the blue-bloods up in the posh Bernardsville mountains ever bowled; if they did, they probably had their own private bowling alleys set up on their estates) when you step into the store. It's a relatively small space, but I can't imagine not finding what you need down its narrow aisles and on its fully-stocked shelves. My hardware needs are very limited. I'm not a "do-it-yourself" kinda guy. If I can nail 2 boards together without smashing my finger with the hammer in the process, I'm ahead of the game. Every couple of months, I buy an air filter here to replace my old one. And...that's about it. Although, I've occasionally had other "hardware" needs, and Bernardsville Hardware has never let me down. When I needed a new flashlight, I bought it here. When I needed a kitchen timer, I bought it here. And then there was that mouse... Years ago, my sister "gifted" me with a cat I didn't want, and didn't know was feral (believe me, this isn't one of my long-winded, irrelevant asides; it's germane to the review-- at least, I think it is). In short order, my furniture was destroyed, and I had semi-permanent red stripes up both of my arms, the result of my misguided efforts to be nice and friendly to the cat, given we both were sharing the same abode. I've always had a deathly fear of rodents and I figured...if nothing else...the cat would be useful if any somehow managed to enter my "mancave." When, years later, the cat was on its last legs (and, believe it or not, I cried like a baby when I had to put it down), I was writing at my desk when I saw the cat acting in an odd, uncharacteristic manner. I couldn't figure it out until I saw a black rodent's head poking out from behind the corner of a nearby box. I'm embarrassed to say that I threw myself out of my chair, and yelled, "KILL IT! KILL THE MOTHERF****!!! KILL IT!!!" (So much for all that pacifistic Buddhist literature I had been reading...) My cat was unequal to the task, evidently thinking the mouse was an entertaining visitor, rather than a nauseating intruder. Practically unhinged, I drove down to Bernardsville Hardware, and asked in desperation what I could do. The man unlucky enough to draw me as a customer (although he was very nice) explained to me the process for killing a mouse, provided me with glue traps and an old-fashioned mousetrap, describing how I should put some peanut butter on the trap and leave it up against the wall, where rodents tend to run and defecate. I did as he suggested, although I was in despair, thinking this wasn't going to work. I went into my bedroom to try and read, listen to music and pray to a God I wasn't sure I believed in that this was all going to come out alright (but then what in my life ever does? Boo, hoo, hoo!!!...anyway...). I heard no sound, no indication that things had worked out as the hardware employee had predicted. But when I went to hazard a look, the trap had been sprung, and the intruder was dead (I'm actually glad it hadn't gone to the glue traps; I mean, I wasn't sure what I was supposed to do when the mouse became stuck to them...Was I supposed to batter the mouse to death with a nearby golf club as it tried to free itself? I was still an executioner, but the old- fashioned mousetrap seemed like a more merciful death, at least to a timid soul like myself). (For the curious, I think the mouse wormed its way through a screen door when I was working out in my living room during the chill of November, and I had the glass door open. At least, that's what I think. I've never been bothered by rodents since, thankfully.) My girlfriend at the time lived down the hall and had a fireplace, so I asked if I could borrow the fireplace tongs to dispose of the mouse. Laughing at me and my distress at the thought of touching the thing, she agreed, but I can't help thinking that's one of the reasons we broke up not long afterward. Or maybe it was something else. Anyway... Parking in the front can be tight, but there's ample parking off to the side. Inside, they even have a machine providing popcorn. I've never availed myself of it, but it's a nice touch. Employees are friendly enough, although the last guy ringing me up took my $20 bill and held it up to the light, examining it from one angle, and then another. This isn't the only store where that's happened, and I get it that no business wants to be ripped off by someone distributing fugazy currency, but it was a bit off-putting. Still, this is a close and convenient store for my limited hardware and mouse-killing needs. And I'm a big supporter of small businesses. Recommended. read more

Went to both Bernarsdville Hardware and new Ace Hardware store recently. In my opinion if you know EXACTLY what you want and willing to tolerate a lack of expertise input or even location of said items in Ace, go there for wider selection. If You have a problem and trying to get more expertise on how to fix go to Bernardsville. Expertise versus ??? read more

Great selection of tools & garden supplies, PLUS a Mr Bill chew toy! xxxxxnn n nnn n

Love my almost weekly visits to Bernardsville Hardware! No matter my needs, projects, questions there is always plenty of helpers in the aisles happy to help, explain, and guide. This excellent customer service has been present since we first walked through the doors 26 years ago. Big thanks and bravo to all the Bernardsville Hardware employees! read more

I love this place. The staff are always friendly and helpful. They have a great selection that covers most of what any homeowner needs for there home. Definitely go here before taking the trip to a big box store. read more

The store has a casual and friendly atmosphere. And Good Service must be their middle name. Always attentive to customers' wants; even it means giving informed advice on where to go to ensure you get the product or service you ultimately need. read more

Amazing and attentive service. I went in there looking for obscure and hard to find piece of hardware. I received undivided attention and the clerk did not tire in trying to help me locate it. After a few minutes I was set. My needed purchase was on 42 cents but they had so many other items things I needed for small home repairs that I ended up spending $100 or so. Prob close to what it would have cost at a further away big box place. So happy to have a local gem and will always try there before hopping in my car to look elsewhere. Outstanding service!! That you!!' read more

Bernardsville Hardware is a small store with a large selection and astonishingly convenient hours, and it's easy to get help here. They have plumbing supplies, electrical supplies, paint, keys and even home goods like towel bars and such. I especially like the huge array of loose nuts, bolts and screws (see the picture!) so you can figure out exactly what fits and buy exactly as many as you need, no hassle with blister packs that have 20 when you only need 2. They have very good hours, even open a few hours on Sundays, and I've always been able to get help finding things. This mom-and-pop operation is holding out just fine against the big box stores. read more

See all

Very well run store. Very nice and helpful staff. For a smaller store they always have the items I need. Happy they're down the street.

I prefer to come here instead of going to one of the big box stores. They usually will have the item I need, especially when I need something quickly. The service is always prompt & courteous. Highly recommended! read more

A few weeks ago, I walked into the Bernardsville Hardware store with an unusual request. I was on a mission to construct a wheelchair, made from PVC, for my 15yo German Shepherd who suffered from spine issues. Not only did the store manager help me, but he walked me through the entire build idea and helped me find the right items for the project. Needless to say, the project was a success and within 2 hours, I was home and watching my dog walk again. I've never been so impressed with customer service. read more

Love The Bernardsville Hardware Store!!!!! The hardware store changed owners several years ago and the location almost became a different business. Thankfully, another family decided to lease the location and keep it a hardware store! The thought of having to drive 15 miles for a nail is quite upsetting. The owner, manager, and salespeople are all knowledgable, super friendly and helpful. They have most everything anyone would need, and if they don't, the item may be ordered. Their prices are the same or very close to Home Depot and Lowes; and for the sake of convenience, would hope locals shop here. If we don't shop here, local businesses like to this won't stay in business. Folks, don't just know the cost of products, know the value surrounding them. read more

Great family run business in a time where one is surrounded by chain stores. They carry a surprisingly large amount of stock and the employees are always great to deal with. Super convenient, as it means no long distance highway driving to one of the big stores. I'd much rather frequent the family business any day. read more

Convenient with quite a large selection. Good prices make this a valuable neighborhood store. I found things here that I could not find in Home Depot. read more

I like the store and for the most part the service is good but at times there are lapses. I especially don't appreciate when the check out person ( Eric?) launches into a long and loud conversation with another customer while he is waiting on you. Not appropriate my view. Deal pleasantly with one customer at a time and socialize with pour pals after work. read more