We've been here twice, and both times the bagels have been quite good. Honestly, it's tough to find good New York style bagels in this area, so it was a very welcome find. It's a casual place, focused on bagels. Not a broad New York menu, but what they do they do well. Counter service have been good across both visits. I recommend. read more

I got a vanilla latte asked for it to be not super sweet and it was very sugary. Barely had any coffee taste to it. Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was yummy but nothing spectacular read more

Benny's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

So obsessed w this place!! They have such good options and they always make it perfect!! Definitely recommend

Just had fasting labs done and I was ready for some coffee and breakfast. Did a search for nearby bagels and Benny's popped up. Nice little place with chill music and really friendly service. I went with my usual sesame bagel with a schmear of veggie cream cheese. I received a fresh bagel with a nice chew and tasty cream cheese. The coffee (choices were Benny's Blend (which I tried) and Southern Pecan) was good also. Definitely was a good choice today for breakfast. read more

Benny's Bagels - Sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

They skimped me on the salmon. Used to come here back in the good ole days when you got lot of salmon. Now, i get almost no salmon. Where did the salmon go? read more

Love this place. Been going here for years and they never disappoint. The bagels are so fresh and the service is always amazing.

Do not order through door dash from this store. I ordered a breakfast bagel on door dash and a toasted bagel with cream cheese. The breakfast bagel was a dry egg cake and the protein option selected was not added. Literally a dry bagel with a dry cake of flavorless egg. No cheese as described, no protein as ordered. On top of that, the bagel with cream cheese was cold when it was ordered toasted and there was so much cream cheese I had to remove it and had enough for a small container. If you are not willing to give your door dash customers the same level of service and care as your walk ins, don't take door dash! This was awful product and service! You should be embarrassed! read more

Benny's Bagels - This was the item received - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

I ordered a bacon, egg & cheese with cream cheese on an everything bagel, and I have to say the sandwich itself was really good overall. The bagel didn't taste especially fresh, but the flavors came together nicely and it definitely hit the spot. The vanilla iced latte, however, wasn't my favorite. The straw was stapled to the bag in my pick-up order (which made it unusable), and the drink itself was much more like a milkshake than coffee--extremely sweet, milky, and I couldn't drink it. That said, if you're going for a bagel sandwich, Benny's does a solid job. I'd just stick to the food side of the menu next time. read more

Benny's bagels sells really good bagels and their cream cheese is delicious. I usually buy their everything bagels and a tub of their scallion cream cheese , a great combo! We love supporting great locally owned businesses like Benny's! read more

Great bagels. Our favorite. Friendly staff and quick service. A must stop when we come to town. read more

Benny's Bagels - Menu as of 12/24/25 - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

My friend and I come here every couple of weeks. We've tried different things on menu and they're all genuinely delicious. My husband favorites right now are the spiced chai and early riser sandwich. The prices are very affordable too, especially for the area. The service is exceptional. No matter when we stop by, everyone is always delightful. It's a great breakfast spot to stop by if you have the time. read more

Good selection of fresh bagels to go along with a variety of breakfast choices. Prompt and courteous service with a very accommodating staff. read more

I had the turkey Rueben . Maybe I should've gotten something else ! It was tasteless and could only eat half but the place is clean and staff nice read more

These bagels used to be good but the past few times I've had them they just taste like they are days old.

I have been coming to Benny's Bagels for over 10 + years for breakfast. The owner and his family are super friendly and nice. The bagels are always great. They have happy employees who like working there which is always a sign of a well run restaurant. read more

I think I was excited to get a bagel sandwich here after being in NYC for a few days. I was not impressed with the bagel fixings. The egg was a bit weirdly cooked, the sausage was grey, and there was more cream cheese than protein after I asked for light cream cheese. We tried them again for good measure and it was the same sadly. We will not go back. The store was fine. Small seats and the absolute worst utensils and napkins. lol 1/10 read more

Delicious food, great service, and just overall great place! We are regulars here and I believe we will keep it that way!

Bagels are fantastic! Everything they do here is fresh and quick. My wife and I got the breakfast Benny and a bagel with cream cheese which was about $15 but honestly worth every penny! This place needs more love! read more

Benny's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Good fresh bagels my wife and I went here 3 days in a row for breakfast brunch. The only gripe would be the lack of generosity on the lox bagels which explains the 4 stars. Taste was on par and the staff was nice. Laid back layout in store if you wanted to eat in. Again it would've been 5* but the portion of lox was very chincy. read more

Good service and it wasn't very busy on a Saturday morning. Seemed like a local spot so that was nice. interior is a little dated. But the bagels were fresh. Had the healthy riser and Benny's breakfast. Would like to go back and try other menu items. read more

Benny's Bagels - Top- Benny's Breakfast with sausage on sesame bagel; bottom- Healthy riser on onion bagel - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Great little neighborhood bagel shop. The bagels are fresh and tasty. For my first visit I tried a jalapeño bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. The bagel was yummy and was definitely made fresh in house. The cream cheese seemed like cream cheese and salsa were mixed together. Not what I was expecting but still good. On my next visit (just a few days later) I tried the NYC bagel. This bagel is their version of the Everything bagel + garlic and onion. Very good and worth ordering again. The menu includes other such staples as lox and cream cheese. The line moves pretty quickly but if you are grabbing to go, there isn't much of a waiting area. If you choose to dine in, feel free to snatch one of the tables inside (probably 8 tables or so). Enjoy this little gem or breakfast in or to go. read more

Benny's Bagels - Counter service - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Best bagel spot in McKinney hands down. Service wonderful, food is amazing. Love this gem so much

Got the lox and had to throw it away, not good. Not coming back. It was very questionable. This bagel gave me food poisoning so not eat here!! read more

We love Benny's Bagels! Their Benny's Breakfast bagel and their smoothies are our favorite options. I literally crave their smoothies! We've only ever been for breakfast but definitely recommend. If I had one suggestion, it would be a little less cream cheese ... I typically have to take some off before I eat my bagel. read more

Don't buy online and get cream cheese. Paid $6.27 for two cream cheeses that are not enough for even one bagel. Unreal! read more

Benny's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

food was good, especially the vanilla chai! and the service was really fast - i hardly had to wait.

I've been coming to this bagel shop since I was 18 (Im now 25) and wow, just wow. Amazing and kind people/business owners. Their food is absolutely delicious and every friend I've brought has said it makes them feel warm and at home. Love love love Bennys Bagels and I could spend all day talking about their great food and service! read more

Bagels were undercooked and almost white on the outside. Everything bagel had only sesame, poppy and sunflower seeds, no onion or garlic. Ordered by phone and picked up to have for Christmas morning - opened the bag when I got home and was so disappointed. read more

Omggg I love bennys!! This is my favorite location. They never miss! Always delicious every time I go! I love the bennys breakfast bagel!! So tasty!! Very cozy shop, very friendly service! read more

For a hole in the wall bagel shop this was so good! This was a fun find so close to home. read more

Benny's Bagels - Spiced chai iced latte; Benny's Breakfast Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Bennys bagel is really good . The only reason I removed a star is due to the lack of meat provided on the bagel. The egg is substantial but could use more cheese and meat. The establishment has. About 6 tables so it's very quaint but I would definitely return. The price is reasonable and the food is good. read more

Benny's Bagels - Benny's Breakfast Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

I'm from New York City, and this The best bagel and breakfast place in the area. Come here almost every weekend with my family. Great service, great food, and a cute atmosphere. Highly recommend this to anyone who is tired of chains and look for a great family-run restaurant to start the morning out right! read more

Great bagels! They are freshly made every day. They have a great selection of flavors. Some of my favorites: everything, NYC, cranberry, blueberry and plain. read more

Don't waste your time or your money here. I ordered for my daughter a plain bagel with plain cream cheese and a sprite via DoorDash. The bagel was completely burnt (my daughter sent a picture to me) and the sprite had zero syrup in it - just plain carbonation. I called to see if we could fix it. The employee had the owner call me and say "We just don't give food to anyone. You can just buy it again." We just wanted her order fixed. Simply that. I even made sure my daughter didnt eat or drink anymore other than the couple bites at first. I've been in the service industry. I know how it works. We were fully prepared to give that order back to the restaurant in full transparancy. I also informed the restaurant of that. Just absurd customer service. I truly will never go back here. read more

I often get their breakfast sandwiches for the family. It's quick, tasty and relatively cheap. I recommend it.

I moved here from Maryland and miss NE Bagles but Benny's does it right and they have Salt Bagels on the weekend.

Total New Yorker here, writing this review. If you are a new yorker, then you know how important it is to have a good bagel with cream cheese and lox. To date, I haven't found a comparable bagel.. until now. My bagel didn't exactly have the tough shell that I'm used to but it had the flavor and the inside chew factor. I was there for lunch, happen to be nearby, and grabbed a honey wheat (trying to be healthy here!) with cream cheese, lox, and yes with the capers. It being lunch, they were out of a few of the flavors of bagel, so my advice is to go early, which I plan on doing next time I'm in that area. If i wasn't seeing patients, I would have totally gotten the everything bagel OR their version of a NYC bagel.. which is an everything bagel + onion + garlic. IMO, that might be overkill! It would definitely keep the mosquitos away. The only thing that would have made this perfect lunch was a little 1/4 pound container of either macaroni salad or potato salad (that's how they serve it in NY) but I really can't ask for too much! read more

Benny's Bagels - Toasted sesame bagel with egg salad and tomato. Reminds me of home (NYC!) - Bagels Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Bagels were good. Though the staff looked bored and the signage was a bit confusing, spread out and messy. The combination made for an awkward exchange when ordering. It fits the bill for a fresh baked bagel, but there's still a bit of finesse missing here. read more

Great little place for bagels and such. Small eat-in area. Nice variety of bagels & breakfast sandwiches. Very nice manager. read more

Benny's was great! My boyfriend and I both got egg sandwiches and they were exactly what we were hoping for. The bagels are clearly fresh and everything is prepared to order- even the eggs are cracked fresh to order! Service was very friendly also. read more