Order Benny Palmetto's Takeout or Delivery
Benny Palmetto's Photos
Business Info
Benny Palmetto's Popular Dishes
BENNY PALMETTO'S ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Benny Palmetto's
Recommended Reviews - Benny Palmetto's
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
This is my first time popping into here. I had a little pizza date outing with my daughter. The slices were huge bigger than our heads lol. She was so excited to see them. She's a plain cheese kind of girly and I decided on pepperoni but next time I'm definitely gonna get a specialty slice. It was fresh hot and I love a crispy crust. It was quick. We didn't have to wait long.
If you're a fan of pizza and portion size matters to you, giant slices are a must-try experience. There's something indulgently satisfying about holding a slice that's bigger than your face. These oversized slices aren't just a novelty--they're often a surprisingly solid choice for both quality and value.
Grabbed bennys the other night after going to shem creek and it was so easy. We just walked over because it's so close. They were about to close but were really nice and put more slices in for our big crowd. We all got pepperoni and it was a hit. This late night pizza is so yummy post drinks. Always, always get a side of ranch! Their crust is by far my favorite part but will eat it all. We sat outside on the bench and just chatted for a bit and it was nice. They also had drinks in their fridges so some of us got water while some got soda, they also serve beer but we didn't need anymore of that hahah! Thank you bennys for a late night snack!
All of the Above! Especially late Night Pizza cravings. No Seating after 1:30. Parking Lot Enjoyment is accepted
I have often passed this pizza shop and have wanted to try it as we love NY style pizza. We finally were able to last night and it was fantastic! We ordered ahead online for pickup and it was extremely easy to do so. Their website is easy to navigate and so is their online ordering feature. We went with a 28" pizza that had us laughing with a car full of people it was hard to get the box in! The pizza was eight HUGE slices and was enough to feed six people (four adults and two children) with two slices left over. It was delicious! The pizza is thin and having lived in New York for several years it was exactly what we remember during our time there. We went with the half cheese/half pepperoni and both were flavorful and filling. If you are wanting to feed a crowd and looking for an easy and fun meal show up with a Benny's pizza box. My kids were shocked at the size and we truly enjoyed our pizza!
I was pleasantly surprised by this enormous pizza. First of all I have never seen such a big pizza pie! When my son came out with it I was amazed with how he was holding it. Then we had to figure out how to get it in the vehicle. We literally had to significantly tilt it to get it inside. Huge! We got it home and thoroughly enjoyed this pizza. It was tasty. Everyone really liked it. Typically there is someone in the group that isn't happy, but not tonight. It was very very good. I suggest you give it a try.
Came here for a slice of pizza since it was close to my hotel and the girl who greeted me did not say hello so should I even say greeted? Didn't seem like she wanted to be there. The slice of pizza itself was ok. It was huge and can be shared.
Holy moly. This pizza was HUGE! I have legit never had a pizza slice this big. Our Uber driver picked us up and we all wanted that greasy 4th meal after drinking a lot. We've all been there...right? He pulled into Benny's. It was about 30 minutes before close but they whipped our pizza up in about 20 minutes. The flavor was great. I love the sauce. It wasn't too sweet but had a nice sweet flavor. It was expensive for pizza but totally worth it. If you're craving pizza, this is the place to go!
My friend and I joked last night that it was probably our first time eating at Benny Palmetto's sober, as it usually occurs after a night of drinking since the place is open and serving hot pizza until 2:00 am. Seems like others have gotten the memo, as well. We arrived around 12:30 am, and were definitely sober, though, even then, the pizza served us well. As others have obviously mentioned, the slices are huge (see my pic with my hand near a slice for comparison). We opted for a classic pepperoni slice while I ordered something on special: spinach, ricotta, and garlic. Each slice is from about $4.00 - $5.50. We used our plastic utensils to slice our pizza slices halfway down the middle so we could each share a different taste. Good stuff. Paid $1.50 for a side of garlic sauce (similar to, but not as good as, Papa John's), marinara sauce, and ranch. There's many drink options in a refrigerator so you're bound to find something you like, whether you drink soda or sparkling water etc. I certainly recommend this place if you're ever looking for a bite especially after 11:00 out in Mt. Pleasant. I'm not sure that I would personally come and sit down to eat here during the day, but others have mentioned its a good choice for that. Overall, I say Benny Palmetto's is A-OK, and I'm certainly glad they came to Coleman Blvd.
I little piece of NY in the Lowcountry. Having lived in NYC with slice places virtually EVERYWHERE- this is a welcome spot for my family. Perfect for getting a large slice to go over to Shem Creek park picnic and walk. One slice is large enough to satisfy. Good drink selection as well. Our take out is usually fast, friendly, and delicious. Pro tip- I get my slice cut in half- but my NYC husband likes it whole to fold while eating.
We were having a hard time trying to find somewhere open at 2 on a Monday. We pulled in, and noticed there were no cars in the parking lot, my husband said "oh no that's never a good sign, but it's 2:00" and I said "who can mess up pizza tho?" We walked in, and was very confused. They have about 5 signs over a register that I assume is the menu.. not many options. The girls at the register, were no help. We settled with the combo for $10 ea, they were confused when we asked for the drink that came with it, telling us the meal didn't and had to ask someone..... the combo was written down right behind them lol. The portions are big I'll give them that. But the sausage on my husbands looks like they just took a piece of cooked cheese pizza and add it on top. I had the jalapeño and cheddar, which looks like they did the same. How can I tell? It's a cheese pizza with diced jalepenos and cheddar sprinkled on top.... Not usually what you would expect. They also have a big oven up front that we never saw used while us and 2 others ordered, so I'm just assuming lol. So, I will say 2 stars because we got a huge pizza, and starving. And you can mess up pizza apparently:(
22 days ago
29 days ago
I love coming to Benny's anytime I'm in a city with one. It's always great quick service and the biggest slices. Their full pizza is 28in and enough to feed many. They have great combo that includes a slice, dip, drink, and cookie and for an upcharge your can get beer or wine. Even with just two people working t the service was quick and friendly. They have a huge selection of soft drinks and teas in the coolers including several soda flavors you don't see often. This is one of the best easy going places for a quick meal while out and about or when in town running errands. read more
1 year ago
This is my first time popping into here. I had a little pizza date outing with my daughter. The slices were huge bigger than our heads lol. She was so excited to see them. She's a plain cheese kind of girly and I decided on pepperoni but next time I'm definitely gonna get a specialty slice. It was fresh hot and I love a crispy crust. It was quick. We didn't have to wait long. read more
3 months ago
1 year ago
If you're a fan of pizza and portion size matters to you, giant slices are a must-try experience. There's something indulgently satisfying about holding a slice that's bigger than your face. These oversized slices aren't just a novelty--they're often a surprisingly solid choice for both quality and value. read more
Grabbed bennys the other night after going to shem creek and it was so easy. We just walked over because it's so close. They were about to close but were really nice and put more slices in for our big crowd. We all got pepperoni and it was a hit. This late night pizza is so yummy post drinks. Always, always get a side of ranch! Their crust is by far my favorite part but will eat it all. We sat outside on the bench and just chatted for a bit and it was nice. They also had drinks in their fridges so some of us got water while some got soda, they also serve beer but we didn't need anymore of that hahah! Thank you bennys for a late night snack! read more
8 months ago
1 year ago
2 years ago
All of the Above! Especially late Night Pizza cravings. No Seating after 1:30. Parking Lot Enjoyment is accepted read more
I have often passed this pizza shop and have wanted to try it as we love NY style pizza. We finally were able to last night and it was fantastic! We ordered ahead online for pickup and it was extremely easy to do so. Their website is easy to navigate and so is their online ordering feature. We went with a 28" pizza that had us laughing with a car full of people it was hard to get the box in! The pizza was eight HUGE slices and was enough to feed six people (four adults and two children) with two slices left over. It was delicious! The pizza is thin and having lived in New York for several years it was exactly what we remember during our time there. We went with the half cheese/half pepperoni and both were flavorful and filling. If you are wanting to feed a crowd and looking for an easy and fun meal show up with a Benny's pizza box. My kids were shocked at the size and we truly enjoyed our pizza! read more
2 years ago
6 years ago
I was pleasantly surprised by this enormous pizza. First of all I have never seen such a big pizza pie! When my son came out with it I was amazed with how he was holding it. Then we had to figure out how to get it in the vehicle. We literally had to significantly tilt it to get it inside. Huge! We got it home and thoroughly enjoyed this pizza. It was tasty. Everyone really liked it. Typically there is someone in the group that isn't happy, but not tonight. It was very very good. I suggest you give it a try. read more
1 year ago
Came here for a slice of pizza since it was close to my hotel and the girl who greeted me did not say hello so should I even say greeted? Didn't seem like she wanted to be there. The slice of pizza itself was ok. It was huge and can be shared. read more
2 years ago
2 years ago
Holy moly. This pizza was HUGE! I have legit never had a pizza slice this big. Our Uber driver picked us up and we all wanted that greasy 4th meal after drinking a lot. We've all been there...right? He pulled into Benny's. It was about 30 minutes before close but they whipped our pizza up in about 20 minutes. The flavor was great. I love the sauce. It wasn't too sweet but had a nice sweet flavor. It was expensive for pizza but totally worth it. If you're craving pizza, this is the place to go! read more
My friend and I joked last night that it was probably our first time eating at Benny Palmetto's sober, as it usually occurs after a night of drinking since the place is open and serving hot pizza until 2:00 am. Seems like others have gotten the memo, as well. We arrived around 12:30 am, and were definitely sober, though, even then, the pizza served us well. As others have obviously mentioned, the slices are huge (see my pic with my hand near a slice for comparison). We opted for a classic pepperoni slice while I ordered something on special: spinach, ricotta, and garlic. Each slice is from about $4.00 - $5.50. We used our plastic utensils to slice our pizza slices halfway down the middle so we could each share a different taste. Good stuff. Paid $1.50 for a side of garlic sauce (similar to, but not as good as, Papa John's), marinara sauce, and ranch. There's many drink options in a refrigerator so you're bound to find something you like, whether you drink soda or sparkling water etc. I certainly recommend this place if you're ever looking for a bite especially after 11:00 out in Mt. Pleasant. I'm not sure that I would personally come and sit down to eat here during the day, but others have mentioned its a good choice for that. Overall, I say Benny Palmetto's is A-OK, and I'm certainly glad they came to Coleman Blvd. read more
I little piece of NY in the Lowcountry. Having lived in NYC with slice places virtually EVERYWHERE- this is a welcome spot for my family. Perfect for getting a large slice to go over to Shem Creek park picnic and walk. One slice is large enough to satisfy. Good drink selection as well. Our take out is usually fast, friendly, and delicious. Pro tip- I get my slice cut in half- but my NYC husband likes it whole to fold while eating. read more
5 years ago
We were having a hard time trying to find somewhere open at 2 on a Monday. We pulled in, and noticed there were no cars in the parking lot, my husband said "oh no that's never a good sign, but it's 2:00" and I said "who can mess up pizza tho?" We walked in, and was very confused. They have about 5 signs over a register that I assume is the menu.. not many options. The girls at the register, were no help. We settled with the combo for $10 ea, they were confused when we asked for the drink that came with it, telling us the meal didn't and had to ask someone..... the combo was written down right behind them lol. The portions are big I'll give them that. But the sausage on my husbands looks like they just took a piece of cooked cheese pizza and add it on top. I had the jalapeño and cheddar, which looks like they did the same. How can I tell? It's a cheese pizza with diced jalepenos and cheddar sprinkled on top.... Not usually what you would expect. They also have a big oven up front that we never saw used while us and 2 others ordered, so I'm just assuming lol. So, I will say 2 stars because we got a huge pizza, and starving. And you can mess up pizza apparently:( read more
4 years ago
It was a big slice but it was not cheesy. Bit into it and instantly reminded me of dehydrated cheese crisps. read more
3 years ago
1 year ago
3 years ago
6 years ago
I've heard lots about this place and had to try it! It's an experience in itself to eat pizza slices bigger than your face, but it was pretty good pizza! Definitely flavorful and filling. Their ranch is also very creamy. I ordered through grub hub via Yelp and it was a very smooth, painless process! read more
3 years ago
5 years ago
I was pleasantly surprised. This pizza is by far the best I've had in a long time. I'm from Long Island and my husband is from Jersey. We are a little picky about our pizza. I've found my new spot . Crispy thin crust. Sauce is amazing . Called and spoke to Alex to let him know how pleased we were. He was so polite and professional and a bonus he's from south Jersey . People generally only call to complain this pie warranted a compliment call !!! Thanks again. Highly recommend. We will be coming in for dinner soon . I'm excited to try your Italian entrees. read more
5 years ago
Awesome star and great soft drink selection! The pizza topping options are limited but the pizza was great. One slice will feed a family. No but seriously huge slices! read more
For some reason I'm just finding this place. Pizza is good. Crust is great. Prices are very reasonable. Taxes are included, and drinks aren't overpriced. Friendly service. The slices are huge! They are literally the size of an entire pizza at chain places like Pizza Hut or Dominos. And they are open until Midnight! Will definitely return. read more
4 years ago
3 years ago
7 years ago
When you need pizza late at night after a baseball game this is the place to go! They have limited options of pizza but at least they have the basics. We chose their April Special which was black olives, banana peppers a feta. Unfortunately my giant slice of pizza only had one spec of feta. The service was great! The gentleman who rung us up was friendly. We had no problem ordering and we were served within 10 minuets. read more
I'm gonna lean more on the positive here because I've had some mixed experiences. I've been going to Benny's since they opened and it's always nice to have as an option for a quick slice at lunch or to feed a late night pizza craving. I've done a whole pie a couple times and with family in town including a bunch of nieces and nephews, a whole pie really fed an army. I'm not a huge fan of adding toppings to pizza and then reheating it, but I understand why they do it I guess. If you have waste at the end of the night, each slice is like a whole small pizza. The staff is where I've sometimes run into issues. They seem to staff the place with mostly young kids who just don't really care at the end of the day. One mishap involved simple instructions to double cut a pizza... they forgot. Another involved the staff finding a palmetto bug on the floor while I was in eating. Instead of discreetly trying to deal with it, the two staff members moved booths around, screaming about a bug, and spraying pesticide trying to kill it. Really? I'm trying to eat over here. Ended up packing it up and just taking it to go. At the end of the day, I do like their pizza and enjoy the fact that they are a late night option in the Coleman blvd area. Overall my experiences have leaned more positive than negative so I'll be the glass-half-full guy. Hopefully they'll get the staff on board with how to run a restaurant. read more
7 years ago
Page 1 of 5
More info about Benny Palmetto's
433 W Coleman Blvd
Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
Directions
(843) 388-4332
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.bennypalmettos.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Benny Palmetto's
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
8 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
10 years ago
4 years ago
11 years ago
9 years ago
6 years ago
5 years ago
7 years ago
