This may as well be called "my second kitchen" since we eat here so much (and get takeout regularly).
Bear Tooth is something Anchorage lacks, which is a good restaurant catering to a number of tastes. If I'm feeling like more "entree-style dining," the Grill usually satisfies my needs. In fact, the Grill and the Theater Pub are so different I'm going to give a rundown of each.
GRILL:
The nicer, sit-down dining portion of Bear Tooth. You can order food to-go, however the Grill is composed of many entrees that taste better when you eat them in house. The dinner menu is weighted heavily towards Southwestern/ Mexican food, which is probably my main gripe. I mean this with love, but it is certainly gringo Mexican food. There are only a few items from the Mexican category that I like at Bear Tooth, and thus I have less desirable options at dinner. Lunch may be the standout.
Nevertheless, I've eaten my way around this menu. Below are the grades:
Garlic Cilantro Fries: A+ (so good they should be outlawed)
Habanero Chicken Skewers: A+ (crunchy outside, moist inside, delish)
Buiscuts and Gravy: A (brunch only)
Fresh Jalapeno Poppers: A
Mexican Corn (special veggie side dish): A
Guacamole and Chips: A-
Peanut Noodles with Tofu and Veggies: A- (available vegan)
Lamb Skewer: A-
Mushroom and Chicken Fettuccine: A-
Pork Tenderloin with Mac and Cheese: A- (B+ for the pork, A for the mac)
Potato Burrito: B+ (delicious in a sinful way, but gets too heavy)
Pork Colorado Tacos: B+ (colorado sauce is good, pork can be dry)
Harissa Pork Chop with Kale and Farro (special): B (kale A-)
El Oso Salad: B
Chile Rellenos: B
Blackened Scallops: B- (have not been seared well every time I've ordered)
Shrimp Tostadas: C (lacking flavor)
Tri-Salsa Plate: C (lacking substance, portion is small)
Avocado Tomato Salad: C (underwhelming, could use some ingenuity)
Anaheim Turkey Club: C
Breakfast Burrito: D (never again, tasted like spicy baby food in a tortilla)
THEATER PUB:
The Theater Pub must have been the brainchild of an extremely wise owner who said, "Okay world, I will give you a second Moose's Tooth, but not call it Moose's Tooth, so we can have all the tourists convene in one location and not spoil the second one."
Thank you, wise owner.
In truth, the Theater Pub is almost indistinguishable from Moose's Tooth, except you're on the theater side of Bear Tooth, which seriously lacks the Moose's Tooth charm. Other than that and a few sparing menu items, I can close my eyes and taste Moose's Tooth Perfection.
As before, below is the breakdown:
Mozzarella Breadsticks: A+ (and on the second day, God created these)
The Classic Pizza: A
Pizza, in general: A (need to order a medium to get the full effect)
Chipotle Steak Pizza: A
Homemade Root Beer: A
Chocolate Chip Cookie a la Mode: A-
Hot Turkey Sandwich: A-
Caesar Salad: B+ (good dressing, but that's all)
Barbecue Chicken Pizza: B
Apple Walnut Salad: C
Blue Cheese Salad: C (half the grapes are usually mushy)
ALL burritos: C (tortillas are cold, taste is underwhelming no matter the combo)
Tostada Salad: D (looks like the Mexican prep counter spilled in a plate)
Breadsticks: D (such a vast difference between these and the mozzarella ones)
***If you are startled by the breadth of my grade list, note the second sentence of my review. I wasn't kidding about the whole "second kitchen" thing.
Overall, Bear Tooth holds a special place in my heart and my cell phone speed dial. It's a local favorite for a reason. And the events are great too. read more