We stopped at BC Pizza in Deposit, NY today while taking a scenic drive from West Point to Fort Drum, and we're so glad we did! BC Pizza is a small, adorable restaurant with outdoor seating. It's very clean, beautifully decorated, and has a menu with so many options that it was hard to decide what to order. I was with my daughter and my two grandchildren, and we all ordered personal pan pizzas. My daughter and I also had side salads. The owner, John, greeted us and took such wonderful care of our family. He was incredibly friendly, personable, and amazing with the kids. When he brought out our salads, he surprised the grandchildren with their own little plates of salad and a dollop of ranch dressing so they could enjoy a salad too. It was such a thoughtful gesture. Our pizzas came out very quickly, and John paid attention to every little detail. The adults' pizzas were cut normally, but he cut our two-year-old's pizza into tiny bite-sized squares and sliced our four-year-old's pizza into very thin pieces that were easy for him to eat. They were both so excited! Even more impressive, our four-year-old--who is an extremely picky eater--ate his entire pizza, which almost never happens. Before we left, we decided to pick up dinner for later and ordered Reubens along with a quart of the smoky chicken and fire-roasted vegetable soup. Everything was absolutely incredible! It's rare to find a place with delicious food, outstanding service, and such genuine hospitality. John made us feel like valued guests, and those extra touches made our visit truly memorable. We don't get through Deposit very often, but BC Pizza has definitely earned repeat customers. We'll absolutely be back the next time we're in the area! read more

This is my second review omg again amazing blt hero there bread is home made . The price is very fair the staff is very nice and friendly

The owner John plus employee are super nice. Their speciality sandwiches you must try especially the London broil Melt. Everything is delicious. So happy you are here close by. Thank you all for your delicious food Have a GREAT 2025 Toby and Barbara's read more

Wow! Stopped at this gem on the way back from Ithica. Drive by Wendy's when you get off the highway and have a great bacon cheese burger and fries or cheese steak - service was friendly and food was great! read more

Clean, great place to eat. Service and subs are awesome . Try the spiedie sub or wrap.

I stopped here while passing through this town. It seemed super convenient and right near the highway. I was glad I found it because they had slices ready to go. The pizza was hot and fresh. But it definitely tasted microwaved. The "crust" was mushy and tasted wet. The cheese and sauce were of very low quality. I probably wouldn't come back here, regardless of how frequently I drive by this place. read more

See all

Absolutely love your chicken tenders, this last time I ordered the quality went down. They aren't crunchy or real chicken, these are formed chicken patties. Other than that, when I walked in the smell of fresh brewed coffee hit me and the sub case looked AMAZING! read more

I was working in the area and decided to stop at BC Pizza for lunch . So glad I did ! I will return , food was fresh and the service was great . read more

Solid sandwich and friendly service. Perfect after a long day fishing the West Branch.

Today I ordered chicken tender, fries and a side of blue cheese dressing. After I got home I discovered the side of blue cheese dressing was missing. read more

The pictures on the menu are not even close to what you receive. I ordered chicken fingers and got small balls of fried breading some had chicken in them. I tried to message them and they blocked me from messenger and their FB page. I never would post such a review had they simply listened to my complaint. Twice they forgot my drinks on delivery and was over charged for a sale item and told it was only for eat in yet the FB page never mentioned it. Expect disappointment and rudeness and you won't be disappointed. read more

BC Pizza & More - What I ordered - Pizza Near Me - Deposit, New York

See all

Good pizza, got the pepperoni large pie for 20bucks I believe. The size of the pepperoni is like super sized. Circumference of my 14yr old daughter fist was smaller the pepperoni. read more

My family orders from here all the time and have always received amazing service. Although no restaurant or food service is ever PERFECT, these guys are always willing to correct any mistake. They are the only place in town that offers delivery. Food is always hot and fresh. Top quality deli meat and cheese. I am quite picky when it comes to my food. John and Randy have always gone above and beyond to satisfy my requests. Delicious food at a very reasonable price. They have also catered a few events for us and have always nailed it. read more

Great Pizza. Very friendly staff. Try one of their Huge 16" Pizzas for a filling meal plus!

Great food! Try their toasted ravioli and homemade mozzarella sticks. If you're a vegetarian the veggie burger is amazing. They also deliver to Oquaga Lake! read more

See all

I haven't had a bad slice from here the many times I've stopped in. I'm from Jersey so I think I know a good pie when I taste it. The sauce is homemade, not the sauce from a tin can. The cheese is really good quality and you can tell by the lack of grease pouring off a hot slice. Cheap cheese is oily and greasy. Their crust is really good firm, light, crispy and nice dark golden brown. By the way, the staff is always friendly and attentive. A real mom and pop family operation. A pizza shaped gem in Deposit, NY read more

Good pizza fresh coffee made for just me. Very nice people. Pizza is great but other food was frozen from box. Fried shrimp did hot the spot. read more

BC Pizza & More - Found this funny this place of Rt 81 It had 5 Stars so we thought we would try it. - Pizza Near Me - Deposit, New York

See all

Driving down hwy 17 and stopped here because of the reviews. So glad we did. Calzones were huge and wonderful! Full of anything you could want. Definitely hand made. Staff really friendly. Will hopefully come back through on our travels. read more

Honestly the owner's Randy and John are so nice. They make you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door. I think that means a lot showing you care about the service you're giving to your customers. Very quick service and the food is always super amazing. Small town hidden gem! Thanks! read more

I ordered from this establishment and asked if they delivered and they said yes your little out of the area but yes, and once I receive the food the order was wrong and when I called and told the owner which happened to answer the phone about it all he's did was started to yell at me about not leaving the driver a tip and that there was a place to leave a tip when the payment method was texted to me. When I explained there wasn't or I didn't see it he said yes there is and never to order back from that establishment again quote. I was then informed there was a $200 minimum to deliver to where I was at which I was not aware of and should have been informed when I placed the order over the phone. I then told the owner it wasn't intentional that I didn't leave a tip and then proceeded to yell and chastise me about the order and said that my business was no longer welcome... So in short he has not only lost my business but a big organization's business that usually orders hundreds and hundreds of dollars from this establishment every year. Great job owner! read more

I have been to this pizza place quite a few times, while I enjoy some of their other food I honestly don't care much for their pizza. Your opinion may differ since pizza lovers palates are always much different! The owners are nice and it is always very friendly when I go inside to pick up my order. read more

This place may be a pizza joint in a small town in deleware county but don't let that fool you. Their hamburgers are top notch delicious. I'm a big fan of the bacon cheeseburger. Mmmmm heading up to deposit tonight this place will be my first stop. read more

We consider ourselves Pizza Snobs and BC is as good as it gets. We drive from Hancock to Deposit about 3 or 4 times a month for pizza and it's worth it every time. Food is always fresh... staff is always friendly. read more

We were very surprised to find a pizza place, in a small town, with really good pizza. Great job BC Pizza!

We have lived in the area for many years and this is by far the best Pizza we have around. I commute several days a week to Binghamton for work and often stop to bring food home to the kids and husband. They are always friendly, the serving sizes are more than adequate and the price is far with a quality and cleanliness that can't be beat in a 50 mile radius. read more

Saw this place on Yelp. Food was fantastic, all home made. Guys were really friendly. Would do share his 45 year old Spedie recipe though LOL. definitely recommend !!! read more

We recently moved to the area and discovered BC Pizza & more and after trying a couple of sandwiches along with their wings, we were hooked! the food selection was amazing! These guys offer a large variety of excellent dishes. The portions will leave you full and the taste is absolutely amazing. Great little place in Deposit NY! read more

This place is a hidden gem! Known for pizza, their BBQ is amazing -- we bought them out of their chicken to feed 12 of us at the lake and they were incredibly helpful and accommodating. Big fan - go there now! read more

Wonderful service. We were brought a high chair for the baby without our asking for one. Our son was overheard wanting some of my iced tea and he was offered some tea in his water. The pizza was very hot and his pizza was cooled for him. The pizza and garlic knots sets delicious. We will be coming again when in the area. read more