Barnyard Betsy&#x27;s

Sooo good! Great cheesesteaks and fries!! Been coming here forever and it is always great!!read more

My ratings are 5 Star Fries 4 Star Philly Cheesesteak with caramelized onions. The Philly was…read morepresented well and had enough meat and cheese. I got this to go and the service was fast and customer service was great. The French fries are made with beef tallow, which you can tell they also had the right amount of crisp, very good. The cheesesteak was solid overall, just lack some flavor (salt,pepper, etc.) would have helped, but overall solid spot in Corolla.

Mushroom and pepper cheesesteak

#3 Philly cheesesteak with wiz

See all

Bacon cheesesteak

OBX Deli & Cheesesteaks

3.3(12 reviews)

47.0 mi

Went here after trying to go to a neighboring bakery because the bakery was sold out and packed to…read morethe brim. The workers here were personable and happy. The service was super quick and the food was exactly what I wanted to start the morning off. Got a sausage egg and cheese bagel and everything was cooked just right with all the buttery goodness you could ask for. It was cool to be able to walk around the connecting store while we waited for the food as well. Overall, very good atmosphere and great food

The cleanliness of the environment was lacking over all. Although the food was edible it was…read moreextremely low quality for the price.

Seating area & Ice cream, candy, drinks & trinkets

See all

Another shot of the seating area

757 Philly Cheesesteak Cafe

3.9(17 reviews)

81.2 mi

I was hungry for a cheesesteak and was curious about this place. Based on the previous reviews I…read morethought it was worth a try. I was also intrigued about the cheesesteak egg rolls. I hate to say it but I didn't like it. I ordered a cheesesteak and a chicken cheesesteak egg roll. My biggest complaint with both was the meat was chopped way too fine for me. I'm use to big slices of steak and chicken in my cheesesteaks. The sub roll was also not substantial enough to stay intact when I bit into it. It just fell apart. I will try this place again when I'm visiting the area because like I said earlier others thought it was great. I'll also go earlier next time because I overheard the cook say while I was waiting, "here comes the end of the night rush." They had some good foot traffic.

Let's get into it! This Cheesesteak Cafe is a "Mom and Pops Joint" located at Peninsula Town…read moreCenter. It serves Philly-style cheesesteaks, samplers, egg rolls, exceptional customer service, and some of the Best Wings I have had in the area! The restaurant is relatively small and gloomy, with enough seating to hold about 20 people for dine-in; however, this place is not a dine-in but a takeout place. I like that they put their full menu online, unlike other places that only put limited items. Service is outstanding; my first time calling in an order, the server not only told me how long it would be. Also, on this occasion, after calling in my order and completing the call, the server realized there was something that they did not have at the time. So she took the time to call and let us know and offered us something else. It was honorable in my eyes that she did that. Lastly, when I arrived, she double-checked to ensure my order was correct before I left the store. I had a cheesesteak, and my wife had the same. They were served hot, cheese melted all the way, and tasted terrific; the only problem was they were light with the meat. This is a very unique menu. They have sampler platters that can feed an army or combo platters that can feed two, and the price is right. You can mix and match them or have the pre-selected item. Now, let me talk about these wings. AMAZING! Fried to perfection, seasoned with a wet or dry rub, plain or on the side. These are cooked to order, so if you get wings to go, they are still hot when you get home. These wings are excellent, and you get them whole or halved. The wings are a must-try; they are some of the best in the area! I recommend you call ahead, but if you don't, there is a seating area where you can wait. I will be back! Happy Yelping!

757 Philly Cheesesteak Cafe @ Hampton - Peninsula Town Center (PTC)

Half Cheesesteak with Fried Onions, Mushrooms and Provolone, Side of Fries

See all

Wall

Philly Style Steaks & Subs

4.3(225 reviews)

72.3 mi

I went in based on great recommendations and found out that they were all true!! The food was…read moregreat, the price was reasonable and the service was quicker than they told me it would be! We'll be going back!!

I.... I think the old owners sold and now there are new owners... it is NOT the same. Not even…read moreclose.

Lunch was served and it didn't disappoint!

See all

Philly memorabilia

Iggles Cheesesteaks & Burgers

4.1(323 reviews)

69.7 mi

I've traveled the whole country & came to realize that the best cheesesteak is right here at home!…read moreYou want a good cheesesteak don't look elsewhere!!!

Never again Wawa actually has a better cheesesteak. This is a half sub for $9.99 plus tax. Never…read moreagain.

This is the Drinks and Chips area. Photo taken January 6, 2023.

See all

This is an overall view of the dining area. Photo taken January 6, 2023.

Phillyfried

5.0(1 review)

77.4 mi

I love your food and the service is always awesome. It's like being around family and friends every…read moretime I see yall over here by food lion. It is high but it's worth it. Maybe you could have a punch card after 5 meals one free that would be cool. Overall love everything!!! Posting this review has made me want to call in a order lol. Have a great day and thank you for everything yall do.

From the owner: Here at PhillyFried LLC, there are no gimmicks, just good authentic Philly inspired cuisine…read more We pride ourselves in providing everyone with the same flavorful experience, every time you frequent our establishment. For us here at PhillyFried LLC, consistency is key, and we keep everything simple for quality customer service. So after enjoying our food the first time out, come on back and Savor Philly's Flavor once again.

PhilyFried LLC Food Truck

Cheesesteak hoagie platter

See all

Fat Philly's

4.0(172 reviews)

70.4 mi

As always, I am greeted with a smile. I absolutely love this place. Great Food. Staff are friendly…read moreand helpful. This is the place I go to and continue to return to for a cheesesteak. I highly recommend.

Great customer service and excellent!!! Phillycheese steak sandwhiches. Just the right salt, a lot!…read moreOf meat, cheese throughout, oinions , superb. Really really good

Storefront, few outdoor seating areas, and plenty of parking

Cheese steak sandwhich

See all

Rick's Cheese Steak Shop

3.7(232 reviews)

80.4 mi

What an interesting place. I'm kind of a cheese steak nerd so some of my review may be a bit biased…read moreas I've had LOTS of different styles over the years. One thing to note is that this place is technically "The Cheesesteak Shop"... you'll see it on the menu when you come in. Rick's is a staple of a name in the Hampton Roads area. Rick's is a name that is synonymous with great Cheese Steak and if you visit them all you'll notice differences in the recipes/flavor amongst them. We were at the one in Williamsburg one week, then went directly to this one the next week later. This one, the meat is slightly more seasoned with pepper or something with a mild heat. Nothing crazy, just noticeable. The bread was a little wet and I really would've preferred it being more toasted. Overall, it was an 'ok' cheese steak. I was going to rate this a 3 but overall I give it a 4 b/c the service was friendly enough to warrant the boost. Food Taste: 3.5 Overall Service: 4 Value of service to cost: 4.5 Facility: 3 Ambiance: A converted bar that serves cheesesteaks. Repeat customer: maybe-ish Dog Friendly: no

The cheese fries will always be a guilty pleasure for me, I have never personally been in the…read morerestaurant itself but I order from Uber Eats and it's always HOT and so good. If you're need a sinful late night snack order the fries, you won't be disappointed

Where you place your order!

Chunks of cheese and huge banana peppers. I also only got one tomato.

See all

Loretta's Pizza

4.1(63 reviews)

81.4 mi

Service was great ! The Pizza tho !!! Yummy if you live a perfectly cooked crust .. damm so good,…read moreit was the best I had had in the longest of times !!

Amazing staff and amazing food! Highly recommend this to anyone considering! The vibe is amazing…read moreand the food is affordable! Pickle pizza is a 10/10 and so are the mozz sticks!

Garlic , Feta , Spinach and Tomatoes with a little kick of Jalapeño! Going to eat the entire Pizza

Same

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Steven P.

0

1

0

3 months ago

This place was a perfect stop for our family, just off the path on the way to vacation.The food was just what we needed. Our vehicle broke down and they were just so nice and helpful. This place has become a "must" for us to stop by and check-in next time we come through! read more

Ashlyn D.

0

2

0

2 years ago

I love love love this quiet little place. If you ever want a really good burger from some really nice people and you're in the area, the barnyard burger is a must. Not only is it delicious but it's HUGE and extra juicy!!! read more

Barnyard Betsy's - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Things to Do near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Restaurants near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Pizza near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Breakfast near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Coffee near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Lunch near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Burgers near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Shopping near Barnyard Betsy's

BEST of Creswell, North Carolina Thrift Stores near Barnyard Betsy's

Best of Creswell

Things to do in Creswell

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Barnyard Betsy's also viewed

Stick Burnin BBQ

4.5

(8 reviews)

I wasn't a fan of Stick Burnin BBQ. I loved the old building and the service, but the food wasn't…read morewhat I was expecting. I arrived in the early afternoon, planning to get a pulled pork sandwich, but I was told that they were out of many items, and that was one of them. I'm not sure that they have the full menu each day or just smoke the meats a few days a week. I went with the Chicken Que, expecting tender, slow-cooked chicken that was shredded. I got what appeared to be a grilled boneless cutlet cut into 1-inch chunks, covered in some bbq sauce. Some people might like it, but I could just manage a few bites. I looked for an image of what my sandwich was to look like, but couldn't find anything like what I was served. The fries were also disappointing, as I like crisp fries, and these were not crisp. I didn't realize when I ordered them that they were fresh-cut fries. Not everywhere is good at making those crispy. I did enjoy the little cup of cole slaw. I'm usually not a fan of coleslaw, but that was good. I was brought mac n cheese too, and once the stuff on top was removed, that was pretty good too. I'm glad others like the food, but it wasn't for me. I should have gone with a burger or pizza.

Very nice SUPER FRIENDLY mom& pop BBQ! They have bottles of BOTH TOMATO & vinegar bbq sauce so you…read morecan SAUCE IT YOUR WAY! Reasons for four stars instead of five : hand cut fries were overcooked so they were crunchy, brisket nachos were not as we had expected. We expected more fresh vegetables less pickled vegetable vegetables. Watermelon, slushy while was tasty it seemed to have the rind taste a little bore overpowering.

Golden Skillet

3.6

(31 reviews)

The drive thru staff? Horrible with the exception of the veteran staff working there for years …read more Cashier arguing otp and at customers. It's an ongoing issue.

Welp, when you're in a small town such as Plymouth, you have to take what you can get food wise…read more Way back in the day, I used to come here with my family but the quality since then has gone down extremely. I got the 2 chicken, bbq plate with baked beans and macaroni salad which both came straight from a can and the macaroni salad was definitely from the local grocery store . I believe only the chicken and fish are made from this place , everything else is not homemade. The service in Plymouth is always not the greatest, they act as if they are so annoyed with everyone for it to be a small town place, we ordered through the drive through so didn't sit down but I'm sure I would have been annoyed getting any service from them. My husband did enjoy his fish plate but he don't know any better since he doesn't eat soul food often lol

ROSIE'S TASTY KITCHEN

5.0

(2 reviews)

Outstanding!! The ribs were nothing short of wonderful with the best BBQ sauce I have ever had…read more All of the sides were very delicious and plentiful. A small restaurant that deserves very high praise!

Such an amazing place! First of all, we drove up at around 8:45pm, with closing time being around…read more9pm. The cook was outside and greeted us to come in. The food they prepared was simply fabulous. We will be back!

Governor's Pub

3.5

(103 reviews)

The is a nice tavern near the waterfront. Sad that there wasn't any fried shrimp on the menu,…read more although it was on the website menu. Sundae was our server, she was very nice. While service was not provided by Katie, she was amazingly attentive to all tables, she removed our discarded plates, took orders while taking cups to refill from other tables. I had to ask her her name, just to mention her. Food was ok. Onion rings good with spicy ranch. Wings ok. Burger was good according to guest.

I've had wings and fries all over the country and other countries. These were by far the best wings…read moreand the crispiest fries I've ever had. The servers are wonderful. The atmosphere is laid-back and chill. If you're in Edenton, your meal needs to be from here.

Famous Subs

3.9

(19 reviews)

Great subs! If you get the large it's big enough for two meals. Recommend calling in your order to…read moresave time. Staff are very friendly. Highly recommend!

One the best places for above average fast food, hot food, soul food. Luv luv luv it.read more

Garden Spot Cafe

3.7

(22 reviews)

We went for the first time last week. I got the fried oyster plate which was absolutely delicious,…read morebig and juicy, the best I've ever had! My husband fried flounder, which was also delicious!

Love love love the Garden Spot!!! Chicken quesadillas, Smothered Chicken and Fried Pork Chops are…read moremy favorite!!! Husband loves the oyster bar upstairs!

The Shed Bar & Eatery

4.2

(9 reviews)

Great burgers! Wonderful service and nice ambiance. Great cocktails as well!…read more I highly recommend it for a quick meal!

Rachael and Clayton have done an amazing job of "kicking up" the menuThe orange crush, nachos and…read moreBrussel sprouts were fantastic!

Bailey's Southside Store

5.0

(4 reviews)

We love this place. Off the beaten path with the best hot dogs and fried fish this side of the…read morebridge. Mr. Bailey also sells fresh grown produce, ice and eggs with a huge wheel of fresh sliced hoop cheese. Two regulation pool tables and cold beer could be your next adventure on the town

Old fashioned roadside convenience with good home cooked vittles you can enjoy at their bar. Fried…read morechicken is a specialty, as is BBQ. But they will serve seafood when fresh and available. When we stopped in when they had trout plates. A couple of pool tables and jukebox add entertainment. Cole Bailey is the proprietor and works here every day.

Old Colony Smokehouse

4.7

(104 reviews)