Barclay Pies is a standout spot in the Cherry Hill area, offering a warm, welcoming atmosphere thanks to the very friendly and accommodating owners. The shop has both indoor and outdoor seating, making it an easy choice whether you want a quick bite or a relaxed meal. They offer pizza by the slice or whole pies, and their style leans thin, crisp, and full of flavor. I ordered the sausage, peppers, and onions, and it was excellent--tasty, well-balanced, and cooked perfectly. Honestly, it may be the best pizza in the Cherry Hill area. With great service, quality ingredients, and consistently delicious pies, this is a place I'll definitely be returning to. read more

See all

Got this delivered. The pepperoni pie with a drizzle of honey made it a little spicy and sweet. Really enjoyed the flavor combo. The mushroom pie was everyone's favorite. Definitely on the softer and droopier side for pizza for the mushroom one. Flavors were phenomenal. read more

Barclay Pies - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

See all

This was Season Pizza before so it was easy to get to from our house. As soon as I walked inc I was asked my name for my order. I had ordered two pies, one Tomato pie and a Vegan Cheese classic with basil. I waited about a minute before taking them to my car. The next time, we're going to try eating in. The dining area looked recently painted and freshly decorated. OMG, I was amazed by how good both pies were. I haven't had a tomato pie this good in YEARS. The ingredients were fresh and it was cooked just right. We'll be back soon. read more

Amazing! Worth the trip from Philly! Tasted like the real deal! Friendly staff and quick service. read more

Barclay Pies - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

This is one of those spots that gets everything right by keeping the menu tight: pies, wings, and salads... Periodt. Quality ingredients, solid portions (i.e. wings that come 8 to an order) and exceptional flavor combos (i.e. honey, rosemary, garlic, chili drizzle on wings). The pizza crust edge bubbles up beautifully in the brick oven (love that crunchy edge) with a thinness that hits allows for the perfect balance of sauce and toppings (I went with pepperoni). The vibe here is cool and easygoing, not your typical pizzeria. It feels more like a neighborhood eatery than a themed Italian joint. The décor is bright, simple, and understated. Bonus points for the complimentary sparkling and still water near the juice cooler; pour it yourself into the clear plastic cups with lids and real straws. Very thoughtful touch, letting guests can stay hydrated without spending extra. Can't wait to visit again so I can try their Hawaiian pizza made with pork roll (or is it Taylor Ham?). Either way, it sounds like pure Jersey-meets-island magic, and I'm here for it! read more

See all

This is easily one of the best pizza spots I've ever tried! We ordered the pepperoni pizza and a side of rosemary honey wings, both were amazing. The pizza was cooked perfectly, full of flavor, and the wings had that ideal crispy bite. The honey rosemary drizzle was so good I honestly wished they added even more of it! The staff mentioned they've only been open since August 2025, which is wild because everything tasted like they've been doing this for years. Everyone working there was super friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. If you haven't checked them out yet, do yourself a favor and go. You won't regret it, you'll probably end up raving about it just like I am! read more

See all

Solid pizzas, wings and salads. Definitely recommend the pepperoni. I liked that there were white sauce pizza options too. The interior is also well designed and service was good. read more

RUN, don't walk, to Barclay Pies- especially if you eat gluten free! It is hands down the BEST gluten free pizza I have ever had. They also offer vegan cheese if you're also dairy free. Everything that comes out of their frier is gluten free. Tried the tenders and they were OK, but think I would try the wings next. Fries are delicious. You order at the counter and take a number to your seat and they bring the pizza out when it's ready. BYOB and they also have a nice selection of sodas in a cooler near the front. Casual atmosphere and friendly staff with tables outside for when the weather is nice. ONLY downside is that it has been cold (for me) every time we have gone, so if you tend to run cold just bundle up. Is a very accessible space for anyone using mobility equipment. read more

Barclay Pies - 2 piece chicken Tender Basket - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

See all

Phenomenal pizza. If you like your pizzas well done, this is the place for you! The sausage pizza was delicious -- crispy, on the thinner side, and a great crust. This pizza place also has a ton of GF options for celiacs and anyone who is looking for gluten free pizza. Definitely would try more things here -- wings, tenders, and mozzarella sticks look great. read more

Barclay Pies - Sausage Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

I ordered here for the gluten-free pizza. It did not arrive in my original delivery order. After reaching out to the restaurant, they had it delivered specifically to me. Once my pizza did come, it was fabulous. The first time I've had a gluten-free pizza that was not like a dried out cracker. read more

I have been gluten intolerant for about 6 years and miss the taste of actual pizza. This is the closest thing to actual pizza I've ever eaten and I've tried them all. The chicken tenders were also huge and delicious. Food was 11/10, came out very fast, service was excellent, ambiance left a little something to be desired but the food more than made up for it. Price for the gluten free pie is pushing it at $27 for a 12" but the quality was exceptional. Chicken tenders with fries were fairly priced they were gigantic, would recommend three. read more

Got their broccoli pie with sausage. It was a sausage pie with a couple of pieces of broccoli. There was also too much....I assume corn meal on the crust (assuming to keep it from sticking) and made the crust, which was otherwise good, really gritty tasting. All told, averages out to completely fine, but at those prices, not really worth it imo read more

Absolutely -- here's a more upbeat, energetic version of your review: --- Barclay Pies in Cherry Hill, NJ is an absolute must-try! Their pies are out of this world -- perfectly flaky crusts, rich fillings, and that homemade flavor that keeps you coming back for more. But what really makes Barclay Pies stand out is their amazing gluten-free menu. They've truly mastered the art of making gluten-free treats that taste every bit as incredible as the originals. It's a game-changer for anyone with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity -- finally, a place where you can indulge worry-free! Friendly service, delicious pies, and genuine care for their customers make Barclay Pies a local favorite you'll fall in love with after the first bite. read more

Great pepperoni pizza with a drizzle of honey and basil! Crispy and tasty. Chicken wings with garlic honey sauce was awesome! Crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. I think this place is a contender for best pizza shop n SJ! read more

If I could leave 6 stars I would. We ordered the GF wings, salad and pizza. We ate the wings before I could snap a photo but wow. So good. The GF pizza? Chefs kiss. Will I be back? Yes. Oh, and don't forget it's BYO! And excellent customer service to top it off, which we all know isn't easy to come by now a days. read more

Got Caesar salad and a large pie. Salad was mediocre. It tasted like bagged grocery store salad. The pie was solid but nothing out of this world. Good spot but one of a million good pizza joints in the area. Not sure I understand the nearly 5 star rating. Service was friendly. read more

I so wanted to LOVE this pizza place... first the place is immaculate and clean.. 5 * .... the service 5*... the pizza is a 3* .. as soon as I saw the automatic ovens.. I knew how it was going to go... I web ordered 2 cheese and 1 tomato to get a feel for the dough and sauce separate from the cheese... the Tomato pie had nice flavor of garlic. The crust was slightly above average at most. The cheese pies were extremely salty.. the sauce is average at most.. Johnnys pies in Medford gets it right for a pizza this price.. I get $10 whole pies that are on par with this at Roma Pizza in Berlin.. not worth the trip for us to go again.. read more

I came here a few times. The Pizza has a really good, unusual taste and better than any other pizza I have ever eaten. They are very caring about how they treat you. Great food and people! read more

came over from Philadelphia to try out the gluten-free pizza. the customer service was amazing! gluten-free pizza is amazing. I was shocked to find they had gluten-free chicken fingers and gluten-free mozzarella sticks, which we also tried and I will be coming back over the bridge just to have this meal again. read more

The gluten free pizza is so yummy I wouldn't even know that it was gluten free. All Of the gf options makes it a solid part of our rotation. read more

First time ordering and got a text the pie was ready while I was driving and almost there. As soon as I entered I was greeted with a smile and can I help you? The pie was still hot (live 7-9 minutes away) when we opened the box. Since it's our first time ordering we got the regular pizza pie. Wanted to taste the sauce, cheese and crust without all the extras. Well all we could say is that it was delicious! The crust was tasty and toasted, sauce was very good and the cheese was good quality not "oily" (not need to blot). Definitely will order from there again! read more

Decided to stop in after seeing the gluten free pizza on social media. I have a gluten allergy and haven't been able to find good pizza. This pie delivered. It was so good - I added chicken and buffalo sauce and can't wait to go back and have more. The gf fries were also delicious. Inside was also clean - service was fast and friendly. read more

The staff was attentive, friendly and quick. We ordered GF pizza and some other stuff to go. The food was delicious and we can't recommend this place enough. Great for take out or eating in! read more

Update: Came back 10 days later. It wasn't a fluke. Had a pepperoni pie this time. Out of this world, with the kind of cup pepperoni that crisps up. And WINGS! I'm a giant wings fan...and these were nice sized, and very fresh tasting, with a light breading. Impressive. And the number of people walking in and out of the place in just the few minutes I was watching says pizza lovers are catching on. read more

My wife was recently diagnosed with celiacs and finding good pizza (and dedicated fried foods) has been a struggle. Barclay came highly recommended so we tried it tonight for dinner. It was amazing. Hands down the best gluten free pizza we've ever had and it's not even close. We also got an order of fries and those were awesome too. I ordered online for pickup and my food was ready when I arrived. The girls are the counter were super friendly. Loved everything about this place and we will definitely be back. read more

It's hard to.put into words how amazing this pizza is. The ingredients are simple, but it's is clear that each piece (tomatoes, olive oil, cheese) are selected with cate. Pizza is easy to do in a mediocre way; this is superb; each slice is a masterclass. read more