What a fabulous array of olive oil and vinegar as well as spices and condiments not usually found…read morein stores. Attentive help and great gift ideas as well. Needless to say I am a repeat customer!

My family and I went to Nutmeg Olive Oil today just to check it out. It was my first time and I…read moreenjoyed the brief beginner's lesson and all the tastings! The sales rep encouraged us to make mixes and even gave us some suggestions, as well as popular items. I focused on getting a combo great for salad and veges and a combo great for meats. I settled in the rep's suggestion for my salad vinaigrette of Blood Orange Olive Oil & Peach Vinegar. My son chose Pepercino Garlic Olive Oil & Bourbon Maple vinegar for a meat glaze he's eager for me to make, lol... wish me luck!

This company is absolutely AMAZING!!!!! I had ordered from the in September for my employee holiday…read moregifts. Just opened shipment the other day to find a few broken and NEW ONES ARE ALREADY IN ROUTE. The most amazing customer service. Will be ordering every year and spreading the word on this fantastic company. Product is amazing and a great gift.

I've bought from them several times. We love the olive oil, all flavors. People are very nice and…read morehelpful

There's a new olive oil/balsamic vinegar store in town! They've got a lovely variety of olive oils…read moreand balsamic vinegars in stock. For olive oils, they've got from savory (Butter; Mushroom and Sage; and Herbs du Provence) to sweet (Lemon), to smoky (Smoked Olive Wood, to be precise!). Oliva's Balsamic vinegars are also fantastic here! Among my favorites: chocolate, elderflower, and fig. If you bring your empty bottle back to re-use, you get a discount--just make sure to wash it first (they are dishwasher-safe, if you have one). The staff are all super friendly and helpful.

A great array of olive oils, both standard and eclectic. The sales associate was super nice and let…read moreus try a bunch. Ended up walking out with a few, would definitely recommend!

I first visited to get the viral ghost coffees in the fall and was instantly hooked on the…read morespecialty drinks. There are so many options and each one I've tried is delicious. This has become a regular weekend stop for fun coffee drinks! I've also picked up some of the hot sauces and olive oils they offer as well

Came here for a quick coffee after walking at the dam, then saw they had olive oil and vinegar -…read moreYES! The girl who prepared my coffee and helped me find regional Italian evoo was also extremely pleasant. Will be coming back for a refill - also very nice that they don't use artificial flavorings

Help listing is bogus and NOT updated in Feb 2025. Business is closed, no longer exists, and link…read moreto website is spammy.

I cannot believe the success I have gotten via the oil shop. The give me the best deals on some of…read moremy favorite lubecrants for my "car" on a completely different note it is the best place to pick up older woman.

i actually bought a cute ghost bowl. great for dips :). its so cute! they have a nice selection of…read moredecor as well. very friendly staff too.

Delicious, top-quality olive oil and balsamic. You can try all the different kinds (garlic olive…read moreoil, basil, strawberry and cranberry-pear balsamic, black truffle olive oil and more). We chose the small bottles of fig balsamic and the garlic oil. They're great for spicing up a nightly salad or treating yourself to a big hunk of bread and dipping it. We'll definitely be back to try and buy others. 5 stars!!!

I can't believe that it took so long for me to finish the review. I noted everything when it…read morehappened, but the draft has been sitting here for 2 months. What can I say, I'm a busy woman! I'm busy trying some olives! When I visited my stepdaughter, she told me about the place, so we went together. The place lets you try every type of oil and dressing they carry. So, what am I waiting for? I tried a few and I'm glad I tried because that's how I decided to buy. Unfortunately, my stepdaughter wanted to pay for my selections. She insisted, so I got the salad dressing that I liked, truffle balsamic vinaigrette. We were assisted by Elena. She did a terrific job explaining the products. I loved the store. It's quite a big store with different sections of products made of olive. There's the cooking oil section, salad dressing section and many others. It's a well organized store, spacious and easy to sample the products! Nice!

What a place!…read more Stopped in here while spending the day in Port Jefferson and am so glad I did. Amazing Olive features homemade blends of infused olive oils and vinegars that complement whatever dish you're making. Looking for a way to spice up your salads? Elevate fresh fruits? Marinate meat? There's an olive oil or vinegar (or both) for that. Service here is friendly, helpful and approachable as well. The man who helped us (who I think may have been the owner? He gave off those types of vibes) let us sample what felt like every option available until we settled on a white peach vinegar we loved. Just as we were prepared to check out with just one vinegar, he asked if we liked Greek food (which I do) and let us sample a more savory infused "Olympic" herb vinegar that was incredible, I had to have it too. It's come in so handy for the abundance of cucumbers and tomatoes I have from both mine and my mother's summer gardens. I don't live in the area but they also ship which I may have to do once I run out of these vinegars, I'm hooked!

Lovely little shop in Fishkill Strip Mall, the place to go if you are looking for that special…read moregift. Besides an array of delicious Virgin Olive Oil, you will find many different gift at many affordable prices. The owner is welcoming and knowledgeable of her merchandise. Definitely with a try.

Walk into Olive U and feel the zen. I'm one of those people who waits until Christmas Eve to…read morerealize that she hasn't completed (OK OR EVEN STARTED) her Christmas shopping. After waiting 1/2 an hour in a packed deli for bagels, I needed this. The center islands are piled with delicacies from Italy (truffles, I am looking at you). Lining the walls you'll find dozens of infused oils and balsamic vinegars, many with flavors I've never considered before. I landed on truffle oil and a cranberry walnut balsamic for my mom. I also noticed a small fridge with Italian meats and cheeses. I could see someone making an extraordinary antipasto with ingredients coming from this store alone. The friendly lady working on this day was extremely helpful and offered up tastes of whatever I wanted. Truth is, I wanted it all, but the thought of stores closing in just a couple hours prevented any such indulgences. The perfect place to get gifts for your foodie and aspiring chef friends! And next time I'm fiending for truffles, I know where I can go to get my fix.

I was waiting for a too good too go order and I wandered into this section. It seemed interesting,…read more and as an italian I was curious. Then this super rude lady with glasses comes out and starts with "we're closing". Then says "especially if you you're not going to buy anything"? Excuse? I never said I wasn't going to buy anything, but you bet I'm never buying from them now. TERRIBLE ATTITUDE. DO NOT SHOP THERE. IF CUSTOMER SERVICE IS THAT BAD HOW CAN YOU TRUST THEM WITH WHAT YOU CONSUME? RUN.

The Crushed Olive is a small chain of gourmet olive oil and vinegar shops that opened in Hickory,…read moreNorth Carolina in 2010. It was founded by husband and wife Bob and Mona Rossero. Bob had owned the Colony Lounge in Huntington Station, New York for 30 years. He and his wife Mona (a former medical transcriber) then retired to North Carolina. On a trip to Northern California, the two discovered a shop that sold infused olive oils and vinegars. They decided to bring the concept to North Carolina and opened their first location there in 2010. A year later, they opened a flagship store in Huntington, New York and more locations would open throughout Long Island in the following years. In 2013, the Rosseros sold off their original Hickory location in order to concentrate on their Long Island locations. Each location offers more than two dozen varieties of flavor-infused olive oils and balsamic vinegars. Today the small chain has five locations in Huntington, Babylon, Sayville, Stony Brook, and Commack. My wife and I visited the Crushed Olive's Port Jefferson location (now closed) in October 2018. We were celebrating our first wedding anniversary on Long Island with a private limousine tour of the North Fork Wine Trail. We discovered the Crushed Olive while exploring all of the quaint shops in Port Jefferson. All of the various oils and vinegars are stored in gleaming stainless steel containers with taps called "fustis". Customers are encouraged to sample the oils and vinegars with cubes of fresh Italian bread from a local baker. Some of our favorite olive oils we sampled included the Blood Orange, Eureka Lemon, Olive Wood Smoked, and Tuscan Herb. Some of the balsamic vinegars we enjoyed included the Black Cherry, Dark Chocolate, Fig, and Pomegranate. We purchased some small bottles to take home. We have since ordered other bottles online and had them shipped to our house, including their 18 Year Traditional Balsamic Vinegar that is aged in oak barrels in Modena, Italy for 18 years. We will continue to order more delicious oils and vinegars from the Crushed Olive for years to come!

We come up to Warwick at least a half dozen times a year. Besides Wolfies, this I place is a must…read more Great selection of oils and vinegars. They recycle so we just bring in our old bottles for refills. Get discounts for that as well loyalty program discounts. Last visit we picked up a specialty risotto which was excellent. See you soon.

Love this place!! When I visit my sister in Warwick, this is one of my spots to visit before I…read morehead back to Boston. The young man that works here is super friendly and very helpful with the huge selection of oils to choose from. I always find something new to try and I am always happy with my purchases. Can't wait to visit again soon. Awesome product and also a great place to grab gifts as well for anyone. It's always superb!! Thanks....