This is a great store. I can't believe some absolute jabroni wrote a negative review because of…read moretheir lighting being too good. And, I'm sorry, if you can't figure out parking in this area, you are an absolute idiot. Great store. Great website. Staff is very helpful, but also happy to let you browse on your own. Support small local businesses! Don't be like Matthew C.!

Awesome comic store just off of Main Street in Sayerville…read more The store is decent sized and the young lady working there was very pleasant. They have a decent selection of mostly newer comics and toys as well. They did have some vintage Star Wars toys and some other vintage stuff too but they mostly have more recent comics and toys. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the area

Milo Toys & Collectables has to be one of the top toy stores in New York…read more Located in a shopping center in Oakdale, Long Island, this super large store offers a huge selection of both vintage and unique items you might be searching for your collection. They offer a variety of old toys, figurines, tapes, CDs, DVDs, all kinds of sports cards, board games, and many other unique items. It's the largest toy store I've ever visited. As a collector of Batman 1966 memorabilia, I found an amazing array of items to enhance my collection. The also Buy Sell and Trade. This place is definitely worth a visit.

If you can't find at least one item at Milo's, it's hard to imagine why. They offer a wide…read moreselection--ranging from toys, cards, and video games to DVDs, VHS, and vinyl--all priced fairly. With frequent restocks and constantly changing inventory, there's always something new and worth checking out. Plus, be sure to talk to Mike--he's the best and always great to deal with.

Great selection!, helpful owner, definitely recommend coming in and taking a look at what they have…read morehere.

Stopped in to speak with the owner about a collection of comics and Pete (I believe his name was)…read morecouldn't have been nicer - he is very knowledgeable about comics and the world in general, and we were able to chat for almost a whole hour and he really instilled that knowledge. The space is a bit cramped, but overall, I could see myself stopping in when my kids get older and they're interested in comics.

I'm only really here for the movie collections (bring back physical media!) so I can't really…read morecomment on the manga, book, or music selections although it seems those sections are just as popular. They do buy items but I myself haven't sold anything to them. They have a generous two week policy to check the discs to make sure they work. I go between here and the city location often to see what's in stock. The employees are kind, welcoming, and knowledgable. I've often called to ask about stock questions and they're always quick to help. I do occasionally check the children's section because my dream is to have the old Sweet Valley books of my youth, but the YA section is I'd say from 2010 on. There's a large lot with plenty of parking.

If you're into books, video games, Manga, StarWars, anything like this or more than this is the…read moreplace for you to browse, buy and sell. I brought in two ds 3D games to sell and within minutes I received about half price the lower rate listed on ebay. This was fine by me because I didn't want the hassle of selling online myself. I bought 2 games that I was looking for. I brought my game with me and I tested them before I bought them. They have a 12 day return policy.

Pretty cool store, very nice selection of comics (new and back issues) and toys (from vintage loose…read morefigures to newer lines like Super7). Great customer service. the owner PJ is a friendly unpretentious guy who greets you as soon as you enter the store. He gave me a good deal in a nice vintage Toy Biz X-men action figure set and a few loose figures. I'm definitely going back. If you are looking for comics or toys, this is the place.

Went to look for some comics, didn't find what I wanted, but a pleasant experience overall and the…read morestore has a decent selection of more modern books.

The staff were friendly, knowledgeable, and very patient with both my daughter and me as we are new…read moreto collecting. I appreciated the time they took to review our trade and explain the process. That said, after carefully comparing the trade offer and store credit amount to current marketplace values, I calculated that the offer was approximately 45% of market value. Thats after I negotiate a slightly higher store credit amount, I would encourage others to review their cards' values beforehand and carefully evaluate any trade offers to ensure they are comfortable with the return. That being said I would definitely go back, they have the cleanest and best shop on the island.

Update: Owner keeps contacting me to argue and is saying I am harassing him now. Says he knows the…read moreperson who doesn't understand pokemon but will not tell me who it is. Please be careful people. To the owner. He was not wearing a shirt from his store. He was behind your booth and everything I said is 100% factual. I want people to be safe in the card community. Shops with people like you damage our tcg community. And its funny, you said you knew the person but at the same time didn't know anyway to contact him, his name or anything else about him. You proudly has your table runner over both booths. Then basically shamed me in to taking down my original review because I was trying to "destroy a small business". No, you are. You are not only destroying a business, but a community I love. I will continue to make sure people know you are very untrustworthy and will not take ANY FAULT IN A SITUATION YOU HAVE CREATED. Again, I would never set foot in your store again. Especially with you being a trump supporter. Everything I stated is true. Even have friends who were there and saw it all. Especially the employees laughing at me. I want to make sure the people who actually love the tcg and pokemon community are safe! Copied from my google review. At a convention they apparently let some one use there booth to also sell stuff. The man at the booth told the price of an item was 30 dollars and when I said how cheap that was, the man started boasting about his prices. When I sent him the 30 he looked at me and said "Where's the rest?" I was confused and said he said it was 30 dollars and the guy laughed "Oh, you thought 30 dollars, no it's 30,000 dollars." Even my friend said to him he told me 30 dollars. He gave me my money back and I came home and wrote a 1 star review. Then one of the guys at his booth was just laughing at us. About a week later I got a Facebook message from some one who turned out to be the owner basically saying it wasn't him and it was some one he was letting use his banner. So I asked how you can see I would think it was your table and he basically told me no, he has zero responsibility to it and I'm just trying to destroy a small business and I should feel bad. So instead of this man trying to extend some kind of olive branch and figure out what happened, he basically just in guns blazing and saying I was just trying to destroy a small business. I was/still am going through a lot family stuff so I just placated him and said I would remove the review, basically because I didn't need anymore stress in my life. But I do want to post this and let people know he will go out his way to track you down on social media. Instead of trying to take responsibility, it was everyone else's fault. It's not me trying to destroy his business, it's him. If you came to me with out the attitude and took some blame for the mess up of some one vending at a table with your table runner on it, I'd go the extra mile and say how great you were. Instead I have avoided your booth like the plague and have not returned to you store. I visited twice and thought it was a nice little shop. I have friends who play there and say they only do so because they have no where else to go. He is also a trump supporter from his response on my google review, which made many people I showed it to said it would make them feel unsafe to enter his store. Be careful at their booths at conventions. If they scam you, its not there fault they let someone else vend from their table.

Took advantage of a first time seller. And wouldn't negotiate at all. Should be comping prices near…read morecustomers.

Terrific "LCS" - local card shop. They carry lots of singles and packs. They also carry a full…read moresuite of supplies at reasonable prices. The folks behind the counter are very cordial and knowledgeable. I'd certainly come back here as I get back into sports card collecting.

Good store, decent prices and tons of stock. The owner is friendly and helpful…read more I picked up a few items in the clearance section and was floored at all the other great collectibles they have as well. Any toy/collectible fan should give this place a whirl!

All things considered, Chosen One is a fantastic toy and collectible store. The store is clean,…read morewell stocked, and the employees are very friendly and helpful. In addition to just being generally excellent, there's one fun detail that sets Chosen One aside from its competition: All of their "blind boxes" have already been opened and identified. Traditionally, every "blind box" series has an unknown toy inside of an opaque box, so the person buying one doesn't know what they'll get. Instead of following the traditional narrative, Chosen One opens each blind box, and then labels what they are. If you are looking for a specific piece within a blind box line, this is the place to go to get that exact one. Outside of their great blind box selection, Chosen One has a fantastic (and very diverse!) inventory of all sorts of toys and collectibles, new and old. I am positive that there's something for every toy enthusiast here.