Bagelry

Highly recommend this place. Highly organized, fresh delicious food, clean and well kept. Staff is…read morefriendly and helpful. Been here many times and continue coming back.

When coming through the 5 Town area of Woodmere on Broadway - and wanting to check out the local…read morebagel shops - Gotta Getta Bagel is sitting pretty with a nice spot on Broadway. Do not be fooled by the quiet exterior - once inside, it's clear everybody is here. Lots of small wood tables to enjoy breakfast or lunch or a snack. They have delicious bagels and do have the Bagel snob required Everything Flagel. That was easy. Sliced with a 1/4 of whitefish to go. Whats nice is this is busy enough to guarantee the white fish is fresh. Not all locations can sell enough to not make you worry- not the case here. People were picking up sushi to go.. smoothies, and the standard salads, bagels, coffee and tea. Would be my go to if/ when here more often.

See all

Boardwalk Bagel

4.1(74 reviews)

2.2 mi

Yummy road side bagel and Delicatessen just like the name says! Tons of options on bagels, cream…read morecheese, salads and much more!! So glad that we turned around to stop. The people were nice too! #shoplocal #smalltowneats

In the past loved the place but lately seems like some staff just does not care..ordered inside 6…read morebagels and 2 bialys Bialys were ice cold and near frozen..ordered from guy 1/2 lb of vegetable cream cheese and said it twice..i should have checked the bag pimento cream cheese so when i pass by going back dont even want money back just to return to person who out right not telling me the truth when i questioned, top of container even says vegetable but was not

See all

Blueberry Muffin

More Than A Bagel

4.3(13 reviews)

1.7 mi

Fast frendly service. Excellent products very clean. Easy parking inexpensive sorry not open on…read moreSunday

Gonna say it was one of the top 3 bagels I've eaten on Long Island. Friendly service, mentioned my…read morewife who is a regular and they gave me a free bagel right out of the oven. I like that their bagels have holes. Holey Bagels! Place is spotless. Fantastic. Cash only keeps the prices down.

Front window

Fresh Fresh bagels and more

See all

Lots of room

Kosher Giant Bagel

3.6(24 reviews)

0.9 mi

The bagels were delicious! The jalapeño cream cheese was…read moreeven more delicious. Unfortunately the great customer service from the young lady that served me was put on the counter for another young lady to ring me up, and she was helping another family that two of the members kept grabbing my bag thinking it was theirs. I would have definitely preferred the person that served me to ring me up. She knows what's in my bag. I will try this place again. Hopefully it will be more organized.

Great selection of kosher bagels easy order in line. Bialys too. Grab a sandwich parking may be an…read moreissue. Worth the trip

Seasoned fries

See all

Fried onion slice

Beach Bagel & Deli

3.3(125 reviews)

2.7 mi

it's awesome! and they are awesome too. would recommend. the guy at the counter is cute tooread more

I cannot fathom how difficult it is to run this place during peak season. They do an absolutely…read morekiller job! When I got here there was a line out of the door and I still felt like things moved fairly swiftly. The bagels are fresh and chewy, yet on the lighter side. The eggs are not overcooked and the bacon is crispy. All of these, in my opinion, make a killer bacon egg and cheese (especially when you're battling a 5th of July hangover from hell). I also made myself a coffee. The station was clean and it's great to be able to control your proportions of milk, flavoring, etc. I will forever be a customer of Beach Bagel!!

See all

Bagels!

Island Bagel Bar

1.9(58 reviews)

0.7 mi

I stopped by Island Bagel Bar, which is located right down the street from Costco Wholesale, and I…read morehave to say I was a little surprised before even going in. When I looked them up, I noticed they had some really bad reviews, but once I arrived, the place was packed. The line was long, and even after I joined it, more people kept coming in behind me. That made me wonder who exactly left those reviews because it clearly seemed like a popular spot with locals. Once inside, I went over to the grill station and ordered a turkey, bacon, egg, and cheese with salt and pepper on a plain bagel, along with a bottle of water. The line moved pretty smoothly. By the time we got to the register, the cashier helping us gave us two free cookies, which was a really nice gesture. The prices weren't overwhelming, and the service was really good. Everyone working there was nice and attentive, and they got our order exactly right. The food was also really good. The bagel tasted fresh, and everything was made well. Inside, they have tables where you can sit and eat. The atmosphere felt bright, warm, and welcoming. I had a really good experience and honestly have no complaints. Based on my visit, they definitely deserve a positive review. I can't speak for anyone else's experience, but mine was great.

Poor service. Employees on phones instead of assisting customers. Bagel getting cold by toaster…read morewhile employee was messing with his phone. This was to the point where he put on one glove then started with his phone again watching a video instead of finishing the order. Then asks if I still want the order after caught on his phone 3 times before this. 15 mins in for one toasted bagel with cream cheese. At this point I had to say no and walk out. Whitefish salad was old as well on occasion. Never again! Poor work habits as soon as owner leaves.

Outside

Turkey bacon egg and cheese

See all

Toddy's Appetizers

3.0(12 reviews)

0.1 mi

Great bagels,coffee,and muffins. Eclectic dairy breakfast and lunch items. Amazing kosher…read moreappetizing for your celebration. Love their pretzel sticks and frozen takeaway food offerings. Whether for a quick breakfast or takeaway they are my choice for kosher appetizing. Try their muffin tops and brownie bites for a treat.

The staff here are rude and spit in my coffee when I asked them to remake it. Super expensive and…read morevery little value for a bagel store.

Store front

Great menu!! All the lunch and breakfast treats you could ever want!!

See all

One of the many cases of bakery treats!!!

Atlantic Beach Cafe Bagel & Deli

3.6(38 reviews)

2.3 mi

So I heard about this place because people at my school tend to order from here a lot. I love me a…read moregood salad so someone told me to try their salads. Ok. I asked for a salad with mixed greens, avocado, tomatoes cucumbers, jalapeños and grilled chicken. My salad was great.HOWEVER I paid $15 and I guess it's because of the location but It was half the size of a salad I would get near my house and I live in the boroughs. I was disappointed in the fact that I felt like I overpaid for it. The salad was great though and did what it needed to do. NOW FOR THE RUGALA!!!!!!!! Omg if you eat them get them from there! The best thing was it was FREAH and I live FRESH BAKED GOODS! They are sooooooo good and if I have a sweet tooth they will definitely be for them!

Great food with a friendly staff. Always treated well here. Great for catering and small get…read moretogethers.

See all

Bagel Delight - Kosher Bagels

2.6(7 reviews)

0.2 mi

•$$$

Not the place to go if you don't feel comfortable spending $9 on a bagel!…read more The first time I went I asked for a bagel with cream cheese and lox (I know ultra Jewish) it came out to be $8 BEFORE they added any vegetables, a simple slice of lettuce and cucumbers cost me another dollar! I don't know where people get off charging that much for a bagel and lox but it's the 5 towns so I'm sure they have no trouble finding JAP's to pay that amount. The second time I alternated to lox spread and even though it didn't taste as good I walked out with some more change in my pocket.

The soft tasty tender delicious bagels are special Great…read morevariety of yummy foods also nice spacious dining and service

Very good

See all

Bagelry - bagels - Updated November 2026

People who viewed Bagelry also viewed

A&S Bagels

3.7

(311 reviews)

I have been coming here for years. What's great about this place is they make their bagels on…read morepremise. What's awesome about that is the freshness. Today I got a baker's dozen. I always keep something to eat but put the bulk of the bagels in the freezer. They come in a paper bag. I transfer them into a ziplock bag before putting them in the freezer or refrigerator period while taking him out the bag, some were still warm and so soft. I wanted to eat them right then. I was able to stay disciplined.

Mother's Day, the place was empty for once on a weekend afternoon. The moment I walked in, I could…read morealready see two young ladies chatting at the counter look at me walk in, give each other a dirty look before walking to the counter where there were 6-8 young ladies working.if three of them said "hi" or "how are you" to me that would have been a lot. Instead I got a bunch of blank stares looking like "excuse me, we have gossip to talk about and you're interrupting it" before another girl walked over very friendly asking how I was and what I'd like to order. Only got a French Toast bagel with butter & syrup & could feel the other girls not wanting me to be there. I was once young myself & had "friends" who worked there who were the center of drama in their circles, so it wasn't quite a shocker to me. I'm sure if any of the older ladies who were probably off for Mothers Day were there, the ship would have been ran a bit more tight. Also came home to my bagel barely having any butter or syrup on it which I could put more on myself, but for almost $4 it would be nice to have it be more filled.

Lynbrook Bagels

3.3

(119 reviews)

Great neighborhood place with a flair! Great bagels to be sure but it doesn't stop there. The baked…read moregoods are great too! Stumbled across the place over 15 years ago and have been a regular every since. Several friends who live out of state demand I arrive with Lynbrook bagels in hand. I'm also a coffee snob and I am never disappointed here.

I was really looking forward to a good bagel so I stopped in here. Unfortunately the bagel lacked…read moreflavor and taste no different than the bagels you would get at a Dunkin' Donuts. Also I informed them that I have an allergy, and although a small oversight she cross contaminated. Thankfully I purchased a dozen so I grabbed from the bottom of the bag and didn't make an issue out of it. Very little wait time. It's very clean inside and I would like to say it's stroller friendly and handicap accessible.

Will’s Bagel Cafe

4.1

(28 reviews)

We love this local bagel store - hot fresh bagels & fantastic bagel sandwiches. Eggs are prepared…read morefresh for each sandwich - I get my eggs scrambled and hubby gets his over medium so the yolk can soak into everything. Delicious! I also had their vanilla yogurt (not on the menu but it's in the case) - they don't make it but it was sweet and tangy and it's a large serving. They do make the rice pudding (also in the case) so we'll have to come back for that. Parking - there is a tiny lot (4 spaces?) behind the store and on the street in front and on the side. Entrance is accessible. There are a few tables inside, but we always get everything to go. Staff are friendly and efficient. Love this place!

First time going there. Bagel egg and sausage and cheese was delicious and fresh…read more Actually couldn't finish it being was so.packed. Definitely this is my place for bagels since moving in the area. The young lady at the counter was extremely cute and friendly

My Three Sons Bagel Cafe

4.0

(112 reviews)

Had a toasted garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox salmon. Pretty tasty…read more Service was fast and pleasant, place clean and inviting as always.

One of the best sandwiches I've ever ordered!!!! When I tell you every bite was so tasty and…read moredelicious!! I have also passed by this area so much times I didnt even realize the store was there (Honestly speaking). Great service all around from taking my breakfast order to my coffee order! The truffled croissant is a must try! Can't wait to go back!

My Three Sons Bagels

3.8

(97 reviews)

Busy bagel shop in Garden City. I walked here with my boo once and we treated ourselves to some…read moreyummy bagels. Happy eats!

Are you kidding??!! You gotta come here!! Three Sons bagel is a hidden gem. I was able to order…read morethru their website and was ready pretty quickly. When arriving, the pickup station is to your right next to the cashier. Staff were friendly and attentive. Inside was clean and smelled like a bagel factory. The sandwich I got was called the works which was egg everything bagel, smoked lox, cream cheese, capers, red onions, lettuce (originally comes with cucumbers) and a tomato. This sandwich was delicious for a bagel spot in Long Island. I'm definitely coming back here. This is a must try.

Bagel Express

3.5

(43 reviews)

This has easily become my go-to bagel spot, if I want a solid bagel weekly I can count on them…read more The food is always fresh and delicious, and they have so many options. What really keeps me coming back though is the staff. Everyone is always so friendly, welcoming, and genuinely nice, which makes a huge difference. If you're in the Valley Stream area and looking for a solid bagel or quick breakfast definitely check this one out.

I am very sick from your store I was fasting all day I told myself I would go to your deli and get…read morea wrap three hours later I was puking my brains out .you need to do better. I will never eat here again....

Hand Rolled Bagels

3.9

(406 reviews)

I praise the bagel in this joint for the dense, classic chew that comes exclusively from…read morehand-rolling the dough. The shop experiences heavy morning foot traffic. Patrons frequently note that bagels are often pulled straight from the oven, arriving warm and soft. The shop earns high marks for affordability. It features an expansive deli counter packed with fresh spreads and solid breakfast. The layout is strictly a traditional, standard grab-and-go storefront. This shop serves a solid, authentic product for purists who value a dense hand-rolled dough over machine-cut alternatives.

Bagels are AMAZING. coffee is great. place is over priced,…read morebut food is good. anything BEYOND bagels... 9x outta 10 your order will be WRONG. tip. you should have a line for JUST bagels and line for cooked foods. why do i have to wait 40 mins for bagels you just throw in a bag, because you have the slowest employees serving hot food? also, i get the whole hiring teenagers, but someone has to be in the front managing. why have 20 employees work the front that can't follow directions? maybe supply pads, because they CANT memorize and order if their life depended on it.

Grand Bagels Inc

3.1

(18 reviews)

Leaving a review because I think the other reviews aren't fair…read more If you want a quick breakfast sandwich, great place. Texture of the bagels is very soft and chewy. Staff is very nice. Ambiance doesn't matter because you're in and out with your sandwich, but if you gotta eat there it's also fine, lots of room to sit, kept clean. The only downside is a lot of teenagers go here for lunch because they're right by the high school, so it can get crowded with noisy kids. Very quiet in the summer though. It's hard not to compare it to LI bagel down the road. I always go to Grand Bagel instead of LIBC because the price value here is better, it's less crowded with actual room to stand, there's room to park, and if you order delivery it arrives way faster.

Quick BECSPK .. IFYKYK! I enjoy my NY special delight on a…read moreroll with crispy bacon. Bread roll is fresh. Bacon cooked to my preference. Never an issue with my order. The bagels are also made to perfection. Price increased, and the rolls might have gotten a lil smaller but still tasteful. Dining area should get a lil more organized and cleaned up after each use.

Bagels Bagels Bagels

3.3

(8 reviews)