Not sure why the negative reviews. Sure, it can take a few extra minutes but the bagels are spot on! read more

See all

Honestly good bagels and decent sandwhiches, but between the time you have to wait for basic sandwhiches, their workers utter lack of urgency and hospitality, and the fact they're ALWAYS out of bagel flavors (even early in the morning) makes this place a waste of time and money more often than it is a pleasant experience read more

If you're looking for a good bagel in CT, Bagelicious in Cheshire and Bagelicious II in North Haven make delicious bagels. The prices are decent and their product is definitely better than the stuff you would find at a Dunkin. I frequently stop at the North Haven location on my way into work, lose to the highway and the back roads to my office. On those few days that I'm lucky enough to bring my son to work, it is always a requested stop. Be warned if you go through the drive thru there can be a wait...sometimes a long wait, but they are worth it. If the line has wrapped around to the doors and there aren't a lot of cars parked, grab a spot and run in because you will probably get served faster. Their bagels with cream cheese are great, but if you get a chance to try one of their sandwiches, you will not be disappointed. If you're like me and you like a chive cream cheese, theirs is a beautiful bright and flavorful green. Don't skip coffee while you're here. They make a great cup of joe. read more

Nice to support independent bagel shops that make sandwiches fresh to order with real eggs. By 9 am on Saturdays the line is out the door. Yay on bagels. Nay on coffee. read more

See all

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel had no raisins only tiny tiny pieces of raisin and did not taste any cinnamon. They cut back the quality to make more money! read more

I went to bagelicous with my cousin for breakfast they have the best bagels around . We tried the sesame the everything as well as the Asiago . . Delicious and I loved the veggie cream cheese . . They also have egg sandwiches which are very good as well . They do serve lunch too . The staff is very nice . It's always busy . Very clean inside as well .. They also have a very convenient drive thru . I highly recommend recommend them and reasonably priced . Enjoy Chris M read more

The bagels are like bread rolls and nothing like real bagels. If you compare them to REAL bagels, it's day and night. read more

Bagelicious II - Yuk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

Bacon eggs and cheese on a fantastic soft toasted bagel of your choice $6.75! You can't beat that! 2 eggs, lots of bacon

The bagels are always cooked perfectly and their sandwiches are great. I see a ton of bad reviews but dont let that steer you away, they sellout everyday and theres always a line, that tells you something. read more

This is a tale of two bagels. 1. Bagels are huge! Very fresh! Sandwiches are very good and these huge bagels serve as buns. 2. These are not your normal NY style bagels, they lack the crisp that I like. Apparently, people in North Haven have never seen one before because they line up early to get them and the staff is a hot mess rotating between being on their phones, talking with each other or pretty much killing time while people wait. In the end, you will wait a long time for pretty mediocre bagels. read more

The bagels were good, but the service was pretty slow considering it was not at all busy inside. The high school girl working the counter was dismissive and rude, and had no customer service. She was making comments about customers under her breath - calling one person obnoxious and making another comments about someone asking for extra butter - and the lady asked very nicely. There was also a LOT of traffic behind the counter, which just seems unsanitary. Lots of young kids who were definitely not working going back and forth. read more

New location of Bagelicious. Bagels and sandwiches, kinda says it all. Plenty of seats in an updated space. Friendly staff. Almost everything you need... except bagels. Got there at 11:30 on a Saturday and they were nearly out of everything including coffee. Maybe that's because they sold out because they are so good? Turkey Club was not bad. Definitely need to get here earlier next time. read more

See all

Not sure who runs this place besides anyone under the age of 18, but all i saw were children eating and playing on their phones walking at the pace of a sloth. One was smacking gum, the other texting, another talking on her phone. I waited 24 min for a TOASTED BAGEL. This place could be a goldmine if it was run properly. Sad what the younger generation has become, and the fact that there is no management in this place is clearly obvious. read more

Bagelicious II - Here is the "cream cheese" on my bagel. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

The bagels are good but unfortunately coming here to get bagels is not an easy task. Their website used to accept online ordering until last year. That was so helpful but now they don't allow online or phone ordering. So we can expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes on any given day. They offer a drive through which also takes almost the same time or may be more. read more

Decided to give this another try. Bagel sandwich and bagel were great. Service lacking all employees look so unhappy to be there. No smiles or greetings a lot of work to do. I was in the bagel business and u have great product but your service needs attention read more

Love Bagelicious! It's in a convenient location not too far off the highway and right on Washington Avenue in North Haven. They have another location in Cheshire as well. I don't recommend going through the drive thru. The inside is a warm welcoming atmosphere with big chalkboard menu panels, a variety of seating options, and the bagels displayed right behind the counter. The quality is unbeatable. They offer a variety of breakfast sandwiches and lunch options. My favorite is the Nova Lox sandwich. They also offer a variety of hot coffee, tea and iced coffee as well. If you're in the area, it's worth a stop. read more

This is our local go to for bagels, they are always fresh and so soft and light unlike the rock hard ones at Dunkin. Went in today for a quick bite so the cafe wasn't open and it was only a drive thru option, so I waited. It was definitely about 5-7 minute wait which isn't terrible unless your in a hurry of course. My bagel was Asiago bagel with avocado delight and veggie cream cheese. We'll looks like the avocado barely made it on there, disappointing since I'm a total avocado fan. The cream cheese is always the best and I should have skipped the hot house tomato's. I love coming here but it's really hit or miss unfortunately. You should definitely try it and make your own judgement. read more

Bagelicious II - Avocado delight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

takes abt 20 minutes to get your food when you go inside. food is good. if coffee is one of your priorities then this isn't the place because they don't have a large selection as they can only make regular iced coffees and hot coffees, not any of the variations, although they have milk if you want to make it different yourself. read more

the best ever we come from orange to get them bagels delish!!!!!!!!!! and the kids that work there are so nice !!!!

Great local place that is good to the community but often understaffed. Bagels are the best around, light airy, and crispy. If you are not in a rush it is worth it. read more

Let me preface this with these bagels are perfect for making sandwiches with. They are soft and delicious. HOWEVER. The terrible attitudes and practices of the employees at this location will be it's ultimate demise. We have come here four weekends in a row for breakfast sandwiches just to see if they possibly were having staffing issues or some other mass catastrophe to explain what goes on here. Clearly no, it's just the attitudes of the employees that are ruining your business. Lets start with hours of operation. Website and Google say they're open until 2pm. Professional signage says open until 2pm. Hand written sign on the door every weekend says open until 1pm. This morning we were in line at 11am and saw an employee literally rewrite the sign to say closing at 12. It's not because they were understaffed. They weren't out of bagels. The employees just decide to close whenever they want, apparently. Next we'll move on to how some days no one wants to work the drive thru, so they post a hand written sign saying the drive thru is closed which causes a massive line inside that spills into the parking lot. The problem here is that cars pulling in don't know the drive thru is closed and the line extends into the drive thru lane. It's only a matter of time before someone gets hit by a car. Last weekend my husband went inside to order because "Drive Thru Closed!" and it was almost two hours before their chosen closing time of 1pm. An employee was bagging up bagels to sell as "Day Old" in view of a massive line and the employee working the register was telling customers in line that they were out of bagels that were literally just bagged up in front of them. How is any of this a sustainable business model?? The final straw this morning was when an employee wearing incredibly short shorts (the shorts were consumed by her backside) decided to SIT ON THE COUNTER with all of her business sitting directly onto the surface. She then proceeds to complain to anyone in earshot including a line of customers ten deep that she "doesn't understand how customers don't get that they are out of poppyseed." Maybe because people have eyes and there are at least a half dozen behind you, ma'am? This will be our last visit to E Coli R Us. read more

Bagelicious II - "Day Old Bagels!" that the line watched be bagged up and then told they were out of when it came their turn to order. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

If you are looking for a good beagle and coffee then this place is the spot. The service is great they are on top of everything. The atmosphere is great they make you feel welcomed and show their care for each and everyone. I would like to tell everyone to come here and enjoy a good meal if it's just a bagel or a sandwich you won't get a bad food item. read more

First time here and I'm so satisfied with my selection. It's so good!!! Why haven't I been here before? They also have a drive-thru making this a quick easy stop. I'll definitely be back soon. read more

Bagelicious II - Lightly toasted French Toast French toast bagel with butter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

Not sure how this place is still in business , it's takes over 40 mins to order your bagel due to one register opened. They never restock the bagels which is wild bc this is a bagel joint. The attire is come to work straight out of bed , they wear whatever they want. Looks a hot mess being a staff member. Nobody wipes off the tables you have to sit down with bagel crumbs and sticky tables. Just rather go to Dunkin' Donuts they're less disappointing. read more

I guess I was spoiled when Lender's used to have a restaurant in Hamden many years ago because there was nothing better than a fresh, chewy bagel. I wouldn't even toast them. They were so good. These days I can't seem to find a place that comes close to those. I do like French Toast bagels. Stew Leonard's usually makes a decent one. On a recent Sunday morning I decided to stop in and get some bagels at Bagelicious on my way home from grocery shopping in the same plaza. There was a large variety of flavors to choose from and the staff member I interacted with was very nice. When I got home I couldn't wait to eat the French toast bagel. When I sliced it in half I was rather surprised that the inside was very doughy (it was not raw). There was no cinnamon or any noticeable flavoring inside the bagel. It was was plain inside and literally was dusted outside (on the top only) with the cinnamon and sugar. Super disappointing. It was like eating a soft pretzel for lack of a better texture comparison. The search for a good bagel continues. read more

Bagelicious II - French toast bagel - more sugar than cinnamon and only on top of the bagel. No flavoring inside. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

I waited for about 7-8 minutes for a bacon egg and cheese despite being the only person in line (drive thru). The girl that took my order wasn't very friendly, either, so I don't think the customer service is that great. The sandwich was pretty good. read more

Truly my favorite place to get bagels! I've tried so many of their items and not a single one disappointed! My personal favorite is the Spinach Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese! For those of you who love veggie cream cheese - this may be one of the best ones I've ever had! It is so light and fresh and absolutely wonderful! The bagels are always fresh and for such a good price, how could you even imagine going somewhere like Dunkin'? They also always have quick service, even during their busiest times of the day! I always recommend bagelicious to anyone looking for a fresh, local bagel shop! read more

Bagelicious II - Spinach Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

Seeing the other reviews is sad...yes sometimes they have a long line but I have NEVER had an issue with any uncleanliness, mold, etc. Bagels are large and fluffy, love all the different flavors. French toast and everything are my favorites. Flavored cream cheese is delicious, and my mom and I just got BECs there the other day that were perfect. This is one of my favorite spots so I'm a little wary about one of the reviews being pages long with info that seems impossible for a customer to just pop in and "see" but ok... read more

I just left the North Haven Bagelicious. The wait in line to order was 30 minutes (1 cashier) and another 15 minutes for one "Lox Sandwich". During my order the cashier asked if I wanted the bagel toasted, I replied that I did. I then asked to add onion to the sandwich and she replied that it already comes on the order and further asked if all of the listed condiments were ok with me to which I agreed. After a total of 45 minutes in Bagelicious and driving back to my destination, I found that the bagel WAS NOT toasted and there was NO onion. The cream cheese was spread EXTREMELY thin on the sandwich to the point where it did not cover most of it. If you decide to ignore this and go anyway, I'll advise you not to go far without first checking to make sure they got it right... read more

Great food, friendly staff! Just make sure you order ahead if you're tight on time! It's quite busy and you may lose out on your preferred bagel! As for what i order, the Pastrami Egg and Cheese on the Jalepeno Cheddar Bagel is devilishly delicious! read more

Bagels good, service was terrible. Attitudes by all felt as if I was a burden. Ambiance dirty front and back. This is a venue that has lost our business. The owner needs to shape up! read more

Excellent experience. Delicious sandwich. Exceptional service. I stopped in on a Friday, late morning, while in the area. Took a look at the menu; counter woman noticed that I'd not been in before; no pressure, took the time to ask what I like and said they'd make anything I wanted. Chicken cutlet was about as good as it gets. Croissant was fresh and crisp, just as it should be. The sandwich was huge; I had the other half for lunch the next day. I will absolutely go back when I'm in the area for a fast lunch. read more

Not a tradional bagel. They're very large and don't have the density of bagels. My guess is that they aren't boiled before baking.

Not happy with the service or the product. Asked for a cappuccino and he told me they do not have it. I told him that he had the machine there and pointed to it and he said they do not use. He told me to get a coffee which I did, and the coffee is lukewarm at best. I wanted a french toast bagel which was out, so I got a poppy seed bagel. It was small and the butter tasted nasty on it. I used to love their bagels and cappuccino, but I will not go back there again. read more

This place is a huge letdown service wise. Every time I attempt to call and place an order they either don't pick up or are closed. Their hours are very limited. They just can't get it together! It's unfortunate because their bagels are delicious! read more

Bagelicious II - Everything bagel with chive cream cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

If America runs in Dunkin, I would be happy if North Haven runs on Bagelicious. My 5 year old daughter said this morning, in between big bites of her blueberry bagel, "You know why they call it Bagelicious, because they make bagels that are DEEELICIOUS." We really enjoy Bagelicious. Their bagels are excellent and their breakfast sandwiches are really good. The other Bagelicious uses a scrambled egg for their breakfast sandwiches, which is ok but not my personal favorite. At the North Haven spot they make fried eggs and it makes a far superior sandwich. I go here with my kids on the weekend and they love it too. As long as you aren't in a crazy rush, service can be a little slow. Not terribly slow, just not the super fast paced response time of the donut shop conglomerates of New England, totally worth the short wait. With that said it's still one of the best places in town for a warm bagel or a sandwich. I will also say that they sell day old bagels a dozen at a time for $3.99 which seems like a heck of a deal to me. A toasted Bagelicious bagel that's a few days old is still better than most other bagels anywhere. I drop off a few to my grandma, and I still have bagels for breakfast all week. read more

Bagelicious II - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

Bagelicious II had some great vegan options for my sister and her husband. The sandwiches on bagels were ready fast and served hot. The slightly spicy Italian was tasty on an everything bagel. Also enjoyed watching another guest drive away with their togo coffee accidentally left on top of the car! Knowledge Corner: It's my understanding (full disclosure - I am a III myself!) that the suffix "JR" is used when an entity is named after it's parent, and "II" is used when an entity is named after a family member of a preceding generation. Therefore the original Bagelicious is probably Bagelicious II's grandmother / grandfather. read more

Bagelicious II - Why you so Halloween? - Coffee & Tea Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

I wish Yelp allowed for half stars because I would give a 3.5. I have visited this location on several occasions and unfortunately what they lack is consistency. On my last visit, my sandwich was absolutely delicious! It was layered and packed full of egg, bacon and avocado. The bagel was nicely toasted and fresh. On my visit today, I can't say the same. Not only was the price different today for the same sandwich, it was no where near as full as the last time and the bagel was barely toasted. While I understand they have several staff members making sandwiches, it would be nice to get the same sandwich and price each visit. read more

I grew up in Cheshire & always loved Bagelicious. However, when the new owners took over and I went back to the Cheshire location, the bagels tasted different. I was a little hesitant to try Bagelicious II, but I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was! The location is nice and there's a lot of seating. The one downfall is there's not enough parking in their lot. I tried just an jalapeno bagel with cream cheese, but I want to try some of their avocado breakfast sandwiches next time. Go check them out! read more

See all

The bagels from bagelicious are good but their breakfast sandwiches are just not it for me. I live close by and still when I would get home and unwrap my sandwich it was always soggy. Their deli meat is super thin and their egg cooked a little too runny for me. Their asiago bagel is good tho! Also once i waited 38 minutes in line midday on a weekday! Service was slow for sure. read more