It's tough to do a bad job at bagels but these are trying. I will give another try but round one was not impressed with the bagels nor the fact they gave us an I correct order. read more

You know it's a decent bagel place when there's a good line upon entering a store. This is my usual weekend bagel stop place to start my day. They always make my BEC on a plain so good. It's located on a s strip mall next to Wholefoods and Dunkin so parking space is never an issue. You can text or call your orders ahead of time to avoid the line. read more

See all

The folks are very friendly. They fill the orders quickly--even though I ordered physically in the store, they still filled my order fast. But there were many orders in the queue by folks that called in. So I was still super happy with the speed of getting my order, I'd recommend calling it in. Nice seating area that you can sit in the restaurant but most seem to take it with them. My favorite is the Taylor Ham and egg on an everything bagel. read more

Bagel Stop - Bfast menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

We live close and it's right next to a Dunkin. But literally will order a bagel with butter and there won't be any butter. I ordered extra butter just to see if i would get butter and this is what we got. Kids wouldn't eat it. read more

Bagel Stop - Terrible - Sandwiches Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

First time stopping here. The place was packed but moved pretty quickly. I got a bacon and cheeses on a toasted everything bagel. The bagel did not feel or taste doughy. The bacon was perfectly crispy and was completed by a nicely melted piece of cheese. Since I know that this combination was good, next time I stop by here I'll get the same thing and add some thinly sliced tomatoes to it!! read more

See all

My first impression of a business are clean windows and doors. No matter how large the window (s) allowing patrons to tape advertisements or other civic events, guitar lessons or the sale of used furniture is a turn off, All this before entering. The first thing I couldn't help but notice were the two young men sitting at a table eating without wearing Any shirts. Could be wrong but the board of health may have something to say about this. I didn't order anything here. I just turned and left. If the owner and/or management doesn't care about the appearance of their shop they certainly don't care about the quality of their products and maybe the cleanliness of their shop read more

I went there for a quick breakfast sandwich and asked for a French toast bagel with Taylor ham, egg, cheese and ketchup but they forgot the ketchup. This place isn't bad, but it used to be a lot better. It'll do the job for breakfast, but don't go out of your way for it. Ever since sams closed down and this place got new owners, there really isn't a good bagel place in town. read more

See all

I can't stress this enough: CHECK YOUR ORDER BEFORE LEAVING! I've been going here for years because the bagels are actually pretty good and it's close to home. With that said, they get the order wrong more than half the time (I mean this literally.) I'll joke about the order being wrong before opening the bag, that's how bad it is. This seems to happen more with sandwiches and the order will *almost* be right so I suspect this boils down to rushing/carelessness. Check your food before leaving, folks! And if it's a big order...bring a friend to help. read more

Ordered at 10:10am at 10:27 I asked if my food was ready. I was told not yet. At 10:30 the young lady asked what my order was and I saw them start making it. 20 minutes and they didn't even start making it. I asked for bacon well done and when it came out at 10:33, it wasn't. I just needed to get out of there because my entire work break was taken up waiting for the food. I'm definitely ordering ahead if I ever come back. Place was full of high school kids getting food too. read more

Bagel Stop - Bacon and egg on a sesame bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

I placed an order everything bagel with cream cheese never got it some lady gave me other person order she ripped the number off the bag and now someone else has my bagel bad customer service read more

Ordered egg, cheese and tomato breakfast sandwich. Needed salt /pepper, thought bagel was not that yummy. I was really disappointed. All the workers were helping and it was so busy but just not my favorite. I enjoyed the self serve coffee bar with lots of options and everyone working was kind and helpful. read more

TEXT your orders!!! Ever since I started texting orders they haven't messed anything up. Also it reduces wait time. The place is as good as any deli. Everything is average... it gets the job done. I have had far worse in the area. So I keep coming here for breakfast sandwiches. I never ate anything gross nor anything to write home about. It just gets the job done. The workers are always nice to me especially when they see me often. read more

Wow very surprised at these reviews. I had to triple check I was looking at right place. Have had twice and both times were better than average. Girls at counter were friendly and the food was better than expected. Prices also good, large selection, and seems clean.. We usually go before or after our grocery shopping at Whole Foods. read more

Bagel Stop - Tuesday Pastrami special. Very good and fairly priced. - Sandwiches Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Good bagels but this place messes up my order every single time I come in here. Despite seeing my order go through correctly on the POS system, the order is always incorrect when I receive it. Check your order before before you leave. read more

Just ok and sometimes good when they get it right. I read some of the other reviews. I'd also say they get my order wrong 50% of the time. I ordered a grilled cheese on RYE bread with bacon and tomato earlier today. They put it on WHITE bread. Not only do I detest grilled sandwiches on white bread, I shouldn't eat them because of the high glycemic level. Rye holds up better under the grilling and it's better for my sugar level. At $8.00, get my order right! I didn't have time to return so I took one bite and threw it away. I don't think I'll be back. I used to go there often. read more

Got a breakfast sandwich and there were pieces of egg shell in it. The bagel was very average - would not recommend this place if looking for a great NJ bagel experience. read more

Was sold a bagel about 10 minutes before closing. I sat down and ate. Then the manager informed me they were about to close but I could finish my food. Right after, (maybe a minute) another employee came up to me and said we're closing, you have to leave and kicked me out, even though I explained that the manager had allowed me to finish. I've been coming here for over 20 years and the place has really gone downhill in my recent experiences. I hope they can clean up their act. read more

I used to LOVE this place. My family and I were regular customers. It has gone downhill. Bagel today was small and dense, nothing like the nice fluffy ones they used to sell. And the price of a breakfast sandwich is getting a little out of hand (over $7 for a taylor ham egg and cheese ) Besides the fact it took 15 minutes to come out on a random Thursday morning read more

This place screws up my order over 50% of the time. Ordered a Taylor ham egg and cheese and you gave me a poppy seed bagel and cheese??? I'm sure you're handing out the wrong orders to people and I see you fixing orders. Fix the problem. I'm tired of ylu wasting my time and money. read more

I wish I had read the reviews before visiting this place. For a bagel store, the bagels were so unsightly and untasty looking that I literally threw the bagel sandwich away. The ham and cheddar omelet meal was not a meal since it was lunch time, yet they still charged me for the bagel and hash browns that they admitted would not come with it. It was also a rather bad omelette. Definitely would never visit again under any circumstances. read more

Everytime i come here they always mess up my order, ordered half a dozen bagels, 4 plain, 2 seasame and she gives me all everything bagels when i didnt even order it. also bagels taste so stale read more

Kinda crazy that Bagel Stop doesn't have any reviews. Anyways, I'm gonna make ordering easy on you: TEC + SPK I honestly* don't even know if there's anything else on the menu besides Taylor Ham**, egg, and cheese. Add in some salt, pepper, and ketchup and you're golden. I know you're gonna say, "Ketchup? For real?" Trust me, I don't mess around with breakfast sandwiches. Peter D. said to me one time that he's really glad he's not from NJ; I know, crazy, right? The thing is, Pete's probably never had Taylor Ham. He's always "bacon this, bacon that", but John Taylor*** is rolling in his grave that such a pork connoisseur as Pete does not know about his gift to the world, Taylor Ham. Next time you guys find yourself in the wonderful place known as New Jersey, get yourself a Jersey Breakfast, you'll be glad you did. *: I'm lying. But the rest of the menu doesn't matter. **: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor_Ham ***: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor_(Taylor_Ham) read more

This place only cares about volume not quality or service. They are very snotty behind the counter. Additionally I was just there on Sunday, I placed my order and went to pay. I only had a hundred dollar bill. The guy at the register started to make change then said "I am not allowed to take 100's" . They clearly had change. There was no sign that the dont accept 100's 0r US currency for that matter. I could have paid with credit card but I didnt like how I was talked to. I go at least once a week. If it wasnt for the location they would never survive with the attitudes of the staff. I will drive further and go to Sams by Shoprite... I recently tried it again and the staff still treat you like your doing them a favor. Good food but horrible service. read more

Decent bagels, decent food. Everything you're looking for for a jersey deli. Typical waiting and service. I've come here my whole life, can't complain. read more

Very nice place, quick service, nice workers. Fools is priced nicely and is very good. This place closes at 3 pm which was an inconvenience for me for a few times in which I wanted to go there just for a bagel. read more

I am standing here waiting for what seems like an eternity for a tuna bagel sandwich. The wait is really ridiculous! I ask and it seems that they forgot my order. This is actually the second time that this has happened here. They get good prices here. The least they could do is hire people who don't lose orders. I had avoided this place for awhile and then gave it another try but there's other bagel places in Wayne. Time for a switch again. read more

Honestly shocked by the 1 star reviews. Moved here from Brooklyn, which has the best bagels. No need to argue that point. Bagels aren't amazing because I've been spoiled by Brooklyn bagels but they're better than all the other bagel shops I've tried around Wayne. Maybe because I lived in NY and work there now, the "attitude" and customer service that everybody complains about doesn't bother me much. Never had them screw up my orders either. Just make sure not to go when the throngs of high schoolers show up, then you'll be waiting a while. read more

Don't know why I went for a second times just give them a chance Ask for dozen you get 10 bagels some the bagel was lite I will newer go back Don't know how they are in business Rather travel farther away at least get a decent bagels read more

Bagel Stop - This how many u get for dozen bagels 10 - Sandwiches Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

I have been a loyal customer of Bagel Stop for basically my entire life, having lived just steps away. Over the last 10 plus years it's become somewhat of a tradition for my family to walk over on summer weekend mornings for bagels. And while I've seen good and bad owners come and go over the years, this new crop of owners and staff are so bad I have to review. Last summer, I got to the point where I boycotted the entire place and started driving across town for bagels. Every single time I went in, which was twice a week at least, I was arbitrarily charged (even when ordering the same things) and then EVERY TIME something was wrong with my order. The last time, I was finally so mad that the order was so wrong we couldn't even eat it - on the wrong bagel, had ketchup when it wasn't supposed to, and another sandwich was wrong too that I tried to call, only to find their phone was OFF THE HOOK. So I got in my car and drove back (not the first time but what I hoped would be the last). When I got there, nearly every customer had an incorrect order. When I told the owner who was in that day what was wrong, she was rude and flippant. She almost wasn't even going to fix my order but I started to get heated and she begrudgingly agreed to fix my sandwich. Then, she didn't even apologize, and did not give me any sort of credit or even a smile. I told her the phone was off the hook and she knew. When I got home, the order was still wrong (and not a complicated order). I didn't go back for months. Finally I decided today to stop in and give it another try. The owner wasn't there, but I noticed there was an entirely new staff. I was optimistic. The girl who took my order was painfully nice and checked over my order several times and i saw it was correct on her screen. And when I got home IT WAS STILL WRONG. I got plain cream cheese instead of scallion on the side, and NO CREAM CHEESE on one of my sandwiches at all and it was on the wrong bagel. I yet again drove back. I got my sandwiches fixed and I did get an apology and a smile, but that's it. There's obviously a disconnect between the people taking orders and making the sandwiches, and there's obviously a lack of care by the ownership who wasn't even present. But fine. If the bagels were better maybe I'd chance it again. But between the crappy quality bagels since the new ownership, the attitude of the owners, the inability to get a single order right, and the lack of improvement over time, I'm done this time. I'll drive to Wayne Bagels, where the bagels are better, the family is nicer, the orders are right, and when they're not you get the right order quickly with kindness and apologies. Unfortunate that after 20+ years, it comes to this. Do better, Bagel Stop. read more

Their bagels are good and the people are nice, but it's honestly incredible how often they get orders wrong. It's wrong more often than not.

Probably the worst Beagle shop in Jersey. Only go there if my regular spot is closed, which in father from my house. I don't think they have ever gotten an order right. It hurts me to give them business, but when you need your fix it has to do. read more

Although it's been a while, I've worked in a deli that served bagels, a diner, a take out place, and a fine dining restaurant. I'm currently a trainer in a technology retail store. The comment I'm posting is directed towards the owners and managers of this location. I'm not sure might even care. But just two points 1 - a good local place needs more than just good food, it needs to be a place where people WANT TO GO. This isn't one of those places. Service is slow. The person taking my order was impatient. The same person later bad mouthed a customer who placed a phone order in front of other customers (it's an open kitchen and counter area). There is also no organization to when orders are given out, or paid for, making the process lengthy and chaotic 2 - it needs to be a place where people WANT TO WORK. The manager here loudly complained about hiring kids and how they don't want to work. This kind of conversation should have been had in the back or quietly. The exchange between the manager and employee should have been constructive and respectful. It's one on the basics of managing. So it breaks down to the basic rules of respect here. This place can have good food but you can't run a business if you don't respect your team or your community. You sure can't charge the prices you do either if the environment is that toxic. The business is hectic and stressful yes, and people who've never worked in the industry may not get how crazy it gets, but there's no excuse for this kind of behavior read more

For one you have to make your own coffee. Iced coffee is given in a pre- frozen ice cup. That just doesn't seem sanitary. The bagels are nothing special and there's a Dunkin' Donuts next door that offers the same thing for a lot cheaper. I'm all for supporting local businesses but I'll pass on this one. Next time I'll just go to Dunkin' and save myself the hassle. read more

You only get one chance to make a great first impression.....so true! I work in the area, looking for a new coffee and bagel place....a young blond girl took my order @ 7:30 am ...a bagel (plain) which was $1 and a small coffee which is $1.80...total of $2.80....she charges me $3.80? I explain that 1.80+1.00=$2.80.....she looked through me like a politician....I tried to explain that my change was incorrect but she would not give an inch! I said since you changed me for a buttered bagel, please butter my bagel....I got the rolling of the eyes......the other guy behind the counter buttered the bagel for me and tried to save face....oh, by the way...the coffee was cold.....needless to say, I will not be returning here...a shame because its a convenient location. Oh well...... read more

The bagels here are fantastic but somehow the order is never correct. No matter how specific you are with your order there is always a problem. Today I thought they finally gave me my correct order only to get home and realize it was wrong again! And the cherry on top was I asked for extra packets of ketchup on the side & they gave me hot sauce instead. PAY ATTENTION IF YOU ARE GOING TO BE IN THE SERVICE INDUSTRY!!!!! People want their food the way it is asked for! read more

Don't go to this location unless it's your last resort. Overpriced and extremely small portions. I ordered a Taylor ham egg and cheese and there was one piece of Taylor ham on there but they still expect six dollars a sandwich. They need to step up their game drastically and stop thinking about cutting corners read more

Bagel quality not a good as before. Lady who took my order was mega rude that last two times I went. After I order my dozen she asked me if I wanted anything else I said no and then I quickly added that I wanted plain cream cheese. She snapped, "so you do want something else" Not acceptable at all Won't be back read more

last sunday ordered a taylor ham and egg on a bagel and half way trough I found a long hair ,trying to support local business on these tough times and all the things we have to worry about this days with the virus and this happens ,inexcusable read more

Why don't they tell you they will charge you extra for credit card ? Even during this pandemic they pick greed over health.. keep your 3%

This place is in a very convenient location for me. It's on the way anywhere I go, and I feel like that's the only reason I ever come here. They're usually pretty sloppy when they make their sandwiches. Sometimes there isn't enough cream cheese and sometimes it's overflowing to the point where there is more cream cheese than bagel. And their Taylor ham sandwiches always seem slapped together, with questionable effort to fully cook the Taylor ham or melt the cheese. The price is right and the location is good, but every time I get a bagel, I am often wondering why I didn't just make the drive to Sunrise. Oh and P.S. If you speak Spanish, beware of the offensive under-the-breath comments the cooks or servers might make not expecting you to understand. read more