Being from NY I definitely have my preferences for bagels. However, at a bare minimum if you get bagels at 6:45am they should be warm. Unfortunately, these were actually cold, which means they were in a refrigerator. Definitely wouldn't recommend it if you are used to good bagels. At best they're no better than bagels bought in a bag at the grocery store. read more

I can't think of a worse iced coffee in the past 20 years than the one I was served this morning at Bagel Basket. It was watery, milky, and had virtually no discernable coffee flavor. I was exceedingly nice to the sweet young girl behind the counter when I ask her if, perhaps, there was an issue with the coffee maker. She promptly retrieved her manager whose first sentence to me, in a nasty tone, was "so... do you want your money back... This isn't Starbucks? ". I said no, just check the coffee. She added some more coffee from this giant dispenser, that likely had gallons of old coffee swill, and it was still awful. I dumped the whole thing in the trash and walked over to Cumby's and got a much better coffee for 99 cents. The 3.4 star rating for this place is deserved read more

Bagel Basket - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Perfect little local spot to grab a breakfast sandwich or lunch! They have different drink options too and the staff are hardworking and hustle! read more

Bagel Basket - Super veggie in tomato wrap no onion and black iced tea - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

Waited in line for a long time, which is cool, but the kids that were working behind the counter were just sort of hanging out talking to each other which made me feel like there was no management. Also when you go into a bagel place you're looking for salmon, capers, onions, as basics. I don't think I have ever been into a real bagel place that didn't at least had salmon spread. So that was hinky and I should have taken the hint. But then when I got the bagel it wasn't really a bagel at all it was sort of dense bread, it wasn't chewy, there wasn't any crust that was recognizable, it just wasn't a bagel. It was like they weren't boiling them or some basic was missing. Anyway I think he's playing to an audience that's only ever had a bagel from dunkin' donuts, and the business seems to be flourishing, so whatever. read more

We saw a big line so turned around to buy 2 bagels. Yikes. To be fair, we are in Maine, not NYC. But the texture all wrong. No crust, no chewyness, no flavor. I had a sesame toasted with cream cheese. Ate half. My husband had a plain with peanut butter. Ate half. Pretty much the worst I've ever had. They are not boiling them first? Just like bland bread in bagel shape. It's too bad. Service and ambiance great. Product not so much. read more

Bagel Basket - Darling town. - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

I have eaten here multiple times. Today may be the last. Five young girls behind the counter - chatting and eating while ignoring customers. Worse however, they are playing with their hair around the food, scratching their heads and faces, and then handling the food... WITH NO GLOVES! This is certainly rude and unsanitary, and I have to wonder if its illegal. Health Department, please take notice and investigate. Unfortunate, because the food is good. read more

The bagels and cream cheese are good. Fast service. Always reliable location to get breakfast or lunch. It's a small location with minimal indoor seating, but there are areas to eat outside. read more

Stopped in here after a bad breakfast at the York Harbor Inn. We are so glad we did. Nestled in an old house this shop is pumping out fresh hot bagels. We grabbed a half dozen and all of them were delicious. Would love to come back to try their sandwiches. Super friendly staff and quick too. read more

Fresh well made bagel sandwiches .. one with egg and sausage and one with peppers , onions and cheese. Those with a cup of good strong coffee were only $15. That is a deal these days. read more

We stopped at The Bagel Basket after taking a yoga class for coffee and a bagel. The Bagels were fantastic! I got an everything bagel with chive cream cheese. It was toasted perfectly and generously smeared with the cream cheese. Not too much but not chintzy either. Just the right amount. Coffee as hot and fresh. Cashier was very friendly and helpful. The seating area is neat and clean. read more

Bagel Basket - Bagel and coffee - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

Very average bagels. Fine if you're in the area, but it's not worth driving out of your way for. The cream cheese I ordered was bland - the chive flavor was not noticeable and the bacon flavor even less so. The jalapeños cheddar bagel was soft and had a decent chew. But again. Bland. read more

Bagel Basket - Jalapeño Cheddar with Bacon Chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Every time I come down to York Beach, this is my favorite breakfast stop! If I lived down here, I'd go broke on their breakfast. I have had jalapenos, blueberry, and everything. My wife had onion. My kids had the rainbow (plain) and regular plain bagels. We were all extremely satisfied. The customer service is top notch. The other patrons were also super nice! read more

See all

Place is cute and sandwich was good, but I ordered a sandwich on a French toast bagel (which they had over 20 of when I ordered) and then waited 10 minutes for them to call us up and say they're out of French toast bagels and then out of multiple other flavors)..... Pro tip: Maybe should just put the bagel aside when people order them so this is avoided. This happened to 2 other parties as well who were waiting. Not exactly professional or what I've seen at any place I've been to before... Note to owner : I did NOT order online. Went in this morning and saw the 20 bagels when I went inside the place. Same thing happened to another couple parties while I was waiting too. But way to assume on the comment back here bud. read more

Coffee was great. The salt bagels seemed wet, swollen, and undercooked. My son's plain bagel looked okay. Not sure if this was a one time thing or not. But not my favorite bagel. read more

This is such a fantastic little bagel spot. Food was great & quick, outside seating was so lovely!!

The jalapeno cheddar bagel sandwich was amazing! My son had a plain bagel with apple butter and he said "MMM" the whole time while eating it! read more

Ample off street parking, cute little place, super friendly service. The bagels were ok, they hit the spot, but nothing to rave about.

Best bagels in York! Fluffy and lots of cream cheese. Service was quick. Ambiance was quaint - perfect for maine! read more

They take credit cards now! Also, my taste in bagels has refined. These are standard bagels. If you want a more authentic bagel, I recommend Lil's Cafe in Kittery, ME. I still love their sandwiches! read more

Great bagel stop just mintues away from where we were staying in York! When we visited in July 2021, they were still following COVID guidelines. If you ordered online, you pickup inside, but there is an order window outside if not. We arrived around 8AM on a weekday and there were a few families ahead of us. We ordered a half dozen bagels with tubs of cream cheese to bring back to the house. I liked how you can choose between two different sizes of cream cheese, haven't seen that a other bagel shops. We opted for the larger size of veggie & wild berry. The bagels were phenomenal and the cream cheese brought them to another level. Great variety of flavors to choose from too! read more

Bagel Basket - half dozen bagels with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

Not the vibe. This place could be great. Cute little spot. But the tension among the staff creates a very uncomfortable atmosphere. The manager is so rude. She speaks down to her staff and customers. I felt bad for the young girls working here. They are being verbally abused and shamed openly in front of their peers and customers. I will not give these people my business. Be kind. read more

Good location for York, decent breakfast sandwiches, but the staff is not the friendliest unfortunately.

The coffee was cold, asked for extra shot didn't get. Service cold be better. Over priced for what you get

Food and coffee is good. Management seems verbally abusive. Witnessed a manager reaming out an employee in front of the line of people ordering. read more

We ordered online and that was a fast process. I got an onion bagel with bacon egg and cheese. The bagels were better than store-bought ones. The bacon was inserted in the eggs and not just strips laid on the sandwich. If I were to go back I would get extra bacon. read more

Did not even want to add a single star, I'd leave 0 if I could! This spot used to be the place to go a few years back. Since the new manager stepped in it has gone downhill drastically. I feel bad for all the employees that are treated like dogs IN FRONT of customers. I can only imagine what happens when no one's around. The bagels are not fresh, the eggs taste like rubber and the bacon is stringy. The coffee had so many coffee grounds in it I felt like I was drinking a bucket of sand. If you're looking for a GOOD bagel with friendly and helpful staff and overall friendly environment, you're better off driving an extra 10 or so minutes to Bagel Caboose in Kittery. DONT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY AT THIS ABUSIVE ESTABLISHMENT!! read more

Love the bagel basket! We stayed in York for our family vacation, and stopped here for some coffee and breakfast bagels. The bagels were delicious, freshly baked. We ordered our food online and our food was ready for pick up by the time we got there. We added coffee to our order once we got there and the staff was very friendly. Definitely a great place to stop by for breakfast! read more

Bagels are not fresh, not made here. I witnessed bagels being pulled from a bag and asked if bagels were freshly baked. I was told no, they are not. They buy them. Manager was incredibly rude and screams hateful things at employees in front of customers. Will not be back. read more

Quaint spot in York Village. Fresh baked bagels, yummy coffee. These are not NY bagels but they are decent. It seemed like the tomato on my sandwich was fresh from the garden, mmmm-mmm. Considering the atmosphere and proximity to the beach, it's a great place to have breakfast or lunch. read more

Bagel basket was packed and it was worth the wait. Grab a coffee and bagel and take it outside to a chair on the front patio. So nice in the fall cozy morning. read more

Not so good bagels:( Nice people, but bagels taste like rubber. I hate to be painfully honest, but it's necessary. read more

Solid breakfast. Had an Asiago bagel with egg and cheese. Very lightly toasted and I would have perfered more well done. Asiago bagel was mild. Still a good breakfast. Quick service considering the crowd. read more

Great people! Fresh Bagels! Real family/community feel. Stop on by, you'll be glad you did

Quick service but both egg sandwich and bagel with chive cream cheese lacked flavor. They also forgot the cheese on the egg sandwich

Did takeout. I averaged my husband's opinion (4) and my own (3) and upped it for the coffee which I thought was quite good. Bagel was just ok... I like a chewier texture. My husband had the BEC in a plain and enjoyed it. Egg portion is omelet style. read more

Bagel Basket - Bagels Near Me - York, Maine

The wife and I enjoyed their everything bagel as a B L T lunch today. Highly recommend their bagel sandwiches! Always very pleasant service! Never artificial Split a bagel blt for under $10 and could barely finish it. Great place for lunch if you don't feel like a sub next door! I am a York native and have lived here for well over 60 years, so I'm not sure I can be totally objective. Love this place! read more

Breakfast bagel sandwich was good but the Latte was so weak I had to look and see if they forgot the espresso. Basically tasted like steamed milk with some tan colored froth. Just order with extra shots and might be ok. read more

Always wanted to try this place since we vacation in the area. Took 25 minutes to get 2 bagels with cream cheese.. I watched several people waiting finish their entire large coffees before getting their order. I'm not sure if they're trained to go in order for making the food, but I shouldnt have to wait behind 15 bagel sandwiches for someone to put cream cheese on a bagel. Have two separate stations going-- there were plenty of young girls working back there. Giving is 2 stars because the bagel was pretty good and a good size. Girls working were also very nice. read more

Even pre-Covid, even before the multiple signs asking for patience, this place is the poster child for typical Maine (and York) inefficiency. The bagels are day old and dry. They automatically toast all bagels unless you specify otherwise. This tells you they're not fresh. A fresh bagel stands on its own. Maybe if the owner would show up once in a while instead of relying on untrained high school girls, you'd be able to enjoy your beach day instead of waiting for a crappy meal. FYI the eggs in the sandwiches are microwaved. read more

Great prices for huge bagels and lots of cream cheese! Wish the line wasn't always long but it's worth it! Obsessed with the energy drink! Seating is outside but there is only one side that is shaded so try to get seating asap. read more