Service was excellent! Our waiter was very attentive. I had the Lobster roll (warmed with butter) and it was absolutely delicious. I picked the Mac & cheese for my side and it was delicious! read more

See all

We have been trying to come into BYB for the past two days but there has been a wait every time and now we know why! This mouth watering bbq joint in the port of Nantucket is a must stop in or out... the staff was fantastic our bartender Armani was fantastic and extremely knowledgeable about the menu. The manager Denise was also super nice!!! Now for the main event... the fooooood was really impressive for bbq! We let Armani pick got us and we had the burnt ends and the ribs. The sauces the pickled onions the corn salad and those fries!!! I guess today will be my cheat day because I couldn't stop eating Needless to say we will be B - ACK!! read more

Back Yard Bbq - What's left of my burnt end I devoured it - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

We came her during Stroll weekend and we were all pleasantly surprised! Somehow, our large group was able to walk right in and get a table (it was a bar type of table that was standing only) but it worked! We were starving and we were happy to even get into a place on such a busy weekend. The place was PACKED but the service was pretty good considering how many people were there. We were able to get our drinks (I got a few pumpkin beers, and others in my party got bloody marys) and everyone was pleased with their drinks. The food was also AMAZING. We got a little of everything, and I have to say, out of that whole weekend, this was my favorite food stop of the trip. I would definitely come back here during my next trip to Nantucket. read more

We stopped by for quick few drinks before boarding our boat back to main land. Quick service. Great drinks - we enjoy nice bourbon cocktails - and BYB gave just that. We'd love to try their food next time when we are in Nantucket. read more

See all

Best French fries I've ever had! Nice staff and fun atmosphere. If you're gluten free and enjoy cider try this one. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Bar area is so much fun! - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Back Yard BBQ had a great lunch. So many great options for GF too. Everyone enjoyed their lunch today!

Backyard BBQ provides great BBQ in the sea of Nantucket fish based restaurants. The casual atmosphere and sports bar style inside would seem like a great place to watch a game post-Covid restrictions. If you're looking for a decent lobster roll while eating with those who don't like seafood this is a great spot. The Alabama Rodeo burger is the best deal on the menu. Don't sleep on the cornbread or Mac and cheese as sides! read more

See all

An island staple. Staff is next level. Hope to get deeper into the menu next time thru.

I can only speak to the atmosphere and the hot chicken sandwich, both of which are a 10/10. There is no food I order out more than chicken sandwiches, I have tried probably hundreds (including many of peoples national favorites, eg. Hattie B's). Back Yard BBQ has the best chicken sandwich I have ever had. I definitely didn't come here expecting anything close. In fact, if anything, I probably tried to downplay how good it was after my first time having it, because expectations just weren't that high (and honestly I don't want this kind of random place in Nantucket be THIS good at making hot chicken) but I have to be honest, it is the best I've ever had. I would come here for the hot chicken if it was hole in the wall but it was actually also good place to have a beer and watch a game. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Sauces - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Fabulous food and service. The restaurant is spotless, and service couldn't be better. Prices couldn't be more fair considering the quality of the food. Lobster roll and hand cut fries are amongst the best I ever had. A must if you're in the area. read more

Good bbq, fair priced for Nantucket. How many atmosphere and warm service. I recommend.

Gluten free Heaven! Our waitress, Mary, was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and what was gluten free (or could be made gluten free with the rolls). I had the brisket sandwich with the Mexican street corn and it was all so good! She even recommended the cinnamon dipped glass for my Downeast pumpkin beer. Highly recommend this place, all of my girlfriends loved it too. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Brisket (gluten free) - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Came here our first night in Nantucket. service was excellent, food was amazing. Had the Alabama brisket sandwich with the white BBQ sauce and it was outstanding Brisket. A great location too. Didnt bring the kids but I did notice a kids menu, and the laid back vibe would be a great Place for families too. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Trio of sauces. The white bbq wasn't out here but it was excellent - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Wow. Really impressed. Meat was really good, portions were large, and the pricing, especially for Nantucket was reasonable. Will definitely be going back. Staff was good and attentive. read more

This place is awesome. If you want substance and quality, then I highly recommend. Great food and atmosphere...makes my pu$$y moist!

Server was attentive and knowledgeable about gluten free options. The Big Pig pulled pork sammie was delicious. And the ranchero baked beans a great side dish. Would definitely visit again! read more

Meh was ok. Probably won't return but was an easy meal before getting on the ferry. One of the few places open before 5pm. No AC read more

Back Yard Bbq - Brisket and ends - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Beer was excellent. They had Maine Dinner on draft. The pulled pork nachos were ok. They used a cheese sauce instead of melting cheese. It was a special so I assumed melted cheese but we got cheese sauce. Brisket was in an au jus which didn't really work for me. The wings had a dry rub but were decent. Everything was made well, just didn't land for me and my palate. Sauces were good and had good flavor. read more

A chill and relaxed atmosphere which is not always the case here on ACK. I've been lucky enough to try some of the best places in Memphis (too many to mention) and further south into Jackson (Pig n Pint) and Hattiesburg (Leatha's) Mississippi. This isn't going to match that level, and I missed the more intense smoke flavor on the meat, but it's good BBQ for this part of the country and outstanding for a seasonal place on an island off of MA. The sides are mostly respectable. And that's a sign of a decent BBQ joint. read more

Great service, everyone is very friendly. Food is subpar but only BBQ on the island. Very expensive for what it is.

Great food and service. Freshly made, great sandwich. Highly recommend this restaurant. Prices were right.

I had the opportunity to go to Nantucket for the day and sought out a place to have lunch. One of the first places to pop up in Yelp was B-ACK Yard BBQ and as I haven't had barbecue in some time I thought we'd give it a try. We started off with some Smokehouse Dry Rub Chicken Wings. We don't like bleu cheese so we asked for some other dressing-like sauce for the wings and the very nice waiter said that was the only option, but he suggested one of the 4 barbecue sauces on the table. The first thing I noted when the wings arrived was that there was a very distinct aroma of cumin coming from the wings. I thought that the cumin would overpower everything else but I was pleasantly surprised that it did not. The wings were nicely spiced and very well prepared. And while I tried each of the 4 sauces I preferred the "sweet". For my lunch I chose the Pulled Heritage Pork Sandwich which came with slaw and a side. I chose the Mac and Cheese for my side dish. I returned to the sweet sauce for this sandwich as well. There was a large portion of very flavorful smoked pork on a delicious buttery grilled bun. The meat had a very "porky" flavor that was terrific. I didn't care too much for the slaw so I didn't put it on my sandwich which I would normally do. The Mac and Cheese was a decadent bowl of cheesy goodness, creamy and piping hot with crushed goldfish crackers sprinkled on top. Man, was that delicious! The plate also had a house pickle and a ring of pickled onion. The service here was quick and attentive. I really enjoyed lunching here and will be back for some more this summer. read more

See all

YeeeeHaw!!! Nantucket? This place has collard greens that rival Texas/New Orleans! I ordered the 1/2 rack of ribs and greens. If I had known this restaurant was in Nantucket I certainly would have eaten there before now! Yum!! Hubs (who by the way is from Texas) had the burnt ends. Although he was surprised they were pork and not beef brisket, he said they were yum! When we're back out there we will certainly be visiting the BYB again!! read more

Food was ok somewhat dry, drinks were very good. Service was very good, Ambiance was very nice. Unfortunately is was overpriced.

Great food and staff! I had a blackened salmon wrap with the street corn side and it was delicious. Great added touch with the pickled onions and pickles that were not overly pickled. Nice choice of sides. Our waitress from Bulgaria was super friendly and on top of refilling my drinks. read more

My husband and I were on vacation and was kindly given a gift card to try it out. We ended up going big or go home kind of deal. Got the feedbag that feeds 3-4 ppl. The burn ends were our favorite and the homemade cornbread and pickled veggies. Highly recommend this place. Nice staff and comfortable place. Great beer selections as well. Can't wait to come back and have some more bbq. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

10/10 for sure. Today first full day on the island from Boston and wanted a super outdoor space to have lunch and picked byb. The hostesses were pleasant and so so kind. Multiple people checked up on us and went above and beyond to make sure we had everything. We dined with two children today and they both devoured a grilled cheese and pulled pork it was incredible. I got the pulled work sammie and others had mushroom dish and the big something was outstanding. A huge should oit to Maddie our server who was outstanding, clear, attentive, and knowledgeable on ALL allergies we had for the table. (It's a lot) Maddie you were a doll. Thank you!!!! read more

Decent food however the server came to the table 2 was inattentive and got upset when I left him a low tip making an audible comment on it. Then made my friends aware of the low tip I should add the meal ended at 221$ the tip was 5$ I could've done more but I needed money for an Uber read more

We stopped here on our day in Nantucket and the food was great! The portions were large and everything had amazing flavor!! They also had 3 bottles at the table of different bbq sauces to put on your dish which was awesome! read more

See all

Please do yourself a favor and avoid this place if you're craving good BBQ. The food is bland and tasteless, the sauces do not make it any better. While the staff is somewhat friendly ??? The food sucks. read more

Excellent food!!! Our group of 4 loved everything we got. Blackened salmon sandwich was moist and so flavorful. All of the sides are yummy and it was hard to choose. Excellent food! read more

Absolutely delicious! We hesitated to eat at a bbq place while on the island. I am SO glad we did!! The Big Pig sandwich was amazing! Cooked perfectly, slightly sweet and super juicy and the cole slaw that came with it was spot on. Not too much Mayo or vinegar. My husband got the brisket sandwich and it was loaded up with meat! For sides we got the fries and corn bread. Both were super tasty! Make sure you ask for a little taster sample of all the bbq sauces!! The staff was warm and welcoming, took time to answer all our questions and make recommendations. Full bar with a good selection of local beers as well. read more

Such a good place. After walking around the island all day we stumbled upon this place. They had a good selection of beer and lots of different bbq options. I got the pulled pork Sammie which was very good. The Mac and cheese side was incredible. We went on an off time but I'm sure this place gets packed especially if there are games going on. read more

Back Yard Bbq - Barbeque Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Surprising find near harbor and quiet but pleasantly surprising great food. Had a quick lunch before heading to the airport. We were seated promptly and we then ordered a blackened salmon sandwich accompanied by coleslaw and roasted asparagus. The next entrée was the brisket sandwich accompanied by collard greens and coleslaw. The coleslaw was a hit for me as I love this refreshing dish, had a very nice acidity to it and was crisp and fresh. The asparagus was equally crispy and was lightly oiled but not overpoweringly so. The brisket was smoky and flavorful. There was an abundance of meat on the sandwich and it was very tasty but needed a little bit of the sauce to get some juice into the sandwich. To be expected but very tasty I recommend this place I will be back read more

Sit at the bar and have yourself a northern belle and a side of Mac and cheese, thank me later

As someone with a gluten allergy, I never know what to expect when a restaurant says they can accommodate me. bACKyard BBQ went above and beyond. 24 hours later I can tell you that I will eat here again. Not only did I not get "glutened" but everything we ate was also tasty! The staff was knowledgeable and friendly. Multiple people made sure I got what I wanted, everything gluten free came out on a separate tray, and checked in to make sure everything was perfect. The games were on, the Nantucket Blue was flowing, great time! Many thanks to the staff! read more

Good mescal and other drinks. Great food! Friendly staff! Good location, close to the downtown and the docks! read more

This place is my first stop on the island! Great food and service! It's hard for a Texan to give five stars to a bbq joint in New England but this place deserves every star. Their menu goes way beyond BBQ and the bar is the best hang on the island! Great food and great service! Don't miss out on BYB! read more

We were a little reluctant to go to a BBQ restaurant on Nantucket where fresh seafood is king...but we were so very happy we did! atmosphere, music friendly service and drink specials were Fantastic, but failed in comparison to the food which was outstanding!! We opted for the "trough", 5 meats and 6 sides...everything was delicious!!! The Mac and cheese and brisket was the best I've ever eaten and there sauces were fantastic. We ate like King's!! If your heading to Nantucket save a fish and eat BBQ you won't regret it! The Herring Family read more

Our concierge recommended this place for lunch. Glad we listened. It was a good change a pace from all the seafood! Service by Gus was exceptional! He was friendly, knowledgeable, attentive and made everything great. We started with the wings appetizer. They are smoked and then fried with a spicy coating; sauces are on the side. Thought they were just ok. The 3 BBQ sauces were excellent: Gold, Hot, Sweet. The chopped BBQ sandwich was pretty good with lots of meat. I had the Nashville hot chicken sandwich. Lots of great reviews on this, but I thought it was just average and a bit disappointed based on my high expectations from the other Yelp reviews. It was cooked fine, but the flavor wasn't there for me. The french fries were fantastic. The potato salad was different than I have seen before and I didn't care for it. Lots of good whiskeys and beers, but unfortunately they were sold out of our choice. Gus recommended two others and let us try them. They were both nice. read more