Cancel

Open app

Search

Back Door Pizza

4.2 (87 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Order Back Door Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Back Door Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Back Door Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Ilene S.

I was disappointed with my experience with back door pizza. I felt that parts were over cooked to the point of tasting burnt. I love a thin pizza but this was so thin even heated up the weight of the pepperoni was too much for the bread. The ordering and picking up Process was very easy and quick.

Miyah R.

Back Door Pizza. Is exactly what it is. Behind The Farm & Fisherman Tavern. Speakeasy type I would say. Preorder, knock on arrival based on your pick-up time slot, wait for a staff member, state your name, and boom there you go. Pizza has a nice thin undercarriage with a crisp. Even distribution of sauce and toppings. Good quality overall. Pies are not my thing, but is for my husband. So he drags me along. Concludes, probably one of the best of South Jersey in my opinion. Might as well have a car picnic date. Bring on some paper plates and ice cold beverages. Best when eaten right then and there while it's piping hot!

Trent O.

Great pizza at this pickup only back door operation behind the Farm and Fosherman in Cherry Hill. If you hit the dumpster you went too far. Go on the website and order your pies. We did the kids cheese that advertises it is slightly less "done"/charred (and it was) and another pie with truffle cream, shaved mushrooms and house made fennel sausage and bacon. Dang it was good. Give it a try for sure! Only downsize is they can sell out, and the window of time is only between 4pm and 8pm o believe.

the entrance to the back door pizza parlor
Angeline D.

Back door pizza is located behind The Farm and Fisherman Tavern. Pretty easy find, however limited hours. They don't open until 4pm Wed-Sat so don't count on eating their pizza for lunch. Highly recommend ordering ahead of time as they do sell out for certain pick up times. You just walk up to the door and knock. Someone will come out and ask you the name on the order. We ordered the "vodka, hold the tonic" pizza with half sausage. The pizza itself was cooked to perfection, did not taste burned at all. The vodka sauce was delicious and the pesto drizzle was necessary to complete this pizza. My only complaint is there was barely any sausage. For the price point of this pizza, I expected a little more. Pretty good pizza in a speakeasy style. Would recommend trying at least once if you're in the area. Wouldn't go out of my way for this though. Plenty of good pizza places in jersey that would offer the same.

a black door and a red light
Abigail W.

I love a speakeasy style Pizzeria. Since seeing photos I knew I needed to get here but it's not a place to just get a pizza for yourself, or do you I'm not here to judge. My friend and I decided on the overloaded pepperoni pie and my Lord, it did not disappoint. Thin slices with a good thick crust, and the most pepperoni per slice I've had in my life. The garlic aioli wasn't something I'd get again, didn't have enough garlic flavor. BUT the most glorious surprise, the butterscotch pudding. Bury me in it. I would literally eat that every day of my life if I could. Anyway, it's super good, definitely try it all. Not cheap but very filling.

Pick up is in the BACK of farm and fisherman.
Jenny B.

Back Door Pizza has been on my to do list for a while now, and I was finally able to order from here and now I'm not sure any other pizza will ever live up to the deliciousness that Back Door served up. My husband placed a Friday night order as soon as they opened for a 4:30 PM pick up. We went with the Mushroom and Vodka Sauce Pizza. The Mushroom was the best, and I could have eaten the entire pie myself. Two pies easily fed 4 people with a few slices left over. I'll be ordering from here again soon!

Little flop
Joseph C.

I've been working in the area been here since April and really haven't had a bad slice of pizza this far . This Back Door pizza place getting great reviews is with walking distance so I had to see what all the hype is. I'm from Buffalo Ny so I know pizza and this was all about the hype as it was the best so far in South Jersey. Got the pepperoni added the Jalepeno topping and got thier house honey to drizze over the top and blue cheese to see if it was homemade and to dip the crust . The pizza was loaded with topping g and the doughy was nice light and still crispy with minimal flop . I highly recommend and will definitely trying this 2 or 3 more time while working on the Jersey shore.

Outside with instructions on what to do
James F.

This place is absolutely awesome. First off the farm and fisherman in the front is a great spot to eat. But back door pizza is awesome!! Really thin crust, extremely good sweet sauce, doughy but crisp crust. It has everything you want. We did cheese and half sausage. Sausage was good and tender you could tell it was real sausage. Will absolutely be coming back.

Vodka hold the tonic pizza
Vivian R.

We had heard great things about this pizza so we had to give it a try. When you get there you drive around the back and follow the arrows to the back door pizza shop. There is a small alley way to park and not much room for multiple cars. You are instructed to knock on the door and ask for your order. We requested a pick up time of 6:30pm and arrived right on time and then proceeded to wait 15 minutes for them to come out with the pizza. Unfortunately, the pizza was disappointing. The pizza was extremely salty and the pesto was flavorless. The pizza crust was also very chewy and not cooked fully. Unfortunately for these reasons, we will not be going back.

Super Pep
Amelia C.

We thought we ordered the Carnizza pizza, but when we got home it was the Super Pep pizza. I don't get why this place is so hyped up. The pizza was good but not amazing; I've had better. The middle of the pie was a bit too soggy. We were expecting the size of the pie to be bigger for being $26, but it wasn't big. Drive to the back of the building, stay in your car and someone will come out to ask for your name. The staff will bring the pizza directly to your car.

Vodka hold the tonic

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

It was simply ok. I only try to post good reviews so I will let you decide. Pizza on pickup not hot, should have delivery

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of P C.
0
40
9

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Back Door Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 28,603 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Joe's Pizza - Pepperoni Bites..... so good!!!

Joe's Pizza

4.3(23 reviews)
3.8 mi
•$

*This review is not for the pizza*…read more We were staying in the Crowne Plaza hotel and were looking for a local pizza place to order delivery from. We chose Joe's based off of positive reviews and were not disappointed. The customer service from the phone call to delivery was phenomenal and so refreshing. The same gentleman who took our food order over the phone delivered the pizza and he was beyond kind. The food was delicious too and a bargain! We ordered a cheese steak hoagie, a house salad, and two orders of fries. We asked for a variety of sauces on the side (honey mustard, bbq sauce, hot sauce, ketchup) and without adding any extra cost we got a hefty portion of all 4. My boyfriend loved his cheese steak and my house salad was insanely good and SO fresh and a HUGE portion (for $4!!). The fries were so tasty as well. Service was prompt- we had the food less than 25 minutes after we ordered it. Overall, outstanding. My only complaint is that they don't have Heinz Ketchup, but that's just because it's the only ketchup that matters in my Pittsburgh eyes.

We have been buying pizza and other things but last night we ordered a cheese steak pizza with raw…read moreonions. The menu said it's $21.99 and they charged us $29. We asked why the huge difference in price and were told the onions are $3 extra. They may have used a half an onion on the pizza and also charge $3 for delivery. This is outrageous after all said and done with tip, a $22. Pizza cost us $35. See ya Joe

Photos
Joe's Pizza - Grilled Chicken Italiano Panini

Grilled Chicken Italiano Panini

Joe's Pizza - Chicken, bacon ranch slices

Chicken, bacon ranch slices

Joe's Pizza - Medium pizza with sausage and pepperoni

See all

Medium pizza with sausage and pepperoni

Back Door Pizza - pizza - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...