Different location -across the street - same great food. Back home for a visit and this was stop…read more#1 for a slice. It will also be the last stop tomorrow so I can take 2 pies back to the new home many hours south. The white pizza is perfect. IThis place never disappoints..

I find this location a bit easier to access and it's the usual Nonna's quality! Have gotten food…read morehere numerous times as Put Valley is a 'sleepier' town with fewer options altho this location is before you get too deep in the woods. The only time I had a meh experience was the eggplant pie- I was looking for chunkier pieces on the slices and maybe some dollops of ricotta. But I still can't knock it bc it was mighty delicious either way. Perhaps if I had asked for eggplant parm pie it might have been elevated. That's my plan for next time!

Only did carry out by my customer for lunch, had it delivered to the job, as she loved the paint…read morejob I was doing. There are no words to describe what perfect tastes like OMG. Probably The Best Italian food I've ever had in New York and I've lived here all my life. Sausage, peppers and Onion Stromboli was through the roof with a Homemade Calzone with such a crunchy cookie stuffed Deliciousness. The next day she sent me a Shrimp Scampi Pizza my taste buds went nuts. With 2 Cannoli's this time, took one home to my wife who said: This is the best Cannoli Ever and she's picky lol. The prices were Unbefrickenlievable too WOW. Check out their Menu on line and if your in the area, it's a MUST and if your not in the area, it's the best trip you'll ever make in your lifetime. Had it not been for this interior paint job, it would've never happened... IAM Blessed. 40min drive for us but we WILL be making it a regular stop whenever possible. So Affordable

I am in love with this place. Their food has always been consistently outstanding. From pizza to…read moresandwiches to entrees you can't go wrong. They have great specials throughout the week and for holidays/special occasions. Their Chicken BLT pizza is one of my favorites.

Huge slices. Great specialty slices. Can always tell a pizzerias weight in gold by their plain…read moreslice, and fornos plain slice hits the mark. Great lunch specials, awesome bang for your buck

Friendly workers. Penne à la vodka is top notch. Very quick on the phone and food is hot!read more

This is our new go to pizza place! Best around. The food is always good. Never had a complaint.read more

The management act like crooks and unapologetic. They may be fiercely people, but they all need to…read morebe held accountable and evaluated. Go somewhere else like Calabria pizza in Shrub Oak and beside they make better pizza and the best part about Calabria Pizza that Village Pizza doesn't have is class. Period.

Took my wife and son out and upon entering we were seated then greeted by our waiter Rob, who we…read morehave not had as a waiter the handful of times we've been previously. He had a great personality and actually struck up friendly conversation which many waiters and waitresses do not do. Aside from the friendly conversation, he was amazingly attentive and helpful. Glasses never made it less than half full. We notice the menu will change with the seasons and we tried some new items. My wife had a spinach tagliatelle with a truffle cream sauce and I had the spicy rigatoni. If you like spice get that but beware because the Calabrian chiles aren't for the faint of heart. Overall it is a great environment and I plan on continuing to be a patron.

I came here with a few family members on a Wednesday night. We made a reservation, but since we…read morewent on a weekday, it wasn't that busy. I ordered the salmon and spinach salad. I really liked the salmon, but I thought the salad was a bit overdressed. The service was great and everyone in our party liked our food.

I order from here often, but after this experience, I won't be ordering again…read more I understand that mistakes can happen, especially with a local business. However, this has happened multiple times, and at this point it feels like there's a lack of care when it comes to getting orders right. When ordering slices online, there is no way to select the type of slice you want (you have to leave your request in the comments). If they don't have what you asked for, instead of calling to confirm, they will ignore part of your order and send whatever is easiest--or, if you're "lucky," they'll take a pre-made plain slice, throw on toppings to get it as close as possible, reheat it, and send it without ever checking with you. What made this worse was their response when I called. I was told they didn't need to confirm the order because it was placed online and already paid for, so they would just give me what they had. The lack of communication and accountability is incredibly frustrating, and it honestly makes me regret giving them another chance after previous mistakes with my order. Also, despite advertising no delivery fee, they charge both a delivery fee and a convenience fee. TL;DR: If you want the best chance of getting what you actually ordered, place your order in person.

Always courteous at the counter and the food is perfect. Prices are also very good. Definitely 5…read morestars!

Food was delicious, atmosphere was warm and inviting, and owner/manager came to the table to talk…read more We live over an hour and half away but we will certainly will be back!

Very upsetting with the service. The restaurant isn't full and the wait for the food to come out…read morewas ridiculous. The server was overwhelmed and I don't know why??? She spent a lot time speaking to friends at the bar. Will rethink about coming here dinner plans.

Amazing, again! Ordered for a quick impromptu dinner and it we even better then last time! New…read moreregular for me!

Home of the 1 napkin !!an iconic place to visit, love the " BOSSMAN" ". Tony and Joe are old school…read moreItalians , you will never experience 2 good guys like them. So go while you can , they are getting older.

Wow. This place has been hiding in plain sight. When everyone asks where in the general area to get…read moresome good pizza- this is where I am telling them to go. Have tried a variety and all are excellent. If you like a crispy crust with lots of toppings, this is the place for you. Give it a try. The place is small and only has a couple of tables so it's not eat-in. But the workers are so nice and friendly. Always serving with a smile.

Place has gone down hill clearly serving frozen garlic knots. The pizza is below average compared…read moreto the rest of the pizza places in Cortlandt/Yorktown. We got 2 salads and they barely gave us any lettuce. 2 salads they gave us could barely make 1 full salad. For a tiny pie, 2 awful salads, and 1 order of frozen garlic knots came out to over $50. Avoid this place

You know it's sad I order from them all the time and now they wanna pull some crap because they…read moremessed up , so theyy can improve their food and their service and their attitudes, especially when they're in the wrong. 0 stars.

I ordered through too good to waste. It's an app that NY have that allows a customers to check out…read morethe food, service and character of a business at a reduced price. I've used it on several occasions. Most business have various times you can pick food up. Calabria time is 30 minutes before the business closed. I went in five minutes earlier, showed my order to the man on register. He asked me to have a seat. He told the other person/worker in the store. I received a box of pizza. When I opened it, it looked like garbage, five slices of pizza they would discard. I have never went to a business, going through too good to waste, where I have felt like I had received garbage. That speaks for the character of a business. With pickup time 30 minutes before closing, there are many food that would fulfill the too good to waste category. For a reduced price, I was given old pizza slices that look like they were sitting around all day. I asked if he can warm it, and he said no. I told him that I have two orders, and he gave me basically the same thing he gave me the first time. Very, very disappointed. Again, this speaks to the character of a business, because thirty minutes before closing, they are many things that are too good to go or throw out. You do not give a customer something that you would throw out. Instead, you give a customer something that is too good to throw away.