Love love love Aunt Mia's sweets! So I called on a Sunday morning because my husband really wanted a banana filled cake, I called many bakeries and no one was available because of such short notice. When I called Aunt Mia's bakery, they didn't have a cake but they did have cupcakes, in both vanilla and chocolate cake. Well, I had to go ahead and try it. Wow wow wow! Their cupcakes were fresh and delicious! We had oatmeal cookies that were sold by the pound and yummy soft and tasty!!! Highly recommended!! !!! Go try them out, read more

Was always curious of this bakery everything I drove by after shopping at the local supermarket down the road. We were gifted these cookies at our job by a client. The office is always happy to receive presents like these. A lovely selection of cookies probably 3 dozen in the box. The cookies were very cute, little cookies treasures. Unfortunately, not much to be desired. The cookies tasted like flour, like they were undercooked. Basic dough with different toppings. They tasted as if they were missing an ingredient, salt? vanilla? It was a shame because they did look pretty. read more

See all

Just stopped into this great little bakeshop for a sweet treat based on their great reviews. Let me just say the staff was extremely nice and helpful. We talked to the owner as well that gave us samples of her amazing cookies. She was very welcoming and takes great pride in her work. This was our first time but they have a lifelong customer now. The cookie variety is plentiful and they are the perfect bite size. Extremely fresh tasting ingredients! The raspberry crumb cake cookie is our favorite so far! 5 stars will be back soon! read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

Got a bag of the mini chocolate chip cookies and something in them was rancid!! The cookie was very bland and the chocolate chips are of very low quality. Also got a few of the big chocolate chip cookies and they just tasted like raw flour. I don't understand what the hype is about this place. read more

This is the greatest gem in Tappan,NY! If you need an incredible box or a tray of cookies for work, family or friends, this is your one stop shop for happiness! Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip; Caramel Crumb; Chocolate Chip Dottie are my favorites. The service is lovely and Aunt Mia's talent and creativity is so appreciated. A delicious & memorable Treat, I also love the gift shop. Check out the website pics! Thank You for being such a memorable part of our community! read more

By far the nicest people and great cookies! Almost as good as my homemade cookies lol read more

The cookies melt in your mouth and are DELICIOUS!!!! Everyone who works there ( including the owner ) is super sweet and will many times offer you a sample . I buy for friends and family when we get together and they always rave about them . As a matter of fact, I plan on being there tomorrow morning when they open to bring to my Dr as a thank you and another box for my friend. HIGHLY recommend!!!! read more

Aunt mias cookies are too die for. I have been going to since she was in her old bakery. She's now in her new location in Tappan. Her cookies are the best. Anyplace I bring them to. People love them. I give them as party favors. Aunt Mias is a must. read more

We had two graduation cakes from here. The icing on these cakes was unbelievable. Some people think it's too sugary, but I love this type of icing over I think buttercream, not sure. My next cake is coming from here for sure. The cake part was also delicious, not sweet at all. read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

The chocolate covered pretzels And cake pops Were perfect for my baby shower. Aunt Mia's was so helpful in helping us see our vision for our puppy themed shower. We highly recommend! read more

See all

I had the pleasure of trying a couple of cookies today from Aunt Mias...I am a fan! The cookies are absolutely delicious, I tried the dulce de leche thumbprint cookie, which was a buttery delight. So flavorful and yet not overly sweet. The grahamello is a dream, better than a classic smores. Its just a great combination of flavors and the chocolate was especially wonderful. I can not wait to try more treats!!! read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - two cookies on a place mat - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

LOVE THIS PLACE. Been going here for as long as I can remember but sad when they moved but there cookies are delicious and the staff have always been nice this is a must try read more

There simply isn't any bakery in the Tri state area that creates this quality of cookie. The variety of tastes is beyond exquisite with flavors unheard of in any delicacy we have ever had the pleasure to ingest. Any review that isn't five stars requires a serious look at the author, not the business. Bravo! The absolutely unequivocal BEST. read more

All I can say is they make the BEST cookies. However, I haven't tried anything else like cupcakes or cake. Their cookies are amazing and they have a variety of flavors that are to die for. My whole family and all my neighbors are regulars at Aunt Mias! read more

See all

The best cookies ever! If you want to bring a dessert to an event people will go crazy for bring them Aunt Mias cookies. They are unique and delicious with a huge variety of flavors. All the cookies are made right there and everyone just loves them. read more

one of the best customer experiences Ive ever had. walked in unknowingly that it was almost closing time, but the cashier was very chill about it. the inside feels very homely like a local business that had years of experience with the town. they offered me a box of cookies as a sample. (Now that's product confidence) Some of the nicest shortbread cookies.. now I'm sold! will def come back again soon read more

My sister ordered her son's 1st birthday cake from Aunt Mias that was Halloween themed and they did a wonderful job. She ordered a funfetti cake that tasted so good! We both have ordered cakes and cookies from Aunt Mias and we will be ordering more in the future! read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Funfetti Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

I got these as a gift and boy were they delicious. They felt like home made cookies. Soft and not too sweet. Loved every single one. They went well with a cup of hot milk tea. read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

See all

I was hoping cupcakes were readily available but the owner informed me it had to be pre-ordered. She was really friendly and courteous. The bakery smelled delicious when I walked in. Beautifully decorated and cookies galore! I got a free cookie...nice! I also bought some to go. I'll order a few cupcakes next time since others' reviews tell how yummy they were. read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

Hi my one to one brought these cookies to school and they were amazing! I will be ordering these myself soon!

If you're looking for some out of this world crumb cake, look no further. The staff was so kind and helpful and their new location looks great. read more

The sweetest staff with the sweetest goods. They came highly recommended and lived up to all our expectations. They gave us free samples and helped us through our choices. Thank you for a great experience. Amanda was especially helpful and kind. read more

Everything is made with quality ingredients and a ton of love!! The customer experience is outstanding and the owner is a wonderful person!

Cookies are to die for!!! Staff was so nice and friendly. Stopped while we were visiting the area on whim after looking for bakeries in the area! Highly recommend!!! read more

Come here immediately for your sweet treats!! If not for the myriad of delicious shortbread cookies then come for the outstanding customer service. We got to sample a number of cookies and the sweet girl even gave us a banana pudding to try. We ended up buying the largest box of cookies because we couldn't resist. Amazing customer service and delicious cookies!!!! read more

without a doubt, the GREATEST cookies on earth. No other way to describe this place. GO!!! Epic.

This place has simply the best cookies around!!! Recently I had the pleasure of working with them for creating a cake for my husbands 40th birthday and the theme for the party was Rocky Horror. They worked closely with me in contact when they had questions and they were sweet and honest about what could be done. The prices were reasonable and the cake and cupcakes were delicious!!! They made me mini cupcakes and they were delicious!! Highly recommend them for any of your baking needs and if you have none just go get there cookies delicious!! read more

So I bought two pounds of cookies from this amazing place. I must say it was soft and tasty. I ate so much that I brought some to work and gave it to my colleague and she fell in love with them. I will definitely be coming back kidding that it is right next to my church. Definitely worth the trip and the two pretty ladies behind the counter were so helpful and so friendly. I wish I had a fast metabolism so I can eat more cookies. read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

I am a regular customer here at Aunt Mia's and my friends, family, coworkers and I can't get enough of these cookies!! Everyone I bring them around says, "Are THOSE the special cookies?!" They are the stuff of legends at this point. Added perks that keep me coming back: reliable free parking, hours are excellent for a working person like myself, owner Maria always handles my last-minute requests with great flexibility and her staff is very friendly (I found out that Mia is a cute nickname her neice gave her =-), and the cookies keep well in the fridge/travel well on a road trip, unlike chocolate, cupcakes, or other baked goods, plus they are not too expensive. What's not to like?! The cookies are just small enough to be a nice treat without being overly filling, so you can easily try a few flavors. I recommend asking for a free sample next time you're in the area! They are far from just ordinary thumbprint cookies: the dough is rich and complex, buttery, not too sweet, and just the right consistency (never dry, never too moist). I love that they have mini chocolate chips baked into the dough and some have a chocolate drizzle on top! My favorites: Raspberry, Banana, Vanilla, Toffee, Gramello (s'mores!), and the Pretzel really grew on me =-) They come in small to medium-sized boxes with optional seasonal bow around them, or in clear cellophane on a round tray, so either way they look very presentable as a gift. Which brings me to American Woman's review: seriously?! Comparing this sweet little American cookie and bake shop to a full-blown French Patisserie eatery blows my mind. DD sells very fancy crepes, macarons, pastries, etc. And you want to talk about overpriced?! I have absolutely nothing against DD as I live in Nyack and have been there occasionally (when I can afford it), too, but there's really nothing to compare between the two. For a quick, affordable, absolutely delicious, and pleasant-looking display for a party, holiday, work event, or just to enjoy with friends, Aunt Mia's Sweets is my go-to. read more

The cookies are to die for!...especially the one that tastes like a s'more!..totally recommend and I love owner Maria...she has always been so accommodating and puts her heart and soul into her confections...5 star! read more

I tried Mia's when it first opened about a year ago and it wasn't good then and hasn't improved. While the prices aren't exorbitant, the quality still doesn't justify the prices it charges. The cupcakes can be stale so it's very inconsistent. You never know quite what you'll get. The cookies are mediocre and also can be stale. The owner is very nice and at first I felt sorry for her, but after a year? Please. Now that Stop and Shop is open, I can vouch that the bakery goods there are better than Aunt Mia's. I just bought 90 mini cupcakes to a party and they were moist, not too sweet and looked consistently perfect. And the only cost $5.99 for 12! They were the 1st dessert gone at the party. While I am an ardent supporter of ALL things local, I cannot in good conscience recommend this place. You will be disappointed and worse, embarrassed, if you bring these goods to a party. It is time for Mia to either change her recipes or I'm afraid she will close sooner rather than later. Now if you want 1st class, our-of-this-world pastry, you must go to Didier Dumas in Nyack. They are expensive but no one has ever experienced anything like these pastries unless they were in Paris themselves. See review on Didier Dumas, read more

Aunt Mia's has a great variety of treats and flavors. The cookies are DELICIOUS perfect compliment to any dining occasion, family get together or party. Excellent gift idea online orders and nationwide shipping ideal for the Holidays. read more

Holy cow! Holy cow! Holy cow! The catering service at my workplace ordered cupcakes from Aunt Mia's and Holy Cow they were amazing!!!! I hunted down the catering coordinator to find out what the magic was. It was this place. I have had all of the best cupcakes in NYC and NJ. These cupcakes are tops! They are gorgeous and their taste is nice and layered with quality ingredients. This bakery does it right and their cupcakes are like none other. There goes my waistband.... L u v ! ! ! read more

I've never been a huge cookie fan. But I swear these are the best things around! The cookies are simply delicious and the owner is just as sweet as her products. Every time I am in there she offers me her newest flavor to try. This is hands down one of the best local businesses I've come across. Must try! read more

My 2 yr old daughter, her friend and I stopped in today for the first time to pick up a birthday treat for myself :-) The owner was there and was SO sweet. She gave the girls a cookie and insisted I try one as well. Initially my plan was to get cupcakes, but after trying the cookies, I went for that instead. They are AMAZING! I had the raspberry chocolate chip and I don't think I'll be the same. The girls loved the vanilla sprinkle ones and I have some magical s'mores concoction for later :-) We will definitely be back. I recommend this bakery to all! :-) read more

Aunt Mias Sweets - Bakeries Near Me - Tappan, New York

Maria and Elaine make the best cookies. Best. They melt in your mouth. They are incredible. Maria and Elaine are very friendly. The cookies really melt in your mouth. They are amazing. read more

Last Friday I went to pick up cupcakes and arrived when the store was closing. The staff saw me in my car as they were walking towards their cars & asked if I was going to their store. When I said yes they told me to give them 2 minutes & they literally opened the store for me! I was beyond words & so touched. I just want to say that not only are the cookies & cupcakes amazing but so is the staff! Thank you Aunt Mias for helping a tired mom who had a stressful day be able to fulfill a promise to her 2 yr old son read more

Aunt Mias was able to fulfill my request for a cheesecake with crumbs from a crumb cake on top. Not only did they give me exactly what i asked for but it was absolutely amazing! Everyone raved about it! I would definitely recommend anybody looking for a cheesecake to look no further they have the best! read more

Simply the best!! I am a bit of a dessert fanatic, and I'm also VERY particular about what bakeries i go to. I drive 35 plus minutes each way to get cookies from aunt mias for every holiday!! My family has come to love them as much as me! As a baker, I can't nail down how she gets the perfect texture, it's a perfect cookie! And the flavors are amazing, something for everyone. Love supporting small businesses, they're always very nice offering samples too. read more

We love to pick up some small treats from Aunt Mia's! My son loves her brownies! Everything about the store is sweet! My husband is a rainbow cookie snob and gives his approval of her delicious rainbow cookies! Wish we could eat Aunt Mia's cookies all day everyday! read more