There are several seafood stores in Old Saybrook but Atlantic is the best. They have the largest selection- including frozen items that are difficult to find elsewhere (like large lobster tails- as big as 16 ounces!). Their fresh seafood selection is also huge, and they also stock homemade items like soups/chowder, etc. Love this store! read more

We rent a cottage in Old Saybrook for one week every summer, and one night of that week we have friends over and do a lobster pot from Atlantic Seafood. It couldn't be easier. Corn, potatoes, mussels or clams, and lobsters are all in one pot--add 3 cups water, boil for about 30 minutes, melt some butter, and serve. Order ahead, pick up at about the appointed time, bring the pot back at your leisure the next day. It's always a special and festive meal and the service is friendly and quick. read more

Dover Sole was amazing! Can't wait to try the cod. Will definitely try again. Lobster claws look interesting.

One of the best fish markets in the area, offering high-quality products, very friendly service, and excellent knowledge about their offerings. I have always been satisfied with the final results for my home dinners read more

Used to be fabulous. But there's a young smart-a// guy behind the counter who not only sold us some terrible, rubbery tuna a while back but recently tried to argue with me about how farm raised "organic" salmon is better than wild caught. One tiny detail: the USDA does not currently have any certification for "organic" seafood. It's a meaningless term when applied to fish. So either he's ignorant of this fact or trying to sell a bill of goods. Many of their selections are now farm raised rather than wild caught. Certainly their prerogative, but disappointing. But be sure to ask because they are not up front about which fish are farm raised. read more

An owner can make or break a business and unfortunately new ownership has led to a few very unpleasant experiences for me. I have been a customer for many many years and when the new owners took over I asked them (as a loyal supporter of their business) to support my run for St Jude's Children's Hospital that I do in Memphis each December. They didn't even respond to my first request and then when I sent a follow up email they said no, they had already donated and no intention of making any additional donations. I was quite disappointed in the way this was handled but continued going there at least once a week. Then around a month ago I had finished ordering and went to the cash register to pay. I was told by an employee to "step aside" for another customer that was after to me; stunned trying to process what had just been said to me I complied. That was strike two and three for me. I have not been back and may never go back. read more

The shrimp and salmon was excellent. The customer service, particularly from a strapping young lad behind the counter named Austin, was top notch. Highly recommend. read more

Takeout game ON POINT. Everything ran smoothly and seamlessly, and the food was all delicious. Highly recommend for takeout during COVID-19. No call ahead, you park and order at the table. All salads and pre-prepared foods from their regular online menu are available. read more

See all

Always a great experience! Whitefish salad, bluefish spread, Asian Calamari salad... picked up some cod to make miso cod... I did not have time for the oysters today but they are always wonderful! Everything's always fresh and the staff is super helpful and smiling! read more

My go to is Saybrook Seabrood and every thing is fresh and not farm raised. I went to Atlantic Seafood. What a mistake. I was guaranteed by the owner that although the salmon was organic and farmraised it was the same as wild. They lied. And the 'white shrimp' was horrible and had a freezer taste. I thought I'd give it a chance but these people have no idea what fresh seafood is. Stay away! They'd sell an old piece of fish before they'd throw it out. read more

Have you ever heard that you can't get a bad lobster roll in New England? I regret to inform you that's a lie. Two of us ordered lobster rolls which were so bad we are still not sure we actually got lobster. In a place with at least a half dozen terrific lobster rolls within minutes, Atlantic Seafood lobster rolls are a big, big mistake. You've been warned. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. I can't recall the last time I got a piece of fish from here that didn't have a bone. They sell rancid fish, they are unethical and lie to you about fresh or previously frozen fish. Shame on the owner of this establishment. Will never return and will never give a recommendation to anyone to buy fish there. read more

This is one of the finest Seafood establishments you will ever find in the country! Service personnel are helpful, courteous, knowledgeable. The products themselves, whether fresh off the boat or frozen, are excellent. My family favorites are their fresh Salmon and Scrod, Shrimp Salad from the deli, and Frozen Baked Stuffed Shrimp. They provide a variety of sides such as local toffee, breads, and produce to complement any fish course imaginable. It is interesting shopping for sure! read more

Bought some fish there the other day and when I got home realized it was bad. Why would they sell me something bad? I guess just to move their inventory. I had to throw it away what a waste of time money and fish. Needless to say I won't be returning. read more

so completely overpriced for not so fresh seafood especially over the holidays. I travel the extra mile to go to seawell seafoods in mystic and pawcatuck now which is super fresh literally right off the boat seafood and cost half the price!! Oysters .90 apiece, super clean no grit steamers 4.99 ib, swordfish 10.95 lb, fresh off the boat stonington sea scallops 12.95 lb...need I go on! read more

Atlantic Seafood is the best! Their fish is always fresh and delicious! The staff is so wonderful! We came in literally one second before close and they couldn't have been more gracious. We come weekly to order swordfish or salmon, tonight we grabbed both plus some steamers. For one pound of salmon, one pound of swordfish, four pound and a half pounds of steamers the total was $70. It is worth every penny! The fish is always the best cut and so fresh. I love Atlantic seafood which is why we come so often! Love them! Special shout out to the wonderful staff!!! read more

See all

Nice selection of some real quality seafood. Prices are very high. Staff is real friendly. Fresh bread, cheeses, caviar, soups. Wasn't impressed with the $15 lobster roll. Roll was soggy, and the lobster had almost no flavor. Specialty gourmet and hard to find items available. Seasonings, pasta, some organic produce, Marinades. Worth a stop. read more

See all

Great selection of seafood - I am sure they have what you are looking for. I picked up a few pounds of steamers in the morning and they were great! Very fresh and clean. Would definitely return. Also had great hours for a Sunday compared to other fish mongers in the area. read more

Atlantic Seafood came highly recommended by my attorney Bull, who lives in Old Saybrook. His brother DotCom and my aunt Judy confirmed its the place for serious seafood on this stretch Connecticut shore. My girlfriend called around and priced lobsters. Not only was Atlantic Seafood a dollar or two cheaper than competitors, they also did not have a tiered pricing structure for different weight lobsters. The selection of seafood was fantastic with multiple delicious species of fish, oysters and shellfish, and shrimp of gigantic size as well. We stuck to the lobster. These we brought home alive for a 12 minute hot water bath. The lobsters were filled with sweet meat! Who can ask for anything more. read more

Atlantic Seafood - Atlantic Seafood, January 2015 - Seafood Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

See all

We were recommended this place for the great seafood. Ordered 20 oysters but ended up being shorted unfortunately. Call the next day, and Lisa was amazing in helping us to fix the problem. Treated us right and went above and beyond for the mistake that was made and everything was fantastic! Highly recommended for seafood that is fresh. Thank you Lisa!! read more

Everything is always super fresh and super delicious, from the seasonal soft shell crabs to salmon and ready made dishes. The salmon burgers are fabulous and the shrimp is bar none. They have been consistent for years and we will continue to go there for the freshest seafood! read more

Local joint friendly staff. Delicious food. I had the calamari cold salad and celery root slaw.

I agree with the owner of this place that know one should handle lobsters like that guy did at the airport. It's personal property and I agree that it should not have been a photo opt for everyone to see... Great lobsters at this place ! Buy them ! read more

As a non-fish eater, I am here to say that my husband and all of our houseguests declare Atlantic Seafood the finest fish store on the east coast. As a former fish eater (before I became allergic), I salivate when they grill Atlantic's swordwish, make crabcakes, sautee flounder, and on and on. A big plus, for me: they are brilliant to carry Howard's Breads! I'm surprised most of the reviews here are about the prepared foods. I gues my husband is a purist. He swears the fresh fish is incomparable. read more

Not sure when the right day to shop here is where the fish is the freshest but it wasn't the day I stopped in. Most everything in the case looked dried out. The scallops I bought were remarkably tasteless. The thing with this place is it looks enticing with a decent selection of fish and prepared food that veers towards a gourmet market. The prices reflect that. There are a number of fish markets on the Shoreline and I would recommend shopping around. Although I pop into this place from time to time-there is something disappointing about it for the money you are shelling out. read more

While the prices were right (well, they were average), the quality was horrible. Came specifically for sea scallops. Sea scallops will vary in color from pure white, to almost orange depending on their diet, but they should be one solid color. They shouldn't be pure white in the center and yellow around the edges, this indicates age. I asked to smell them and they reeked of pure ammonia. No thanks... wont be back. read more

We have gotten lobster from there and it was good but they are not the only game in town and they are rude and act like they are doing you some sort of favor. If I was the owner I would fire the entitled girl that answers the phone and drives away the business. Just a thought but be kind and have good customer service. This place is not worth it. Try another place in town. The staff at Big Y are very accommodating. read more

This is our "go to" seafood market. Lisa, the owner, is very helpful with great preparation suggestions and always willing to suggest something new and delicious. The oysters here are great and they usually have at least 3 options to choose from. Or if you are like us, you don't choose, but rather get some of each. Bomster scallops... the best you can get in our opinion. They are flash frozen right on the boat to ensure freshness, trust me, this is the way to go. We typically buy them in the 5# blocks that Atlantic receives them in from the fisherman. We then take them home and break off 1 to 1.5# meal-sized portions, only defrosting them as we need them. Tender, succulent, and soooo delicious simply seared with salt & pepper in unsalted butter. Hands down, we we love this place and rarely buy seafood from anywhere else. We drive by no less than 4 other seafood sellers to get here, and the extra trip is well worth it. read more

We had the lobster bisque and butternut squash seafood. They were good but very bland. At $15 a quart I got 3 container which was too expensive. Not much seafood either. read more

My family has been buying fish + from Atlantic Seafood since moving to Westbrook 6 years ago. You will always get the freshest products from the nicest people! I love the suggestions on how to cook whatever I'm buying (they've actually suggested fish for me when I just couldn't make up my mind on more than one occasion!). You will not find fresher, better fish! Lisa and her staff are amazing! read more

I have always liked Atlantic Seafood; found that the staff are friendly and helpful, the selection is top notch and the prices are really reasonable. But today I stopped in and one of the young men that helped me totally went above and beyond; I felt like their customers really do come first. They also have prepared foods and a fresh selection of local breads and cheeses. Highly recommend! read more

My family was in town, so we stopped here to grab some food for lunch. We got the clam chowder and lobster rolls. The lobster rolls were so delicious. The chowder was frozen so we had to patiently wait for it to thaw and warm in the pot. It was pretty good. We will definitely go back! read more

Great selection of seafood. Love the quality and the friendliness of the staff. The shark steak we got here was awesome. For some reason Yelp thinks this is a restaurant, it isn't. read more

It is absolutely the best sea food not only in this area but also through out New England. It is always fresh and delicious, They are handling this virus situation very well but I do miss seeing them behind the counter read more

Drive to Atlantic Seafood. Pick up your Lobster Bake In A Can. Add 3 cups of water. Heat on the stove or grill for 25 minutes. Feast on two beautiful, hard-shelled lobster, a bag of steamers (or mussels, if you prefer), corn on the cob and fingerling potatoes. Return can. Brilliant! Give Atlantic a day's notice (or more if you're feeding a crowd). $29.99 per person. No website. read more

I purchased 2 lbs of steamers on Sunday 6/23 and I was absolutely shocked at the poor quality. They smelled terrible when we went to cook them later that same day despite rinsing them several times and looking them over carefully in case there were one or two dead ones causing the odor. Against our better judgement we steamed them anyway and the terrible odor immediately filled our kitchen. Thankfully we decided that the $15.00 wasn't worth being sick and we pitched them into the woods. I used to be a good customer of Atlantic but not any more. This was not a borderline case. They had to have known these were bad and sold them to us regardless. read more

Stopped in a couple weeks ago and bought some frozen lobster meat . It was so fresh when I used it later that day. Went to grocery store and bought 6 lobsters and never again. I picked all the meat out but they were shedders and not much meat .. they don't tell you that when you buy them. Lobster meat was well worth the price !! Next time just will buy lobster meat from here. It's wonderful ! read more

I made the mistake of trusting a fish monger where I can't see and smell the product before purchase. I ordered sea scallops. They were brought to me in a sealed bag showing they picked them for my order. Home is literally 4 minutes away and it took that long to get them into the refrigerator. In preparation for dinner, we of course opened the package. At first the smell seemed confined to the kitchen, and they only have been dried and seasoned not cooked. Now, still before cooking the horrible fishy odor has permeated the house. I hope the taste does not reflect this odor, more of low tide than sea salt. From now on, I'll only purchase from a fish monger from whom I can see and smell and trust the product. read more

Do not go here seriously, it's overpriced and the quality is very poor . If you get steamers, half them will prob be dead, they cook dead lobsters that are from the tank and use them for lobster rolls, soft shell crabs smell really bad and ooze yellow stuff out of them, and the cooked shrimp they sell by the pound isn't really a pound more like .85 . Very shady practices to cut costs read more

Best seafood I've gotten from anywhere. Everything is super fresh, the staff is extremely helpful and friendly. I am there every week getting Arctic char, salmon, swordfish or whatever we're in the mood for! We love their lobster cakes , Crab cakes and lemon dill shrimp! They have done an awesome job during Covid. I don't mind paying the prices because the fish is highest quality and I totally trust them. read more