Stay away from this dealership as they do the bait and switch tactic. I called to ask if a car was still available for sale and Carmen told me that it was indeed still available. I made an appointment to see the car that same day and drove two hours to the location as I was coming from Queens. When I get there they tell me that the car had sold a FEW DAYS AGO and then asked me if I was open to buying a different car. Classic BAIT AND SWITCH TACTIC just to get you in the door. Huge waste of time and very unprofessional of them to lie to me and waste my time. I will not recommend this dealership to anyone. read more

BAIT and SWITCH. car adversed as 7,900 ended up being 13,000 . They have ZERO SHAME, and asked me whats the problem with a few thousand dollars more. read more

Bait & switch scam don't waste your time. They list cars on their website for cheap that are not available for sale.

Misleading Pricing & Dishonest Practices Beware if you're planning to pay cash at Atlantic Kia -- their advertised prices don't apply unless you finance through them. I was originally texting with Eddie, who told me there would be a $2,000 "fee" because, and I quote, "that's what the bank charges them for taking cash." Total nonsense. When I pushed back and pointed out that this was really about the dealership losing out on the financing kickback (yes, dealers make money when you finance through them), he eventually admitted it was to make up for the profit they wouldn't get from me financing. That's deceptive and shady. So just know this: if you're paying cash, expect to pay $2,000 more than any price they post online. It's a classic bait-and-switch tactic. Absolutely not how a reputable dealership should do business. read more

Update: everyone is awesome when you're buying. It's how they are after they get you to sign that shows the true character. Service is not what I expected or what was explained to me. It's a good plan, but not what they told me. I was told point blank that I would never have to spend a dollar on any service/maintenance. That's not exactly true. I bought the platinum level plan, which maybe I'm dumb, but it still seems pretty good. Anything that breaks, they cover no deductible for 10/100,000. The issue I have is that when I bring it in, they recommend that I get 2 different air filters, and a tire alignment. Now, I'm at 15,000k. Why do I need an alignment or filters. No way are they dirty yet, and the car drives perfect. To be clear, I really like the car. They wanted... 198.00 just for the alignment and 89.00 for each filter. I was a bit shocked thinking I'm covered and then they're asking me to get almost 400.00 in "recommend" services. I looked up prices and I found the range for alignment to be 50-130 (130 if it needs a lot). So, what's up with the 198?! I decline bc no way I'm getting anything without researching. I go home read my plan. Every part is covered. So I'm confused. I go back. The lady at the service desk tells me that my plan only covers oil change and tire rotation. I show her and she's flipping through the plan saying the same thing over and over. And then tries to sell me ANOTHER maintenance plan. I almost leave, but I was getting upset. I go back and ask to speak with whomever sells the plans bc if this is the case I'm out. After speaking with him, it becomes clear that the services (filters/alignment) were not necessary-- only "recommended." Read: the car did not need the 400.00 in services at all. Is this the scam? If I didn't ask questions, would I have unnecessarily spent 400.00? It feels wrong; it feels scammy to say we think you need this...? And the prices are crazy high. read more

I wanted to let Long Islanders know about a shitty trick an auto dealer tried to pull on me: ======================================= Atlantic Kia tried to pull the "bait and switch" on me. I called the dealership at 1:05 PM on a Sunday, asking about a used Nissan Altima they had there. They checked and told me the auto was still available, and I said I would be right down there to test drive the car. They said "Great, see you then." I arrived at Atlantic Kia at 1:35 PM and they set me up with salesman Matthew Lopez, who then proceed to intake all my information, etc. After I had been there for 15 minutes, he finally told me that the Nissan Altima wasn't available; someone had put a deposit on the car at 10AM when they opened. That was over three hours prior to my call. Atlantic Kia then tried to get me to look at other, more expensive cars instead. When I said I wasn't interested, the manager tried to get me to leave a $500 "second deposit" just in case the first buyer's credit didn't go through. ATLANTIC KIA TRIED TO BAIT AND SWITCH ME, KNOWING FULL WELL THAT THE CAR WAS NOT AVAILABLE FOR PURCHASE. THE CAR HAD BEEN HELD BY A DEPOSIT FOR HOURS AND THEY STILL TOLD ME TO COME DOWN AND SEE THE CAR. This is 100% flat-out DISHONEST and they should be ashamed of themselves. Atlantic Kia WASTED TWO HOURS OF MY TIME to try to sell me cars that I wasn't interested in. Beware of this dealer! I would give ZERO stars if it was possible, but you have to give one star before Yelp will log your review read more

Brian Okeefe rug pulled us by selling the vehicle the moment the younger sales staff took the meeting for the used vehicle. This sales tactic involves stalling while Sales Mangers attempt to sell to other dealers while the buyer sits unattended at a representative's desk, in this case Sean's desk.   While my partner was waiting for Sean to retrieve the keys for a test drive. 38 minutes into being stalled, Brian Okeefe had began the process of 'pulling the rug' from her and sold to a sistering dealership. Then proceeded to disrespect her by offering a new car to her for a premium rate. Brian is bestowing these disrespectful habits on the younger staff so that they can optimize their profits by taking advantage of what they perceive to be naive young woman. read more

I would definitely never buy a car here I came with the intention of seeing a car and buying it because I had agreed to see it today and arriving I checked the car on my cell phone and it was still available I arrived and the car disappeared. They explained to me that that car never existed but I saw it on the page. I don't recommend this place read more

I leased a Telluride from Atlantic Kia about a year ago and I was working with a sales rep named Alex. The process was pretty easy, but he and the manager and Alex were adamant that I pick up the vehicle the following day. I picked up the vehicle on the day asked only to find out the Telluride went on a major sales special the following day which would have lowered my payment considerably. Also, the app with the remote start was important to me since I have a long walk to my car in the winter from my complex. I was never told the app will work for one year and now they want $20 a month for the balance of the lease. Will be going to different dealer in the future if I even lease another Kia. read more

Fran was such a pleasure to work with. She helped me get into a new K5 with no headache and made it an easy experience.

I visited Atlantic Kia to purchase a Honda Accord Sport priced at 13,450, but after putting down 9 and financing, the total cost somehow ended up being 45,000, which is outrageous. read more

Do your research, this is not the place you want to buy a car from. They are deceptive in every way. They added costs to my lease deal, did not disclose fees, and when questioned, they acted like they didn't know what I was talking about. They tell you to leave them a good review while you're sitting at their desk and watch you do it and won't give you the keys until you do it . They literally hold your keys until they see you do it .. it's absurd. I bought a car in July 2024 and they have said they will give me a resolution to how they overcharged me, but they won't respond to emails or phone calls anymore. Pathetic! read more

Artur and Vinny made the process of buying a vehicle and trading in my old vehicle so seamless. From the process of walking in to the financing process. Loved the attention to detail and accommodations waiting. This isn't the first time buying a vehicle with Atlantic Kia and won't be my last. read more

Atlantic Kia - 2024 kia telluride ex xline - Car Dealers Near Me - West Islip, New York

Great place, everyone is nice and professional. Picked up Kia Soul 2022, awesome!!!! 2024 Kia Soul, SOLD! read more

After trading in our Nissan Rogue and leasing a new Kia Seltos we found out that for months after the deal was done this dishonest dealership never paid off the lease on the trade in as agreed to. We had to make numerous calls to get them to finally pay their debt as we received collection notices. When we spoke to the general manager of the dealership, since this is an ongoing issue, he got very defensive and nasty saying I should go get a lawyer while hanging up on us. NEVER EVER do business with these less than honest or caring people! read more

We already love Kia. Have been apart of the family for 13 years. We've moved recently and our lease was up so we brought our trade in to our neighborhood dealership. This is the cleanest location I've ever seen! They even have a hot chocolate machine for the kids! Our daughters fave! Lamelle helped us get our dream car at the perfect price! He listened, was super helpful and kind. Everyone was professional and welcoming. We are proud to be part of the KIA family! read more

My son just purchased his first new car from Atlantic Kia. Great service was provided by Lamelle, Melvin and Brian. The showroom is spacious and comfortable. The car was delivered in perfect and glowing condition. Lamelle took his time explaining all the cars features. Highly recommend Atlanta Kia in West Islip. read more

Atlantic Kia - Brand new Kia Forte GT - Car Dealers Near Me - West Islip, New York

I will forever come back for Atlantic Kia for my future cars! Andrew was so amazing, professional, humorous and friendly! He was able to listen to my wants and needs for a car and was able to get me what I needed! Sean was able to help me build the best coverage protection and monthly payments! Absolutely amazing customer service! read more

See all

Incredibly rude and unprofessional dealership. Long story short they cancelled my deal while finishing the paperwork for the "delivery" of the car and after spending over 3 hours there. I objected to signing an inappropriate document and they told me to leave not allowing me to have these executed documents voided and/or shredded. They also have not refunded the out of pocket payment of $736. This car was for my son who is 23 years old (his first new car) and it was his money that they didn't refund! This all happened just 4 days before Christmas. They have no shame. Please do not go to this dealer unless you are willing to pay and sign whatever it is they want. Stay away! read more

Car dealerships exist to serve the vehicle needs of their communities. A new lease was carried out easily in Summer 2022 because the salesperson and finance manager were mature, experienced, and knew how to do their jobs. Was very happy with the experience. I would refer others on South Shore Suffolk County to them. read more

This was the absolute worst, but thankfully the shortest experience we have had looking for a car. We weren't even there 10 minutes before we got up and left. A very inexperienced salesman named Matt was asked to sit with us and didn't or couldn't explain the cars he had. We walked in asking if there was a rebate on the Sportage Hybrid as a friend just leased one this week and instead of telling me what Sportages they offer and trim levels he said not once but twice for me to text my friend and ask what exact car she got and he would find out from his manager if there was a rebate. We explained to him that we have never looked at Sportage can he explain the trim levels and if they are offering a rebate and he said he is only the salesperson the manager does the numbers and knows which cars have rebates. We said you aren't trying to sell us anything because you want me to tell you which exact car I want first instead of explaining the cars specifications. We were there to see what the numbers were because we have a lease ending soon, and we believe if we said to another salesman we are interested in the Sportage Hybrid and heard there was possibly a rebate incentive that would of been enough information to begin a possible sale. We got up and told him that we are leaving and going to go to another Kia Dealership and he replied "Good luck with that." How disrespectful and unprofessional to comment that. We believe he is the one that needs all the luck in this profession. read more

At first, the experience seemed promising, but after evaluating the deal, I realized I was taken advantage of. Don't fall for the games as I did. Despite having a perfect credit score and a clear agreement on my down payment, they added an unexpected $100 per month to my payments for "something they forgot to add" and my down payment also grew an additional $1,000 then agreed upon. Nothing was accurate, numbers were all over the place, very long wait times and I regret bringing my business here. I wouldn't recommend this dealership. The manager Vincent won't return my messages. read more

Great working with Andrew , Malvin and Jason (from finance ). Once I did my research and worked with the team - walked away with a new carnival . read more

I just purchased a Seltos here. Writing this review because of my experiences with other dealerships. These folks are good people, straight shooters. Very happy I purchased my car here. Got a good deal from Larry. Highly recommend. read more

Bait and switch even using True Car they would not honor their offer over the phone. They Offered us the car at the agreed monthly lease price BUT after paying almost an additional $1,000.00 down! We traveled 1 1/2 hours to LI to be duped. Don't shop at Atlantic Kia. read more

Got two letters stating my 20-22 Sportage was going to get an upgrade on the alarm system . Also got a recall stating if my vehicle had a hitch there was a danger of a fire . Went in there today the biggest bunch of idiots I could have ever spoken to . They checked out my car for a hitch all you have to do is look at it , and I had made an appointment for an oil change but they called me to tell me my vehicle was ready it didn't need the alarm it didn't need the hitch to be fixed as if I didn't know that and they didn't do the oil change . Smithtown Kia for me from now on . The young lady on the phone at 1:00 was lovely I forgot her name but she is smarter and more responsible than anybody else in that building or maybe in the dealership . Enough with the Atlantic Auto Mall read more

*******RIP OFF ***BEWARE****** Sales person I dealt with was AJ Jamaddar I Negotiated a sale price with Mel, supposedly a sales manager. Reached an agreement after both he and AJ tried ripping me off for a $3000 "dealership fees". AJ then said he would submit a loan application via Alexander Maisonneuve (finance paper pusher) to get approved. I got a callback from Alex saying the loan was approved but he wouldn't give me any information of the loan terms. Asked for a callback took all day and still didn't call me. I thought we were good based on good faith and the word of Mel the sales manager about the sale price. They were aware I was driving four hours to get there. Once I get there once again, he will not give me any loan term agreement information until I persisted. And then come to find out that he submitted my loan application for $3000 more than the sale of the car. WITHOUT MY permission. Alex then kept trying to swindle me out of more money and would not keep the price agreement I had made with The sales manager MEL. I was also going to put $2000 as down payment ..yet they insisted that it would NOT be deducted from the sales price!!! instead they wanted to ADD MY $2000 to the price of the car!!! Along with another $3000 ! When they realized I was on to their dishonest business practices, they kept giving me the runaround, and I eventually walked out of the dealership. Anyone who has purchased a car here before definitely -without a doubt -was ripped off. Those are the type of people that do not read all the added bogus fees to the contract and are not well-versed on the theft that goes on with sales people at dealerships like this!! if you were contemplating buying a car here, do yourself a favor and read all of the B.S fees they add to the sale price of the car. And as we all know, don't let them tell you that your down payment is added to a loan. A down payment is an option for the buyer, unless the finance company requires it, but it should not ever be dictated by the dealership as they do it. They have no right to impose a down payment on the sale price of the car. A down payment is towards the purchase of your car and should be subtracted from the sales price ! They couldn't outsmart me and steal from me so they lost a deal. And I hope they lose a lot of other customers. THEY ARE CROOKS! If the sales managers word is worth Nothing! after a sales price is agreed upon -then it's obvious those people can't be trusted for anything!!!!! Sales manager -MEL Sales consultant- AJ Jamaddar Finance manager- Alexander Maisonneuve BAD BUSINESS PRACTICE. DISHONEST. THIEVES. CROOKS! *****BEWARE***** read more

Hey thank u so much to Andrew & Alex for getting me in a car I love! Made buying a car easy!

Satisfied with the car, but appalled by the lack of care that goes into treating the customers after the purchase. I have been trying to cancel my extended warranty for over a week at this point. I tried calling several times and leaving messages. Eventually I went down to the dealership and got verbal confirmation that the warranty will be cancelled. But that of course is worthless if it's not in writing. I thought I finally got somewhere when I pushed for a signed and dated warranty cancellation contract. But it has been days and there hasn't been any indication of my warranty being cancelled. No email confirmation, and Power Protect says they have not received anything. I tried reaching out multiple times to the dealership to check for an update, and have not gotten an email back. I find this experience and lack of communication to be completely unprofessional. read more

Experience was fantastic and Andrew was great to work with. Would recommend working with him.

The salesperson and manager were very shady. They refused to be honest of the actual dollar amount they wanted to give me for my trade in. They claimed my trade in would cover the taxes but didn't want to be transparent on actual breakdown. I put a fully refundable down payment on the vehicle I was interested in which they sold and they have not returned my call. I now have to dispute the charge with my credit card company. Buyer Beware... read more

Ask for Andrew. Extremely informative, personable and made our entire buying experience great!

Buying the beautiful new Telluride was a wonderful experience with the help and patience of Andrew, Pete and Sean. I highly recommend stopping I. For you next new car. read more

I had the WORST experience here trying to lease my first car. Be careful and don't trust everything they say and don't get pressured into making a decision same day cause it was chaos & you won't be happy in the end. I went in with my friend for the Kia K5. Spoke to one salesman and he went to his manager and brought back pricing that was ridiculously high so I said not interested. Then his manager came to talk to us and dropped from 6k down payment and over 500 monthly payment to 0 down 439 (huge jump). I wanted to be at max 400. They kept going back and forth with pricing with me and another salesman then jumped in also so its a 3rd person now. I kept saying I'd call them tomorrow but was getting pressured and told I needed to make a decision that night. I was making calls to my friend that knows about cars and even got questioned why do I need to call someone. I finally accept the deal for 750 down and 409 monthly. Then they press me into doing insurance first before i even did the credit app or got the breakdown of taxes and fees that i kept asking for. I wanted to wait to do insurance with my agent the next day but they kept telling me todo insurance that night. I said I already had got quoted by my agent and would rather do that the next day (since my agents office was closed) and they still pushed and said it's ok your agent can change everything tomorrow don't worry (lies). So I did insurance and it was a ridiculously high rate than what I got quoted for prior and they took a deposit of $345 and while dealing with insurance I was asked for my debit card by the sales rep which i denied cause i wanted to use credit and also I wanted to get the full breakdown of the car before i did any sort of payment. I then go into the finance managers office and they hit me with almost 5k in taxes and fees (taxes i understand but fees were ridiculous) which I knew that would happen hence why I wanted the breakdown from the start but was pushed into doing insurance first before I even got the car which how does that make any sense?. I ended up not taking the car and thank god I didn't because #1- i wasn't ending up with the deal we had agreed upon after the fees etc and #2- I later confirmed that it was a lie that I can change everything with insurance with my agent the next day so the extremely high rate I got over the phone with the insurance rep would not have been able to be changed by my agent the next day like they told me and I would have been stuck with it. There was way too much pressure from the 4! people I dealt with and strong armed into taking the car that night no matter what. And now I cancelled insurance and have to wait 2 weeks or so for a refund from that and my credit got hit with 3 hard inquiries. I would not recommend this dealership or trust anything they say until you have everything in black and white reading everything word for word and full number breakdown and only deal with your insurance agent, not the 800 number they call for you just to make you get the car that day (if its your agents after hours) . Absolutely terrible experience and huge waste of time and so happy I walked out and found a better dealership to deal with. read more

Came here to get into a new lease, sat down with Andrew V. He immediately made us feel like we've known him for years. Took the time to answer all of our questions and explained every detail of the car. 10/10 customer service. If you're in the market to buy a car I highly recommend Andrew read more

this dealership is terrible , the salesman had no teeth and his breath stunk so bad ....wasted our time with a vehicle that was already sold . so guy that looked like he crawled out of the back of a strip club named charlie told me i couldn't pay cash because he gets a kick back with financing . total scum operation. take my advice and please go elsewhere read more

Went in on a whim without an appointment. First we checked in with the receptionist who stated that we would be next in line for a sales person. After a bit we were asked by a salesperson if we had an appointment or were being helped to which we answered no, we were waiting for the next available sales person. Same male associate also asked the the two men who had just walked in if they had an appointment - they also said NO. The male associate decided to help the male clients - trading in his Mercedes for a Forte. No one asked what I was looking at to know that the commission on my sale could have been better or worse. It seemed strictly sexist - men and their toys! Rest assured we walked out. read more