Great food, service and clean! Always enjoy going to the Butter Dish in Pikeville, Tn!read more

Decrease the amount of seasoning. 1) Undersalt a dish so the patron can salt to their personal…read moretaste. 2) Don't overuse white pepper unless it's noted as "spicy" on the menu. 3) A server shouldn't present the check prior to discussing dessert options and never assume the dessert is ordered "to go". The ambiance could be likened to an auction barn which means the noise just bounces off the ceiling making conversation difficult.

Visited for the first time in a minute last night and our food was so good. The blackened chicken…read morehas become a favorite. My daughter loved her shrimp tacos too! The portions are super generous you will always leave full. Our server Carissa was the absolute best. So sweet and perfectly attentive. The restaurant was quiet so it was a perfect early dinner.

I had no idea this place existed until a family member recommended it. Staff were all super…read morefriendly, food arrived to the table with an okay speed. I chalk any wait up to it being made to order vs prepped and just quick heated. Portions are a good size, but heavy on the salt with all the dishes. The space is odd. It's really open, high ceilings, exposed duct work, but hunting paraphernalia hanging all around. Prices are high for the area.

This is a must go eat place. Great food, great service in a…read moregreat location in Dayton, TN. All fresh, all great recipes, good sized portions and reasonably priced. We recently took a group of 14 and they, effortlessly, served us all in a timely fashion. The meat loaf is off the chain good.

I'd give this place a solid 3.5 stars…read more We've eaten here twice and, overall, have enjoyed our meals. I especially like the atmosphere and the history of the house--it has a lot of charm and makes for a unique dining experience. Most of the food has been good, but the shrimp and grits were a definite miss for us. The flavor just wasn't there, and it's not something we would order again. Overall, I'd say this is probably one of the better places to eat in Dayton, especially since there aren't a lot of restaurants in the area that consistently offer higher-quality food. The biggest reason I can't rate it any higher is the service. We've had the same waitress both visits, and unfortunately, she just hasn't been friendly or welcoming. Dining out, especially at these prices, is about more than just the food. You want to feel like your business is appreciated, and we've walked away both times feeling more like an inconvenience than valued customers. That said, we'd still consider going back because the atmosphere is enjoyable and most of the food has been good. I'm hopeful that a different server--or a more welcoming service experience--would make a noticeable difference.

I got an Italian and the Cuban with the cowboy caviar and potato salad and a sweet tea and it was…read moreamazing! So so good! Cozy atmosphere. And even friendlier staff. 10/10 recommend!! Stopped with the girls here on a bachelorette

Really good little sandwich shop! It's off the beaten path but definitely worth searching for. It's…read morejust off the round about but you have to look hard to see it. It's no longer behind an antique shop, so don't let that confuse you! Excellent Italian sub and one of the best Cubans we've ever had. The macaroni salad was good, too! Please come support this woman-owned business and make sure to stop at the bakery next door!

This place is easily accessible off SR-30 and there's plenty of parking for that quick stop and…read moreshop. The food is excellent and very fresh, the service is great, and there's plenty of seating if you're looking to dine-in. I've tried the bbq ribs, bbq chicken, bbq pulled pork, the Philly cheese steak sandwich, and every burger on the menu. I've enjoyed every one of them and plan to order again. A couple of my faves are the bison burger and chicken-salad salad, which is great to take on-the-go.

The Club sandwich was very good. We ordered steak fries also which were good also. Very friendly…read morestaff. Looking forward to trying the BBQ next!

Great food, service, ambience! Fried pickles were the spears (extra points for this!)read more

We had a very pleasant meal there, the food was delicious, our waitress was very good & definitely…read moreearned her tips that day as we were in a party of about 16. Yet, she was fast, attentive, and very pleasant and helpful. Great place to go if you're visiting Dayton. I highly recommend

I ordered two pizzas, and ate one there. This is a second restaurant for these folks the original…read moreis in Pikeville. The building is much newer and nicer. Bathrooms were clean, and so was the restaurant. I enjoyed the pizza, it's exactly like the pizza in the original restaurant. Point off, it was slightly saucy. But I can live with that. Pepperoni was a little light, good amount of jalapenos. They were busy, right at lunchtime but the pizzas were out in about 12 minutes. So overall good job. I was very happy with the experience.

Arrived to the restaurant and was greeted nicely. One of the front cashiers even walked an elderly…read morelady out to keep her covered from the rain. I got a personal pizza that was delicious. The stretch on the cheese reminded me of Godfathers Pizza. A trip to thaw salad bar was also gotten, the selection of toppings was plentiful. The meatball sub was also ordered with fries. The sandwich was delicious and the fries were too good to put ketchup on. We will definitely be back.

Crazy busy place! Sit at the old school soda fountain counter so you can watch them makes shakes,…read moresundaes, and cones. If you sit outside or at an inside table you order at the counter. At the bar, they take your order. Staff is extra friendly and they do a great job of checking on you and keeping your drink full. I ordered a chicken Philly. Their Ruben must be extra good because several people have ordered it. The fruit I had with mine was very fresh and good. Don't miss Payne's if you're near the area. You won't regret it.

Amazing place to get a sandwich and an ice cream. The staff here are so friendly and kind too. I…read moregot a roast beef on rye with assorted accompaniments, it was grilled, delicious, and served promptly. Then I got the smores sundae and it was amazing too. Lots of ice cream, rich, creamy, and lots of whipped cream. Comfy cozy place with booths and tables and cute decor. Scottsboro is a small town but the ice cream and sandwich love at Payne's is big and bright! Thank you to Payne's for making me visit to Scottsboro glorious and amazing.