I am now a regular and Antonio's really does not disappoint. Their delicious pizza is a highlight of my workday. I've tried other toppings: pepperoni, cheesesteak, chorizo, chicken bacon ranch, and everything is consistently good! My favorite is to order a custom pizza: penne vodka with sausage added- it's Olive Garden in a slice! The staff are warm and always helpful. read more

Can't beat the $6 lunch special. 2 slices and a drink. Wish there were more pies to choose from when I was there but the pizza was tasty and the guys behind the counter were friendly. Perfect afternoon refuel before back out to running errands. read more

See all

Order cheese fries 6.95 Order mozzarella cheese, fries, and I get yellow cheese fries They're not even cooked soggy and disgusting read more

Antonio's Old World Pizza - Fries - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Plain cheese pizza was very bad. Maybe it was an off day or just take-out. Garlic knots were good.

Very smooth experience with ordering online and pickup. Good pizza! Will try some of their other items in the future. Also, good prices.

Was in the area for youth travel sports. Was in the mood for pizza and fortunately had stopped into Antonio's. We ordered an extra large cheese pizza and small margarita pizza. We watched the dough freshly prepared and topped. The pizzas were plentiful and delicious. Had the pleasure of chatting with Antonio, a hard-working gentleman along with his staff. We'll definitely come back! read more

See all

Great food. Excellent prices. Large portions. I had the chicken carbonara and took half home. The garlic knots were spectacular.

Pizza was thin and crispy as requested. Could've used some more cheese and topping it to the edge. Eggplant parm sub was good and included some chips. read more

Antonio's Old World Pizza - Pizza large cheese - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a medium Penne Vodka with sausage pizza and wings at 7:35PM via Yelp. Delivery via GrubHub was estimated for 40 minutes to an hour later. When it got to 9:20PM, I called GrubHub. They called the restaurant and relayed to me that the driver was "2 minutes away". Fifteen minutes later, a car rolled into the hotel parking lot. A nice lady apologized and handed a pizza box and some wings to me. I went upstairs and opened the box and examined the contents. I honestly have no idea what kind of pizza they delivered, but it was definitely not a Penne Vodka with sausage pizza. Those tend to have penne pasta, vodka sauce, and sausage. I immediately called the restaurant. The man I spoke to confirmed that my order was incorrect and asked if I wanted him to fix it. I stated that I did, he promised that it would be on its way immediately. It's been an hour and 10 minutes. They closed 50 minutes ago. I was pretty sure they' weren't coming. At approximately 11:30, my pizza finally arrived. Stone cold, but finally here. It tasted OK after a minute or so on the microwave. Tl;dr: incredibly late delivery. wrong order. Even later redelivery. NEVER AGAIN. read more

Antonio's Old World Pizza - THIS IS NOT WHAT I ORDERED - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Major props to Antonio's for delivering during the COVID outbreak! The lady and I were looking for somewhere to snag delivery from on a Friday evening and Antonio's was right around the corner, so we figured...why not?! She ordered their basic calzone (just cheese) and I got an Italian Hoagie with a large Caesar (came with garlic bread). Delivery arrived in just under the estimated time (45mins) in about 35mins. The calzone was top notch - really nice crisp on the dough with a good crust to cheese ratio and a tasty tomato sauce to accompany it. The GF rated an 8/10, I'd give roughly the same. The Chicken Caesar salad I got was actually the highlight of the meal. The dressing was definitely house-made, and had an excellent flavor that was heavier on the parmesan. It was a perfect compliment the fresh romaine and chicken, which was cooked to perfection. Many times, chicken that comes with a Caesar salad is pre-cooked and dried out, but this grilled chicken was not dry at all and had a solid flavor to it. I ordered the "large" size which came with garlic bread. The garlic bread was the same bread they use for their sandwiches but uncut and with a nice garlic butter spread across the top - a nice treat. The croutons in the salad also appeared to be house made, I believe that it was their bread they used for their sandwiches and garlic bread cut small and seasoned/fried. They weren't as crunchy as the typical store-bought crouton but I appreciated this. I do like to judge an Italian restaurant or deli by their Caesar Salad and Italian Hoagie, and the hoagie was the more lackluster of the two. While it was definitely not bad, the qualities that REALLY MAKE a stellar hoagie just weren't there. I would have preferred a bit more of a spicier salami and maybe sharp provolone. The salami did not have enough bite to cut through the mild provolone and the heavy ham flavor. The bread had a nice outer chew to it but coming from Trenton and knowing the value in a nice crusty, chewy roll for an Italian hoagie, I'd stick with other menu items from Antonio's such as their calzone. Next time, I'll be giving their pizza a shot and see how it holds up against their peers. read more

See all

This place recently opened up and the curb appeal caught my eye. It has a nice new sign and the inside certainly follows suit as well. Very clean and a good place to grab a quick slice or sandwich. I had 2 slices and some wings. Unfortunately, as I ate my lunch, my enjoyment went down. I first ate the traditional cheese slice. It was a pretty good--a standard slice, but could have had a little bit more sauce to it. The slice also had a decent thickness to it. As for their "Corleone" style, it's a thin and crispy square pizza. For my liking, it was too thin and crispy-- I need a little bit of chew! Lastly, the wings were terrible. They were those crappy breaded wings served dry with a side of hot sauce. I'd expect the same from a rest stop. A few other things I've noticed. Their website has pictures of a traditional pizzeria with checkered tablecloth layered over white tablecloths. It portrays a completely different atmosphere and I was a little surprised when I walked in. Another thing I was confused about is the name. "Antonio's Old World Pizza". To me, I'm thinking straight from Italy. I was a little disappointed to see the pizza ovens as opposed to a brick or wood fired oven. And finally, the music in a restaurant being played should be for the customers, not the employees. For some reason, I'm in an Italian eatery and they're playing music in Spanish I can't understand. If I'm eating tacos in a Mexican place? Awesome, it adds to the ambiance, but it doesn't make sense here. I'd give this place another try, but I'll probably be walking instead of running to it. read more

Antonio's Old World Pizza - Cheese and "Corleone" style slices - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

BIG tasty slices of pizza! Garlic knots are good as well. The app is making me write more for some reason.

Great food and service! The best upside down pizza I've tasted. Great fries too! Our go to spot to order out with

Excellent pizza and good customer service! The pizza was well seasoned and hot when it arrived. read more

I've noticed Antonio's when I drive by and I finally decided to get diner there. We ordered 2 chicken wraps and I ordered a sweet potato fries too. I didn't see that they included fries with the wraps. When my husband went in to pick up our order he saw fries were included. They not only let him cancel the sweet potato fries order but they gave us regular fries with one wrap and sweet potato fries for the other! That was so nice!! And here's the most important thing- the food is so delicious, lots of grilled chicken, tender and flavorful and the fries were so good, cooked perfectly! And huge portions, especially for a side. I'm so glad we found Antonio's; we'll be back soon. read more

I usually come here with my sisters and we love it but yesterday it was not it. First thing I see a guy standing at the front counter on his phone and not knowledge us took 5 min for someone to come up and take our order. While we were waiting the guy who is the phone keep staring at my sister which she felt uncomfortable and he kept picking his nose in front us while he was on the phone the whole time just standing behind the counter. We order chicken fingers and fries it was horrible the chicken is hard to chew, burnt and taste awful. After this visit I wouldn't ever come back just terrible service and food. read more

When your kid is in travel sports, it likely means you also have a bunch of kids and their parents hanging at the same hotel. While this is a fun, epic sleepover for the kids, it's basically like herding cats for parents. The last thing you want to do is coordinate a team dinner. Antonio's to the rescue! Their pizza is so good. Everyone in our crew was very happy. The concerned moms tried to pump vegetables into the kids by ordering a couple of salads it was difficult to choose because all of them were great. The team's favorites were the arugula pizza and the margherita pizza with vodka sauce. Even our hotel staff was gracious enough to take our leftovers and one desk agent said it was her favorite place. It was a win! When we arrived to Antonio's to pick up our order, the staff was apologetic, but they ran out of ingredients for a salad we ordered--this was a good sign, in my opinion. We substituted a different salad and the guy behind the counter was kind enough to give us a complimentary 2 liter of soda for the kids (not that they needed it.) Thank you, Antonio's for your hospitality and excellent food. Everyone went to bed stuffed, happy, and some of us full of sugar. Fun times! read more

Tops! I stopped by for a spur of the moment slice of pizza. I got a slice of the white pizza and was blown away with how delicious it was. Perfect mix of garlic and oil. One of the best white slices I've had anywhere! Nice people too! read more

The best! Pizza is as good as my Nona's! Authentic Italian! From meals to wings -- white-pizza with ricotta and Procuttio to traditional pepperoni--I order and am always sure it will be good, fresh, hot, made-to-order and consistently excellent-whether it's a "stay in pizza night" or to have a couple over for pizza, antipasto and a casual meal around the fireplace there is no other place I trust for an always excellent and (not to be redundant) consistently authentic Italian meal! Thank you fir getting us through the Virus with great meals! read more

Food was great. The pizza was crispy and not chewy. Ravioli was stuffed with fresh cheese. The place was fast and clean. Plenty of sausage on the pizza slice. Can't wait to go back for the chocolate cake. read more

Antonio's Old World Pizza - Ravioli was stuffed with fresh cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

I look forward to Antonio's Pizza every time I'm in town. Perfect crust and a list of options you can't go wrong ordering.

Whenever I come in this pizzeria, the staff are always friendly and polite. I once tried the Corleone style pizza when I walked in, it was so good. I tried ordering it for delivery but I forgot the name of that pizza so I ordered the Rustica instead ‍. It was still good but Corleone is my fave! read more

First time ordering, ordered plain cheese pizza and works cheesesteak. Very good Cheesesteak, excellent meat and roll. Pizza also very good, as a prior reviewer said, could use more sauce, although extra sauce is available for an upcharge. Will definitely return to try other stuff. read more

Very disappointed with the reliability. I asked what time they were open until on Christmas Eve so I could order some pizzas. When I called ahead to ask they said 8:30 pm. When I called a little before 7 they were closed. If you say you're going to be open until 8:30 stay open until 8:30. read more

Ordered personal size pizza, the works, it was a vegetable pizza, very little meat and cheese and sauce

Excellent pizza, even better service! The guys at the counter actually pay attention and make the food as you ask! Quality is excellent, prices are fair and it's clean! Love that they have tons of drink options in plastic and glass bottles as well as a coke freestyle machine! read more

The pizza was lacking salt and the garlic knots were the worst felt like eating raw dough. The pizza also had an off smell had to throw everything. Will stick to chain restaurants from now on read more

Possibly one of the best pizzas I have ever had. Can't wait to try the entire menu. Great place!!!!

Ordered from here a few times. Food is always great and worth the wait. Delivery drivers are usually nice, but the last driver made sure to let me know that the restaurant is a 25 minute drive away. Then I guess you can save those 25 minutes from now on. read more

I rarely write reviews, but wanted to give high praise to Antonio's Pizza and especially their manager Melinda. We were a huge group of families in town for the weekend and ordered a ton of pizzas, trays, and salads. The food was delicious, the delivery was on time, and they even drove back with one smaller item left behind. I can't recommend this place more. If we come back to the area, I'd be happy to order again. read more

This place is a hidden gem. I'm so glad I found a pizza place this close to me that not only is authentic in true italian flavor, but also has amazingly affordable prices for people who don't wanna spend 20 dollars on an overpriced take out dinner.. This is your place! The dinners are family friendly priced.. I think 15 dollars is the highest priced meal and they have daily specials. I can't wait to try everything on the menu!! The pizza is amazing. They hit every point on the pizza criteria, the texture of the crust, flavor of the sauce, and the right amount of cheese.. the real test was eating a cold slice straight from the fridge and it was still great! On top of everything else, the owner is an absolute sweetheart and is a joy to interact with. Please give this place a try, you wont be disappointed! read more

The Original Antonio's Old World Pizza is truly quite awesome. The menu is impressive, I was overwhelmed with the choices. Everything was amazing and delicious. Everybody who works there is always very helpful. A very remarkable experience at The Original Antonio's Old World Pizza. read more

Went to Antonio's after we received one of their menus in the mail. Since is was on my way home from work, we gave it a try and I'm glad we did. We ordered a Sicilian pizza and it was awesome. The crust was perfect not stale feeling and it was baked to perfection great taste and texture and the right thickness . My wife is picky when it comes to pizza and she raved about the crust, sauce and cheese and I agreed. We will definitely be going back. Give it a try you won't be disappointed read more