It was a few years since we last dined here. Good to know you can now make a reservation. We've always enjoyed the Signature Pie and shared a small salad which had been plenty for two. The crust was more of a cracker rather than a thin crust pizza. While we generally enjoy a well done pie this really bordered on over done, resulting in the cracker type texture. We also remember the chopped tomatoes being robust and it was sparse, though it was still tasty. We shared a wedge salad that was really just for one. With so many pizza options in the area not in a hurry to return. read more

Pizza joint. Good food , good service , nice atmosphere. Definitely a must if you're in the areas. BYOB

The pizzas and pastas are first-rate. Lots of pizza options, something for everyone. The tasty crust is perfect - thin, but not cracker-like. read more

I had a great experience at Tacconelli's. I thought the thin crust pizza had great flavor and texture. Thin crust may not be for everyone but I'm a fan and it was cooked well. The pastas are also decent but I felt the pizzas are a must get. They also allow customization for the toppings. There is ample seating and parking in the back but it can get packed in the restaurant. It is a great setting for large groups. Highly recommend! read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

Yum!!! Our family favorite. Family owned, lots of great pizza and pasta options. Service is always so friendly and helpful - even for big parties. Love the vibe. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Delicious pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

This place truly never disappoints. The pizza is consistently great! We had a margarita and their white with tomatoes. Both fantastic. The Greek salad is amazing and a staple in what we get every time we go. We also had their corn ravioli special which we wanted to lick the bowl clean (but refrained). Reminder this place is cash only and they do have a ATM on site! read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

Awesome cup and charred pizza! Great service too! One of the best pizzas I have had! read more

Sometimes it's very good sometimes not so much so. I only had the peaches several times. I never had any other food they offer.

Amazing atmosphere and tremendous pizza. Their sauce is so sweet and nothing like I've ever had before!! definitely going back very soon :)) read more

See all

Started off with a small Caesar salad, which was big enough to share. Very tasty. Our pizza was slightly over cooked as some of the pepperoni was well done. The other half had spinach which had almost no flavor. The place was busy with large parties so it did take a while to get our pizza. Our server was nice, refilled water glasses as needed. With low ceiling it made it difficult to hear one another. Strangely enough they ran out of pizza boxes for our leftovers. So they were layered on top of one another allowing the toppings, sauce and cheese to get every where - not the best way to package up leftovers. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Small Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

It's a different kind of pizza. Like a delicacy. It's the best if you want something light. There's pasta dishes that are also excellent.

Pizza is always amazing here but the fresh capellini with lump crab was the best dish! So much so that we forgot pictures. Hostess and waitresses are always attentive and love that they are BYOB! Make reservations when possible and remember that they are cash only. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Cup and Char Pepperoni with Hot Honey - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

The allure is better than the reality. I might be overstating my opinion, it's definitely not bad and it's a great experience. In house, the food is a much better experience. Friday night pizza at home thing maybe to so much. read more

The pizza is good. I Love their salad! Am I going to wait two hours for it good? No. Never again. My husband and I went there for dinner on a random weeknight. We both had a really busy and long day. We barely ate and were STARVING. We don't go out to eat much but the entire point was we didn't want to cook, we wanted something quick and close. To start we each got our own side salad to hold us over. I don't think a side anything would have been able to hold us over for this wait. We ordered one simple pizza, that it is it. That's all they do! It's their one job lol other than pasta. Well, we sat there and waited and waited .. so much waiting I even got to watch one table in the corner get served .. paid .. left .. another family came in and sat there. They too got served, paid ... left. Two turnarounds and still I wait for my one pizza. I looked around and watched other tables who came in way after us get served, holding their slices, taking bites, laughing .. I'm starving. I felt very singled out at this point and out of hunger and frustration could almost feel my eyes water. We only had the server stop by to refill our water. We were even told that our pizza "would be right out" but continued to wait another hour. I wish she would have been more attentive, I wish she would have refilled my salad not my water. I wish she would've said we are backed up and still may be a little while instead of telling me it's coming right out. I wish she would have done anything but ignore the one and only table not getting the one and only thing they make! Now yes there was a function in the private eating area but.. no excuse. TWO HOURs for a pizza . why did I have to watch the entire restaurant get served twice? If you can't balance both then don't do it. We tipped her off course cause we live in wild times where we reward people for doing nothing or the bare minimum. Did she deserve it ? No .. I had put my purse on and was ready to walk out when it finally came. We ate we were both miserable at this point. I got there at 6:20 and got home , which is up the street, at 8:30. We had other things to do that night but didn't get to any of it cause of the one single two hour pizza. I don't think I'll be back at least not anytime soon read more

If your style pizza is thin and crispy this is the place for you. I called around 6:30 and placed an order for pick up. I ordered a plain red pie and asked if they could have it ready for 7:20. The girl answering the phones was upbeat and friendly and had no issues making accommodations for me. They are cash only which I was notified over the phone when placing my order. I arrived at 7:19 to pick up my order and it came out of the oven pretty much right at 7:20. The pie looked beautiful. I thought it looked so good I sent pictures of it to a bunch of family and friends who all also thought it looked great. I wanted to look at it before I left the restaurant and I'm glad I did. It made me excited to arrive at my destination so I could eat. The sauce was a tad sweet for me but the thin and crispy texture of the crust was perfect. The price and value was extremely reasonable for the quality of the pie. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Red Pie / Plain - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Always the best place , always knows your name . Their pasta is amazing and salad also . O forgot to mention pizza best ever . Vince and Doris and young Vince keep up the good work . read more

The pizza is paper thin and delicious! The service was amazing - our server, Sophia, was so nice and personable! Giving 4 star review due to the long wait times for a table on a Thursday and it's a tad bit inconvenient that the restaurant is cash only! But truly a great spot, don't let those two factors hinder trying this local spot out! read more

We went for a celebratory dinner. Pizza was good which is a given since that's what they're known for. Their pasta was really good. The Calabrian chili pork ragu was excellent. Portions though were pretty small even for dinner portions? Three stars though because service was lacking. Our server was nice enough but there was an edge to her. Food was slow and two items were missing. The worst part was the forgotten food items were for the littlest ones so there was some crankiness amongst our guests that we felt badly about. The space is great though and it would be good for larger parties if service was better. We wanted to love it but my husband said he'd go back for the pasta. (No pics this time) read more

Wow! I knew about the Philadelphia location, and just learned about this one. In fact, my former neighbor is in the family. I'd never been to either location until last night. There was a small celebration in a private room. Very nice décor. 16 pizzas had to be ordered (for around only 30 guests) to book the room - interesting. I LOVE pizza, but how much could you possibly eat, especially with all of the other goodies being served? Their gnocchi was fantastic, and the sauce was delicious as well. (My dad even liked it and he doesn't even fancy gnocchi). Good bread, and everything else that I tried. I'm glad I finally got here; unfortunately, I live about a half hour away, and God knows when I'll be back. (Sorry - no pic - SO much going on). read more

We had such a nice dinner here the other night for a friends birthday! Service was super friendly and quick, and we really appreciated the honest recommendations from our server (everything she recommended was absolutely delicious). Three of us split the gnocchi gorgonzola and a plain pie with mushrooms. We probably could have used one more dish (another pasta or a salad) since there were three of us. Pricing was also super affordable! The gnocchi were decadent, and we loved the pancetta sprinkled on top of them. The pizza was flavorful and the crust was so perfectly thin and crunchy. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the area! read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

Wow! Even if you flunk out of culinary school you can still make a living. Ok we tried out this place for first time. Nice ambiance so we THOUGHT this might be a good place to eat. Hoo boy were we wrong. The VERY limited menu consisted of pasta dishes and pizza only. We ordered a signature white pizza and a plain pizza and a large salad. The salad was fresh but lacked enough dressing to actually taste flavored. The pizza was charcoaled like a burnt offering to a deity. The white pizza was actually brown and tasted like charcoal. The plain pizza was more like a hot tomato pie. The ONLY saving feature was the dessert. The dark side of the moon and the tartufu were delicious. Oh yes - this place is CASH ONLY. Now I know why. After eating here you would want a refund on your credit card. If you pass by and smell burning it's just them destroying another pizza. Don't call the fire department. read more

This is my favorite go to spot. Service is excellent. The atmosphere is great and they play my music!!! read more

See all

I heard it was national pizza day... checked out this pizzeria in the Maple Shade area of New Jersey with the #fam and #girlfriend. Upon walking in, very nice open kitchen, fresh dough being made, smelled so good! We ordered a couple of their pasta dishes, you can tell everything was made in house, huge portions, perfect for sharing, delicious! The pizza, if you're a fan of thin crust, oh my! The red sauce was so flavorful, perfect crisp on the crust, yum yum and yum! Bring your drinks, it's a byob, and service was amazing! read more

See all

Excellent white pizza with tomatoes and onions along with a house salad which was also very good. Pizza came as I ordered it. Salad had red peppers, cucumber onions mushrooms and the best dressing. read more

Why haven't I ordered from here earlier? This pizza is awesome. Perfect crust, nice variety of pizza types and toppings to choose from. Can takeout or eat-in. It's easy to order online. The pick-up time was the exact time my pizza was ready. They are known for their pastas and Gelato too. I'll have to get one of each next time. Huge parking lot behind restaurant to use for dining in our taking out. Tips for online ordering: 1. Garlic is Garlic Powder. There is no fresh garlic as a topping. 2. Well Done Crust is their "normal" preparation. You can get it undercooked so you can reheat at home or more well done to your desire. They only take reservations by phone. Don't bother placing an order by phone. It'll be quicker to do it online. I'll be back for sure! read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

Amazing! Pizza is fabulous and homemade pastas to die for. Super friendly staff and great service. One of our favorite places!

I love this place, specially for groups. The house salad is the way to go, plus pastas and the signature or the special with spicy sweet pepperoni. Bring a red and plenty of cash. YUM. read more

have you ever been somewhere where you want to go back the next day because that's how good it was?!?! i almost don't want to write this raving review because i want to GATE KEEP this incredible place but they deserve it the pizza here is perfect; thin and crispy with a great cheese to other ingredient ratio. but so is the handmade pasta! i had somewhat of an idea what i wanted to order but the server made recommendations and we went with them and i'm so glad we did! we started with the caesar salad, got some pizzas and pastas to share and honestly i wish my other friends werent there so i could eat everything by myself! PASTAS - ricotta cavatelli w/ their ragu - this was INSANELY amazing. the pasta is cooked perfectly, and the sauce is so simple but so much flavor. i'm craving this as i'm writing this - gemelli w/ vodka sauce - this was delicious as well but honestly the cavatelli stole the show for me PIZZA - Margherita, Marinara w/ sausage and something with proscuitto that i can't remember but they were all incredible! but the marinara was amazing BYOB & CASH ONLY and def make a reservation if you can! read more

See all

I was finally able to try this Tacconelli outpost! It's just as busy as the original so I suggest making a reservation, however you do not need to order your dough in the morning like the original. The pizza is delicious! We always order a plain pie. This one has a thin crust, slightly sweet sauce and a nice amount of cheese. It has a crunchy crust with some charring. The Margherita was also delicious. The fresh mozzarella and basil were so good. The spinach and tomato pie is a favorite! It has just the right amount of veggies and cheese. This location also has salad and dessert. We shared a salad. It had a good mixture of lettuce, tomato and cucumber. The balsamic vinaigrette was delicious. The gelato was yummy! Our waitress was so sweet! She gave us a sample of some of the gelatos so we could choose. Note: cash only It was a nice experience from beginning to end! read more

See all

Just awful. Wait was terrible, 5 minutes to get seated, 10 minutes before waitress came to our table, 40+ minute wait for pizza. Waitress stopped by once and got our drinks but forgot straw read more

Rating is for the pizza only. Crust is way too thin and since they char the pie, it comes out somewhat crackly and dry. Sauce was ok. Skimpy on the cheese, Not recommended read more

You offer "not well done", "well done" and "burnt" as options. Ordered this one not well done - it's burned to a crisp and completely dried out. The red "XCHZ" pie, ordered "well done", is completely black and barely has as much cheese as the white. Seriously, we'd have been better off with a mass produced chain or convenience store pie- at least we wouldn't risk breaking a tooth. Not even going to bother eating it. What a waste of time, effort and money. Thanks. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Burned to a crisp and completely dried up despite ordering *not well done*. Not even going to bother eating it. Thanks. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Amazing fresh pasta made in house. I had the gnocchi and the garganelle. They each have their own unique texture and flavors. Gnocchi is fluffy and the garganelle is springy. I will definitely come back to try other fresh pastas read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pasta menu changes seasonally. This is July 2024 - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

I have a pretty firm stance that really good pizza is hard to come by in South Jersey. Tacconelli's is one of the few pizzerias that is an exception to this. I visited their previous Moorestown location in what feels like a million years ago. Since then, I've eaten a lot of pizza and have come to think of myself as somewhat of a connoisseur. Although, I can't fully remember all the details of my first visit, I do remember enjoying the experience and most importantly the pie. Fast forward to a decade later and I find myself ordering from here with a friend that appreciates pizza almost as much as me. We tried their red/plain pie w/pepperoni - thin crust, flavorful red sauce and mozzarella w/roni cups (the good kind curl while cooking). It was fantastic. Recently, my friends and I caught wind that Dr. Brewlittle's Beer Co. opened nearby. Needless to say, we paid the brewery a visit and ordered from Tacconelli's which is just 2 blocks away - a combination that I highly recommend. This time we did a red pie w/pepperoni along with a margarita - both were exceptionally good and didn't last very along amongst the group. Looking back at my previous review, I complained about the prices being too high but 22 year old me has since learned that you pay for what you get. Tacconelli's prices are not high but they are not cheap. They are just where they need to be for high quality pizza made with love. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Hubs had been wanting to give this place a try for a while. We were really happy to find out that they have a location in NJ so we didn't have to travel to Philadelphia. We arrived right before the lunch hour rush and were immediately seated. The restaurant is large and vast, with the space seemingly going on for miles. The lighting is dim, almost in a romantic manner. Rows of lights dangle from the ceiling near the front of the restaurant and sconces adorn the rightmost wall. A long, continuous booth runs along the rightmost wall, while regular booths sit along the leftmost wall. There were regular tables with chairs sit in the center with one table being round. We ordered 2 pies: One with hot sausage and anchovies and the other one was a Margherita pie. Both pies were delicious. It was hot and the undercarriage was perfect! The pies were surprisingly quick. We enjoyed watching the owner making the pizza pies and putting it into the oven. Obviously, they perfected the technique! Almost forgot. The waitress asked us if we wanted some hots. I thought it came along with it since she asked. Nope, we got charged. Didn't matter. It was only 75 cents. The lunch crowd eventually came in and the place was busy! Service was friendly and quick. Will definitely return when in the area! read more

Cute little Pizzeria in Maple Shade. We came on a Saturday night - which was very busy! The wait wasn't too bad, considering the crowd. It's BYOB & cash only... FYI. We ordered the white cheddar Mac & Cheese for my son. It was on the watery side, but he still ate it. When we asked for napkins, our server came back with only 2 napkins and told us "it was all she could find". That was a first for me! The pizza was just ok. The ambiance is what got the four stars for me! Not sure if I'll be back or not. read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Plain Red Pie w/pepperoni & basil - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

The food here isn't that good. Judging by the photos of others, you can see that I'm not the only one here that feels this way. The Caesar salad wasn't that good. The pizza was very sloppy and wasn't made right. Prices are reasonable and service was ok but the other things were lacking read more

I haven't been to the Philly Tacconelli's location but recently met some friends at the newer Maple Shade location. The restaurant itself is very big and has several seating areas. We were given a table at the front of the restaurant overlooking Main Street. Our server was friendly and extremely attentive. We had no complaints as some other Yelpers had mentioned. The pizza itself was very good. We ordered two pies for four people, a regular and a formaggio white pie The Taconelli crust is thinner and crispy then most standard pizzas I have had in our area. We didn't add any toppings. I did really like the pizza but it wasn't an "oh wow" experience for me. It was very, very good but not great. For dessert, I ordered the Key Lime Cheesecake and that was excellent. It was not overly sweet and the Key Lime taste was just the right percentage. Definitely a fan of Tacconelli's but no more then that for now. 4 yelp stars read more

Tacconelli's Pizzeria - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

I think this might actually be the worst pizza I've ever had. I'm sure others would say it's "the style", and it was takeout which could possibly be the difference, but it seemed like just dry shriveled up triangle-shaped crackers. It hurt my mouth. read more

Easily the best pizza I have tried in the area and their fresh made pasta is also delicious! It's a whole vibe in there, it's byob-highly recommend. read more