Base my reviews off what you pay: *Place was half full for breakfast on a Sunday. Price - ~$25 (coffee, dish, tip) Food - 2/5 - pretty bland with ok portions Service - 3/5 - quick and on par. Ambiance - 3/5 - clean vibe. Overall - 3/5 - this place is ok for a breakfast stop. The food is pretty bland to be quite frank and they skimp out on portions (for what you pay). Home fries were pretty good though. Service was fine, quick and on par but no interaction. Inside is nice and clean, nothing remarkable. Ok spot in a pinch but there are better options. Best Dish - Home fries Would Return - Probably not read more

Delicious food and great service. They navigated my son's food allergy with ease. Portions were big. It is an old school place in Montauk. Great pancakes! read more

Great place for pancakes. Service is fast. Very busy place but tables turn fast. Great fresh OJ read more

Anthony's Pancake House - OJ - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

Well the French toast is define! Service is great. Sausage was cooked to perfection. Home fries were great! Hands down some of the best pancakes I've ever had. Pro-tips: -For "Scrambled eggs", specify how scrambled. -Don't sit outside on a hot day- the bees are out to get ya. read more

See all

Food was delicious and the portions weren't tremendous so if you're starving, throw in a side. In addition to indoor tables, they have ample outdoor seating and seating at the counter. The service was a little spotty due to how busy they are but they did have ample seating in and outdoor. read more

See all

Bad customer service. The host didn't greet us, pointed out our table instead of walking us there and the waitress was slow. The ambiance was nice and the food was mediocre. read more

Terrible customer service. Does not allow you to tip on a credit card, doesn't allow you to split the check on a two top. Owner doesn't know the meaning of good customer service read more

I have been going to Anthony's since I was little and it might have the greatest French toast ever.

Anthony's Pancake House, in the heart of Montauk's town center, was such a great spot for a lazy brunch on a rainy morning. (I felt like setting the scene, so bear with me, haha.) It was our first time there, and after settling into a cute spot by the window, we ordered the whole wheat blueberry pancakes, the Eggs Benedict, and sides of homefries and breakfast sausage. The pancakes were the STAR of the show, and I can definitely see why they are known for pancakes here. (I wasn't sure if the whole wheat would throw anything off, but it really exceeded our expectations with a delectably warm vanilla flavor and so many blueberries in every bite!) The Benedict, always a classic, definitely had a worthwhile hollandaise, and the sides were delicious as well! (I can certainly see why their homefries are 'famous.') Anthony's Pancake House was super satisfying, and I'm still dreaming of those pancakes... read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Whole Wheat Blueberry Pancakes, Eggs Benedict, Homefries, and Breakfast Sausage :) - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

I guess I thought that because I was in the Hamptons, brunch would be epic, but instead, it was just basic. The customer service was good and friendly. The hotel and driver both recommended this breakfast spot compared to the competition, John's Pancake House ( wow, they were so creative...lol), but if this was supposed to be the best, then I think a whole new standard for brunch needs to be created. I had the scrambled eggs with corn beef hash. I always ask if it is the canned corned beef with chunks of little potato look alike or real sliced beef with the home fries for hash. The wait staff said it was the can, but he swore it would be a cut above the rest. It was not. Smh... The hot chocolate came in a glass cup for style, but it defeated the purpose because my "hot" chocolate did not stay "hot"; it was lukewarm. Finally, my companion shared that their burger was just ok. So that about sums up our experience at Anthony's Pancake House. read more

See all

I took my granddaughter for a trip before she went off to college. We ate every morning at Anthony's Pancake House. The owner, Diana, was wonderful . Our waiter Danny was the BEST!!! The food was excellent and most importantly, it was one of the cleanest restaurants ever!!! Thank you so much for a great experience Grace N. read more

The service was good and the restaurant comfortable and clean. I ordered the eggs, pancakes and sausage. The eggs were fried perfectly and the sausage was delicious. The pancakes were dry, so not sure I would order that again. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Pancakes, eggs, and sausage - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

A much preferred venue and breakfast spot versus their competitor across the street. Establish is clean, modern, priced accordingly, friendly staff, great service. Parking in the rear or street parking if you can find it. Here off season (end of October) and was quite surprised to see how busy it got. Get there early to beat the rush. At time of visit - I believe credit cards were accepted but bring cash - there is an ATM in the back- next to one of the gender neutral restrooms. read more

See all

Breakfast was delish. Good service and atmosphere was easy going. 2 eggs bacon, ham and home fries were all tasty.

We went back to Montauk for a wedding after not having been there for quite a few years. Anthony's was one of our favorite breakfast places back in the day. So naturally we needed to go back... this time with our grown children and grandchildren. WELL, Anthony's did not disappoint. The restaurant has expanded obviously to accommodate the daily crowds. However the food, the service, the cheerful workers made us feel as if we never missed a beat! The breakfasts are incomparable to any other place in the east end. And although you may find a line to get in, the service is so good you will be seated before you know it. Please give it a try and OH buy one of their tee shirts..... a memoir for me :) read more

Visited for after-thanksgiving-breakfast with family. I like the surprisingly modern looking white interiors, and parking at the front (street) and the back (parking lot). We ordered French toast, Pancakes and Egg Benedict, which were all served well. Fresh fruits on top of the toast were a nice addition, and coffee/orange juice were above expectations. We were a bit frustrated when we found out tips should be paid by only cash. Had to trip to my car to find some. I understand there must be a reason, but it would have been great to be mindful that not many people carry cash nowadays. Other than that, it was a great cute place for breakfast during holidays. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - French toast, pancakes and egg Benedict - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Awesome breakfast spot in downtown Montauk! Definitely busy so give yourself extra time. We waited about 20 minutes on a Wednesday morning around 10 AM. Menu has tons of options with some healthy ones, I opted for probably the least healthy and got Oreo waffles with ice cream but it was so good I'm still thinking about it. Both my husband and son got pancakes and potatoes and said they were great. It is slightly less expensive if you pay with cash and you are not able to tip with a credit card. Fortunately they do have an ATM. Super cute and a must if you are in the area! read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

I don't get the negative reviews left on here. Went in on a Saturday morning, was seated immediately and pancakes were better than what I get at my normal place in Manhattan read more

Incredible breakfast, we came here 2 days in a row on our weekend trip to Montauk and both meals were absolutely delicious. Fast service. Cute dining area & a great brunch option. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - steak & eggs with hashbrowns & toast, and famous fluffy pancakes with fruit, scrambled eggs & sausage - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Absolutely fantastic end to our montauk trip! We stumbled upon this place and are so glad we did. All the food was delicious! The star of the show for me was the french toast! Great food, service and friendly staff! read more

Anthony's Pancake House - French toast, pancakes, omelet, home fries, and eggs and avocado toast - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

It's a classic casual American restaurant with pretty underwhelming food. I went for brunch on a busy weekend with some friends, and we were seated fairly quickly and the staff were nice, but the food was pretty mediocre and under seasoned for my taste. Also, trust the sign at the front. Yellow jackets were really swarming my friends and I while we waited to be sat. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

Busy breakfast spot downtown. We only waited a few minutes to be seated. Our server was friendly & prompt even though the place was full. Eggs Benedict was delicious with perfectly cooked eggs. The home fries were the tastiest I've ever had. Pricy, but I'd say worth it. Casual, quick service. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Eggs Benedict & Home fries - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

Though crowded, the service was impeccable. Our food arrived promptly and it was hot and delicious. I highly recommend the coconut pancakes as well as the eggs Benedict, fantastic!! Great breakfast spot in Montauk. Don't miss it. read more

Cute little diner in Montauk. We couldn't NOT have pancakes, so we ordered silver dollars for the table which was the perfect treat. The Eggs Benedict with spinach had a lovely hollandaise that was rich and delicious. Great iced coffee too. read more

Another great breakfast option in Montauk. Superior in some ways to other local pancakes houses, but inferior in others. The bathroom here is CLEAN. Service is quick, and the homefries are unusually good. Like almost all other places in Montauk, the coffee here is extremely good as well. Eggs Florentine here is high above average. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

We come to the Montauk Music Festival most every year and Anthony's remains our favorite spot for breakfast right in the center of the village near the main stage. Great menu selection and all well prepared. Very clean and comfortable establishment with responsive staff and friendly owner. Get there early as a waitlist quickly forms. read more

Really love this place to get some breakfast or brunch. Staff really helpful with orders. We went on this place twice in a week. From pancake, to waffle, to hash everything is just really good. Will 100% recommend this place. read more

Delicious breakfast with friendly service. Fresh squeezed OJ is fantastic. Pancakes are amazing. Always a must stop when in town.

Good location. Solid breakfast option with lots of classic choices, eg eggs, pancakes. It's kind of like a fancy diner. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Service is prompt and attentive. read more

Came here 2 days in a row, honestly best breakfast food I've ever had. Service is super fast and all the staff is so nice. Food is incredible read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Eggs Benedict with lox - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Nice, modern little luncheonette with a cozy vibe. Some of the breakfast options are on the pricier side, but I was craving an omelette so decided to give it a try. Service was decent and the place looked clean and well-kept. The coffee was excellent -- definitely a highlight! I ordered the broccoli and mozzarella omelette, which was tasty, though I was a bit surprised that sides like home fries weren't included and had to be ordered à la carte. read more

We wanted a good breakfast, and were getting a late start. We ended up stopping at Anthony's Pancake House on our way to explore. It was a great choice! We were almost exactly between the breakast rush, and the start of the lunch crowd. Our server was attentive and very nice. He was very kind and chatty with a couple of tables who looked like regulars. The waitstaff seemed to really work as a team and were all attentive. We ordered Corned Beef Hash with toast and egg, and then French Toast with a scrambled egg. The corned beef hash was quite tasty, and the french toast was perfectly done. At first, looking at the French Toast, I was afraid it would dry, but instead it was so tender and tasty, sprinkled with cinnamon, and then drizzled lightly with syrup, it was awesome. The coffee was also enjoyable. I wish I had taken photos, it was a delight. read more

I love Anthony's Pancake House! The owner/staff are so attentive and they really take care of their customers. The food has all the hits. The pancakes are my favorite but you can't go wrong with anything else on the menu. Highly recommended Montauk spot to hit when you are there! read more

Not what you remember. Way over priced for crap!!! They scrimp on everything. Avocado toast with tomatoes was vile and avocado only on one slice. Bagel store down the road is so much better and prices better. read more

Out here on vacation and wanted a breakfast spot to go to. This location is cute and the food is good. The only thing lacking is the service overalll. I just feel like I really didn't see the waitress. I understand it's busy but still it would be nice to see them besides just ordering our food! I got the country fried steak and it was super yummy! Everything about that meal was great. It came with biscuits, hasbrowns, eggs and apparently Toast but they forgot my toast which is unfortunate. I'm not complaining though. My brother ordered the chicken tenders and they were great he said compared to the crappy chicken tenders we had yesterday. Overall the food is great but I would have to say I felt a lacking in the staffs aspect. Thanks for a great meal. read more

See all

This place seemed packed every time we drove past it but I get the hype now! Seriously every bite tasted like heaven in my mouth. Some of the best breakfast food I've had and quick af service considering how busy it was. The ideal place to take a family, too. My partner and I will rave about this spot every time the topic of Montauk comes up! read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Very nice. Food was good, smallish portions, service was slow but it was summer. Ambiance okay.

This place is a dump. The front end is rude. The food is terrible. How can you screw up breakfast.

This place has been reborn! We haven't been to Anthony's in quite a few years (or John's), but figured we give it a whirl. WOW! It has been totally redone on the inside, and looks brand new (not sure if it was done recently or a few years ago). Anyway, very nautical in decor, but like an upscale cruise, not to much, and classy shiplap all around. Super clean. Super friendly staff. Large earring area plus huge counter and outside too. Endless coffee. Event a few GF options! Food was very good! The BIG breakfast was BIG. The bacon was crisp. I ordered my standard of poached eggs and home fries and the poach was perfect, which is an art. Not that it's a competition, but beats John's Pancakes by several nautical miles. read more

Anthony's Pancake House - Poached eggs atop a mound of home fries. GF bagel - Waffles Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Super cute find. I'm not gonna lie, I picked this p li ace because it's my sons name and the choice was a good one. I'm not a breakfast person so I rely on my families choice of breakfast and I usually get lunch. The staff were very attentive and so friendly. The food is the typical diner type of food but so good. I love finding little diners that offer yummy comforting food and this place is one of them! read more

See all