For a chain, the food at Anthony's is always pretty solid. We like the garlic parm wings, pepperoni pizza with hot honey, and their caesar salad (would love to know what dressing they use, it's an especially flavorful Caesar). We get delivery from here fairly often and it's always been ready on time. Our only complaint is that it's over $35 for a pizza which seems steep compared to other pizza places in the area. read more

Stop by for a quick bite,salad is always fresh,chicken wings are a must,had the stuff pepper ,of course the Pizza ,always well done .The staff was super attentive You can never go wrong with Anthony's Coal fire pizza read more

To the owner . Someone name Kranze left a review saying the sauce was not seasoned enough. Sauce is why I come here, never garlicky or overwhelmed with seasoning. Keep this fabulous sauce just as it is , coming from a true Italian read more

Been here atleast 10x. Always a good go to stop for delicious pizza. Salad, wings and meatball ricotta are a must. Service was good, we had a larger party of 8 and didn't need a reservation, easily accommodated us for 4pm dinner! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Food here is always okay, but today the service was so bad... well it was awful. Wasn't that busy so that's not an excuse. Took the 1st 15 or so to be acknowledged, then another 20 to get a soup and salad, then another 20 to get wings. Ordered 20 wings and only got 10. Found that the servers today were very disengaged. Had to ask about refills for drinks and the easy miss was asking for very well done wings, which where just as the come as usual. We come here often but this, just scratching the surface, just the service, not just sub-par but zero par. A big -EH. Not to mention the time it took just to get a check, then get it re-done to reflect what we got, but not what we ordered. read more

See all

Food is really good, I have a couple go to dishes, never disappoint... nice setting, friendly service!

Went there for dinner a few nights ago. Wings were good. The garden salad: while I like vinegar on my salad, this one was swimming in it. The pizza: I'm a big fan of San Marzano tomatoes but the sauce was only that. No seasonings; just tomato sauce from a can. And the crust was gummy. Pretty disappointing. What happened to the cooking here? read more

Went for lunch and they have a nice lunch menu. We had a plain personal pie. The crust was very good but not a fan of the splotches is sauce. I asked hew big is the small meatball sandwich compared to the large. Waitress could not tell us. The sandwich is a 10" pizza crust folded over. Not much cheese and hard to eat. Not sure I'm going back. read more

See all

I don't eat pizza because of a tomato allergy but my son loves pizza so a group of us went for dinner. There was ample parking in the parking lot. They had indoor and outdoor dining. The outdoor dining had heaters as it was a bit chilly that evening. The indoor had a large bar which allowed patrons to not only drink but eat and watch television. The location had televisions strategically placed to watch various games. The walls had photos of past patrons which is always a nice touch. I had the dry rub chicken wing, Caesar salad and the garlic knots. The dry rub chicken wing was delicious it was juicy, Smokey and seasoned just right. The serving size was perfect I got 10 wings which was great for me. Wings come in sizes of 5,10 or 20 and are topped with fresh parsley and served with focaccia bread. The garlic knots are topped with fresh garlic and parsley, olive oil and hand-grated Pecorino Romano. My son and his friends loved the pizza and have eaten at various locations over the years. The service was outstanding from our entry to our departure. The servers, hostess and owner were helpful with seating time to be seated and questions about the menu. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

The service is good. I've been a couple of times now. The pizza is not great but I like the wings. Unfortunately mine were undercooked. The waitress took them back to the kitchen and they remade them. The knots came in a pool of oil. While I usually go for the wings and the staff is nice the quality of the food isn't good enough for me to return. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Brendan is the best server I've ever had, he is so attentive and very on top of everything very friendly and warm. Love coming here with my family to see Brendan!!! read more

Food was awesome but they didn't tell me that only the bar gets happy hour prices. And there was limited seating so none available. So when I pointed at the happy hour sign and ordered the meatballs and then later pointed and said I would like to try the wings. I feel as the server they should have told me that rule when I ordered so I paid full price for what I thought was gonna be a great deal. So buyer be ware here read more

I have been going back since my first review and it needed to be updated based on performance which is what counts. Pizza done well, not burnt, attentive and friendly service. Always a good experience. Thanks for fixing the burnt pizza problem. read more

Sunday pizza stop! First time here and it is has a lively bar and casual dining area. Tried variety of pizzas, salads, white & red sangrias. You can't go wrong here. Pizza is thin and crispy! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

I got my food to-go. I always used to order the meatball and ricotta pizza whenever I used to eat at the restaurant, so of course I stuck with my usual and got it again. It was yummy as always! This time I also ordered the garlic knots. The garlic knots were ginormous!! I've never had garlic knots with this much garlic on them but they were great as well. Next time I need to get their chicken wings as I definitely missed not having them. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Meatball & Ricotta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Have been coming here for years- the staff turnsover seasonally but the manager has been here for years. Good selection of local breweries- Brix-Sloop Juice-Kane/Defiant and enough mixed drinks for non beer drinkers. The last two times we had a blonde Ciera and then a blue haired Ciera. She was a little new our first trip but today after some more experience and training you could tell she had the confidence and demeanor to be a top server here. Both times she was energetic, attentive, friendly and In a good mood- you never feel as if you are bothering here. The italian salad is excellent and your dressing is our favorite. We love the Italian long hots on the pizza- lately they have been duds but more the time of year than anything. Keep the holiday gift card promo's- we look forward to them. read more

Have never had a bad meal here. The pasta fuzzle is only one item is absolutely wonderful. All food and service is outstanding.

I have a rule of thumb: "If the restaurant looks too nice, then the food is crap" Boy was I proven right again. First of all, for what it is, it's too expensive. The margherita pizza is bland and is not worth what it is. The wings... the BBQ is basic and salty and the dry rub ones... those are just plain disgusting. The dry rub has some cinnamon and other spices that don't belong on wings; it almost tastes like someone just discovered seasoning and started experimenting with it. The garlic knots... again super bland, dry, and just unappealing. Save yourself from this place and just order Papa Johns, this place doesn't know what it's doing. Also, forgot to mention, the AI ordering is awful. read more

Anytime I'm shopping in the area I always have to order from here. They have the best fire roasted wings and pizza is amazing. They never disappoint always hot and fresh. read more

See all

We stopped by this place by accident and we were delighted with the quality of wings and their thin crusted pizza. They donhave a small bar and a few T.V.s fornthe sports fans. I will definitely stop by again. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Love this spot! always our go-to ...and now some new favorite items on the menu! burrata and proscciutto spaghetti was awesome, great new shrimp and of course their coal fired wings are amazing! Stop in or order on line- you won't be disappointed! read more

Came for late dinner While our squared margherita pizza pie. Dirty martinis were so delicious!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Dirty martini - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Staff was excellent. On top of everything the whole meal. Food was good as well. And the prices were damn good too. Overall a darn good meal. read more

First time at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza and Eggplant Marino pizza was very good. The imported Italian Plum Tomatoes were cooked perfectly and fresh The eggplant sliced thin and the crust was crisp. A visit in the future is certain. read more

Stopped in yesterday on the way home from New York City. Was looking for a good pizza place not far from Route 17. This place was a jackpot. The pizza was fresh thin and very tasty. All the ingredients were very fresh. The lemonade was fantastic and both my son and myself Were very happy with the meal. Service was prompt and very friendly. We will go here again. read more

How can you be named for your wings and your wings look like this? These were the worst wings I've ever had. Just gross. read more

See all

I go to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza at least once a week. The food and service is exceptional. Tina the bartender is excellent. When we walk in she always has our drink ready for us. Kudos to TINA the smiling bubbly bartender. Kim DeFelice read more

Really enjoy this location for the extra crispy pizza, wings and beverages when that is what we are craving and looking for a good solid chain. When we aren't dining in, the curbside pickup is ideal. The space is large and can get loud. In the warmer months they open up the space to have an indoor outdoor bar area/seating. It gets super crowded for that exact reason over the warmer months so be prepared to wait if you're looking to hang outside on a Thursday or Friday night... Big after work happy hour crowd. I just love a good dirty martini with blue cheese stuffed olives and I'm often able to score one here. Plenty of beers on tap if that is the direction you are going in. For pizzas our go to are the broccoli rabe sausage pie and meatball ricotta pie. As with any Anthony coal fired, the crust has a burnt flavor and the toppings are savory and plentiful. Their chicken wings aren't your normal bar wing. They aren't smothered in sauce or served buffalo style. Instead just nice and crispy smothered in sautéed onions and served with focaccia bread. So unique we keep coming back for them. read more

The bartender could not maje a drink due to lack of ingredients i ordered food from a waitress and some slop guy comes out with his hairy thumbs in my plate and when I asked him where my waitress was he said that I should be happy I'm getting my food and to top it off he was training a new waitress I paid tipped and left Never go there read more

what happened to this incredible restaurant. What happened to the incredible fresh pizzas, the eggplant, the service? So sorry to watch it go down in Pinecrest. read more

So good I didn't realize it was a chain. Crowded but quick quality service. Classic thin east coast pizza. Beautiful crisp burnt edges. Really tasty pie. Good beer selection. Tasty house red ale worth ordering. Defies the chain stereotype. read more

First and last time ordering a pizza. Can only order on the website ordered half mushroom half pepperoni it was disgusting as eating pure salt for $36.04 including tip burnt thin pizza they need to learn how to make sauce not salt. Requesting a refund. read more

This restaurant is the best hands down. A casual go to for relatively inexpensive pizza, wings and salads. Wine, liquor and soft drinks all at very low prices. read more

We just had a Sunday lunch here. I haven't been here for about 6 months, but it's always been great. It's always had great pizza, super wings, lively bar scene, and all around, a great dining experience. Now, very bad. We sat down, the waiter was good and attentive, but the place was dirty. There was garbage under our table, which I picked up and placed on the next table to be cleared away, which took 45 minutes to be cleared. Meanwhile, two tables away, it was cleared but it still had bits of straw wrappers and garbage on it, it took an hour for that to happen, meanwhile, in the other direction towards the bar, a high top had a wadded napkin and many chunks of what looked like sausage that had been dropped off the pizza on the floor, not under the table, but right almost in the traffic area. That mess was never swept despite the numerous waiters and bar staff walking by numerous times.I had even mentioned the mess to our waiter and he couldn't understand what I was talking about. Aside from the sloppy and messy dining area, the salad we shared was great as always but the pizza was HORRIBLE. This place is famous for well done pizza and so we got a pizza that was almost raw, with a doughy feel and flavor. Where is management and why do these hard working people have no guidance? Sad to see such a great place go do downhill. It also looked like the staff didn't want to bother with the dirtiness and simply didn't care. In that case, poor morale. I blame management and at this rate, they will all be out of a job soon. I will come back if I hear it improves. Good luck! read more

We are fans if their cauliflower pizza and wings. The pizza tastes better when eaten at the restaurant! Try to go off hours, less crowds! The wings are awesome.if you prefer take out, reheat in a hot oven for 5 minutes. read more

Delicious pizza! I was in the area for training for work and this place was located close to the hotel I was staying at, making it a convenient spot. I ordered a margherita pizza and italian salad. The food was great and enough that I was able to eat it for lunch the next day. The place has tables outside too which is great if you prefer to dine outside and enjoy the sun Also, the service is great! The staff there is so nice and recognized me when I came to pick up the order. Very hospitable! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

It's ok food and the service is very curteous but they need to tell their customers who are gluten free the price of pizza is $10 more. I told the waiter that I need a gluten free pizza but he didn't say it would go from $15 to $25 for gluten free version. That's just too over the top of an extra charge because I can go to another restaurant that only charges $10 for their gluten free cheese personal pizza. read more

We love going to Anthonys!!! Tina the bartender and her contagious laugh is what makes the night. She is the best. The whole crew never disappoints ...food is great, service is great!!! ALWAYS A GREAT TIME WHEN THERE!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza is a great place to go. Food and service are exceptional. Bartenders are very attentive Tina is the best. Drinks are ready as soon as we walk through door. The outdoor seating is great. You always run into someone you know there. The staff is great. They are always smiling. read more

The cauliflower pizza is incredible. Just thinking about it makes my mouth water. I wish there was one in Brooklyn. But when I visit my sister in East Hills it's one of my favorite places to get a casual meal. My family also loves the meatballs and chicken wings but since I don't eat meat I didn't taste them. Although they were devoured by my family. The only thing from keeping him from being five stars was the wait time. read more