I have been to this store several times over the last ten years. The first time it was an amazing experience. Unique import goods, a rental system which even then was starting to be rare; though I didn't live downtown so it was somewhat useless to me, and the widest selection of English language manga possible outside of a convention experience.
However, every subsequent visit, I am sad to say the common complaints and rumours surrounding this establishment became increasingly visible and frustrating. Every so often, on a slow day, there will be a friendly temporary or part time cashier, any other time it seems like a miserable workplace with part time staff seemingly afraid to make it clear they work there; heads down, never addressing customers, and doing menial tasks. I have had a few "main" cashiers, and very rarely are they anything but rude, and at worst can be condescending and give preferential treatment to some customers seemingly arbitrarily.
On a recent visit, my friends and I were passive aggressively asked if we needed help with anything. We replied no, and said we were just looking around. A few minutes later we were asked again, and we replied that we were fine. We were then told that they had a "pretty strict no loitering policy on the weekends." Fair enough I suppose, but we mentioned how we were looking for a present, and thus it wasn't a specific objective kind of shopping trip. Hearing that, there was some unintelligible grumbles or some sort of response that made it clear he was frustrated with our presence but didn't know how to respond. Now, believe it or not, this I can understand to a degree based on the size of the store; but at this time it was by no means bustling. So, my friends and I continued our search, just at an increased pace. A few minutes later, I heard him tell some other customers the same "no loitering" message, and at first was a bit relieved that it wasn't just us that he was singling out.
However, just a few minutes later, some customers who I suppose were looking at some higher priced items and had been there about as long as we were, were asked if they needed any help. They said no; but this time, instead of a message about loitering, they were told "Okay great, take your time."
It was that "take your time" which hurt, and made me decide to write this review. I don't know if he knew those customers and thus they were trusted, or if it was the fact they were looking at higher priced items, but the fact that they didn't once get told the same thing two separate groups of other customers were told just minutes prior really rubbed me the wrong way. Again, I don't know if it was an issue of trusted customers, or elitism, or what, but it's not how one should conduct themselves as an owner/employee.
I don't mind the bag policy personally, I think for this type of store it's acceptable, and kind of expected at any comic book store of a certain size. It has a lot of blind spots, and is neither large enough to be able to have a good overall view of the store, nor small enough to be able to keep tabs on everyone and everything going on. However, perhaps instead of being scared about loitering on the weekends when it comes to certain customers, the staff could be there to help and ask customers for help in a non-passive aggressive way, watch for shoplifters, or address issues of actual loitering instead of normal shopping behaviour. Maybe a camera system could also help, but I know it may be too much of a cost for a small-ish store like this.
The selection is good, and better than you'll find "in person" in Toronto when it comes to specifically Japanese character goods. I wouldn't call any of their prices overpriced to a large extent. They seem "tough but fair" when you factor in the convenience and experience of shopping in an "anime store."
If customer service and price don't matter to you, and you want a large selection and the experience of shopping at a store catering mostly to anime and manga, then you'll probably actually have a pretty good time at this store. Outside of a convention it's the only place in the area that can provide what it offers.
However, if pleasant staff and good prices are what you're after and you don't want to shop online, I recommend waiting for a convention, or shopping around at any of the general comic book stores in the city. The selection won't be as good if you're looking for specifically anime/manga goods, but you probably won't be urged to write a negative review based on your increasingly negative experiences over the years. read more