Angelo's was recommended to us after we complained to a friend about how disappointed we were at a different Italian restaurant. Angelo's is a small restaurant but man is it big on flavor! We opted for pizza and loved it. We'll be back to try the pasta and salads soon! The service was friendly and the place was filled with regulars... always a great sign! read more

After debating whether we should order a medium sized pizza or a large, we made a huge mistake and ordered the medium, which was still a pretty significant size. But it was so delicious we ate the entire pizza almost instantly. Angelo's oven cooked the pepperoni pizza quickly and perfectly, with those big bubbles of pizza crust that are so good that you eat the entire piece including the crunchy but easy to chew 'bones'. Feeling pretty stuffed, we both agreed it was actually better than wood fired. Will probably return tomorrow for the onion, green pepper, sausage topped large version. read more

The side salad and cheese steak sandwich was amazing! The service was fantastic. Well worth the visit. read more

Well I want to leave a raving review because the pizza was very good.... but when your told it's a 45min wait and it turns into 1hr and 20 minutes your attitude towards the experience changes. Yes it's dang good pizza, but before I order from here again I'm gonna consider if I want to wait that long again. Anyway I hope your experience differs from mine and it's a 5 Star meal. read more

Angelo's Downtown Pizza - pepperoni, sausage, and onions - Pizza Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

A cute little place in downtown Hayesville. Service was great and we really liked the food. Absolutely loved the cheesy breadsticks! Have been there a couple of times and we intend to make it a regular stop. read more

Pizza is excellent and salads are the best. Always great food and excellent service every time we've been there

Delicous! We ordered take out for five people and everyone was happy. Food was fresh and well cooked.

The BEST pizza in town. We have eaten here for years. Perfect place to pick up a pizza to go or dine in.

Great food, service and staff! We had the Stromboli and the Eggplant with Spaghetti, it was delicious! We can't wait to return! We took it to go due to a burst pipe, such bad timing on the pipes part but it was delicious for dinner! Highly recommend you give it a try! read more

Great Stromboli!! Order ahead for pickup or to eat at the restaurant. Staff is friendly!

Yum! Pizza is great! We had pepperoni and pineapple, sauce is excellent and the crust is nice and crisp. Great pizza.

Really good pie. This area has a lot of pizza places, but nobody quite gets it right. This is the best around, but still not quite 5 star pozza. read more

Best NY style pizza in the south. The house special is always a must. Having grown up in upstate New York with authentic Cicilian and Italian restaurants their food holds true! The noisy and hot atmosphere are also authentic to the northern pizzerias. We rarely eat in because we live so close. So I can't really speak for the dining experience but the food is amazing. read more

I read the reviews, many which were bad. So I kinda never gave this place a chance. One day I was in downtown Hayesville, and I craved a cheesesteak, so I stopped in. It was actually pretty darn good. I'm from the Philly area originally, so I occasionally crave a cheesesteak or Italian sub, so I stopped in last week and tried their sub. It too was pretty good. While waiting I saw a few pizzas go out, and they looked really good too....that'll be my next visit. They do tend to take a while, but I'm happy to wait a few extra minutes for good food. read more

Consistently excellent pizza, calzone, stromboli and salads. By far the best in this area.

The food is great, but the staff is not wearing masks or taking any safety measures during the pandemic. I will return for the pizza, but only after the pandemic. read more

This place is excellent!! Everything is freshly made and always taste great!! They now except credit cards which is a plus for everyone. It is a family owned and operated which is so nice!! They are great people !!! Stop by and see them if your in town! read more

This place is by far the worst Pizza Joint I have ever been into a my entire life. I ordered a large pizza and ask for green olives on half of it they never even bothered to put it on the pizza and proceeded to bring me a green olives on the side which was ice cold. We ask for a side of ranch which was nothing more than a tablespoon and then wanted to charge me $1.00 for it I would never go here again even if it was free fuck this place. * update* one of their employees contacted me. Such an outstanding employee. read more

Angelo's Downtown Pizza - This is the outcome of negative reviews by employees - Pizza Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Delicious, handmade pizza in a vintage pizzeria. Great customer service and wide variety of pizza toppings available.

After four visits here I have come to the conclusion that if you like pizza with toppings this is not the place for you. For 12.00 you will get the best cheese pizza you have ever eaten. For 18.00 you get a pizza with very few toppings couple of onion slivers, a few chunks of meat. That six dollars should add some extras. Not just make the customer laugh at how little they put on. If they would throw some toppings on their House pizza, that thing would be amazing! It would blow away a Mellow Mushroom pizza. They absolutely make a perfect crust. This place makes a good pizza, but who doesn't? read more

Not sure why this local is getting beat up on reviews but the salad I had today was fantastic, get the house Italian dressing. Really very good. Had the big Hawaiian pizza 8 in size and really enjoyed it as well. The place does not skimp on toppings for sure. Great lunch. Thanks Now, let's work on the credit card acceptance though. Pure luck I actually had cash today. read more

Angelo's Downtown Pizza - a plate of salad with onions and pickles - Pizza Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Great pizza and the rest of the menu is great as well. I would highly recommend when in Hayesville !

Most authentic pizza I've had in a long time! It's as good as pizza on the boardwalk in seaside Heights, NJ!

Pretty good Italian food! We ordered the pizza and lasagna. Just wish they wore masks. Friendly staff and they often have homemade goodies in the front. Surprisingly good for the area! Will be back when we want Italian or good pizza. Not necessarily homemade Italian, but if you want a certain dish and are in the area this hits the spot. Wish certain things were a little higher quality, like the garlic bread, but it is good for the price. read more

Ordered 2 large pizzas to go. They were ready in the 25 min they told me. I ordered pepp with extra cheese. I asked if I should get extra pepp and she said it had plenty. I beg to differ. The pizza did not have much flavor because not many pepperoni. If that was extra cheese would hate to see regular cheese. The sausage onion had a little more flavor but also lacking double cheese. $49 and a bit disappointed. read more

The pizza here is really tasty, and the location is excellent. If you are downtown then stop by! :)

We ordered the veggie pizza and while it took a while to get to our table, after we took a bite we didn't mind the wait. It was packed with veggies and so cheesy. Enjoyed our lunch here while visiting Hayesville. read more

Great pizza in downtown Hayesville. I got two slices for lunch and they were giant, thin crispy crust, good toppings. Later had a meatball sub that was very good. Outdoor table is dog friendly and staff very attentive and helpful read more

Their food is very good and fresh and authentic I have to give them credit there. Best I have ever eaten. My issue is their absurd business practices. It's a pizza/Italian restaurant and they close at 7:30 on Friday and Saturday night?!! Just ridiculous and even worse is the last order for takeout is 7:00. That is extremely early to be shutting down! Next issue is no credit cards cash only. Who the hell doesn't take credit cards at a restaurant in today's world? When asked they said because it cost money. DUH!!!!! This makes no sense and not everybody has an extra $50 on them at the last moment when they decide to eat there or get to go. So have to go to an ATM first, again, blah blah blah.. I can't EVEN begin to tell you how much money they have lost from me alone because if it's 6:30 on a Friday and I decide to get something to eat there because I love their food, its either already too late or I don't happen to have cash on me! When you close at 7:30, that means it has to be around SIX O'CLOCK for you to decide if you want to drive there and go out to eat. Cuz if it's 630 or later, and you decide to go you still don't even bother, because by the time you get there and sit down it's 7:00. And if you have to stop at an ATM machine on the way you can absolutely forget it!! You just don't go. Even if everything happens to fall perfectly in line and you make it, guess what? Now you have that rush rush situation going on cuz you KNOW they are closing and you have to hurry up and eat. In other words, it's a big joke... I don't know many people who are pre-planning what they're going to eat an hour and a half later as most people who order pizza are doing so at the last minute. Closing at 7:30 means you need to be sitting down by 630. You need to stop by an ATM that means you're planning at 6 o'clock and if they don't think things out like that they are just crazy!! read more

Really good pizza. Got the House Special pizza. Very tasty, with a great crunch to the crust, not soggy with fresh topping and great service. read more

Angelo's Downtown Pizza - House Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Best Pizza in town! My entire family loves Angelo's. Family owned and operated. Nice people! read more

Horrible service. Waited an hour and a half for pizza we called in that they said would be ready in 45 minutes, and then the cashier started laughing and talking rudely about us where we could hear. She was standing there laughing, while in the kitchen, pulling her hair out of a ponytail, and shaking her hair everywhere. We asked to speak to a manager, who was completely useless and the whole time the cashier was standing there laughing. Worst customer service ever. The only redeemable quality is that their pizza and breadsticks are delicious. read more

I am just finishing lunch with my lady we had to slice Pizza from each had a Hawaiian and how special and to have all fresh toppings and a good cheese and a nice crust on it this is New York pizza don't go anywhere else. read more

Simply the best italian food . Pizza is excellent , lasagna is to die for. prices are fair also. definitely will be back read more

Great place to eat, right on the square. Waitresses are very nice and attentive. Cheap prices for quality food. Wish I could go everyday!

Best pizza in town and wonderful customer service. Absolutely love the subs (especially the italian combo sub). The pizza is to die for and the environment is perfect for a pizza joint. conveniently located read more

Best Pizza in Hayesville and may be the best cheesesteak I have ever had. Friendly staff and pretty quick. I do wish they were open a little bit later and on Sundays. read more

Watched the staff jump all over a customer today because they told them their pizza was not prepared as they asked. This made me sick to my stomach. I had a hard time finishing my lunch after watching this. Absolutely no customer service. Even if they did order what they got this is certainly no way to handle a customer complaint. I typically eat from this place at least once a week for lunch. No longer will that be the case. So not only did they lose the customer they told to get the hell out to but 5 more that we're in the place too. Can't tell you how disappointed I am with this place. read more

I have been coming to this area for many years. Originally from NYC lived out west since early 70's my wife and I made Clay County our home 5 years ago. This place by far has the best Pizza in the area. read more

Dear food critic, This is a response to Deborah S. Review. I am the server that waited on this table and I would like to get a few facts straight. First our sub's are all toasted and this is stated on the menu in large bright lettering. That is why I do not ask if they need the sub toasted or not. As for our menus being tacky, not sure where that is coming from, our menus are actually quite nice, compared to a lot of restaurants. I have never seen stale pretzels ever served with any meal. We serve fresh foods! We have however switched from pretzels and are now serving optional bag chips with our sub meals now. Our menus do not contain descriptions of every little detail but this has never been a problem before if you have any questions, just ask we are always happy to answer any questions. As for the real kicker... We make our food fresh to order so it takes about 15 minute's to cook a Calzone, which is something that is also on the menu. When this diner came in it was a very busy day so her wait was 5 minutes longer the usual. She was also apologized to for her 5 minute longer wait. As for the calzone its self the cheese she was unsure about was ricotta cheese, which she was warned about before ordering. Calzones come with our homemade marinara sauce on the side. Calzones are not supposed to get pizza sauce inside. The order was for a mushroom and sausage calzone, I have never had a complaint about the amount of toppings put inside, we sell quality food. The calzone is also one of our most popular meals. When this customer complained about her food it was over halfway eaten and she wanted her meal for free. I am sorry but this is a business not a free food give away. My response was defiantly not "what do you want me to do about it" it was "I am sorry you did not enjoy your meal but because you have eaten the meal you are still responsible for the check. I also told you that it had ricotta cheese, if you do not like ricotta cheese we have a Stromboli that just contains mozzarella cheese and toppings of your choice" she refused the Stromboli, insisting on a calzone. As for her complaints about the check, our diners pay up at the front counter before leaving, which I told her was the case. She was not the one to pay the bill anyway, her mother was and she understood how it worked and also apologized to me for her daughters rude behavior and left a generous tip to make up for her daughters behavior. I would also like to clarify that I am not the only server, manager or owners daughter. We are a family owned business, therefore it is all family members that work here. I am the current owners wife, my husband is the son of the previous owners. We have been in business for 12 years, I have been here for 6 of those years and never have I had a customer like this. I have lived in Hayesville for 14 years and I have never been told that I was rude or seen someone quite like this critic before and I hope not to see her again. As for the other table she spoke to, I do not believe this because every table around her are regulars of mine, who I see multiple times a week. I am sorry that this critic feels this way about our business because we are a very friendly establishment that serves fantastic food. We also have a very clean and well decorated restaurant. I have been told this by many of our regular customers. I hope that this one misunderstood critic does not turn anyone away because her statement is not at all correct. This is unfortunately one of those few people who are not happy with anything. read more