Our absolute favorite Mexican restaurant. We even had our Valentine's Day fajitas here! We moved to Hayesville at the end of January and have been here numerous times and the food is always fresh hot and tasty. The chips are so light and the salsa is the right flavor. The guacamole is also great! The service is great and the place is nicely decorated. read more

Anejo - Beef stuffed pepper rice and beans there is also a taco included in the meal just not in picture. - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

See all

We really enjoyed our meal at Anejo today! Everything was delicious and they have a wonderful atmosphere. Our service was top notch as well. True authentic Mexican food! Check it out;) read more

Easy review to write, and I'll get 'right' to the point. BEST Mexican restaurant I've visited in ages. That speaks volumes because I get around! Our party of four ordered a nice variety of menu items so it was fun sampling them. Everything was excellent! Great flavors to savor. Great atmosphere. GREAT service! Our attentive server was Kelsey. She completed the Anejo experience! Thank you! read more

See all

We stopped in at Anejo for the first time, because we love Mexican food and trying new restaurants. Having been to dozens of this style of restaurant, I would say overall that it was average - not bad, but nothing impressive either. The chairs are really cool and decorative and the dining area and bathrooms are clean. The service was good and the food was pretty typical. My husband ordered the fajitas, and they did NOT come out fresh and sizzling - they were room temperature at best and there was very little meat. The kids meals, on the other hand, were huge! It was the first time my 10-year-old couldn't finish her kids meal plate. My lunch special was pretty yummy - grilled chicken and shrimp with beans, rice, and a generous sized guacamole salad. If you live in this town or are visiting and have a hankering for Mexican food, by all means, stop in! But if another Mexican place sets up shop in town, they may have to step up their game a bit to not lose business. read more

See all

Went there last night with three friends. We were there about four hours chatting it up till they closed. Our server was Dustin, FANTASTIC service by him!!!! Very friendly, efficient, and courteous!! He would be my go-to person when we go again. Food was very good, prices really reasonable, and again, awesome awesome service!!! It was my first time there. Would I go again, absolutely! Highly recommend this place! Will be going again! read more

Went here when staying in shooting creek about 20 minutes away. We had no idea what to eat and decided on mexican and ended up at anejo . First impression is definitely a mexican restaurant, which i loved the authentic feel with staff speaking spanish to one another. Menu was extensive and had a ridiculous amount of options as we as create your own plate where you could pick and choose We dined-in almost immediately and received complimentary chips and salsa, which my party destroyed and loved. Staff is attentive and replaced our salsa without asking and was very helpful ordering. Waiter was also hilarious and didn't hesitate to joke with us, loved the experience. Food is cheap and portion sizes are massive for the price compared to what i'm used to. I was hungry from a day of hiking and barely finished my meal. I got a combo of a burrito, taco, and enchilada for less than $10! food was excellent and delicious. Obviously on the heavier side but who goes to a mexican restaurant for light food. Don't see how anyone couldn't like this restaurant, as I loved it and would recommend it to anyone looking for cheap eats in hayesville north carolina, especially if you're craving mexican food! read more

Anejo - Burrito, Taco, and enchilada - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

See all

Can get the same meal out of a can from the store. Margaritas just say NO. went twice and will not go back.

Great food ! Authentic Mexican. The waiters where very nice and worked hard. Homemade Chicken soup , tamales , tacos etc.

We are on the hunt for good Mexican restaurants since we moved to NC. We recently tried Anejo and were mostly disappointed. The waiter told us the Texas margaritas have extra shots of tequila, but we discerned zero tequila (no tequila flavor nor "buzz") in the small and medium sizes of our drinks. They also lacked tart lime flavor and seemed to have an additional unwanted fruit flavor (orange?). At least they weren't sickly sweet. My husband's combo #11 was missing seasonings and tasted pretty bland. My tacos al pastor with grilled pineapple chunks was better and benefited from my adding salsa verde (not the same as their tomatillo sauce, which is red and spicy), cilantro, lime, and white onions. Interestingly, the rice and refried beans were satisfying. Adding the spicy red tomatillo sauce helped my husband's dish somewhat. The flan was good and simple, as I prefer (was not garnished with whipped cream and a cherry). We will continue to search elsewhere. read more

When it comes to Mexican food, I have pretty high standards. After all. I was raised on the best food, spent summers in Oaxaca, and learned from a culinary genius (from Mexico City) in college. Y'all, this place is legit. I came with my family over Labor Day and everything we ordered was great. The margaritas--just a touch of orange juice--NOMS. My parents had the Alejandro and the #16 and they were quite satisfied. I had the mole and, though a tad too runny, was flavorful. OH--GET THE FLAN. Definitely get the flan. Finally, the service was incredible. We loved our waiter and all of the wonderful folks with which we interacted. 100/10 will be coming back read more

Muchas Gracias, mi amigos!!! Excellent authentic Mexican cuisine. Great place for lunch with affordable lunch specials and divine margaritas! read more

The food is very good and the servers do a great job. I have been over 10 times now. I have no complaints about anything. I hope they can expand in the future. read more

We are Mexican food snobs and visiting from Atlanta we were looking for a good Mexican restaurant, not Americanized! Do not order the Margaritas, they are horrible! Get beer. The tortillas are handmade and all of the food was prepared fresh! The guacamole was not from fresh avocados, but was tasty. The cheese dip was thin but the salsas were great. Ask for the hot one. My kids ordered burritos and they were HUGE! read more

We had an excellent meal including the best chicken soup I've had in a long time with just the spice and a generous helping of avocado. Chicken fajitas (no photo, sorry) came out sizzling, stuffed poblanos filled with beef and chicken enchiladas in corn tortillas were delicious with traditional flavors. I recommend giving it a try. read more

See all

Was quite surprised by the quality and authenticity of the meals here. I asked for a chimichanga which is not on the menu and no issues at all Asked for the full bday treatment and got the sombrero, flan, song, and whip cream in the face. Great service and a lot of fun. read more

Always excellent food and service!! Nicely decorated, comfortable place to sit and enjoy your meal read more

Despite all that is going on in the world, Anejo has stayed open to serve the Hayesville community warm, affordable, Mexican comfort food during the pandemic. They transitioned to an efficient to-go model with a car line for placing and picking up orders. Good to see things get back to normal now that the pandemic restrictions have come to an end. Their friendly, familiar faces are an asset to the community. read more

I liked this Restaurant because the food was reasonable, was promptly served and was hot . The plates were heated which is not always done . Overall thumbs up ! read more

After trying various Mexican Restaurants in the area our neighbors suggested we try Añejo. It has become our go-to Mexica restaurant when we are in town. We drive from Marble to Hayesville to eat at Añejo. The service is friendly and efficient. As soon as you sit down they bring you fresh chips with salsa. My husband and I always order the fajitas for two and it doesn't disappoint. It's a huge portion filled with shrimp, chicken and steak. It comes sizzling in the pan. The tacos are also very good. I highly recommend Añejo for authentic Mexican food. read more

Been going there for years. Their food has always been "so-so" at best. My go to dish, the fajitas, have NEVER come out sizzling (restaurant owners, that's the entire reason they come out on a frying pan) which means NOT fresh and NOT recently cooked, but previously cooked and warmed up on the "frying pan" And NEVER get their pork, as only had it twice and BOTH me and my wife BOTH times got food poisoning and threw up all night. And their Flan is VERY inconsistent. One day it's very soft and taste good and the other day it's tough and rocky and tastes like leather. Still, like everyone else, it's the only Mexican place in town, so what are you going to do? Which is also why you can ignore all of the good reviews, as after awhile, like us, you just get used to the local crappy food to the point it tastes good AND everyone knows the owners so they say good things... But TONIGHT I draw the line and will never go again! I WILL NOT BE POLICED WHILE I EAT!!! My wife has been getting a pitcher of beer there for years and whatever is left over we pour in a to go cup. Never a word from anybody. Yes I know it's technically illegal but so what, that's NOT their problem, business or concern. They are not responsible for the customers actions! They can't watch and see what every customers pours into a to go cup! What's next? Strip searchers at the door??? My wife has mental illness and because of this I am always a great tipper. We always spend anywhere from $50-$75. I ALWAYS tip $15-20. But tonight the waiter wanted to make a complete ASS of himself and go out of his way to come running across the restaurant when he saw us pour the beer in a cup and forbid us to leave with it!!!! Yes, FORBID. Pretty stupid because he didn't have the authority to prevent me from doing anything...and truth be told I almost got really mean and was getting ready to make a scene. But then I thought, thats a pretty stupid thing to do when the customers are getting ready to tip you!!! So I left NO tip. The beer was $6.99 so he paid for my beer AND saved me another $10 in tips. WIN-WIN :) ps: If you want to work in law-enforcement then go apply at the sheriffs department. It's not your job to harass customers.. read more

Small town surprise that rivals any authentic Mexican anywhere else in NC. Fresh chips and salsa and a house margarita are a great opener. Enormous menu full of old favorites and new ones. Had (and LOVED) the Quesadilla Mucho Grande. Enough food to feed a family of 2-3 for $8.50! Creamy cheese, marinated chicken and juicy shrimp with refried beans and amazing guacamole (creamy with a perfect kick of garlic) on the side. Great value, wonderful food, and some sweet ambiance to boot. Highly recommended. read more

Delicious! I just had the poblanos vegetarian-hold the cheese! It's hard to find a Mexican restaurant with good options for vegans-but they several vegetarian dishes that would be easy to make vegan by holding the cheese. It was so good. read more

Anejo - Poblanos vegetarian. - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Anejo did not disappoint! The salsa was good. We both got the poncho which was a great bang for your buck! I ordered mine with black beans. Our server Marcos was great & very attentive. Next time we're in town we'll come back! read more

Anejo - The poncho! - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Went in at 845 to get food to go before I even asked they said they were closed when there hours say they are open till 9pm

By far this has become my favorite Mexican spot in the mountains. The staff is always friendly and the food is great, hot and fresh. Try the chicken soup! Try the chicken soup in a tortilla. I live for a bowl of their chicken soup. read more

Anejo - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Good was great. Margaritas weren't so good. But surprisingly one of the best meals I've had in this area. I could drink your tomatillo sauce through a straw! It's that good! read more

Marcus is an EXCELLENT and EXCEPTIONAL Server. Awesome recommendations. Great food, great service and very clean I got the Valerta Special and 3 yr old grandson got a hard taco and cheese dip read more

Good mexican. Good margarita specials. We actually used to go to a little mexican place right across the street from here because Anejo is always pretty crowded. And yeah, it's crowded for a reason. Get the authentic tacos instead of the "Amercanized" ones, you won't regret it. read more

Service is pretty bad. I've been a couple times and haven't seen any improvement. Food is nothing special. Dry, seems like it was cooked days ago. read more

This is hands down the Mexican food in the area. It's located in a strip mall but don't let the outside keep you from the great food on the inside. I had cheese steak tacos and my wife loved her shrimp tacos. We will definitely be back to this little gem. read more

Anejo - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Anejo is the Hayesville jam. I live in Atlanta but spend quite a bit of time in NC and this is always my first stop when I am in the area. I may be obsessed with their Choripaso and their Chicken Soup. Very friendly service, cold draft beer and fantastic chips/salsa seal the deal on 5 stars for me. read more

Several weeks ago my wife and I decided to see if the new boy on the Mexican block was as good as or even better than my local favorite, El Alazan. The staff was friendly and attentive, but the food and management left a lot of room for improvement. My wife was relatively satisfied with her food, but I was not. I ordered Chile Verde, one of my favorite Mexican dishes. The pieces of pork were more fat than meat and had not been grilled. It was bland, fatty, and not even hot. When I asked for a hotter spicier salsa, I was told they did not have another salsa than the bland routine salsa. The enthusiastic waitress brought me two different bottles of habanero sauce. My complaints about the poor quality of the pork pieces appeared to confuse her. There was no offer to replace my dinner and no adjustment made on the bill. We will not be back. That's alright, as we still have El Alazan. read more

We've been eating at Anejo for a few years now and we love it. Food was always served hot and exactly as we ordered it (I love my tacos with just meat, onions and cilantro). It's truly authentic Mexican fare. Service was great and it seems each time we always get someone to wait on us who is very outgoing and attentive. I'm usually not much of a drinker but when I'm there I can't leave without a frozen strawberry margarita. The best! read more

The food is inconsistent. Have been three times for brunch and ordered Chilaquiles each time - first time was amazing, second time was terrible and taken off the bill, third time they were edible, but we're not really Chilaquiles. I think Añejo's days are numbered. read more

Anejo - Chilaquiles Añejo - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

The food and service is always excellent. The only problem is smokers standing outside. This week a lady was sitting in a chair at the front door smoking. We decided to leave and dine elsewhere as opposed to walking through her cloud of smoke. Wish Hayesville had an ordinance, no smoking within 40 feet of doors to public places. read more

Good Food...the stars would be 5 if based on only the food. The service was very slow on a Friday night. The restaurant was so hot I watched people at other tables using napkins to wipe their faces. read more

Anejo - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

Our first visit here and it was delicious! We ordered from the lunch menu : lunch Vallarta & lunch ponchos- both very awesome! Full of chicken, shrimp & fresh veggies! Service was fast & friendly! We will definitely return!! read more

Consistently delicious! Love this place! Great food and drinks. I always get the chicken quesadilla and it never disappoints. The chicken soup is our go-to at the slightest hint of a cold. It's delicious and is chock full of fresh ingredients. Great service! read more

When this Mexican Restaurant opened it quickly replaced the one that we always visited prior. The wait staff is always very nice and the food has yet to disappoint. My favorite there is their chicken soup, but my husband has yet to find his favorite since it's all tasty. Also, they serve a fantastic breakfast with both American and Mexican choices. The Mexican choices are by far my favorite since it's something that I would rarely prepare for breakfast at home for my family. Worth the visit and prices are very reasonable. read more

Anejo - Chicken soup - Mexican Near Me - Hayesville, North Carolina

August 23, 2021. Anejo. Delicious Mexican food! We accidentally found this restaurant while visiting the area for the first time. The restaurant is located in a small strip mall. You know the saying : don't judge a book by it's cover. We ordered fajitas (mix chicken & beef) and combo 27, and added a couple of cold beers. Absolutely delicious and plentifully. We'll definitely return again and recommend to others. Enjoy. read more