Absolutely amazing bakery! I have trusted them for years and years. Their affordable prices are unmatched. They have made many celebrations in my life much sweeter! lol. I appreciate their consistent dedication to help create cakes perfectly to my liking. The best thing about this place is their cakes are fully customizable. From shape, to color, to what fillings you want inside. My personal favorite is the tres leches- the pina colada. I haven't went anywhere else since I've been here. I stop by time to time for a sweet treat, as they offer slices, and other sweets. I have recommended this place to many friends and family. The cakes taste better than they look. read more

See all

This is my second year ordering my kid's birthday cake from Andi Cakes, and they were wonderful. Very affordable and the cakes turned out absolutely amazing!! Many friends and family asked where we got our cakes from. read more

Andi Cakes - Custom Cakes Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

See all

A HUGE HUGE thank you to the team who helped with our order for our company holiday event. Even though we ordered over 700 portions worth of cake between two back-to-back dates, they were able to deliver! The sheet cakes were still incredibly moist and full of flavor. The deliveries were on time, and I also love that they went above and beyond when it came to drawing out the portions for us to cut (each cake was 80ct). I've had lots of team members ask where we ordered the cakes from. I will always recommend this place to friends and family, especially for large events!! (We ordered the tres leches caramel sheet cakes) read more

Andi Cakes - Tres Leches Caramel Sheet Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I placed a cake order for 9/21 and received a beautifully decorated but dry cake. After reaching out to this establishment to solve this problem as a returning customer I was extremely disappointed in their lack of accountability and willingness to offer a better solution to the problem. I was refunded $35 after paying $160 and requesting half ($80) be refunded. Additionally, the owners threw the remaining of the cake away which was about 50% without my consent after I requested that it be cut in front of me to avoid any further trouble. As a host of a party I was extremely disappointed to see cake lying around and hearing feed back of the cake being dry. I hope in the future other customers are handled with the same standards of quality that this business promises. read more

re-editing my review just because I wanna say I used to use them for cakes, but they've increased their prices substantially and I do not wish to pay $100 for 24 cupcakes. I think that's ridiculous but my problem with them is that when I stated that on Facebook, they felt the need to block me which I'm just saying I can definitely find a cake elsewhere that's affordable. I just inquired with them because I thought they'd be reasonable, but they are not. I wouldn't use them if I were you. read more

We ordered a cake for my daughters birthday and it was dry. The amount of cake filled plates around the party was absurd. Upon reaching out to see if they would work with us on some type of resolution for the cake they only offered us a $35 refund. I would not recommend a company that can't take care of simple dispute with a returning customer. read more

This place made us the perfect cake for our daughter's sweet 16 birthday! The cake was so delicious and so very pretty! We will be back! read more

Andi Cakes - Sweet 16 - Custom Cakes Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

See all

Cakes are beautifully decorated but the taste and texture of the cakes do NOT match. They failed to come to a fair conclusion on the matter of the cake. Very disappointed and will not shop ever again. If you want your cake the texture of a popeyes biscuit, this is the place for you! But, If you would like a nice, moist, delicious cake this is definitely not the place best for that! read more

Do not order your treats, cakes or anything else from this bakery! Poor quality cakes they are extremely DRY and expensive!

This is a remarkable little bakery in the heart of Fairfield with great cakes and pastries. I stopped in last week to get a birthday cake and they personalized it for me on the spot. It was a dulce de leche cake (I think) and it was divine. read more

Andi Cakes - a man holding a birthday cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

This is a hidden gem in the area! Everything is so delicious, cakes, pastries, cupcakes... and if you are look one for a healthy option they also have fresh fruit juice :) definitely a must go bakery in town, read more

Andi Cakes - Jello mix flavors. - Custom Cakes Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I ordered a birthday cake from here and it was very reasonably priced. They gave me exactly what I asked for and it was delicious. Everyone enjoyed it and couldn't stop talking about how pretty it was and how delicious. I will definitely be ordering more cakes here in the future and highly recommend it for anyone looking for a cake. We also tried a few of their pastries and they were also delicious, the cupcakes and Chocoflan are amazing! Do not pass up this place. It's good, great customer service and amazing cakes. read more