Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Amy’s Cakery

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 10:00 am - 5:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Amy’s Cakery Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Amy’s Cakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Sugarz Bakery - Carrot cake

    Sugarz Bakery

    4.0(21 reviews)
    0.9 mi

    I put in an order for a gender reveal cake on March 11th for an April 3rd party. I talked to the…read moreowner about all of the details in person. The cake was set to be picked up at 8:00 am. At 7:30 am, day of the gender reveal, I get a call asking if I could come in later for the cake. My husband and father in law go to get the cake at 9:00 and it was done incorrectly. I had to drive down myself, just two hours before guests were arriving. The cake said "Baby Herbert" which is NOT our name. There was a reference picture sent and the details were not clearly communicated to the bakers at all by the owner. The bow on top of the cake should have been about three times the size it actually was. The baseball stitching were two different blues. The actual cake itself tasted like it was frozen and then thawed out, especially the frosting. On top of it all, when my husband went to pick the cake up, the bakers let him see the paper that said "GIRL" and he had no idea of the gender considering it was a GENDER REVEAL PARTY. We went through infertility and IVF for 3+ years and this place completely took a once in a lifetime moment away from my husband. I was also told I would be called and NO ONE reached out to me. Absolutely awful experience and I do not recommend anyone to go here.

    This is the BEST carrot cake in CT. We have had carrot cake every year for birthdays and wedding…read moreanniversaries and I can genuinely say this is the best we have ever had. The service at this bakery is top notch. Highly recommend this place.

    Photos
    Sugarz Bakery
    Sugarz Bakery - Carrot cake

    Carrot cake

    Sugarz Bakery

    See all

    Who Cut The Cheesecake - Pistachio

    Who Cut The Cheesecake

    4.7(49 reviews)
    13.4 mi
    $$

    Little delayed due to 3ft of snow…read more I needed snow snacks before a storm & they had so many options & my dog got a treat too! Reasonable pricing and I wish I knew the young man's name around 930 on Sunday 2/22 because he was great, personable and helped me decide which coffee concoction out of so many great choices. Definitely helped during the storm. Will be back soon!

    "Who Cut the Cheesecake" leans into flavored, smaller-format cheesecakes instead of the classic…read moredense New York slice, which already makes it more approachable if you're not into that heavy, overly rich style. Everything is portioned more like a cupcake than a full slice, so you can actually try multiple flavors without committing to one. Side note: you can order whole cheesecakes along with custom cakes for those special occasion's as well! I went with the cookie dough, cookies & cream, and birthday cake cheesecakes. Across the board, they were solid. Lighter in texture, not too sweet, not overly dense, and easy to eat. If you're expecting that thick, classic New York style bite, this isn't it. But that's the point. These feel more like a hybrid dessert cheesecake meets whipped, flavored treat. The surprise of the visit wasn't even the cheesecake. It was the chocolate chip cookies. Perfect execution.. thin, soft, chewy center with a crisp edge. They had that exact homemade quality you can't fake, like something straight out of your grandmother's kitchen. Balanced sweetness and proper texture. I could've easily gone through an entire tray without thinking twice. From a menu standpoint, they're clearly built around: - Flavored, individual-sized cheesecakes (cookie dough, cookies & cream, birthday cake, etc.) - Rotating or staple dessert flavors that lean more fun than traditional - Classic baked goods like cookies that honestly compete with (or outperform) the main attraction If I'm being critical--this isn't a destination for purists looking for a traditional cheesecake experience. But if you want variety, lighter texture, and more flavor-driven desserts, it hits. Overall: came for cheesecake, would come back for the cookies.

    Photos
    Who Cut The Cheesecake - Turtle

    Turtle

    Who Cut The Cheesecake - Key lime!

    Key lime!

    Who Cut The Cheesecake - Carrot cake

    See all

    Carrot cake

    Serenity Sourdough Bakery - Serenity Sourdough Bakery-- where all the magic happens! The owner is hard at work packaging cookies.

    Serenity Sourdough Bakery

    5.0(4 reviews)
    13.8 mi

    I've gotten several loaves of bread, coffee cake muffins, and scones from Serenity Sourdough…read moreBakery. They've all been excellent. The bread was a huge hit with extended family on the holidays. I highly recommend grabbing a treat or two from this stand.

    I've been in San Diego for the past 14 years, so sometimes I forget about the amazing, random…read morehidden treasures you can find back in Rhode Island. This trip, my dad decided to take my husband and me on a very important "bread journey". We went down a few small roads that led to... a bread shed filled with the most wonderful, fresh-baked goods. We grabbed a classic sourdough, the roasted garlic sourdough loaf, and some cookies. Honestly, I would drive here every weekend if I still lived here! The sourdough is truly phenomenal. The roasted garlic loaf is a masterpiece. It's fantastic when toasted up with some roasted tomatoes and pesto. Just be warned: it's so packed with flavor, it's also a great way to ensure people stay a respectful distance from you all day long (hello, garlic breath!). I also got to try the banana bread brownies. I could do without the frosting, but the actual banana bread base is perfection. This is a great little spot to fulfill all your carbohydrate needs. It's best to follow on instagram to see what will be available for the weekend and either placing a pre-order or risking it all and stopping by when the shed opens to see what you can grab. Everything is so tasty! Five stars for the best bread shed I've ever been to.

    Photos
    Serenity Sourdough Bakery - Jumbo Coffee Cake Sourdough Muffin

    Jumbo Coffee Cake Sourdough Muffin

    Serenity Sourdough Bakery - Sourdough Raspberry & White Chocolate Chip Scones with vanilla glaze

    Sourdough Raspberry & White Chocolate Chip Scones with vanilla glaze

    Serenity Sourdough Bakery - Roasted Garlic Sourdough Bread

    See all

    Roasted Garlic Sourdough Bread

    Amy’s Cakery - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...