Cancel

Open app

Search

Amish Cheese House

3.0 (2 reviews)

Amish Cheese House Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Amish Cheese House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Jil S.
205
288
175

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

3 years ago

Just ok. The sandwich was a bit overpriced and felt like a hog pod experience. The cheese used for the sandwich was excellent.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Trenchers Delicatessen - Homemade chips. Would be awesome if they had a chip seasoning bar. Like pickle seasoning, ranch powder, cheese powder, etc

Trenchers Delicatessen

4.3(484 reviews)
43.8 mi•Midtown
•$$

I placed a delivery order and was blown away by how good everything was. I tried two half…read moresandwiches and two cookies, and each item impressed me. Both sandwiches came with homemade potato chips, a mix of regular and sweet potato and they were absolutely delicious. The Dutch Crunch Sandwich was packed with turkey, bacon, swiss, tomato, arugula, and avocado mayo on dutch crunch bread. They don't skimp on toppings at all, there was plenty of turkey and bacon, and every bite was flavorful. Dalton's Double Deuce was another standout. Ham, egg salad, olive tapenade, and arugula on a fresh Italian roll. It felt like a grown up version of an egg salad sandwich. The olive tapenade adds a great punch of flavor, though it leans a little salty. And the cookies... unbelievably good. Truly some of the best cookies I've had. The Brown Sugar Cookie has a gooey center and deep caramel flavor, and the Oatmeal Cookie without no raisins, surprised me, I didn't miss the raisins at all. It tastes like it has a light honey glaze to me, and it's phenomenal. Trenchers is definitely a new favorite.

Wow, the sandwich was amazing! I got the Stram Don, and it absolutely hit the spot. The pastrami…read morewas hot and flavorful, paired perfectly with the coleslaw and a fresh, soft roll. I ordered the full size, and it was huge. I ended up splitting it into two meals. My only complaint was the house-made chips. They seemed like they had been fried ahead of time because by the time I got them, they were soggy, which was a bit disappointing. I paired everything with a root beer, and overall it was a fantastic meal. Aside from the chips, I really enjoyed it and would definitely come back.

Photos
Trenchers Delicatessen - Inside dining area

Inside dining area

Trenchers Delicatessen - Tomato mozzarella and avocado with turkey on the side.

Tomato mozzarella and avocado with turkey on the side.

Trenchers Delicatessen

See all

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - photo 3

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

4.1(35 reviews)
49.7 mi

Got into Tulsa around 1pm and was quite hungry. Checked in to my hotel and then hit up a local…read moresandwich shop. Capriottis it was. Service was fantastic! Everyone was very nice and accommodating. The food wasn't very good in my opinion. I chose the turkey sandwich. Although the turkey was real turkey breast, not deli meat, it didn't have a lot of flavor. There also weren't a lot of toppings, and bread ratio was too bready. There isn't an option to "build your own" like Jersey Mikes or Subway, so you're kind of stuck with what you get. It wasn't awful, just not that good. Service made up for mediocre food.

I arrived at Capriotti's to pickup my sandwiches. Never been here before so I stood at cashiers…read morestation and waited for assistance. Both employees were at the grill working diligently. Neither looked up to see me standing there. After six minutes standing there one looked at me. Came up and asked me if she could help me. I told her my name and was there to pickup my sandwiches. With this "you dumb butt look" and said "it's right over there"and walked off. Remember I've never been there before and I hadn't seen the shelf holding our food. Place is small with six or so tables. Got home with our sandwiches. My Italian Sub was SO WET AND SOGGY! The lettuce and thinly sliced tomato were drenched in some unidentified liquid substance. I pulled all of the let out of the sub. Leaving me with a bun that was falling apart. Torn off about half of the top and bottom of the bun. Flavor of meat was okay at its best. I ate one half Wife's Homemade Turkey sub was bland and tasteless. She ate 1/3 of one half. Two bags of chips were the hit of the meal. $29.60 wasted. Can't say we didn't try.

Photos
Capriotti's Sandwich Shop
Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Photo 6

Photo 6

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Photo 1

See all

Photo 1

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - photo 1

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

4.2(89 reviews)
39.1 mi

My Fiancée and I had been out running around together and I got hungry and wanted a sandwich ,I had…read moreseen the name of this place pop up on Yelp and I looked over and there it was.So I go in and am greeted by an older silver haired gentleman who was beyond polite and gave me time to figure out what I'd like,he also guided me smoothly with my choices.The sandwiches came out within 7 minutes and I proceeded to a nice spot in the back of the parking lot to indulge in.Man these sandwiches were so good both my socks flew off! One hot Italian that tasted like it came from Sicily and a Philly cheese that reminded me of West Philadelphia!I could eat here once a week and I'm kinda mad there's not one close to me!

So the workers' friendliness is a 5 star effort! I took an elderly aunt here for lunch and they…read moreliterally read the menu to her and suggested sandwiches. They even customized her sandwich a bit. When we were leaving, they got her a water to go. Nice touches and it was appreciated. I tried the regular cheese steak with sweet peppers. I didn't get a lot of cheese or mushrooms but the meat was good and tender. (I just wanted more cheese and mushrooms, and peppers for that matter.) I ordered a small and know they are SMALL. I did love the bread. My aunt got the pastrami signature sandwich without the coleslaw. She said it was great (and she can be a bit picky sometimes). :) We went around 11:15 and we were the only ones there. By the time we left, it was filling up. It's a small spot and they were doing a lot of carryout orders. I did like that they have one flavor of Stubborn soda--Agave Cream--on tap. So good! I will be back.

Photos
Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Kitchen

Kitchen

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Photo 6

Photo 6

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Photo 3

See all

Photo 3

Amish Cheese House - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...