$23 for Eggplant Parm?!?! Are you out of your mind. Take this place off the list. I don't care how good it is. $23 speaks volumes about what this owner thinks about his customers. read more

Came in for a loved ones birthday dinner, made a reservation for 6 people, arrived and was sat at a 4 person small table, other dining groups of 4 had a larger table than ours. After being sat, waited almost 10 min after being sat to get menus. Very uncomfortable seating. Must be a flaw in the planning and positioning of diners. read more

Amerigo - Photo attached of small table and small bread plates for reference. 6 people seated at this table.... - Italian Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

What beautiful service, place and way to fill up your heart and belly! My friend Dorentina had an event there today and I didn't know this place existed and I'm so happy I now know. I will be back with friends and my spouse. Thank you everyone read more

great food! great service! friendly and very good menu choices i have had dinner there by myself, table of 4, and larger family parties fantastic read more

Disappointing all around. The dining room is very noisy - difficult to have a conversation. The food is average at best. Portions are small for the price. Warm food (not hot) served on cold plates. Midway through our meal, a strong noxious odor passed through the room after which the outside doors were opened. We will not be returning. read more

Came here with a large party over the holiday season, so that's the only thing preventing me from giving 2 starts. For the first 30 minutes, we got nothing but water, and the waiter only came to take our orders 15 minutes after our initial ask. Food came out 45 minutes later. I ordered the Brook Trout over Angel Hair, and when it came out, I received a small piece of fish with maybe 10-12 pieces of pasta. None of the potatoes or green beans that THE MENU SAID WAS INCLUDED WITH THE DISH. For some reason we decided to give them another chance, and ordered their desert. For $11, instead of a "Flowing Lava Cake," you get a tiny piece of something I don't know if you can legally call cake, that tasted purely of unbaked flour. If anyone knows how that tastes, this was way worse. The ice cream on top was alright, but I ordered the cake, not ice cream. Throughout the entire meal, there was pop music blaring, drowning out most conversations. Servers were amazing, that was it. read more

This was an absolutely perfect meal in a wonderful location we will be back (maybe tomorrow night:) The service was so attentive they seemed to know what we needed before I did! I felt like I was in another world in this adorable Italian restaurant. Thank you!! read more

Just went here for a late lunch with my wife and had a delicious meal, with warm ambiance and prompt service. Definitely recommend!

Solid food, great service, love the ambiance, the did a great job with the space. Our meal was excellent.

Arrived a little early for our reservation and the table wasn't ready on our reservation. Waited about 10 minutes which was not terrible. We were seated without menus. The place was packed and very noisy. Had to call the waiter over to alert the hostess that we needed menus. Had to call the waiter over to take our order after we sat a long time. I observed the waiter standing around chit chatting with the hostess. Had to call him over to ask for desert menus and had to call him over for the check. 4 out of 5 touch points I had to call him. Each time we waited a while before I called him over. The food was average to below average. My calamari in my seafood dish was rubbery and chewy. No alcohol; no coffee, 2 deserts. One and done. Ameri(No)go read more

Girls luncheon this afternoon at Amerigo, first visit and will not be our last. Restaurant is lovely and warm, casual yet elegant. Service was friendly and on point, and our lunches were outstanding . Salads are crisp and fresh....Eggplant and Mozzarella appetizer was perfect, followed by the Lasagna Bolognese which was truly out of this World. So glad we had room for dessert, The Tiramisu was like a cloud . Fiorino's in Summit has been a long standing favorite, ....finding the sister restaurant, Amerigo hands down a winner ! ! read more

We were very disappointed . The ambiance was terrible,the service was sketchy and the food quite ordinary

The oil they're serving there with the bread is canola/vegetable oil. Why not buy some good olive oil and serve that to your guests. No one wants that kind of oil served with Italian bread. I know as a matter of fact, we asked that question when we were there and even my son asked the same thing and other people have put up the same review how terrible that is to do to your guests. Don't bother to put it out at all if you can't put good olive oil out. read more

New Italian restaurant--lots of competition around. Middle of the pack. Food was neither worth complaining about nor praising. There's a weird sitting area taking up a quarter of the seating space, it would be nice in a restaurant with a bar, but they are BYOB, so it seems really out of place. Maybe they are planning to get a liquor license in the future. It was packed on a Saturday night so clearly other patrons liked it. The night I was there they seemed very focused on a few large parties so we had to wait quite a bit for service for two. read more

As a New addition to the many Italian places in the area, I'd add this joint to the list of "NEW" red sauce/modern Italian places to try. Recently had dinner at Amerigo in Berkeley Heights and it was SOLID. Spicy Rigatoni in Vodka Sauce is Stellar, The Chicken Scarparello was prepared the right way, with spicy sausage, potatoes, Calabrian chile. We did try one of the "red sauce" traditional items, the chicken parm, it was very good. I saw many "red sauce" items on tables I.E Chicken Parm, Lasagna, etc. and all looked nicely done. My only complaint was the fries served with the burger were not actually fries but rather a shredded, oily, undercooked nest of potatoes that were not very good. I much prefer they stick to a regular French Fry. Service was attentive, friendly, & knowledgeable, I highly recommend & it's BYOB! read more

So happy this place opened up in town. Everything is delicious here. But the spicy rigatoni is amazing. So is the amerigo burger. Love the decor. Service is so friendly. Def recommend it. read more

Not good. Overpriced. Avoid. Overpriced and mediocre at best and that's being generous. Food came out barely five minutes after placing the order which means it was pre-cooked, not made to order. Pasta dishes at $27 for a small portion in the middle of NJ is barely reasonable but an upcharge of $12 for an addition of three small meatballs is absurd. Had no drinks other than water and three plates of pasta, that's it. Bill came to over $150. Don't give me the excuse that it's inflation. Inflation my arse. This was downright a waste of money. Service was decent but their claim to fame is to associate themselves with Fiorino in Summit. It's not even in the same class. This is one step above a chain restaurant like Olive Garden but with NYC prices. Don't bother. Any high end Italian place doesn't offer pre-grated Parmesan on the table like at a pizzeria and even the olive oil is questionable as it is clear with barely a hint of flavor. Tastes more like canola oil. Avoid. read more

the food and service is outstanding. I have had dinner there 5 times and each time it was excellent and at the right price thanks read more

Amazing food, amazing service!!! I could not recommend this place enough. First time going there with my family for my mom's birthday and every single person there was very kind and attentive. The food was amazing and the place in general was lovely. read more

Ambiance is nice, but the food is just average. The sister restaurant, Fiorino, is a lot better in my opinion.

Great service. Delicious food. Very nice atmosphere. Gluten free pasta. BYOB. Can't beat it.

Was there on crowded Friday nite. Find the surroundings to be very loud making conversation difficult. Food was good but not spectacular. I had bucatini in a pork tomato sauce . Could not find the pork.. but it was tasty and pasta was cooked well. Service was good in spite of crowds. It was my second visit and better than the first. I had the sole oreganata which I did not care for at all since it was very thick and it came with spinach that lacked taste and was not baby spinach as it was very chewy but in spite of this decided to try it again. Maybe it was my choices but was not impressed. read more

Great food, great service w/ friendly staff. Love the ambiance too. Lots more things on the menu I want to try. Will definitely be coming back!!! read more

Went there today to celebrate my birthday. The atmosphere is wonderful and the service was nice, but the food was terrible. Worst meal ever. Won't be going back. read more

we dine there on Saturday night. I ordered a pork chop. with my surprise I got a pork loin. we were with other people and didn't want to question the server. At the end I asked the manager and he responded that is a pork chop without bone. I challenged him that pork chop is a different cut with bone. he did not apologize and said that I am right and they are going to change the menu to reflect pork loin and not pork chop. read more

Save you money! Hostess greeting was poor and it went down hill from there. Shrimp was a bland version of Bowl & Basket from Shop Rite. Calamari was terrible; bread was skimpy and the request for butter went unheaded. Good canoli and cappucino was the only good thing. Never going back. read more

Food service and ambiance all were exceptional. Bring that nice bottle of wine you have been saving for a special occasion and enjoy it at this amazing BYOB read more

Food was great, owner makes you feel happy you came to his restaurant . Service couldn't do enough for you