We loved their buy six and get free shipping! Every time we go in there, we find New and exciting stuff to try. The management is extremely kind and friendly.! And the samples are out of this world GOOD! read more

American Spoon - BUY 6 GET FREE SHIPPING. Can't wait to try the new flavors - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

American spoon jams and preserves are so good! The employees were so welcoming! There were plenty delicious samples out. I ended up getting some lemon curd and a cherry chipotle salsa. As someone who typically does not like jams I was blown away by how amazing it was. Thank you friendly people from American Spoon! read more

All I can say is Wow I was given this gift by my fellow Yelper Aleana W. This is the perfect gift for someone who likes salsa and jams plus the fudge. It came in and everything was packed to perfection and nothing was broken. The salsas I've tried have been really good. Plus we've had the Haven peach jam which is outstanding. If you're looking for a gift or wanting to gift someone a nice gift I would definitely recommend this place. They have a great website to look at all the different things they have to make up your own gift pack. I just wanna say THANKYOU AGAIN ALEANA W You did great read more

American Spoon - Box - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Top notch ingredients, everything was delicious and staff was super helpful. We ended up buying a gift pack and can't wait to share.

I was introduced to American Spoon by a friend who gifted my wife and me with a wonderful assortment of this company's premium jams, salsas, fruit butters, condiments and more. We were immediately impressed with the presentation of our gift basket and how well the shipment was protected from potential damage. American Spoon is a family owned and operated company with several locations in Michigan. If you don't live near a physical location you can still easily order from their online store and have your purchase shipped. Enjoy it yourself or send it to a friend, they have wonderful gift baskets. They source the best local ingredients for their products and prepare everything in small batches. Their products taste amazing and have a lot of character. My wife and I are working our way through our gift box. So far we have only sampled a few items and have found each one truly fabulous. The Chili Jam is spicy and delicious on so many things. We have also enjoyed the Mango Habanero Salsa and the Dried Chili Salsa. We look forward to sampling the rest of the products we received, I know they will be wonderful. read more

See all

What a cute little store. Best part is that there was a free shipping (to Honolulu!) with the purchase of 6 (or more) things promotion happening. The problem was limiting it to 6! We did pick up a jar of granola for father's day, which was well received and thoroughly enjoyed. Quality locally made products, you cannot go wrong. read more

American Spoon - Stuff - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

What a delicious place to visit! I enjoyed the Michigan Blueberry. It was so flavorful. My daughter had the spearmint chocolate chip which she loved! The service was attentive and offers samples before you commit to a flavor. They have inside or outside seating options. Inside had a spacious seating area for many groups. read more

Purchased the Christmas Cheeries for $20 for two small jars and finally got around to making it today. Total disappointment for a very expensive product that didn't live up to the expectations. Pie turned out ok because I know how to bake, but the pie was a total disappointment. Guests left most on their plate and I ended up throwing it out. Batting close to a zero on this one American Spoon. Could have given the money to a homeless person instead. read more

My family received American Spoon's Complete Pancake Breakfast for Christmas. It included a bag of pancake mix, two jars of fruit toppings (sour cherry and blueberry), and a jar of their maple syrup. I hadn't previously heard of the company and didn't know what to expect. It turns out that their pancakes, fruit toppings, and maple syrup are exceptional! We were really impressed and the quality was excellent! Delicious and highly recommended. Unfortunately the promo photo that came with the kit shows a disgusting stack of lopsided pancakes that are drowning in fruit toppings. It's not aesthetically pleasing or even remotely appetizing. The product team did their job very well, but the marketing team blew it with this photo. Not sure how this image slipped by the QC team. Yuck! read more

American Spoon - The marketing team really missed the mark with this image. Nothing about this photo is appetizing or even remotely appealing. Sorry, folks. - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

American Spoon produces and sells the BEST jams, butters, salsas, conserves, and all condiments on the planet!!! Special note: get the ketchup and Bloody Mary mix - you will fall in love. The product does cost a premium, but you won't be disappointed. I wish they would expand down and around to Chicago and Wisconsin... Quick update... the whole mustard seeds are incredible. They are marinated in Chardonnay and you can reasonably just eat them right out of the jar. read more

I support the local food thing, I do. And generally, I am happy to pay a lot of money for seriously good stuff. And I tried the local sour cherries from a nearby fruit stand. HOLY COW! Tart. Bursting. Delicate. Bright. Beguiling, even? And then I try American Spoons Sour Cherry products, and it just misses, in my book. Too much sugar and too much heat kills the delicacy of the fruit. I mean... I know it's got to be shipped all over the country, and be made in quantity, etc. etc. I just don't see all the fuss or why you would pay the tariff for such a thing. It's like the salt water taffy or maybe even fudge of jam shops (if that makes ANY sense). It is nice that they have a big tasting bar. It was less nice that some of the crackers tasted rancid. But I was glad to be able to sample their products. Jam tasting, as an activity, is WAY underrated. read more

American Spoon - Front door - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

Finally got to shop at the store. Have ordered from catalog. Staff was very friendly and helpful and thoughtful. Wonderful experience

What I love about American Spoon Foods is the tasting bar in the middle of the shop. You can sample a few dozen jams, curds, salsas, and toppings. Don't see what you want to try? Just ask! They'll open up a new jar of whatever you want to sample. The red haven peach preserves are amazing. I'm seriously addicted. Also love the rhubarb, blueberry, and cherry jams. I think they shine in the jams vs salsas. The odd thing about their store is that if you live in Michigan it's cheaper to buy downstate in a specialty grocery store! Very odd, as you would think it would be cheaper at the source. You can hardly go wrong with anything you get here though. read more

American Spoon - Specialty Food Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

We discovered this place when we rented a house in Saugatuck, Michigan. All I can say is wow! Everything we have tried has been so fresh and delicious. I've since placed many orders for ourselves and gifts for family and friends. Their service is always so fast and packaged so beautifully. Some of our favorite items are the Cherry BBQ sauce, Bloody Mary Mix, Chili Jam...and our newest favorite...The delicious blueberry coffee cake! Would highly recommend. read more

Wonderful treats. Might be a little more DOUGH, but it makes our homemade BREAD RISE to the temptation! The MICE in our cupboard apparently think the PEANUTBUTTER is TO-DIE-FOR ... and we do too!! read more

We have received, ordered and sent these delicious preserves, and not only are all the products high quality, but the company personnel are great to work with! read more

I love American Spoon! Before coming to Petosky, my boyfriend always told me I'd love this store, and man was he right! This place is like a food lovers paradise - so many free samples!!! You could get a whole meal with all the crackers, jams, and salsas. Everything I tasted was delicious, especially the spoon fruit stuff!! I ended up leaving with some fruit jam, fig preserves, and their vanilla maple syrup (it literally had a vanilla bean in it and it is my new addiction). They have so many fun and delicious concoctions. You've got to come check this place out! read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE! First of all, the store is ridiculous. So cute and little. It's filled with homemade jams, jellies, preserves, butters, salsa, dried cherries, crackers...and crack. You can watch them make everything by their little demo station at the back of the store. All natural ingredients and cutely packaged. In the middle of the store they have a little tester section where you can try said goodies. I tried the apple butter and nearly passed out. It was amazing!!! I bought 3 little jars, one of the apple butter (obviously), 1 red raspberry perserve and 1 rhubard marmalade. I almost bought the mango habanero salsa, but I didn't and now im sad. You can get cute little gift boxes or they will pack it for you (since most of their clients are prolly tourists). When I went to pay I asked if they could pack it and their response was "Sure, our pleasure." Awesome. Buying all natural (or even organic) jams and stuff, can sometimes be a crap-shoot. But these were refreshing and looked delicious! American Spoon, you have my heart. read more

First, pay no attention to the review of a restaurant posted on this site. There is an associated restaurant where they use Spoon products but this page is for the retail store. We have a summer cottage in Petoskey and have been patronizing American Spoon Foods for years. It is absolutely incredible stuff -- local fruits, artisanal recipes, small batches. You can taste test the products in the store, and each year when we go , our biggest problem is trying to narrow down our choices. For the uninitiated, a few of my favorites. Early Glow Strawberry Jam is hands down the best jam I have ever tasted. These low-yield strawberries have such intense, almost dark flavor. Red Haven Peach is also a winner. Anything with cherries can't be beat, since that is one of the local specialties, but I especially love the cherry and cranberry mustards. They are terrific on a sandwich or as a sauce with fish or chicken. We like to buy a case at Christmastime (free shipping if you buy a case) and give them for all of those little gifts - coworkers, teachers, etc. - where you want to get something special for not a lot of money. read more

This store is so cute! It's very cozy an homey with an assortment of relish, jelly, salsa, etc etc. There are tons of open jars for you to sample before you buy. My first visit, I bought a jar of salsa, a jar of mushroom relish, and orange thai bbq sauce. They run around $10/jar. There are other cute little knick knacks you can buy like small wooden spoons, Michigan (mitten)-shaped wooden cutting boards, etc. This place is a jem! read more

Amazing jelly butters and salsas! We order them by the case to be shipped to California. Still hoping kiwi-lime salsa comes back even though mango-habanero is terrific. And we miss cherry butter too. read more

This store is perfect for the Up North goer looking for something special to bring back for either themselves or as a gift. I went into the American Spoon hoping to find a thank you gift for some neighbors taking care of our house while we were gone. I left, absolutely impressed by the quality of the food. The flavors alone will make you moan with delight and I really liked the overall feeling of the place...the decor, the packaging, it's all so quaint but yet modern. Just trust me. It's a gem of Petoskey. I sampled the various jams and jellies and my favorite was the Tart Cherry. The cherry flavor is so bright and has this great sweet/tart note that has a great balance to it. It's sweet without being too heavy and that's just right in my book. I also really enjoyed the dried cherries. Cherries are after all, the area's specialty so I was focused on my gift featuring cherries since it is what this area of Northern Michigan is known for. I noticed two things as I was checking out...a James Beard award, apparently that was won many years ago and a trophy next to their big seed mustard. I guess it just won this year, I'll have to go back and give it a try another time. They do have a website, so check that out if you can't make the drive. You may not be able to sample the offerings but you can get an idea of what they offer or if you're feeling brave, can order blind without trying it! If you are in the Petoskey area, stop in and give it a try...I challenge you to leave empty handed! read more

Love the store. Love their Instagram account. Still need to visit their cafe. In 2016, I've really enjoyed their whiskey maple syrup & wild blueberry compote. I've visited both the Petoskey & Traverse City locations & prefer Petoskey overall. Nice spot to stop for an edible, northern Michigan souvenir. read more

We stopped here while visiting Petoskey. We stopped at the little store, not the restaurant. This store has several different kinds of jams, jelly, fruit butters, salsas, grilling sauces.....and in the center is a little sampling table with all different kinds to try. I got some mango butter. Prices to me, are a little high, like $10 for salsa, $8 or $9 for jams.....I did get some, and they are good, but I don't know if they are $9 good. When we got back, I found American Spoon jams and jellies at a nearby market. I live over 250 miles from Petoskey, and at the market here, they were over $1.25 less per jar. To me, it seems Petoskey store marks up, because of tourists. I would pay $7.49 here, for the same kind in Petoskey was $8.95. read more

This is my go to for gifts! They have such a unique selection and are so helpful! Love this place! The whitefish dip is amazing!

I did not fully appreciate American Spoon Foods until it became more difficult to acquire! I am contemplating a road trip to get some pancake mix and some cherry-peach salsa. The cherry peach salsa alone would be the worth the day's drive to Petsokey! American Spoon Foods features a nice selection of "spoon" foods and a few dry goods. The jams/jellies are fantastic but, like I said, the cherry peach salsa is on another level. The pancake mix is the greatest comfort food. Even though my love for those two things is extreme, I can't say I've had a bad product from this company! Exceptional stuff! This stuff is amazing and has mail order! But who wants to wait!? You can pick up some of their products at specialty grocerys--like Whole Foods--but it's hit and miss at best! read more

Retail experience is always good , plenty to sample even unopened ones . I just wish they would find a way to be cheaper . $10.95 for the peach preserves is too $$$ for Michigan, I'm sure downtown Manhattan this price wouldn't be outrageous but this is northern mi. Maybe food for the middle class is out of fashion , let them eat cake, with preserves. read more

Best little spot in Petoskey loaded with deliciously good jams, jellies, sauces and CARMEL SAUCE. this is the place for delicious gifts and they have everything out to taste. It's hard to decide what to purchase! read more

I was looking forward to making several purchases at the store in Petoskey. I had visited the store in Saugatuck a few years ago and loved the items. When I entered, the clerk there shooed us away with no explanation. There were 2 other people in the store at the time so obviously it wasn't busy. I didn't realize it at the time but there was a small sign that said "4 at a time". Since I was with my 2 daughters it would have been 5 in the store not including the rude clerk. An explanation would have been nicer than the waving of the hand like shooing away a pesky fly. I won't shop there again and I hope that management trains their employees in the future to not be rude to customers. read more

Love the raspberry jam!!!! Please bring the gelato back to the Harbor Springs store!!!! read more

I LOVE this place! Cute little store with very friendly employees. They have so many flavors to sample before you buy. During our visit, I really enjoyed the sour cherry products, as well as the marmalade. Since I was on vacation and only brought a carry-on, I was sad that I couldn't bring back jars and jars of everything. Luckily, they have a catalog! I'm looking forward to ordering some goodies by mail. read more

I love American Spoon! My boyfriend and I vacation every year at his family's lake house in Cheboygan and we always make a trip to Petoskey to walk around and shop and of course, go to American Spoon. Their stuff is moderately priced to expensive-ish, running $8-$12 or so per jar, but I think it's worth it. Everything is delicious, adorably packaged, and the flavors are generally unique (especially the savories - my favorites are the apple & onion jam and the dried chile salsa). Also, the store employees are so friendly and nice and helpful. And the store itself is so cute. AND you can try all the jams/jellies/sauces/etc before you buy! I know my review isn't really saying anything new but I want everyone to know how awesome American Spoon is! read more

This is the sort of place that Michigan could use more of. Michigan foodstuffs that you may or may not have grown up with. I appreciate how it's focused on the things that Michigan has done well agriculture-wise for ever: cherries, preserves, apples, the like. It manages the perfect balance between touristy and authentic; the number of Petoskey-ers inside and next door eating gelato and lunch is a testament to that. If you want a comparison think Great Traverse Pie Company but more genuine - and better! read more

"Crispy Double L Farms buttermilk chicken with lemongrass vinaigrette, herb salad, pickled cucumbers & our Chili Jam on challah" Hunrgy yet? After viewing the menu posted outside American Spoon, I knew *exactly* what I was having for lunch. Bright and airy inside, with a slight whiff of elitism. Everything is made from scratch and priced accordingly. That said, I'd go back in a heartbeat. My companion and I found our fried chicken sandwiches (described above) incredibly delicious. Tender, perfectly seasoned. Wonderful melding of savory flavors. My accompanying side of green bean salad was similarly delicious. The gazpacho was so fresh -- great for a warm summer day. This place is a gem and well worth a little lunchtime splurge. read more

Daniel- I understand if some of the products were not to your liking, but i just wanted to clear up some facts. Forgive me for sounding like a sales person for a minute, but I do sell gourmet food products for a living and I am very familiar with American Spoon. They actually put very little sugar in their products- so little in fact the their preserve BARELY qualifies as a preserve because it doesn't have enough sugar. They put about a pound of fruit in every jar and I think sometimes people confuse the intense flavor of a fruit-rich product for something that has a high sugar content. Their other product line, Spoon Fruit, doesn't have any added sugar at all but is sweetened with fruit juice instead for a clean, tart flavor. Perhaps that would have boon more to your liking. read more

Been to Petoskey and visited American Spoon many times. It's always an important part of the visit. Service and products always top notch. I don't know if there's anything else on the market that compares. read more

My cousin that lives in the area highly recommended the food here, but unfortunately we were unable to try it because the hostess was SO rude. Some of us locals and some us visiting, we were trying to figure out if we were going to wait or go somewhere else in order to maximize our shopping time while in Petoskey. There was a misunderstanding within our group regarding who spoke to the hostess the first time and who was speaking the second time we came in as to whether or not we had put our name in already. The server we spoke to letting her know we were back went to get the hostess who promptly came over and was condescending and extremely rude. I am not sure if she thought we were trying to pull a fast one and cut the list, which we were not, but she was snapping at us about we could get on the list this time but we would have to wait just like she told the first time. Also, scolding us for coming in and lying to the server...? My sister and I had to step in tell her to calm down that there was clearly a misunderstanding within our group and she was misinterpreting what was going on. She continued on, so we said we will support local business elsewhere..thanked her and left. There are a lot of other cute places to eat that would love to have your business in Petoskey...go where you dollar is appreciated. As a nice closer, we walked out to her hollering at us that it was the lunch hour and we are going to wait anywhere in town(insert smart a*s tone here.) Well that is a lie because we walked right into another place, sat down immediately, had a delightful meal and service. If Michigan is going to push so hard for tourism and people to come visit the state, the locals should be welcoming the business with open arms. We also wanted gelato at the end of the hot day and made a point to not give AS our business and went elsewhere. Thank you for making our decision on where to eat much easier. read more

I love this place. My favorite item is the Kiwi Lime salsa... incredible! Also the gelato is amazing. I live in Nebraska and don't get up to Harbor Springs too often so I really like that you can order from them it is really convenient. read more

I went in to the American Spoon at the Grand Traverse Resort over the weekend. I have always loved their products. The young women working there was the most unfriendly sales person I've encountered in ages. I was the only person in the store and I spoke immediately upon entering. She never spoke one word period the entire time I was there... No hello, goodbye, nice day , thanks absolutely nothing. She couldn't work one second in my store and with the most sour look in her face. I forgot something I wanted to purchase, as I only got one thing, but refused to go back in !!!! read more

Over priced and mediocre sandwiches. Go to a chain and the food tastes better and the value is there or go to any of the other local restaurants and you'll be happier read more