I am slowly doing a little tour of semi-celebrity chef Jose Garces dining establishments.
Tapas places are popular today partly because of Jose Garces's status and television exposure. His exposure has not been overwhelming yet and unlike many celebrity chefs that turn their attention to national exposure, nationwide chains, and a line of frozen pizza's found at Safeway, Jose Garces appears to be staying to his roots with slow expansion.
The result is a small set of high quality establishments. Several follow a similar theme such as Amada and Tinto, while others offer a different experience like Village Whiskey and Guapos Tacos mobile truck. Amada was his first, opened in 2005 and is still going strong.
Amada is billed as "authentic Spanish Tapas". I cannot speak to the authenticity (never been to Spain) and I am certainly not Spanish. What I can tell you is that in my 3 dining different experiences there, I walked away very happy and satisfied with the food - though I had bad service once, as you will read.
1. Dining alone, I was seated in the end seat at the Chef's Counter - a divider between the buzzing dining room and the high energy kitchen. It was a perfect place when alone - with the the entertaining view into the kitchen & the ability to scan the dining room or watch the crowd in the bar.
I started with a Matador cocktail, sweeter than I prefer, but still tasty. I ordered the soup, Pulpo, Piquillos Rellenos and a glass of Tempranillo. The dishes were all well prepared, delivered in a timely fashion and full of flavor. The 1 thing I would change is the Rellenos - quite tasty but the more delicate crab meat was a little lost in the other flavors. The food was too much for me so I shared a little with the two young ladies to my left. They too were very pleased with their dishes. The service was excellent.
2. My second visit was with two others. We were able to score a table in the bar area. Plenty of action to see & pretty people to watch. Service was a little slower because of the crowds in the bar, but we enjoyed the scenery and did not mind the extra time. A round of cocktails was followed by 6 small plates and a bottle of wine. Again, every dish was well prepared and very good. We got a variety of meats & seafood and finished off with a selection of two cheeses. Sorry, can't remember the specific dishes - it was a few months ago, and I had a few glasses of wine with dinner before walking back to the hotel.
3. For my third visit I took my beautiful daughter - we were in the area for a wedding and were able to swing 2 nights in Philly before flying home to our respective states. It was the evening fireworks in Philly, so the streets, bars, and restaurants were all quite crowded. We were seated at a table off the bar area and right by the large windows looking out onto the street. It was another good location for people watching.
Unfortunately this time my visit was a let-down - thus the 4 stars vs the 5 stars I was going to give them.
The food was great as usual, but the service was painfully slow. I am not a pain-in-the-ass who expects prompt service all of the time. I enjoy a leisurely meal, I understand slower service on busy nights, I am very tolerant - and besides, I was enjoying a final evening with my daughter so I was in no rush. But service that night was bad to the point where I finally complained (something I rarely do).
One thing about small plate dining is they bring out the dishes as they are prepared. So you get them spaced out during the meal and some of them come fairly quickly. This evening, after finally ordering, nothing came for quite some time. It wasn't everyone though, which is what really bothered me. The table of 3 guys seated outside after us received all of their plates & the bill before we received our first dish.
The staff rarely smiled when they came by - particularly the female wait staff. They had a smile for just about everyone else. I got the strong feeling they thought I was an older guy dating a young hottie. So I did 2 things:
first, politely told the hostess "MY DAUGHTER and I are getting quite hungry and have been here for quite some time. Could you please have someone check on that status of our order."
Second, when our waiter came to ask if I wanted another glass of wine (still no food), I told him I did not want to order any more wine because I was afraid it would further delay delivery of our food and MY DAUGHTER is quite hungry.
After that the food began arriving fairly quickly and the staff smiled at us when bringing it (including one of the ladies that was at the hostess stand.
So did we really get bad service because they thought what I think they were thinking? I don't know, but after I made sure they knew that the young woman with me was my daughter, things picked up. Either way, I should not have had to say something.
So that knocked them down to 4 stars. read more